Esther E. Manheimer

Mayor since Dec 2013 · on council since Dec 2009

Esther E. Manheimer has served on Asheville City Council since Dec 2009. This dataset begins in January 2020; across the 2,622 votes recorded from Jan 14, 2020 to Oct 27, 2026, Manheimer voted yes 2,480 times and no 16 times (0.6% of yes/no votes cast), was absent for 68 and recused 31 times. Manheimer was on the losing side of 5 votes, made 3 motions and seconded 1, cast the most no votes on Zoning & Land Use items (10), and on split votes agreed most often with Maggie Ullman (93% of 100).

2,622recorded votes
16no votes (0.6%)
5times on the losing side
3motions made
68absences
Yes 2,480No 16Recused 31Absent 68No vote 11Ballot 16

Who Manheimer votes with

Agreement on split votes (items where at least one member voted no) that both members voted on.

ColleagueAgreedShared split votes
Maggie Ullman93%100
Sandra Kilgore92%120
Sage Turner83%171
Gwen Wisler81%84
Sheneika Smith77%184
Bo Hess76%55
S. Antanette Mosley73%183
Kim Roney31%179

No votes by topic

TopicNo votes
Zoning & Land Use10
Boards & Appointments2
Transportation2
Public Safety1
Community Programs1

Every no vote by Esther E. Manheimer (16)

DateItemResult
Jul 28, 2026Motion to deny the rezoning of 3 S. Tunnel Road from Urban Place Form District to Regional Business
Zoning & Land Use
Failed 2–4
Aug 26, 2025Roney motion to amend Helene Recovery Boards resolution to instruct staff to accept RWG support for boards wanting to meet regularly
Boards & Appointments
Failed 2–5
Mar 11, 2025Motion to deny UDO amendment on cottage development standards (carried over from Feb 11 meeting)
Zoning & Land Use
Failed 3–4
Mar 11, 2025Motion to deny UDO amendment on flag lot standards (carried over)
Zoning & Land Use
Failed 3–4
Feb 11, 2025Motion to deny the resident-led proposed amendments to Chapter 7 regarding cottage development standards
Zoning & Land Use
Passed 4–3
Feb 11, 2025Motion to deny the resident-led proposed amendments to Chapter 7 regarding flag lot standards
Zoning & Land Use
Passed 4–3
Jul 25, 2023Motion to delay the LUIG application for Aston Flats LLC for 46 Aston Street until after the LUIG policy is revised
Zoning & Land Use
Failed 3–4
Feb 22, 2022Conditional zoning request for property at 363 Hilliard Avenue from CBD to CBD Expansion-Conditional Zone
Zoning & Land Use
Failed 2–5
Feb 22, 2022Second and final reading of ordinance approving Blue Ridge Rickshaw to operate a pedi-cab transportation service
Transportation · ORD 4929
Failed 3–4
Feb 8, 2022First reading of ordinance granting a franchise agreement with Blue Ridge Rickshaw to operate a pedal bicycle taxi service within the City of Asheville
Transportation · ORD 4929
Passed 4–3
Jul 27, 2021Amendment to repeal Chapter 10 Article IV noise ordinance with modification subtracting 8 decibels in residential districts
Community Programs
Failed 2–5
Mar 9, 2021Resolution requesting the local delegation pursue a modification to the School Board selection process (hybrid model)
Boards & Appointments · RES 21-48
Passed 5–2
Feb 23, 2021Ordinance to amend the UDO (hotel standards) - Roney motion with 100% public benefits increase (restated, deleting quarterly review)
Zoning & Land Use
Failed 2–5
Feb 23, 2021Hotel Overlay District - Roney amendment to remove properties adjacent to Urban Renewal Program Area
Zoning & Land Use
Failed 3–4
Sep 22, 2020Motion to deny the budget amendment regarding the fiscal year (public safety reimagining)
Public Safety · ORD 4829
Failed 2–5
Mar 24, 2020Motion to continue the second and final reading of Ordinance No. 4794 (RAD Lofts conditional zoning) until April 14, 2020
Zoning & Land Use · ORD 4794
Failed 2–5

Recusals (31)

DateItemResult
Jun 9, 2026Budget amendment of $100,000 in General Fund to fund the City's annual contribution to the Economic Development Coalition
Economic Development · ORD 5226
Passed 6–0
Jun 9, 2026Motion to recuse Mayor Manheimer from voting on Economic Development Coalition budget amendment per N.C.G.S. § 14-234.3
Administrative
Passed 6–0
Sep 9, 2025Resolution No. 25-212 allocating $10 million of affordable housing bond to WNC Affordable Housing Loan Fund (Self-Help Ventures Fund)
Housing · RES 25-212
Passed 6–0
Sep 9, 2025Motion to recuse Mayor Manheimer from remainder of meeting (VI-A WNC AH Loan Fund discussion)
Administrative
Passed 6–0
Jun 10, 2025Fiscal Year 2025-26 budget amendment for the City's annual contribution to the Economic Development Coalition
Economic Development · ORD 5144
Passed 6–0
Jun 10, 2025Motion to recuse Mayor Manheimer from voting on the budget amendment for the Economic Development Coalition
Administrative
Passed 6–0
Jun 11, 2024Budget amendment of $100,000 to fund the City's contribution to the Economic Development Coalition
Economic Development · ORD 5085
Passed 6–0
Jun 11, 2024Motion to recuse Mayor Manheimer from voting on the budget amendment (Economic Development Coalition)
Administrative
Passed 6–0
Dec 12, 2023Ordinance to conditionally rezone 2 Butler Road from Community Business II District to Residential Expansion-Conditional Zone
Zoning & Land Use · ORD 5053
Passed 5–1
Dec 12, 2023Motion to recuse Mayor Manheimer from the 2 Butler Road rezoning due to conflict of interest
Administrative
Passed 6–0
Nov 14, 2023Public hearing to conditionally rezone 2 Butler Road - motion to continue to December 12, 2023
Zoning & Land Use
Passed 6–0
Nov 14, 2023Motion to recuse Mayor Manheimer from the 2 Butler Road rezoning due to conflict of interest
Administrative
Passed 6–0
Jun 13, 2023Budget amendment of $100,000 in the General Fund from City Manager's Contingency to fund the City's annual contribution (Economic Development Coalition)
Economic Development · ORD 5022
Passed 5–0
Jun 13, 2023Motion to recuse Mayor Manheimer from voting on the budget amendment (Economic Development Coalition conflict)
Administrative
Passed 5–0
Oct 25, 2022Public hearing - ordinance to conditionally zone property - conditional zoning request
Zoning & Land Use · ORD 4980
Passed 5–1
Oct 25, 2022Recuse Mayor Manheimer from participating due to conflict of interest (re ORD 4980 conditional zoning)
Administrative
Passed 6–0
Sep 13, 2022Public hearing to rezone 645 Brevard Road from RS-8
Zoning & Land Use · ORD 4968
Passed 5–1
Sep 13, 2022Public hearing to rezone 651 Brevard Road from RS-8
Zoning & Land Use · ORD 4969
Passed 5–1
Sep 13, 2022Motion to recuse Mayor Manheimer from participating in the two public hearings on the rezonings of 645 and 651 Brevard Road due to a conflict of interest
Administrative
Passed 6–0
Jun 28, 2022Fiscal Year 2022-23 budget amendment to fund the City's contribution to nonprofits (Economic Development Commission)
Economic Development · ORD 4955
Passed 5–1
Jun 28, 2022Motion to recuse Mayor Manheimer from voting on the budget amendment (Economic Development Coalition)
Administrative
Passed 6–0
Sep 28, 2021Public hearing/ordinance to amend the UDO to establish a new Urban Place Form District
Zoning & Land Use · ORD 4044
Passed 4–2
Sep 28, 2021Ordinance to rezone 57 acres (phase one properties) to Urban Place Form district and amend the Future Land Use Map
Zoning & Land Use · ORD 4405
Passed 4–2
Sep 28, 2021Motion to recuse Mayor Manheimer (conflict of interest) on the Urban Place Form District matter
Administrative
Passed 6–0
May 25, 2021Approve the purchase of real property at 50 Asheland Avenue (ratify grant agreement with Dogwood Health Trust)
Contracts & Procurement · RES 21-100
Passed 6–0
May 25, 2021Budget amendment to establish a budget in the City's General Capital Projects Fund for the purchase of 50 Asheland Avenue
Budget & Finance · ORD 4377
Passed 6–0
May 25, 2021Motion to recuse Mayor Manheimer from the discussion of the purchase of 50 Asheland Avenue (conflict of interest)
Administrative
Passed 6–0
Oct 13, 2020Ordinance amending a previously approved conditional zoning for the Coxe/Asheland/Federal Alley mixed-use development
Zoning & Land Use · ORD 4832
Passed 6–0
Oct 13, 2020Motion to recuse Mayor Manheimer due to conflict of interest on conditional zoning amendment (Ord. 4832)
Administrative
Passed 6–0
Sep 22, 2020Public hearing to consider an amendment to a previously approved conditional zoning (Ordinance No. 4785) (continued)
Zoning & Land Use
Passed 6–0
Sep 22, 2020Motion to recuse Mayor Manheimer due to conflict of interest on conditional zoning amendment (Ord. 4785)
Administrative
Passed 6–0

Most recent votes

DateItemManheimerResult
Oct 27, 2026Agreement to reimburse NCDOT up to $664,304 for bicycle, pedestrian and aesthetic betterments on I-26 Connector Section I-2513AC
Transportation · RES 26-213
YesPassed 7–0
Oct 27, 2026Monthly municipal property tax refunds or releases per North Carolina General Statute section 105-381
Budget & Finance
YesPassed 7–0
Oct 27, 2026Emergency Watershed Protection sponsorship for streambank stabilization and debris removal; and budget amendment
Environment & Sustainability · RES 26-212 / ORD 5269
YesPassed 7–0
Oct 27, 2026Application for 2027 High Intensity Drug Trafficking Areas (HIDTA) grant funds on behalf of the Asheville HIDTA branch
Public Safety · RES 26-211
YesPassed 6–1
Oct 27, 2026Public hearing relative to amending a conditional zoning at 21 London Road
Zoning & Land Use · ORD 5270
YesPassed 4–3
Oct 27, 2026Conveyance of City property near Hominy Creek and Shelburne Roads to NCDOT for the I-26 Connector Project, Section I-2513AC
Transportation · RES 26-210
YesPassed 7–0
Oct 27, 2026Construction contract amendment with Harper General Contractors, Inc. for the Malvern Hills Park Project
Parks & Recreation · RES 26-209
YesPassed 7–0
Oct 27, 2026FEMA Assistance to Firefighters grant; and budget amendment to purchase wildland personal protective equipment
Public Safety · RES 26-208 / ORD 5268
YesPassed 7–0
Oct 27, 2026Budget amendment of $359,822 from the State Bureau of Investigation for the Local Law Enforcement Bonus Program
Public Safety · ORD 5267
YesPassed 7–0
Oct 27, 2026Renewal of the agreement with the Appalachian Sustainable Agriculture Project to produce the Asheville City Market
Economic Development · RES 26-207
YesPassed 7–0
Oct 27, 2026Interlocal agreement with Buncombe County to administer its $100,000 match for Code Purple emergency shelter, Fiscal Year 2026-27
Housing · RES 26-206
YesPassed 7–0
Oct 27, 2026Ratifying submission of renewal Planning and HMIS grants through the Fiscal Year 2026 Continuum of Care Program
Housing · RES 26-205
YesPassed 7–0
Oct 27, 2026Motion to recuse Councilman Hess from participating in the Asheville Buncombe Community Christian Ministry funding agreement (Consent Item B.2) due to a conflict of interest
Administrative
YesPassed 6–0
Oct 27, 2026Funding agreement with Asheville Buncombe Community Christian Ministry for the Right at Home homelessness prevention initiative
Housing · RES 26-204
YesPassed 6–0
Oct 27, 2026Funding agreements with Homeward Bound of Western North Carolina, Operation Gateway and Pisgah Legal Services for Right at Home
Housing · RES 26-203
YesPassed 7–0