City Council regular meeting — October 13, 2020

Asheville City Council recorded 15 votes at its regular meeting on October 13, 2020; none drew a no vote. Most items fell under Zoning & Land Use, Housing and Utilities & Infrastructure.

Met: 5 pm–6:42 pm. Voting: Brian Haynes, Esther E. Manheimer, Julie Mayfield, S. Antanette Mosley, Sheneika Smith, Gwen Wisler, Keith Young.

Votes 15 recorded · 3 substantive · none split

Item D · RES 20-178 · Utilities & Infrastructure · Resolution · consent agenda

Resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a change order with Brown & Caldwell for clearwell baffles at the North Fork Water Treatment Plant

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Julie Mayfield

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $346,500 change order to the contract with Brown and Caldwell
  • $819,500 bringing the total of the project to $819,500
  • Brown and Caldwell contractor or recipient
  • Water Resources Capital Improvement Program (CIP) funding that is already budgeted funding source
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adopt a resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a change order to the contract with Brown and Caldwell for the emergency repairs to the North Fork WTP water storage tank baffle curtains for an amount of $346,500 bringing the total of the project to $819,500.

Background:

  • The North Fork Clearwell (water storage tank) was constructed in 1976 and has a five (5) million gallons of water capacity.
  • Inspection of baffle curtains confirmed significant deterioration. The baffle curtains are critical for attaining required disinfectant contact time within the clearwell to meet regulatory requirements.
  • The baffle curtains are beyond repair and must be replaced.
  • Inspection discovered minor needed repairs to the clearwell roof, vents, and other equipment.
  • The requested change order includes both structural engineering and complete repair costs.

Vendor Outreach Efforts:

  • N/A

Council Goal(s):

  • A Financially Resilient City; A Clean and Healthy Environment

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • The North Fork Water Treatment Plant will more easily be able to meet the EPA and State requirements for Giardia & Cryptosporidium

Con(s):

  • The North Fork Water Treatment Plant clearwell has a capacity of the five (5) million gallons. To meet EPA and State requirements for Giardia & Cryptosporidium the clearwell has had to be maintained at a higher capacity level and limits operational flexibility.

Fiscal Impact:

  • Funding for this repair will come from Water Resources Capital Improvement Program (CIP) funding that is already budgeted.

Staff: David Melton, Water Resources Department Director; Leslie Carreiro, Water Production Manager.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item E · ORD 4831 · Transportation · Ordinance · consent agenda

Budget amendment from the Federal Transit Administration for Section 5339(b) funds to be used to improve and enhance bus stops in the service area

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Julie Mayfield

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $1.25 million a budget amendment in the amount of $1,250,000
  • $250,000 local match
  • Federal Transit Administration contractor or recipient
  • remaining City approved General Obligation (GO) Bond funds for bus stop improvements ($62,000), unspent funds provided via development project conditional approvals ($40,000), and previously budgeted funding in the Transit Capital Fund ($148,000) funding source
Description in the minutes

TRANSIT ADMINISTRATION FOR SECTION 5339(b) FUNDS TO BE USED TO IMPROVE AND ENHANCE BUS STOPS IN THE SERVICE AREA

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a budget amendment in the amount of $1,250,000, which includes $1.0 million from the FTA Section 5339(b) Discretionary Grant Fund Program for bus stop improvements and a $250,000 local match.

Background:

  • On March 24, 2020, the City Council adopted Resolution No. 20-137 authorizing the City Manager to apply for, and accept if awarded, grant funding from the FTA FY2020 Buses and Bus Facilities discretionary grant program.
  • The City applied for, and was awarded $1 million, in grant funds for the purpose of improving bus stops in the service area.
  • Improvements will be prioritized at high-ridership stops and stops serving vulnerable communities. Improvements might include bus shelters, benches, solar lighting, and ADA accessibility improvements.
  • The local match for the grant award will come from multiple sources, including remaining City approved General Obligation (GO) Bond funds for bus stop improvements ($62,000), unspent funds provided via development project conditional approvals ($40,000), and previously budgeted funding in the Transit Capital Fund ($148,000).
  • Staff is also expecting to receive donations from partner associations; these donations would be used to lower the required contribution from the Transit Capital Fund.

Council Goal(s):

  • Transportation and Accessibility

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • Project funding is provided by the FTA and will help support improvements of transit amenities in the service area.

Con(s):

  • The grant requires a 20% local match for the acquisition and installation of transit amenities, and a 10% match for ADA accessibility improvements.

Fiscal Impact:

  • As noted above, there is a required local match of 20% and 10% depending on the specific types of improvements implemented. The maximum required local match is $250,000. The sources for the local match are discussed above.

Staff: Ken Putnam, Transportation Department Director; Jessica Morriss, Assistant Transportation Department Director; Eunice Lovi, Transit Planning Manager.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item V-B · ORD 4832 · Zoning & Land Use · Ordinance

Ordinance amending a previously approved conditional zoning for the Coxe/Asheland/Federal Alley mixed-use development

Passed6–0 · Moved by S. Antanette Mosley, seconded by Julie Mayfield

Yes: Brian Haynes, Julie Mayfield, S. Antanette Mosley, Sheneika Smith, Gwen Wisler, Keith Young  ·  Recused: Esther E. Manheimer

Recommendations

Council’s vote matched the city staff recommendation.

  • City staff (staff report): Approve — Staff recommends approval of this amendment as the project includes market rate and affordable units in a location that is proximate to downtown and still includes a mix of uses to activate this area of the city.

Public hearing continued from Sep 22, 2020

No one from the public spoke.

Vice-Mayor Wisler said that this public hearing was held on September 22, 2020, and in accordance with recent legislation amending North Carolina G.S. § 166A-19.24(e), regarding public hearings conducted during remote meetings, written comments for this public hearing were accepted for an additional 24 hours. … Hearing no more public comment, Vice-Mayor Wisler closed the public hearing

Key facts

  • Coxe/Asheland/Federal Alley address
  • CBD EXP CZ → Central Business Expansion District (CBD EXP CZ) zoning, from → to
  • Maintains the original amount of affordable residential units affordability

This motion was seconded by Councilwoman Mayfield and carried unanimously, with Mayor Manheimer being recused.

From the staff report

Amend a previously approved conditional zoning for a mixed-use development for changes to the design of the project

  • Tribute Investment & Development Inc asked for this item
  • Central Business District Conditional Zone (CBD-CZ) → ? zoning, current → requested
  • 4.43 acres 172 Asheland Avenue, 185 and 99999 Coxe Avenue and 5 Federal Alley
  • Asheland Properties LLC and South Slope Holdings LLC owner
  • Tribute Investment & Development Inc applicant
  • 9648.37-2643, 9648.38-0052, 9648.37-1928 and 9648.37-2825 parcel ID (PIN)
Staff’s stated reasons · approve
  • Conditions from the original approval for traffic mitigation and affordable housing are unchanged with this amendment.
  • the applicant has made efforts to break up the visual massing of the building along Asheland Avenue and the redistribution of uses throughout the site is acceptable.
Before it reached Council
  • Technical Review Committee (TRC): approve with conditions — approved with conditions
  • Downtown Commission (DTC), July 10, 2020: approve — recommended unanimous approval with suggested conditions
  • Planning & Zoning Commission, September 2, 2020: approve (7–0) — ultimately voting at the September 2, 2020 meeting and unanimously recommended support.

Staff: Todd Okolichany, Planning & Urban Design Director; Jessica Bernstein, Urban Planner II.

Description in the minutes

At the request of Mayor Manheimer,

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Show the other 12 votes · consent agenda and routine items · consent agenda moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Julie Mayfield

Item B · RES 20-176 / ORD 4830 · Environment & Sustainability · Resolution · consent agenda

Grant from Urban Sustainability Directors for the Climate Justice Initiative; and budget amendment

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Julie Mayfield

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $15,000 accept funding in the amount of $15,000 from Urban Sustainability Directors Network (USDN)
  • Urban Sustainability Directors Network (USDN) contractor or recipient
  • appropriate the funding in the City’s Sustainability Fund funding source
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to accept funding in the amount of $15,000 from Urban Sustainability Directors Network (USDN) for the Office of Sustainability’s Climate Justice Initiative, and a budget amendment in the amount of $15,000 to appropriate the funding in the City’s Sustainability Fund.

Background:

  • In January 2020 Asheville City Council declared a Climate Emergency by adopting Resolution 20-25.
  • The adopted resolution acknowledges the urgent need to combat climate change, and the disproportionate impact of the climate crisis on low income communities and communities of color.
  • Through this project, the City of Asheville’s Office of Sustainability seeks to learn from the energy, cooperation, and proactivity of Asheville’s Black, Indigenous, People of Color (BIPOC) to guide climate equity planning and to shape the direction of the City’s emerging Climate Justice Initiative.
  • Grant funds will be utilized for Sustainability’s Climate Justice Initiative outreach efforts to engage the community through story circles and photo art.
  • Outreach efforts will include:
  • Story circle compensation, interpretation and translation,
  • Photovoice compensation and supplies,
  • Graphic note taking for final report, and
  • Creation of a semi permanent kiosk fabrication and translation.
  • USDN Grant recipients are not required to provide a cash match.

Council Goal(s):

  • An Equitable and Diverse Community
  • A Clean and Healthy Environment
  • A Connected and Engaged Community

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • Helps support City’s Climate Emergency Resolution while leveraging USDN funding

Con(s):

  • None

Fiscal Impact:

  • None; there is no required City match

Staff: Amber Weaver, Office of Sustainability.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item C · RES 20-177 · Public Safety · Resolution · consent agenda

Amended license agreement with Verizon Wireless extending the term until September 30, 2022

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Julie Mayfield

All members present voted yes.

Recommendations

Council’s vote matched the city staff recommendation.

  • City staff: Approve — Staff recommends allowing Verizon to stay on the tower during the transition period, with an extension of the existing agreement for 2 years.

Key facts

  • $44,000 $44,000 per year in revenue
  • $3,666.67 $3,666.67 per month
  • 57 Crestwood Drive address
  • Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems LLC, dba Verizon Wireless contractor or recipient
  • extend the term until September 30, 2022 term
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to sign an amendment to the existing license agreement with Bell Atlantic Mobile Systems LLC, dba Verizon Wireless to extend the term until September 30, 2022.

Background:

  • Verizon has been one of two tenants on the City-owned Royal Pines Cell Tower located at 57 Crestwood Drive.
  • The City has its own public safety communications equipment on the tower.
  • Verizon has been leasing a portion of the tower since 2009. The current license agreement expired at the end of September 2020.
  • A recent Structural Analysis has shown that the tower is near maximum capacity and equipment upgrades recently requested by Verizon could not be installed.
  • Verizon has decided to relocate to a tower owned by Duke Energy in the vicinity but the transition period could be as long as two years.
  • Staff recommends allowing Verizon to stay on the tower during the transition period, with an extension of the existing agreement for 2 years..

Council Goal(s):

  • A Thriving Local Economy

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • The presence of Verizon on this tower strengthens the signal for the many users of Verizon in the city.
  • Allowing Verizon to remain on the tower during the transition will give the City time to plan for the tower usage after they relocate.

Con(s):

  • None

Fiscal Impact:

  • The City receives approximately $3,666.67 per month or $44,000 per year in revenue.

Staff: Jeff Reble, IT Services; Nikki Reid, Economic Development Program Director.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item F · RES 20-179 · Utilities & Infrastructure · Resolution · consent agenda

Resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a three year service contract with 120Water for the Lead Education & Prevention Program

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Julie Mayfield

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $446,648 three year service contract with the option to renew for an additional two years with 120Water
  • $44,664.8 10% contingency
  • $491,312.8 for a total of $491,312.80
  • $163,770.94 yearly contract amount of $163,770.94
  • 120Water contractor or recipient
  • the yearly contract amount of $163,770.94 in its operating funds funding source
  • Three year contract with the option to renew for an additional two years. term
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adopt a resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a three year service contract with the option to renew for an additional two years with 120Water for the Lead Education and Prevention Program in the amount of $446,648 with a 10% contingency of $44,664.80 for a total of $491,312.80.

Background:

  • The United States Environmental Protection Agency is scheduled to pass (fall of 2020) the new Lead & Copper Rule Revisions which will require a data management platform that has the ability to cohesively manage all required Lead and Copper Tap Monitoring, Primacy Agency & Customer Results Reporting, Service Line Inventory, and Lead Service Line Replacement in the Water System.
  • 120Water is a digital water company that provides data management along with sample kits, analysis, and assistance with public education.
  • 120Water has a data management platform that manages all areas of the new rule revisions.
  • 120Water will provide the required sampling kits, laboratory analysis, and provide assistance with public educational outreach.
  • The revisions require water purveyors to not only manage the water distribution system side of the water meter service line, but also requires research and monitoring of service line piping material to the home and provide customer education if a lead line is found to be on the customer or utility side of the water meter.
  • Staff has taken a proactive approach in preparing for the Lead & Copper Rule Revisions.
  • A Request for Proposals for required services was issued on June 15, 2020.
  • Proposals were received on August 13, 2020.
  • The Lead and Copper Coordination Team reviewed proposals on August 21, 2020. Three firms responded:
  • 120Water
  • Zionsville, IN
  • Camanse
  • Arden, NC
  • Miracle Software Systems
  • Novi, MI 120Water was selected as the most qualified firm to provide the required services.

Vendor Outreach Efforts:

  • Staff performed outreach to minority and women owned businesses through solicitation processes which include posting on the State’s Interactive Purchasing System and requiring prime contractors to reach out to Minority & Women-Owned Business Enterprise (MWBE) service providers for subcontracted services.
  • No MWBE firms submitted bids with this prime contractor.

Council Goal(s):

  • Clean & Healthy Environment

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • Ability to continue compliance with Federal and State regulations
  • 120Water has ongoing experience with large water utilities throughout the United States.
  • 120Water has proactively prepared these utilities for the new lead and copper provisions.
  • Data platform will allow public access to easily consumable and transparent data.

Con(s):

  • Failure to adopt resolution will result in difficulty complying with Federal and State regulations.

Fiscal Impact:

  • Three year contract with the option to renew for an additional two years.
  • The Water Resources Department currently has the funds to encumber the yearly contract amount of $163,770.94 in its operating funds.

Staff: David Melton, Director Water Resources; Brenna Cook, Laboratory Supervisor.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item G · RES 20-180 · Utilities & Infrastructure · Resolution · consent agenda

Resolution authorizing the City Attorney's Office to condemn a stormwater easement over real property located at 2 Springdale Road

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Julie Mayfield

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $5,000 The expected value of the needed easement is less than $5,000
  • 2 Springdale Road address
  • included in the project budget for the subject stormwater improvement project funding source
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adopt a resolution authorizing the City Attorney’s Office to condemn a stormwater easement over real property located at 2 Springdale Road.

Background:

  • The City’s Stormwater Division has a capital improvement project planned for 2021 in the City’s Kenilworth neighborhood.
  • The City has obtained all required easements needed to complete its Kenilworth stormwater project except for one along the edge of real property located at 2 Springdale Road.
  • This property is shown as lots 12 and 13 of Block K on a plat recorded at Plat Book 154, Page 109A in the Buncombe County Register of Deeds Office.
  • Regina Tate owns the property at 2 Springdale Road. She has not responded to any of the City’s attempts to contact her regarding the easement needed to facilitate the stormwater project.
  • To date, three separate City departments have attempted to make contact with Ms. Tate.
  • In order to maintain the project schedule, obtaining the easement via eminent domain is the only option available to the City.
  • The City will deposit with the Clerk of Court the value of the easement which will be available to the property owner at any time.
  • The easement needed at 2 Springdale Road is immediately adjacent to the City’s right of way and is entirely within an unbuildable setback. As such, the City’s condemnation of the needed easement will only minimally disturb Ms. Tate’s use of the property.

Council Goal(s):

  • Clean & Healthy Environment

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • Will facilitate the completion of a needed stormwater improvement project.

Con(s):

  • Will result in the commencement of an eminent domain action against a citizen.

Fiscal Impact:

  • The expected value of the needed easement is less than $5,000 which is included in the project budget for the subject stormwater improvement project.

Staff: Eric Edgerton, Sr. Asst. City Attorney; Lee Morrison, Stormwater Project Manager.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item H · RES 20-181 · Transportation · Resolution · consent agenda

Resolution authorizing the City Manager to renew an existing contract with Smarking, Inc. to provide real time and predictive parking data

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Julie Mayfield

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $35,260 contract value of $35,260
  • $97,935 increases the total value of the contract to $97,935
  • Smarking, Inc. contractor or recipient
  • Parking Services Fund operating budget funding source
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to renew contract with Smarking, Inc. at a contract value of $35,260 which increases the total value of the contract to $97,935, for real-time data aggregation and predictive data analytics service for Parking Services.

Background:

  • The City of Asheville entered into a contract with Smarking, Inc. during November 2018 at a contract value of $29,500 for real-time data aggregation and predictive data analytics services.
  • The original contract included two, one-year renewal terms.
  • The first renewal term was executed with an effective date during November 2019 at a contract value of $33,175 which increased the total contract value to $62,675.
  • The annual cost has increased from the initial contract due to the addition of several parking facilities since the contract was first executed.
  • Smarking provides Parking Services with real-time monitoring of all of our parking facilities, and tracks metrics including usage, revenue, and future demand.
  • The analytical capabilities of the Smarking system are critical in Parking Services operational response.

Vendor Outreach Efforts:

  • N/A
  • This is a current contract.

Council Goal(s):

  • Transportation and Accessibility
  • A Financially Resilient City

Committee(s):

  • None.

Pro(s):

  • Enables the City to continue to use data to inform procedures and decision-making.
  • Enables Parking Services to maintain a healthy operating status in spite of financial challenges presented by COVID-19.

Con(s):

  • None

Fiscal Impact:

  • The required funds are included in the current Parking Services Fund operating budget.

Staff: Ken Putnam, Transportation Department Director; Garrett Male, Parking Services Division Manager.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item IV-A · Housing · Public hearing

Public hearing to amend the U.S. Dept. of Housing & Urban Development plan (continued)

Passed7–0 · Moved by Sheneika Smith, seconded by Julie Mayfield

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

Councilwoman Smith moved to continue this public hearing to amend the U.S. Dept. of Housing & Urban Development 5-Year Consolidated Action Plan until November 10, 2020.

Description in the minutes

5-Year Consolidated Action Plan until November 10, 2020. This motion was seconded by Councilwoman Mayfield and carried unanimously by roll call vote.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

Item IV-B · Zoning & Land Use · Public hearing

Public hearing to consider an amendment to a previously approved conditional zoning (Ordinance No. 4570) at 236 Charlotte St / 336 Hilliard St (recessed)

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by S. Antanette Mosley

All members present voted yes.

3 spoke · changed before the vote

Recommendations

Council’s vote matched the city staff recommendation.

  • City staff: Approve — Proposal allows for upgrade and expansion of the child care center and better management of vehicular access on both sites.
  • Planning & Zoning Commission: Approve, 6–1, September 23, 2020

Public hearing advertised Oct 2, 2020 and Oct 9, 2020

3 spoke in favor · 0 spoke against

  • For Ashley Lasher · for the applicant, Jewish Community Center Foundation of Asheville — Ashley Lasher, representing the applicant, gave a brief history of the facility, the quality of the program; and the reputation of the Shalom Children’s Center.
  • For Suzanne Godsey · for the applicant — Suzanne Godsey, representing the applicant’s design team, showed the site plan of the existing Hilde’s House, along with the proposed site plan.
  • For Wendy Legerton · for the applicant — Wendy Legerton, representing the applicant’s design team, showed the proposed floor plan and the proposed overall 3D view. They asked for Council’s support in the amendment to the conditional zoning.

Mayor Manheimer announced that there were no advanced live call-ins for this public hearing item. … Vice-Mayor Wisler moved to recess this item until October 27, 2020, at which time this public hearing will be voted.

Changed before the vote 1 change recorded

  • Staff revision The Commission voted 6-1 at the second meeting to support the amendment but with a recommended condition that the driveway onto Murdock would be right-turn out only.

Key facts

  • 236 Charlotte Street and 336 Hillside Street (PINs 9649-54-9873 and 9649-54-7812) address
  • Jewish Community Center Foundation of Asheville applicant

Vice-Mayor Wisler moved to recess this item until October 27, 2020, at which time this public hearing will be voted.

Presented by Shannon Tuch, Principal Planner.

From the staff report

Amend a previously approved conditional zoning to alter site details at the Jewish Community Center campus, currently zoned Community Business II District/Conditional Zoning (CBII/CZ)

  • Community Business II District/Conditional Zoning (CBII/CZ) → ? zoning, current → requested
  • Neighborhood Center and Traditional Neighborhood future land use designation
  • Jewish Community Center Foundation of Asheville owner
  • Jewish Community Center Foundation of Asheville applicant
  • 9649-54-9873 and 9649-54-7812 parcel ID (PIN)
Staff’s stated reasons · approve
  • finds that the proposal allows for upgrade and expansion of the child care center and better management of vehicular access on both sites.
  • The physical changes included in this amendment address accessibility and access concerns and are designed to keep with the character of the residential area.
Before it reached Council
  • Technical Review Committee (TRC), April 6, 2020: approve with conditions — approved with conditions
  • Planning & Zoning Commission, September 23, 2020: approve (6–1) — The Commission voted 6-1 at the second meeting to support the amendment but with a recommended condition that the driveway onto Murdock would be right-turn out only.
Conditions
  • The separation of the driveway from the property lines on Murdock and Hillside will be as shown on plans (less than the standard 10 foot spacing required).
  • The width of the driveway will be approximately 12 feet on Murdock and maintain approximately nine feet on Hillside as shown on plan (less than the width standard of 24 feet for a non-residential use).
  • Condition number three is amended to indicate that access to the JCC main campus site will no longer be from Lennox Court.
  • Condition number four is amended to note that parking spaces at Hilde’s House will be available for both staff and visitors.

Staff: Todd Okolichany, Planning & Urban Design Director; Jessica Bernstein, Urban Planner II.

Description in the minutes

Principal Planner Shannon Tuch said that this is the consideration of an amendment to a previously approved conditional zoning approval (Ordinance No. 4570) for property located at 236 Charlotte Street and 336 Hilliard Street to modify the site plan to reflect the right-of-way closure of Lennox Court and to make changes to the site and building footprint at the Hilde's House infant care facility. This public hearing was advertised on October 2 and 9, 2020. Project Location and Contacts:

  • The project site consists of two parcels located at 236 Charlotte Street and 336 Hillside Street (PINs 9649-54-9873 and 9649-54-7812).
  • Owner / Petitioner: Jewish Community Center Foundation of Asheville; Contact: Michael Mitchell Summary of

Petition:

  • The applicant is requesting to expand an existing day care building (called “Hilde’s House” and located at 336 Hillside Street) at the Jewish Community Center (JCC) main campus.
  • The expansion includes a new ramp for accessibility, enlarged side porch and a small increase to heated area.
  • The proposal includes a new accessible parking space behind the building and a new driveway cut onto Murdock Avenue to allow for egress only.
  • The subject parcels were conditionally-zoned by City Council on March 28, 2017, under ordinance number 4570, for the expansion of the JCC main campus building (located at 236 Charlotte Street), the use of the property at 336 Hillside Street for the infant day care (Hilde’s House), and minor site improvements. Most of the work included in the approval has been completed.
  • An amendment to the previously approved conditional zoning and related site conditions is required due to the requested site plan changes.
  • This amendment also includes the closure of a driveway through the JCC main campus building site (located at 236 Charlotte Street) from Lennox Court to Hillside Street, thereby ceasing its use by the general public through this private property.
  • The action by City Council to formally close a portion of the Lennox Court right-of-way was granted by Council in 2019 under resolution 19-266 but the site plan approved in the ordinance did not show closing off vehicular access.
  • This amendment formalizes the site plan which was not part of the previous conditional zoning approval.
  • The project maintains all of the conditions that were approved in the previous ordinance and includes the following new conditions:
  • The separation of the driveway from the property lines on Murdock and Hillside will be as shown on plans (less than the standard 10 foot spacing required). This design would be similar to the residential development pattern in the neighborhood.
  • The width of the driveway will be approximately 12 feet on Murdock and maintain approximately nine feet on Hillside as shown on plan (less than the width standard of 24 feet for a non-residential use). This change also mirrors the residential development pattern in the neighborhood.
  • Condition number three is amended to indicate that access to the JCC main campus site will no longer be from Lennox Court.
  • Condition number four is amended to note that parking spaces at Hilde’s House will be available for both staff and visitors.

Committee Review:

  • The Planning & Zoning Commission considered this request at their meetings on September 2 and September 23, 2020, and discussed concerns regarding the new egress connection onto Murdock and the turning radius having possible conflicts with on-street parallel parking spaces.
  • The Commission voted 6-1 at the second meeting to support the amendment but with a recommended condition that the driveway onto Murdock would be right-turn out only. The applicant was agreeable to this condition and it has been reflected in the B.1 Conditions.

Comprehensive Plan Consistency:

  • This proposal is consistent with the Living Asheville Comprehensive Plan in that the project site is within the areas designated as Neighborhood Center and Traditional Neighborhood in the Future Land Use map, which anticipates non-residential community-focused activity.
  • This section of the Plan specifically mentions community centers and other small-scale uses with an emphasis on pedestrian scale and walkability.

Compatibility Analysis:

  • The community center and child care uses are currently in place and have been operating on this site for many years, providing services to the neighborhood and larger community.
  • The buildings and uses are considered to be compatible with the development along the corridor and scaled down, transitioning into the neighborhood.
  • The physical changes included in this amendment address accessibility and access concerns and are designed to keep with the character of the residential area.

Committee(s):

  • Technical Review Committee (TRC)
  • April 6, 2020
  • approved with conditions
  • Planning & Zoning Commission
  • September 2 and 23, 2020
  • recommended approval 6-1

Staff Recommendation:

  • Staff recommends approval of this amendment and finds that the proposal allows for upgrade and expansion of the child care center and better management of vehicular access on both sites. In summary, (1) Master plan for the JCC campus approved by Council in 2017 (ordinance 4570); (2) Council approved a right-of-way closure for Lennox Court in 2019 that modified access to the Charlotte Street parcel; (3) Specific conditions in the 2017 approval limit ability for expansion or improvement of Hilde’s House infant day care site; and (4) This amendment allows for changes to the building, parking and site access for Hilde’s House and formalizes the current, changed parking lot access configuration for the main campus site. Ms. Ashley Lasher, representing the applicant, gave a brief history of the facility, the quality of the program; and the reputation of the Shalom Children’s Center. They want to renovate Hilde’s House in order to (1) maintain home/neighborhood environment; (2) facilitate implementation of licensing requirements; (3) create uninterrupted sight-lines for supervision; (4) improve ADA accessibility; (5) improve security; and (6) reduce impact of pick-up/drop-off traffic on the community, increasing safety of participants. Ms. Suzanne Godsey, representing the applicant’s design team, showed the site plan of the existing Hilde’s House, along with the proposed site plan. Ms. Wendy Legerton, representing the applicant’s design team, showed the proposed floor plan and the proposed overall 3D view. They asked for Council’s support in the amendment to the conditional zoning. Mayor Manheimer opened the public hearing at 6:10 p.m. Mayor Manheimer announced that there were no advanced live call-ins for this public hearing item. In accordance with recent legislation amending North Carolina G.S. §166A-19.24(e), regarding public hearings conducted during remote meetings, written comments for this public hearing will be accepted for an additional 24 hours. Therefore,

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item IV-C · Zoning & Land Use · Public hearing

Public hearing to amend the Unified Development Ordinance Articles II, III, V, VIII, VIX (Historic Preservation) (recessed to Oct 27, 2020)

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Julie Mayfield

All members present voted yes.

Recommendations

Council’s vote matched the city staff recommendation.

  • City staff: Approve — Staff recommends approval of the proposed zoning text amendment to update Chapter 7 because this is felt to be consistent with the Living Asheville comprehensive plan in that it seeks to align the city’s development code with North Carolina General Statute Chapter 160D.
  • Historic Resources Commission: Approve, unanimous, August 12, 2020
  • Board of Adjustment: Approve, unanimous, August 24, 2020
  • Planning & Zoning Commission: Approve, 7:0, September 23, 2020

Public hearing advertised Oct 2, 2020 and Oct 9, 2020

No one from the public spoke.

Mayor Manheimer announced that there were no advanced live call-ins for either one of these public hearings.

Key facts

Vice-Mayor Wisler moved to recess this item until October 27, 2020, at which time this public hearing will be voted.

Presented by Shannon Tuch, Principal Planner.

From the staff report

Adopt a zoning text amendment related to historic preservation to align the city’s Unified Development Ordinance (“UDO”) with North Carolina Session Law 2019-111, commonly referred to as “160D”.

Fiscal impact

None

Staff’s stated reasons
  • a more streamlined review process for applicants; would act to discourage frivolous appeals, thereby improving the City’s ability to enforce
Before it reached Council
  • Historic Resources Commission, August 12, 2020: approve — voted unanimously to recommend support of these amendments
  • Asheville Board of Adjustment, August 24, 2020: approve — voted unanimously to recommend support of this amendment
  • Planning & Zoning Commission, September 23, 2020: approve (7:0)
City Code sections

Sec. 7-5-11(b)(8), G.S. 160D-947(c)

Staff: Todd Okolichany, Planning & Urban Design Director; Shannon Tuch, Principal Planner; Brad Branham, City Attorney; Jannice Ashley, Senior Assistant City Attorney; Aarin Miles, Assistant City Attorney.

Item IV-D · Zoning & Land Use · Public hearing

Public hearing to amend the Unified Development Ordinance Articles II, XII, XVIII (enforcement and definitions) (recessed to Oct 27, 2020)

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Julie Mayfield

All members present voted yes.

Recommendations

Council’s vote matched the city staff recommendation.

  • City staff: Approve — Staff recommends approval of the proposed zoning text amendment to update Chapter 7 because this is felt to be consistent with the Living Asheville comprehensive plan in that it seeks to align the city’s development code with North Carolina General Statute Chapter 160D.
  • Historic Resources Commission: Approve, unanimous, August 12, 2020
  • Board of Adjustment: Approve, unanimous, August 24, 2020
  • Planning & Zoning Commission: Approve, 7:0, September 23, 2020

Public hearing advertised Oct 2, 2020 and Oct 9, 2020

One hearing covered this item and agenda item IV-C; the counts are for the whole hearing.

No one from the public spoke.

Mayor Manheimer announced that there were no advanced live call-ins for either one of these public hearings.

Key facts

Vice-Mayor Wisler moved to recess this item until October 27, 2020, at which time this public hearing will be voted.

Presented by Shannon Tuch, Principal Planner.

From the staff report

Adopt a zoning text amendment to align the city’s Unified Development Ordinance (“UDO”) with North Carolina Session Law 2019-111, commonly referred to as “160D”.

Fiscal impact

None

Staff’s stated reasons · approve
  • because this is felt to be consistent with the Living Asheville comprehensive plan in that it seeks to align the city’s development code with North Carolina General Statute Chapter 160D.
Before it reached Council
  • Planning & Zoning Commission, September 23, 2020: approve (7:0)
City Code sections

sec. 7-18-3(b)(1)-(2), G.S. 160D-404(a)

Staff: Todd Okolichany, Planning & Urban Design Director; Shannon Tuch, Principal Planner; Brad Branham, City Attorney; Jannice Ashley, Senior Assistant City Attorney; Aarin Miles, Assistant City Attorney.

Item IV-E · Housing · Public hearing

Public hearing to consider updates to the 2020-21 Action Plan (continued to Oct 27, 2020)

Passed7–0 · Moved by Sheneika Smith, seconded by Julie Mayfield

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $154,711 ALLOCATION OF $154,711 IN COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT CONTINGENCY FUNDS
  • $1.1 million REALLOCATION OF AN ESTIMATED $1.1 MILLION IN HOME INVESTMENT PARTNERSHIPS PROGRAM FUNDS
  • $889,456 $889,456 IN CDBG-CV FUNDS

Councilwoman Smith moved to continue this public hearing to update the 2020-21 Action Plan until October 27, 2020.

Item V-A · RES 20-182 · Zoning & Land Use · Resolution

Resolution to permanently close a portion of an unopened right-of-way known as Gayle Street

Passed7–0 · Moved by Brian Haynes, seconded by Sheneika Smith

All members present voted yes.

Public hearing continued from Sep 22, 2020

No one from the public spoke.

Mayor Manheimer said that this public hearing was held on September 22, 2020, and in accordance with recent legislation amending North Carolina G.S. § 166A-19.24(e), regarding public hearings conducted during remote meetings, written comments for this public hearing were accepted for an additional 24 hours. … Hearing no more public comment, Mayor Manheimer closed the public hearing

Key facts

  • Unopened right-of-way known as Gayle Street address
From the staff report

Adoption of a resolution to permanently close a portion of an unopened right-of-way known as Gayle Street.

  • James Sandusky Paris and Carson Kinlaw Delinger have petitioned for this closure asked for this item
Fiscal impact

There will be no fiscal impact related to this closure.

Staff’s stated reasons
  • The closure aides in meeting required setbacks.
  • This closure allows maximum land use potential for further development complying with Living Asheville - A Comprehensive Plan for our Future.
Before it reached Council
  • Multimodal Transportation Committee, June 24, 2020: approve — Recommended closing the right-of-way by unanimous vote
City Code sections

N. C. Gen. Stat. sec 160A-299

Staff: Greg Shuler, Public Works Director; Chad Bandy, Streets Division Manager.

Description in the minutes

Mayor Manheimer said that this public hearing was held on September 22, 2020, and in accordance with recent legislation amending North Carolina G.S. § 166A-19.24(e), regarding public hearings conducted during remote meetings, written comments for this public hearing were accepted for an additional 24 hours. Hearing no more public comment, Mayor Manheimer closed the public hearing and said that members of Council have previously received a copy of the ordinance and it would not be read.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item V-B-recuse · Administrative · Motion

Motion to recuse Mayor Manheimer due to conflict of interest on conditional zoning amendment (Ord. 4832)

Passed6–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Julie Mayfield

Yes: Brian Haynes, Julie Mayfield, S. Antanette Mosley, Sheneika Smith, Gwen Wisler, Keith Young  ·  Recused: Esther E. Manheimer

Key facts

At the request of Mayor Manheimer, Vice-Mayor Wisler moved to recuse Mayor Manheimer from participating in this matter during a conflict of interest. … Mayor Manheimer turned over the gavel to Vice-Mayor Wisler.

Description in the minutes

At the request of Mayor Manheimer,

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

Discussed, no vote

Manager’s report

30/60/90 DAY WORK PLAN

[Shaunda Sandford] said that there are 11 sites, 23 PODS (10 students in each POD) with 200 students. … Gene Bell, Housing Authority of the City of Asheville Board Member, spoke about the internet access for Housing Authority residents.

Presented by Debra Campbell, City Manager; Shaunda Sandford, Housing Authority of the City of Asheville Director of Resident Services; Kidada Wynn, Asheville City Schools Executive Director of Student Support Services; Gene Bell, Housing Authority of the City of Asheville Board Member.

Presentation: Manager's Report ↗

Council remarks

Gwen Wisler

  • Vice-Mayor Wisler asked if we can see what we can do to help the community participate in making a donation to this project.

S. Antanette Mosley

  • In response to Councilwoman Mosley, [Kidada Wynn] said that the overall quality is better for our children and they are excited about coming to our PODS everyday.

Sheneika Smith

  • Councilwoman Smith when she asked if there is a long-term vision.

Esther E. Manheimer

  • Mayor Manheimer said that there is a regional effort to bring free wifi access throughout the county, but complemented the Housing Authority team on moving forward.

Other business

INFORMAL DISCUSSION AND PUBLIC COMMENT

Mayor Manheimer announced that the continuation of the worksession held earlier today regarding the proposed hotel development regulations will be on October 27, 2020, at 2:30 p.m. That worksession will be remote and public comment will not be accepted. … In response to Mayor Manheimer, City Manager [Debra Campbell] explained the process for hiring a new Equity & Inclusion Director, which recruitment process will start in the next 2-3 week.

Presented by Debra Campbell, City Manager; Brad Branham, City Attorney.

Council remarks

Julie Mayfield

  • In response to Councilwoman Mayfield, City Manager [Debra Campbell] said that regarding the Re-imagining Public Safety Survey, many people did not fill out the demographic part of the survey but we did have a significant number of African Americans participate in the virtual conversations.

Esther E. Manheimer

  • In response to Mayor Manheimer, City Attorney [Brad Branham] said that regarding the Crossroads Development, the City is an adjoining property owner in that the City owns the existing Hominy Creek Greenway.

Open public comment 3 speakers · 4 topics, as the minutes list them

Work session, Tuesday, Oct 13, 2020 the agenda briefing after this meeting · 2:30 pm–4:25 pm

Presentation

Proposed Hotel Development Regulations

Because of time restraints, at 4:25 p.m., it was the consensus of Council to continue this worksession to a date to be determined.

Director of Planning & Urban Design Todd Okolichany reviewed with Council the key takeaways (1) Hotels can’t be “banned” out right; (2) Development impacts can be managed; and (3) New innovative tools to regulate hotel development approvals: (a) Hotel Overlay District; (b) Development and operational standards; (c) Public benefits; and (d) Design review and design guidelines.

Presented by Todd Okolichany, Director of Planning & Urban Design.

Document: Worksession - Hotel Development Standards ↗

Council remarks

Esther E. Manheimer

  • Mayor Manheimer felt that we will need to give clear direction to staff on whether we conceptually agree to the idea of this and want to move it forward for community input.

Julie Mayfield

  • Councilwoman Mayfield said that if we can’t get comfortable with this structure, are there other options.

Brian Haynes

  • Councilman Haynes felt we should make the public input points bar higher so projects do not get points for doing something minor.

Staff briefed on

  • Proposed hotel development regulations
  • Hotel Overlay District
  • Public benefits
  • Design review and design guidelines

This resource, to the best of its ability, is copied word for word from the official minutes, “…” marks words left out, and [brackets] a name the minutes give elsewhere. The minutes are the record. Staff report details are quoted from the city’s meeting documents, prepared before the vote.