Asheville City Council recorded 22 votes at its regular meeting on September 22, 2020; 3 drew at least one no vote and 1 failed. Most items fell under Boards & Appointments, Public Safety and Zoning & Land Use.
Met: 5 pm–9:35 pm. Voting: Brian Haynes, Esther E. Manheimer, Julie Mayfield, S. Antanette Mosley, Sheneika Smith, Gwen Wisler, Keith Young.
Votes 22 recorded · 7 substantive · 3 split
Item B · RES 20-160 · Utilities & Infrastructure · Resolution · consent agenda
Change order with CDM Smith Inc. for the Water System Distribution Project - Phase 2 professional services
Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Keith Young
All members present voted yes.
Key facts
$699,514change order with CDM Smith Inc.
$884,124original total contract
$1,583,638Professional Services Contract from a total amount of $884,124 to $1,583,638
CDM Smith Inc.contractor or recipient
Water Resources Capital Improvements Project Fund in the Small Waterline Replacement Projectsfunding source
Description in the minutes
Action Requested:
Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a change order with CDM Smith Inc. in the amount of $699,514 to increase the Water System Distribution Project 2 – Professional Services Contract from a total amount of $884,124 to $1,583,638.
Background:
On February 27, 2018, City Council adopted a resolution to authorize the City Manager to execute a professional services contract with CDM Smith, Inc. for the Water System Distribution Project 2.
The original total contract was for a not-to-exceed amount of $884,124 and the project work included: a survey, a hydraulic analysis, engineering design, construction administration, and other related professional services for approximately 10,600 linear feet of 24” potable water transmission main and all associated appurtenances along Patton Avenue from Craven Street to Haywood Road.
The original transmission main alignment along Patton Avenue assumed construction would be within the travel lanes and therefore the survey and preliminary design was performed for the new water transmission main to be located within the NCDOT right-of-way only.
On April 8, 2019, the preliminary plan was submitted for the required NCDOT Encroachment Agreement, which would allow the new water transmission main to be located within the NCDOT right-of-way; however this Encroachment Agreement was denied by NCDOT in accordance with its policy to not allow utilities to be placed under the roadway. Within the past five years, NCDOT has increased its enforcement of this policy.
The Water Resources Department appealed the decision to deny the NCDOT Encroachment Agreement via the hardship appeal process procedure provided by NCDOT. The hardship appeal was based on impacts to private property and additional project cost; however the appeal was also denied.
Because of the denial of the NCDOT Encroachment Agreement and subsequent appeal, the proposed water transmission main alignment had to be changed to be outside the NCDOT right-of-way to be installed within private property throughout the project corridor.
This change in alignment of the 24” water transmission line created the requirement for an additional survey to be performed and a new design drawing to be developed which added a significant cost increase to the professional services contract.
Also moving the new water transmission main onto private property creates the need to obtain 37 permanent and temporary construction easements for the installation of the proposed transmission main which requires additional funds to be added to the project for easement acquisition specialists, preparation of easement plats and documents, appraisals and purchase of the necessary easements. These efforts and associated costs were not considered in the original contract scope since the plan did not impact private property.
Over the course of the design phase, CDM Smith also discovered three (3) North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality – Division of Waste Management (DWM) sites located adjacent to the new alignment requiring the additional services for assessment of potential impacts from residual contamination associated with the three sites.
Water Resources Staff requested that the consultant provide an amended scope with the additional tasks and cost outlined. The proposed change order request is based on the amended scope.
It is anticipated that the final project design and easement acquisition will take approximately 9 months being completed by July 2021. Following completion of the design phase, construction of the project is projected to begin in September 2021 with an 18 month duration.
Vendor Outreach Efforts:
Not applicable, change to an existing contract
Council Goal(s):
A Financially Resilient City
Committee(s):
None.
Pro(s):
This project is aligned with the City and the Water Resources Department goal of continued investment and improvement of the City’s water system through Capital Improvement Projects to provide safe and reliable service.
Con(s):
None
Fiscal Impact:
The funding needed for the professional services agreement is currently allocated within the Water Resources Capital Improvements Project Fund in the Small Waterline Replacement Projects.
Staff: David Melton, Water Resources Director; Chad Pierce, Engineering Services Manager.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Item C · RES 20-161 · Utilities & Infrastructure · Resolution · consent agenda
Contract with T&K Utilities Inc. for the Water System Neighborhood Enhancement Project Area 5 Part 1
Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Keith Young
All members present voted yes.
Key facts
$3,810,200bid amount
$381,02010% contingency
$4,191,220total project budget
T&K Utilities Inc.contractor or recipient
Small Waterline Replacement Projects” within the Water Resources Capital Improvement Fundfunding source
Description in the minutes
Action Requested:
Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a construction agreement with T&K Utilities, Inc., for the Water System Neighborhood Enhancement Project Area 5 Part 1 Project.
Background:
On July 28, 2020, the Water Resources Department (WRD) issued an Advertisement for Bids for the Water System Neighborhood Enhancement Project Area 5 Part 1 Project.
The scope of work for this project includes the installation of approximately 12,100 LF of 6-inch, 5,000 LF of 8-inch, and 1,200 LF of 12-inch ductile iron water line along with related appurtenances and materials required to complete the work located along various streets within the following areas:
Muirfield Subdivision
Mills Gap Road
Swannanoa River Road
S. Tunnel Road
Brookwood Road
Brevard Road
Hazel Mill Road
Joe Jenkins Road
This proposed project has been determined to be a critical installation that will increase the water systems reliability by replacing undersized and older waterlines that have high failure rates and also by providing improved water pressure and flow characteristics for domestic service and fire fighting capabilities.
Thomas Construction Company, Inc.; Johnson City, TN – Bid: $5,838,960
Following a review of the bids by City Staff and WK Dickson & Co., Inc., the project engineers; T&K Utilities, Inc.was selected as the lowest responsible, responsive bidder.
The WRD requests authorization to contract with T&K Utilities, Inc. for the bid amount of $3,810,200 plus a 10% contingency in the amount of $381,020 for a total project budget in the amount of $4,191,220.
Vendor Outreach Efforts:
Staff performed outreach to minority and women owned businesses through the solicitation processes which include posting on the State’s Interactive Purchasing System and requiring prime contractors to reach out to Minority & Women-Owned Business Enterprise (MWBE) service providers for subcontracted services.
MWBE owned businesses are being utilized as subcontractors for traffic control and asphalt paving by prime contractors.
Council Goal(s):
A Financially Resilient City and a Clean and Healthy Environment.
Committee(s):
Not Applicable.
Pro(s):
This project is aligned with the City and the Water Resources Department goal of continued investment and improvement of the City’s water system through Capital Improvement Projects to provide safe and reliable service.
Con(s):
None.
Fiscal Impact:
Funds needed for this construction agreement are already budgeted in the “Small Waterline Replacement Projects” within the Water Resources Capital Improvement Fund.
Staff: David Melton, Water Resources Director; Chad Pierce, Engineering Services Manager.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Item F · RES 20-164 · Public Safety · Resolution · consent agenda
Contract with Carolina Specialities Construction LLC to expand the Skyland Fire Department at 9 Miller Road South for Fire Station #4
Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Keith Young
All members present voted yes.
Key facts
$524,516contract with Carolina Specialities Construction LLC
$68,187contingency amount
9 MILLER ROAD SOUTHaddress
Carolina Specialities Construction, LLCcontractor or recipient
Adopted Capital Improvement Program budgetfunding source
Description in the minutes
Fire Station #4; and further authorizing the City Manager to execute any change orders that may arise during the project up to the contingency amount of $68,187 (13%).
Action Requested:
Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to enter into a contract with Carolina Specialities Construction, LLC. in the amount of $524,516 to renovate a building for Fire Station #4; and further authorizing the City Manager to execute any change orders that may arise during the project up to the contingency amount of $68,187 (13%).
Background:
AFD Station #4 was built in the mid 1990’s as a 6,800 sq. ft. building that is attached to the end of the existing Skyland Fire Department building at 9 Miller Road.
At the time, the City owned portion of the station was not fully built-out for the fire department, and until recently, AFD shared the space with an Asheville Police substation. As a result, the City of Asheville Fire Department occupied shared living quarters with the Skyland Fire Department.
The Skyland Fire Department has identified a need for the space that AFD currently occupies and has requested that the City vacate the shared space.
This project will renovate the existing City owned space to create living quarters and dedicated operations space for Fire and allows the City to completely vacate the Skyland portion of the building.
The project will include interior renovations, building envelope repairs, and high efficiency mechanical systems.
Skyland Fire & Rescue has asked AFD to vacate their portion of the facility by May 1, 2021.
Bids were advertised on August 12, 2020. The City received and opened seven bids on September 3, 2020. The names of the contractors and bid amounts (with selected alternates) are listed below:
J. Bartholomew Construction, LLC., Hendersonville, NC $642,190.00
Patton Construction Group, Inc., Asheville, NC $592,860.00
Simpson Young Construction, LLC., Arden, NC $559,693.55
Carolina Specialties Construction, LLC. was the lowest responsible responsive bidder.
This project will start immediately with a target substantial completion date of April 1, 2021.
The property and the building are owned by Skyland Volunteer Fire Department.
The City is in year 25 of a 99 year lease of $1 per year agreement. The agreement allows for Skyland FD to sell the property. If they do so, the agreement states that the City shall receive the fair market value of the City’s portion of the building structure. These improvements are considered “the City’s portion” of the building.
Vendor Outreach Efforts:
Staff performed outreach to minority and women owned businesses through solicitation processes which include posting on the State’s Interactive Purchasing System and requiring prime contractors to reach out to Minority & Women-Owned Business Enterprise (MWBE) service providers for subcontracted services. None of the general contractors that bid on the project were WMBE.
Carolina Specialties Construction will subcontract with AOA Signs, Inc. which is a Woman-Owned business located in Yadkinville, NC.
Council Goal(s):
A well-planned and livable community
A thriving local economy
A clean and healthy environment
Committee(s):
None
Pro(s):
A better workplace/living environment for Asheville Fire Fighters.
The work will not impact the current operations at the station.
High Efficiency HVAC System Upgrade (In collaboration with the Office of Sustainability)
Seven bids were received and all were close to the construction cost estimate.
Con(s):
Although this project will bring the facility into full operation, it will still be undersized in comparison to contemporary fire stations.
Fiscal Impact:
Funding for this contract is already included in the adopted Capital Improvement Program budget.
Staff: Jade Dundas, Capital Projects Director.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
1 spoke · changed before the vote · 2 council remarks
Recommendations
HCD: Approve, unanimous, August 18, 2020
Public comment on this item
1 spoke in favor · 0 spoke against
ForAl Clement · applicant, The Juna Group Inc. — Al Clement, developer, thanked City Council for their support so far. He explained how home ownership can be a powerful tool to lift people up. … He has reached out to the Asheville-Buncombe Community Land Trust, OnTrack Financial and Habitat for Homes to help find people who may qualify for these homes
No advanced live call-ins for this matter.
What council members said 2 remarks from 2 members
OpposesVice-Mayor Wisler supported home ownership, but could not support the project without a guarantee of lower than 100% AMI. She was troubled by the idea of allowing the option for 120% since that does not fit in our Affordable Housing Policy. … And mostly she was concerned about the 10 year affordability.
The minutes record no remarks on this item from Brian Haynes, Esther E. Manheimer, S. Antanette Mosley, Sheneika Smith and Keith Young.
Changed before the vote 1 change recorded
Staff revisionthey agreed not to put anything in any of the loan documents about the 120% AMI request after 6 months
Key facts
$1.1 millionHousing Trust Fund Loan
$770,000the remaining 11 lots of 1.1 acres
“Alice Clement Lane”, currently known as Shakedown Street, (PIN #9657-88-4092)address
1.1 acressite size
11 units11 of them affordable
available to be sold to individuals and families at or below 100% of the Area Median Income (AMI)affordability
Al Clement d/b/a, the Juna Group Inc.applicant
The Juna Group Inc.contractor or recipient
City’s Housing Trust Fund (HTF)funding source
over a period not to exceed 2 years at 1% annual interest rate, with no payments due until the full payment is due, maximum 2 yearsterm
Presented by Paul D'Angelo, Community Development Programs Director.
From the staff report
Approve a request by The Juna Group Inc. to utilize a Housing Trust Fund Loan of $1.1M to construct 11 affordable single family homes on property located at Alice Clement Lane in the Oakley area.
a request by The Juna Group Inc.asked for this item
$1.1 millionThe project would require
$770,000valued at
Housing Trust Fundfunding source
1.1 acresAlice Clement Lane
The Juna Group Inc.applicant
9657-88-4092parcel ID (PIN)
Fiscal impact
The project would require $1,100,000 from the City’s HTF.
Before it reached Council
HCD, August 18, 2020: approve — Unanimously approved
Conditions
The homes will come with a deed restriction of affordability for 10 years, meaning if the home is sold within that time period, the owner will sell it to another income qualified family at or below 100% AMI.
Staff: Sam Powers, Community & Economic Development Director; Paul D'Angelo, CD Program Director.
Description in the minutes
Community Development Programs Director Paul D’Angela said that this is a request by The Juna Group Inc. to utilize a Housing Trust Fund Loan of $1.1M to construct 11 affordable single family homes on property located at Alice Clement Lane in the Oakley area.
Background:
Al Clement d/b/a, the Juna Group Inc., an African American Developer, has proposed the development of 11 single family homes available to be sold to individuals and families at or below 100% of the Area Median Income (AMI) on a 1.1 acre parcel (each home .10 acre) to be constructed on “Alice Clement Lane”, currently known as Shakedown Street, (PIN #9657-88-4092) in the City of Asheville, directly off Broadview Street. All 11 homes are intended to be at least 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths and approximately 1300 sq. ft.
Beginning in 2017, Al Clement purchased 4.8 acres, with 2.6 of the acres buildable.
Plans were submitted to the City of Asheville to develop 19 lots on the 2.6 acres.
Approval was received June, 2018, and in July, 2018, construction began on infrastructure.
The Infrastructure and eight of the homes are either complete or will be completed soon.
The developer is requesting Housing Trust Fund dollars for the remaining eleven homes.
The Juna Group Inc. consists of Al Clement, owner, and his brother David Clement, Project Manager. Proposal:
The developer seeks a loan of $1,100,000 from the City’s Housing Trust Fund (HTF). The Juna Group Inc. needs this funding, $100,000 per home, to complete Phase 2 of 5 homes and Phase 3 of 6 homes for a total of 11 single family homes.
The Juna Group Inc. is committing the property, the remaining 11 lots of 1.1 acres, (valued at $770,000) as equity.
The Juna Group Inc. proposes to borrow $1.1M over a period not to exceed 2 years at 1% annual interest rate, with no payments due until the full payment is due, maximum 2 years.
Units will be made available to qualified affordable individuals and families with a sale price of approximately $275,000, a sales figure that can work with a 100% AMI family.
However, the developer with assistance from City staff, will attempt to find buyers below 100% AMI, down to 80% AMI, that can qualify for these 11 homes with the help of Down Payment Assistance Programs.
The developer is committed to finding individuals and families, in partnership with the City and other agencies like Habitat for Humanity and affordable housing lenders, between 80%-100% to purchase these homes.
The homes will come with a deed restriction of affordability for 10 years, meaning if the home is sold within that time period, the owner will sell it to another income qualified family at or below 100% AMI.
The City will work in partnership to help find buyers that qualify and a sales figure that works.
The developer has requested that if a qualified individual or family between 80%
100% AMI can not be found within 6 months of the issuance of the Certificate of Occupancy, the developer can move to find an individual or family at or below 120% of AMI to purchase the home. Staff is committed to assisting in the marketing effort of the home and finding a qualified buyer between 80%-100% AMI.
Committee(s):
HCD
August 18, 2020
Unanimously approved
Pro(s):
The project produces 11 homes for individuals and families at between 80%
100% AMI at a location near the City’s core, with good access to transit and essential services.
The developer has successfully completed Phase 1 of Alice Clement Lane and demonstrated capacity with both Community Development and Development Services.
Working with the Juna Group Inc. shows the City of Asheville’s commitment to working with other developers, including for-profit developers, to be a part of the solution to affordable housing, both rental and homeownership.
Affordable homes sold to individuals or families between 80%
100% AMI at a sales price that better aligns with the incomes and wages produced in Asheville allows residents to have an opportunity to build wealth with homeownership.
HTF loans for homeownership allow the funds to be paid back much quicker, at either the sale of the home, or a limited time period like 2 years.
An affordability period of 10 years helps protect the City’s investment in affordable housing.
Con(s):
Loan amount per unit is above the Housing Trust Policy’s recommendation of $20,000 per unit.
The affordability period is just 10 years.
Fiscal Impact:
The project would require $1,100,000 from the City’s HTF. Mr. D’Angelo said that after doing some research, it shows only 40 homes for sale in the City of Asheville under $275,000, with an average & median price above $550,000 for all 303 listings. Outside of Habitat, who builds maybe 15 to 18 homes a year, Mountain Housing Opportunities who helps with DPA, maybe 24 homes a year, and now the CLT, we have no solution on the table for homeownership. We need more local, infill developers to help us out. This is hard to make the numbers work. This will help expand the pool of developers. The Juna Group is a local and infill developer. Mr. Al Clement, developer, thanked City Council for their support so far. He explained how home ownership can be a powerful tool to lift people up. He will continue to work with Mr. D’Angelo to get the $275,000 down, but noted that as soon as someone moves in, they will already have equity in the home. He has reached out to the Asheville-Buncombe Community Land Trust, OnTrack Financial and Habitat for Homes to help find people who may qualify for these homes, along with banks who are familiar with down payment assistance programs. Councilwoman Mayfield suggested Mr. Clement also reach out to the Housing Authority who has a home ownership program. Vice-Mayor Wisler supported home ownership, but could not support the project without a guarantee of lower than 100% AMI. She was troubled by the idea of allowing the option for 120% since that does not fit in our Affordable Housing Policy. She was also troubled by the fact that the collateral is less than the loan value. And mostly she was concerned about the 10 year affordability. Mr. D’Angelo said that he spoke with Mr. Clement and they agreed not to put anything in any of the loan documents about the 120% AMI request after 6 months. He said he has been speaking to Mr. Clement for 14 months and he has been committed to trying to be part of the solution on affordable housing. He could not tell you how hard affordable housing is, let alone affordable for homeownership. The number of units currently for sale speak for themselves. We are making great headway in rental, with over 420 units he believed over the past 18 months. We still need many more. But regarding homeownership, we need to think creatively and effectively to get more homes for sale and he thought this is a very good start. He also believed we can protect our investment with oversight. Mayor Manheimer announced that there were no advanced live call-ins for this matter. Mayor Manheimer said that members of Council have been previously furnished with a copy of the resolution and it would not be read.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Item NB-C · ORD 4828 · Zoning & Land Use · Ordinance
Ordinance extending the temporary moratorium (expiring no later than February 23, 2021)
Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Julie Mayfield
All members present voted yes.
Recommendations
Council’s vote matched the city staff recommendation.
City staff (staff report): Approve — Staff recommends that the temporary moratorium on new hotel development be extended until November 24, 2020
Key facts
for five months so that it expires no later than February 23, 2021term
From the staff report
Extension of an ordinance imposing a temporary moratorium on hotel development approvals within the City of Asheville.
Fiscal impact
None
Staff’s stated reasons · approve
The COVID-19 pandemic delayed opportunities for community engagement early in the planning process
During the pandemic, city staff and resources were redirected to address other priority community needs
Additional time is needed to complete the hotel development study, conduct additional community engagement, draft the proposed zoning amendments and present the new zoning amendments to the Asheville City Council for consideration of adoption.
City Code sections
N.C.G.S. 160A-381
Staff: Todd Okolichany, Planning & Urban Design Director; Stacy Merten, Principal Planner; Brad Branham, City Attorney; Jannice Ashley, Assistant City Attorney.
Description in the minutes
Mayor Manheimer said that this public hearing was held on September 8, 2020, and in accordance with recent legislation amending North Carolina G.S. § 166A-19.24(e), regarding public hearings conducted during remote meetings, written comments for this public hearing were accepted for an additional 24 hours. After receiving additional written public comment, Mayor Manheimer closed the public hearing and said that members of Council have previously received a copy of the ordinance and it would not be read.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Council’s vote matched the city staff recommendation.
City staff (staff report): Approve — staff is recommending the attached amendment to the FY 2020-21 budget ordinance.
Public comment on this item
One hearing covered this item and agenda item NB-D-deny; the counts are for the whole hearing.
0 spoke in favor · 0 spoke against · 9 stance not recorded
From advanced live call-ins, nine individuals spoke to Council, including, but not limited to the following comments: significant rise in the City’s population, 911 calls for service, daytime population, etc. in a 10 year timespan; need to continue to invest in our APD and make sure our officers are replaced when there are vacancies and trained; opposed to adoption of this budget amendment; need to dismantle the APD which is a malfunctioning institution; equity should be a part of every aspect; opposition to any budget cuts to the APD; and institute a hard freeze on hiring in the APD. The minutes give counts but do not name the speakers.
What council members said 7 remarks from 6 members
ConcernCouncilman Haynes said it has been brought to his attention that for a cost of $33,615 a year we can bring the 35 firefighters that are currently being paid less than a living wage, based on their 56 hour work week, up to a living wage.
QuestionCouncilwoman Mayfield said that we are hearing different information and suggested a small meeting with perhaps Councilman Haynes, some firefighters, the City Manager and the Human Resources Director so we can all agree on the numbers and the impact of those numbers.
SupportsThese are only the first steps at shifting APD resources in order to better utilize them in other departments and better serve the public. … For example, we are in deep discussions with the county, MAHEC, Homeward Bound and other partners about a new model … So voting no tonight is not an option for me
SupportsVice-Mayor Wisler confirmed that City staff and Council is willing and committed to making changes to the current year’s budget as soon as new initiatives are identified and vetted.
SupportsHe knows this is just the beginning. He also stated it’s a grave mischaracterization when people think when they call the police there won’t be anyone there to answer your call because they have been defunded.
OpposesThat is why she could not support the budget amendment. … She would have liked to have seen a dollar amount put towards that so we can be assured that we are being heard and investment is being considered.
CommentAs we move this forward and make changes, safety will be her priority in reimagining public safety.
The minutes record no remarks on this item from S. Antanette Mosley.
Key facts
$770,000Total of approximately $770,000
$220,0004 Animal Control positions (reassigned to DSD)
$110,0001 Assistant to the Chief position (funding reassigned to CAPE; individual moving into another position)
$90,0002 Park Warden positions
$300,0006 Telecommunicator positions (all currently vacant; funding being reassigned to ITS and DSD)
$50,000Salary savings from sworn police officer positions (resignations between July and September - one-time)
Mayor Manheimer agreed with the small meeting and then the Finance & Human Resources Committee can review the numbers.
Presented by Debra Campbell, City Manager; Tony McDowell, Assistant Finance Director of Finance Budget & Forecasting.
From the staff report
Adopt an ordinance amending the FY 2020-21 annual budget to provide City departments with a full year of operational funding.
$770,000reallocation and reinvestment of approximately
Fiscal impact
There is no change to the overall total General Fund budget that City Council adopted on July 30, 2020.
Staff’s stated reasons · approve
Provides departments with full annual funding for fiscal year 2020-21.
Incorporates community input based on the initial review of survey results, other communications, and engagement efforts.
Staff: Barbara Whitehorn, CFO, Finance and Management Services Director.
Description in the minutes
City Manager Campbell said Assistant Finance Director of Finance Budget & Forecasting Tony McDowell will provide you with an overview of the budget process; give a brief financial update; present the FY 2020-21 Manager’s recommended budget amendment (reimagining public safety; and investment recommendations); and explain the next steps for the FY 2021-22 budget process. Mr. McDowell said that this is the consideration of an ordinance amending the FY 2020-21 annual budget to provide City departments with a full year of operational funding.
Background:
On July 30, 2020, City Council adopted the Fiscal Year (FY) 2020-21 annual budget ordinance with each department receiving funding in its budget for operations through the end of September, with the remaining budget being held in reserve in non-departmental.
Over the last two months, the City Manager’s Office has completed a community engagement process to evaluate investments in the Asheville Police Department, other City departments, and various community programs.
Influenced by the input from the community engagement process, staff is recommending the amendment to the FY 2020-21 budget ordinance.
The budget amendment includes the reallocation and reinvestment of approximately $770,000 from the Proposed FY 2020-21 Police Department budget that was presented to City Council in May 2020.
Specific prioritized recommendations are based on the initial review of the survey results, other communications and engagement efforts (open data initiative), and on what we can do and do well right now.
Focus areas for initial reinvestment/reallocation are outlined below. a. Nuisance Response:
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Council’s vote matched the city staff recommendation.
City staff (staff report): Approve — staff is recommending the attached amendment to the FY 2020-21 budget ordinance.
Public comment on this item
0 spoke in favor · 0 spoke against · 9 stance not recorded
From advanced live call-ins, nine individuals spoke to Council, including, but not limited to the following comments: significant rise in the City’s population, 911 calls for service, daytime population, etc. in a 10 year timespan; need to continue to invest in our APD and make sure our officers are replaced when there are vacancies and trained; opposed to adoption of this budget amendment; need to dismantle the APD which is a malfunctioning institution; equity should be a part of every aspect; opposition to any budget cuts to the APD; and institute a hard freeze on hiring in the APD. The minutes give counts but do not name the speakers.
What council members said 2 remarks from 2 members
OpposesCouncilman Haynes moved to deny the budget amendment because it does not advance our stated goals and instead perpetuates systematic racism when we have a generous call for community healing which includes a demand that 50% of APD’s budget won’t be invested back into the Black communities.
SupportsThis motion was seconded by Councilwoman Smith.
The minutes record no remarks on this item from Esther E. Manheimer, Julie Mayfield, S. Antanette Mosley, Gwen Wisler and Keith Young.
Key facts
$770,000reallocation and reinvestment of approximately $770,000 from the Proposed FY 2020-21 Police Department budget
Presented by Tony McDowell, Assistant Finance Director of Finance Budget & Forecasting.
From the staff report
Adopt an ordinance amending the FY 2020-21 annual budget to provide City departments with a full year of operational funding.
$770,000reallocation and reinvestment of approximately
Fiscal impact
There is no change to the overall total General Fund budget that City Council adopted on July 30, 2020.
Staff’s stated reasons · approve
Provides departments with full annual funding for fiscal year 2020-21.
Incorporates community input based on the initial review of survey results, other communications, and engagement efforts.
Staff: Barbara Whitehorn, CFO, Finance and Management Services Director.
Description in the minutes
City Manager Campbell said Assistant Finance Director of Finance Budget & Forecasting Tony McDowell will provide you with an overview of the budget process; give a brief financial update; present the FY 2020-21 Manager’s recommended budget amendment (reimagining public safety; and investment recommendations); and explain the next steps for the FY 2021-22 budget process. Mr. McDowell said that this is the consideration of an ordinance amending the FY 2020-21 annual budget to provide City departments with a full year of operational funding.
Background:
On July 30, 2020, City Council adopted the Fiscal Year (FY) 2020-21 annual budget ordinance with each department receiving funding in its budget for operations through the end of September, with the remaining budget being held in reserve in non-departmental.
Over the last two months, the City Manager’s Office has completed a community engagement process to evaluate investments in the Asheville Police Department, other City departments, and various community programs.
Influenced by the input from the community engagement process, staff is recommending the amendment to the FY 2020-21 budget ordinance.
The budget amendment includes the reallocation and reinvestment of approximately $770,000 from the Proposed FY 2020-21 Police Department budget that was presented to City Council in May 2020.
Specific prioritized recommendations are based on the initial review of the survey results, other communications and engagement efforts (open data initiative), and on what we can do and do well right now.
Focus areas for initial reinvestment/reallocation are outlined below. a. Nuisance Response:
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Show the other 15 votes · consent agenda and routine items · consent agenda moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Keith Young
Item D · RES 20-162 · Public Safety · Resolution · consent agenda
Resolution authorizing the City Manager to enter into a renewal agreement for automatic aid service with Reem's Creek Fire Department
Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Keith Young
All members present voted yes.
Key facts
$91,733.36renewal for the FY20-21 services
Reem's Creek Fire Departmentcontractor or recipient
The term of the renewal agreement will end June 30, 2021term
Description in the minutes
Action Requested:
Adoption of the renewal of the automatic aid agreement between the City of Asheville and Reems Creek Fire Department.
Background:
In August 2013, City Council approved a resolution authorizing a multi-year agreement with Reem’s Creek Fire Department for automatic aid service
The City of Asheville has a need to strengthen its standard of response and cover in the Beaverdam Valley and the Reem’s Creek Fire Department is the most appropriate organization to provide the service
The initial agreement costs were $82,656 and as stipulated in the agreement, the costs are to be adjusted every year based on the consumer price index
After seven years of positive consumer price index increases, the renewal for the FY20-21 services cost and are budgeted at $91,733.36
The term of the renewal agreement will end June 30, 2021
Vendor Outreach Efforts:
No other vendors are able to provide this service
There are no Minority & Women-Owned Business Enterprise (MWBE) firms able to provide this service
Council Goal(s):
Connected and Engaged Community
Committee(s):
None
Pro(s):
Allows standard of cover to be met greater than 90% of the time.
Con(s):
Fiscal impact.
Fiscal Impact:
Execution of the agreement renewal is budgeted at and costs $91,733.36.
Staff: Scott Burnette, Asheville Fire Chief; Abigail Riley, Financial Business Manager.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Item E · RES 20-163 · Public Safety · Resolution · consent agenda
Resolution authorizing the City Manager to enter into a 2020 contract with the N.C. Dept. of Public Safety for hazardous materials emergency response services
Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Keith Young
All members present voted yes.
Key facts
$69,000administration, equipment, training, medical surveillance, and workman’s compensation
State of North Carolina Department of Public Safety Division of Emergency Managementcontractor or recipient
State of North Carolinafunding source
November 1, 2020 - June 30, 2024term
Description in the minutes
Action Requested:
Adoption of 2020 Contract Agreement for the State Regional Hazardous Materials Response Team Number Six (6).
Background:
North Carolina is divided into seven geographical regions for the purpose of hazardous material emergency response.
The North Carolina Department of Public Safety contracts with municipalities across North Carolina to respond into the geographical regions and provide technician level hazardous materials emergency response.
The region's six areas encompass the westernmost twenty counties.
The City of Asheville has been a regional hazardous materials provider since Fiscal Year 1994-1995.
The State of North Carolina provides funding that fully supports the operational costs of the program.
The City receives $69,000 annually for administration, equipment, training, medical surveillance, and workman’s compensation.
The truck and equipment provided to the City by the State for use on State and local hazmat missions are valued at $1.5 million.
The City is reimbursed at 100% of the costs expended when the team is deployed for a state mission.
City Council approved an extension of the current agreement due to circumstances surrounding COVID-19, the North Carolina Department of Public Safety Division of Emergency Management wanted to activate the fifth-year extension clause of the agreement for four months with the City of Asheville for Hazardous Materials Emergency Response Services from July 1, 2020 through October 31, 2020.
The new agreement is for November 1, 2020
June 30, 2024.
Vendor Outreach Efforts:
Contract is with the State of North Carolina Department of Public Safety Division of Emergency Management.
Council Goal(s):
Smart City
Committee(s):
None
Pro(s):
The State of North Carolina provides the hazardous materials response truck, all response equipment and provides for administrative costs of operating the team.
In addition, the state funds extensive training for members of the Asheville Fire Department to enable us to competently handle hazardous materials emergencies.
The City of Asheville has full use of the truck and all specialty equipment within the City of Asheville.
Without the state hazardous materials contract, Asheville taxpayers would need to provide much of the resources necessary to properly respond to hazardous materials emergencies within Asheville.
With the contract, we have the advantage of the equipment and resources being funded at the state level, rather than at the local level.
During the twenty nine years that the City has provided regional hazardous materials response services, the City has not experienced difficulties or disadvantages with the program. This program is also consistent with the City’s Strategic Operating Plan in partnership.
Firefighter and citizen safety will be enhanced.
Con(s):
None have been identified or known at this time
Fiscal Impact:
The City receives a $69,000 reimbursement annually for training, equipment, medical surveillance, and worker’s compensation.
Staff: Scott Burnette, Asheville Fire Chief; Abby Moore, Emergency Management Specialist.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Item G · RES 20-165 · Utilities & Infrastructure · Resolution · consent agenda
Supplemental agreement with Cavanaugh and Associates for the advanced metering infrastructure request for proposals
Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Keith Young
All members present voted yes.
Key facts
$175,520supplemental agreement to the master agreement
Cavanaugh and Associatescontractor or recipient
AMR Replacement Project” in the Capital Improvement Program Fundfunding source
Description in the minutes
Action Requested:
Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a supplemental agreement to the master agreement in the amount of $175,520 with Cavanaugh and Associates to develop, facilitate, and complete the RFP process for the selection of a new Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) system and third-party contract manufacturer and installer.
Background:
The City's customer water metering system consists of approximately 60,000 meters which are read mainly using drive-by Automated Meter Reading (AMR) radio technology.
The City installed its current metering system from 2009-2012. The Automated Meter Reading equipment is reaching the end of its lifecycle and is beginning to fail.
Advancements in metering technology have greatly increased this lifecycle and increased warranty periods.
This issue requires staff to begin the process of implementing a long-term strategy for meter asset management.
During FY19, Meter Services collaborated with the Customer Service, GIS, IT, and Administrative management staff to form a Customer Metering Task Force. The task force developed a customer metering strategic plan with technical support from Cavanaugh and Associates.
A business-case recommendation was developed for the City of Asheville.
This recommendation includes a wholesale replacement of all 2” and smaller water meters with new meter assemblies, implementing a fixed-base network meter reading system, AMI and retrofit meters 3” and larger to the AMI reading system.
The recommended mechanism for product selection and installation is utilization of a third-party contract manufacturer and installer, procured via Request for Qualifications & Proposal (RFP) process.
Vendor Outreach Efforts:
Through a qualifications-based selection process beginning in February 2020, the City of Asheville selected nine consulting firms to provide on-call professional services for an array of different types of water system projects.
Cavanaugh and Associates was one of the selected firms due to their expertise in areas of non-revenue water, metering systems, etc.
The City of Asheville entered into a master agreement with Cavanaugh and Associates on August 31, 2020 for on-call professional services valid for three years with the option to renew for two additional years.
If approved, the proposed services described here within will be developed into a subcontract under the conditions of the master agreement.
City of Asheville Water Resources Staff determined that utilizing the on-call professional services for General Projects was the best method to deliver this project and Cavanaugh and Associates was the most qualified of the on-call firms.
Based on the current master agreement, no additional vendor outreach was performed.
Council Goal(s):
A Financially Resilient City
Committee(s):
None.
Pro(s):
This project will be the initial step in updating metering and reading infrastructure that is reaching the end of its useful life cycle.
The project will result in improvements to efficiency of operations, through significant reduction in the number of trucks on the road to read meters.
This reduction will also decrease the City’s carbon footprint associated with Metering Services operations.
This project will ultimately result in water customers having access to more timely data and provide customers with the ability to monitor and better manage their water usage.
This project will provide the framework for monthly billing processes.
Con(s):
Failure to approve resolution will result in a delay in the process of exchanging equipment that has reached the end of its life.
Fiscal Impact:
The Water Resources Department currently has the funds needed for this agreement budgeted in the “AMR Replacement Project” in the Capital Improvement Program Fund.
Total agreement cost of $175,520.
Staff: David Melton, Water Resources Director; Brandon Buckner, Metering Services Manager.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
N.C. Governor's Highway Safety Programcontractor or recipient
The total of the grant is $5,000 and does not require local matching fundsfunding source
Description in the minutes
Action Requested:
Adoption of a resolution authorizing the Mayor to apply for and accept a grant, in the amount of $5,000, for the North Carolina Governor’s Highway Safety Program, BikeSafe 2021 Grant, Year 2; and adopt the associated budget amendment, in the amount of $5,000.
Background:
The Bike/Safe NC program is a partnership with the Governor’s Highway Safety Program and the North Carolina State Highway Patrol that is aimed at reducing motorcycle fatalities.
Grant funds will be used to promote awareness by contacting motorcycle dealers, clubs and associations to discuss current highway safety activities, training opportunities and to provide legal updates.
The Asheville Police Department will act as fiduciary for the program.
The total of the grant is $5,000 and does not require local matching funds.
Council Goal(s):
A Connected and Engaged Community
Committee(s):
None
Pro(s):
Grant funds are used to pay for travel and training.
Potential reduction of statewide and regional motorcycle fatalities.
Con(s):
Funding is evaluated annually and is only available for a one-year period.
Fiscal Impact:
There is no local match required.
Staff: Elise Lewis, APD Financial Business Manager.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Item I · RES 20-167 / ORD 4827 · Public Safety · Resolution · consent agenda
Federal Emergency Management Agency grant for the Fire Prevention & Safety Program; and budget amendment
Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Keith Young
All members present voted yes.
Key facts
$42,884added safety equipment to outfit its investigators
$2,145matching funds
$45,029a budget amendment in the City’s Special Revenue Fund
Federal Emergency Management Agencycontractor or recipient
To receive the funds the City has a one-time match of $2,145 which will be taken from the adopted Fire Department FY 2020-21 operating budget.funding source
Description in the minutes
Action Requested:
Adoption of a resolution for City Council to authorize the City Manager to accept grant funds from the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) for the Fire Prevention & Safety Grant and a budget amendment in the City’s Special Revenue Fund in the amount of $45,029 utilizing the $42,884 in grant funds and $2,145 in matching funds.
Background:
In March 2020, the Asheville Fire Department applied for FEMA’s Fire Prevention & Safety Grant for specialized equipment for fire investigators.
In September 2020, the Department was awarded $42,884 for this added safety equipment to outfit its investigators.
The equipment to be purchased includes specialized Personal Protective Equipment, reliable lighting, documentation tools (such as software), and excavation tools.
Additionally, the funds will be used for supplies that have the ability to decontaminate the equipment and tools without the fire investigator having to call a suppression company on scene.
FEMA is requiring a match by the City of $2,145.
The Department requests City Council to approve acceptance of the grant award and allow for a budget amendment to assign the grant funds in the City’s Special Revenue Fund.
Vendor Outreach Efforts:
N/A
Council Goal(s):
Smart City
Committee(s):
None
Pro(s):
The grant increases firefighter safety.
The grant enables investigators to effectively manage a multi-day fire scene without having to take a suppression company out of service to provide support.
Con(s):
The City’s total match over the two year period of performance is $2,145.
Fiscal Impact:
To receive the funds the City has a one-time match of $2,145 which will be taken from the adopted Fire Department FY 2020-21 operating budget.
Staff: Scott Burnette, Asheville Fire Chief; Abigail Riley, Financial Business Manager.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Public hearing to permanently close a portion of an unopened right-of-way (continued)
Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Julie Mayfield
All members present voted yes.
Recommendations
Multimodal Transportation Committee: Approve, unanimous, June 24, 2020
Public hearing advertised Aug 28, 2020 and Sep 4, 2020 and Sep 11, 2020 and Sep 18, 2020
No one from the public spoke.
Mayor Manheimer announced that there were no advanced live call-ins for this public hearing. … written comments for this public hearing will be accepted for an additional 24 hours.
Key facts
99999 Morse Drive (Pin # 9627-22-9286)address
James Sandusky Paris and Carson Kinlaw Delingerapplicant
Vice-Mayor Wisler moved to recess this item until October 13, 2020, at which time this public hearing will be voted.
Presented by Chad Bandy, Streets Division Manager.
From the staff report
Adoption of a resolution to permanently close a portion of an unopened right-of-way known as Gayle Street.
have petitioned for this closureasked for this item
James Sandusky Paris and Carson Kinlaw Delingerowner
9627-22-9286parcel ID (PIN)
Fiscal impact
There will be no fiscal impact related to this closure.
Before it reached Council
Multimodal Transportation Committee, June 24, 2020: approve — Recommended closing the right-of-way by unanimous vote
City Code sections
N. C. Gen. Stat. sec 160A-299
Staff: Greg Shuler, Public Works Director; Chad Bandy, Streets Division Manager.
Description in the minutes
Streets Division Manager Chad Bandy said that this is the consideration of a resolution to permanently close an unopened right-of-way known as Gayle Street. This public hearing was advertised on August 28, September 4, 11 and 18, 2020.
Background:
N. C. Gen. Stat. sec 160A-299 grants cities the authority to permanently close streets and alleys.
James Sandusky Paris and Carson Kinlaw Delinger have petitioned for this closure. They are owners of the property known as 99999 Morse Drive (Pin # 9627-22-9286).
The unopened portion of right-of-way extends into the subject property.
Upon closure, if granted, the unopened right-of-way will become part of the above property.
The plan is for the property to be subdivided.
The closure aides in meeting required setbacks.
This closure allows maximum land use potential for further development complying with Living Asheville
A Comprehensive Plan for our Future.
Committee(s):
Multimodal Transportation Committee
June 24, 2020
Recommended closing the right-of-way by unanimous vote
Pro(s):
The closure would allow for more efficient use of the existing adjacent property.
Meets Council’s goals to promote sustainable high density infill growth that makes efficient use of existing resources
Con(s):
None noted.
Fiscal Impact:
There will be no fiscal impact related to this closure. Mayor Manheimer opened the public hearing at 6:14 p.m. Mayor Manheimer announced that there were no advanced live call-ins for this public hearing. In accordance with recent legislation amending North Carolina G.S. §166A-19.24(e), regarding public hearings conducted during remote meetings, written comments for this public hearing will be accepted for an additional 24 hours. Therefore,
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
3 spoke · changed before the vote · 1 council remark
Recommendations
Council’s vote matched the city staff recommendation.
City staff: Approve — Staff recommends approval of this amendment as the project includes market rate and affordable units in a location that is proximate to downtown and still includes a mix of uses to activate this area of the city. … Staff does have some concern regarding the unsettled land acquisition that would provide safe pedestrian connectivity offsite to Coxe Avenue.
Downtown Commission: Approve, unanimous, July 10, 2020
Planning & Zoning Commission: Approve, 7–0, September 2, 2020
Public hearing advertised Sep 11, 2020 and Sep 18, 2020
3 spoke in favor · 0 spoke against
ForChris Day · for the applicant, Civil Design Concepts — Chris Day with Civil Design Concepts provided Council with several design changes, noting that their priority was residential.
ForBrian Cook · for the applicant — Brian Cook, architect, walked through some of the visual changes.
ForWyatt Stevens · for the applicant — Wyatt Steven, attorney for the developer Matt Maynard, stressed that the project includes at least 48 of the residential units to be dedicated to affordability at 80% AMI for at least 20 years and at least 10 of the affordable units will accept housing vouchers.
Vice-Mayor Wisler announced that there were no advanced live call-ins for this public hearing. … written comments for this public hearing will be accepted for an additional 24 hours.
SupportsCouncilwoman Mayfield felt that the contracting proposal made by Mr. Maynard could possibly be some criteria that we use in other big projects, e.g., hotel developments.
The minutes record no remarks on this item from Brian Haynes, S. Antanette Mosley, Sheneika Smith, Gwen Wisler and Keith Young.
Changed before the vote 2 changes recorded
Offered by the applicantat least 48 of the residential units to be dedicated to affordability at 80% AMI for at least 20 years and at least 10 of the affordable units will accept housing vouchers
Offered by the applicantFollowing the model of the Lee Walker Heights Development, we will make a good faith effort to follow, and we will expect our subcontractors to follow, the principles set forth in the Federal Procurement Regulations of 24 CFR 85.36 (e) regarding contracting with small and minority firms, women’s business enterprise and labor surplus area firms
Key facts
172 Asheland Avenue, 185 and 99999 Coxe Avenue and 5 Federal Alleyaddress
4.43 acressite size
Central Business District Conditional Zone (CBD-CZ) → ?zoning, from → to
474 units48 of them affordable
80% AMI for at least 20 yearsaffordability
Tribute Investment & Development Incapplicant
Councilwoman Smith moved to recess this item until October 13, 2020, at which time this public hearing will be voted. … carried on a 6-0 roll call vote, with Mayor Manheimer being recused.
Presented by Shannon Tuch, Principal Planner.
From the staff report
Amend a previously approved conditional zoning for a mixed-use development for changes to the design of the project
Petitioner: Tribute Investment & Development Incasked for this item
4.43 acres172 Asheland Avenue, 185 and 99999 Coxe Avenue and 5 Federal Alley
Asheland Properties LLC and South Slope Holdings LLCowner
Tribute Investment & Development Incapplicant
9648.37-2643, 9648.38-0052, 9648.37-1928 and 9648.37-2825parcel ID (PIN)
Staff’s stated reasons · approve
Staff finds that while the residential liner building was preferable, the changes to the Federal Alley parking structure still provide a mechanism for activation at the street level, as well as a creative design that allows for the redistribution of residential units to Asheland Avenue.
the applicant has made efforts to break up the visual massing of the building along Asheland Avenue and the redistribution of uses throughout the site is acceptable.
Conditions from the original approval for traffic mitigation and affordable housing are unchanged with this amendment.
Before it reached Council
Downtown Commission, July 10, 2020: approve — voted unanimously to support the proposed change
Planning & Zoning Commission, September 2, 2020: approve (7–0) — unanimously recommended support
Staff: Todd Okolichany, AICP, LEED AP ND, Planning & Urban Design Director; Jessica Bernstein, Urban Planner II.
Description in the minutes
Principal Planner Shannon Tuch said that this is the consideration of an amendment to a previously approved conditional zoning (Ordinance No. 4785) for properties located at 172 Asheland Avenue, 185 and 99999 Coxe Avenue and 5 Federal Alley for changes to a mixed-use development zoned Central Business District-Expansion/Conditional Zone. This public hearing was advertised on September 11 and 18, 2020. Project Location and Contacts:
The project site consists of four parcels with a combined area of approximately 4.43 acres, located at 172 Asheland Avenue, 185 and 99999 Coxe Avenue and 5 Federal Alley (PINs 9648.37-2643, 9648.38-0052, 9648.37-1928 and 9648.37-2825) that are owned by Asheland Properties LLC and South Slope Holdings LLC.
Petitioner: Tribute Investment & Development Inc; Contact: Warren Sugg Summary of
Petition:
The project was approved by City Council on December 10, 2019, under ordinance no. 4785 and is zoned Central Business District Conditional Zone (CBD-CZ).
As detailed in the current ordinance, the development was approved for a mixed-use project with frontage on Coxe Avenue, Asheland Avenue and Federal Alley with residential and commercial uses throughout multiple buildings, a parking structure integrated into the development and urban open space in the form of a series of public and private interior courtyard spaces connecting the frontages and running through the site from east to west.
The requested amendment primarily impacts the use and design of the northernmost building on Asheland Avenue and the use and design of the structure along Federal Alley. There are no changes to the Coxe Avenue buildings, interior courtyards or streetscape.
The Asheland Avenue change proposes a residential building instead of the previous design that was intended for office use and the revision eliminates the residential liner building that was previously shown along Federal Alley.
The changes to the buildings on Federal Alley and Asheland Avenue still comply with City of Asheville Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) standards such as: fenestration and expanses of solid wall and providing pedestrian entrances along street frontages. Since Federal Alley is not a key pedestrian street, the liner building in the previous design is not expressly required.
The applicant has clarified that the land needed to construct the six-foot sidewalk connection from Federal Alley to Coxe Avenue is subject to the acquisition of land currently owned by the State. The process to acquire the land is currently underway but not yet complete and the construction of this offsite improvement is subject to completion of the acquisition.
The ordinance includes a number of site specific conditions that are still applicable (B.1 conditions).
This amendment does not conflict with those conditions, except that the approval was linked to the previous site plan and renderings; therefore, removing the liner building and altering the facades along Federal Alley and Asheland necessitate an amendment to the previously approved conditional zoning approval.
The summary of changes is as follows:
Slight reduction in residential units (from 488 down to 474)
While the number of residential units is reduced there will be no reduction to the number of affordable units; the applicant will still provide the originally approved amount of affordable units (10 percent of 488 units, which is 48 affordable units)
Reduction in commercial programming (from 86,000 square feet down to 44,199 square feet due to a reduction in the large office component in the original plan)
Parking garage footprint remains the same but scale reduced (from 973 spaces down to six levels and approximately 574 spaces)
Federal Alley liner building eliminated with those residential units now relocated to the Asheland Avenue north building
Parking garage pulls up to front directly on Federal Alley and has been designed to include 18 foot deep “stalls” along the ground level that can be activated with a variety of temporary “pop-up” uses
Asheland Avenue north building was previously a 30,000-square foot, four story office building; now five stories and all residential use with significant aesthetic changes to facade due to the new use
Asheland Avenue south building was previously seven stories (two commercial ground levels with five residential levels above); now six stories (one level of commercial eliminated)
Rooftop patio previously on north end of Asheland Avenue building eliminated
The Downtown Commission considered this request at their meeting on July 10, 2020, and voted unanimously to support the proposed change but with the following suggestions:
Revise the design of the north building on Asheland to differentiate and minimize the massing of the building, perhaps using the location of the vehicular entry as a "break" point (the applicant agreed to and made the changes)
Consider adding ground-level commercial space to the north building on Asheland (the applicant prefers to maintain residential units on the ground floor)
Minimize 24-hour parking deck lighting (the applicant is agreeable to this suggestion)
Consider adding amenities / facilities for year-round market stalls on Federal Alley (the applicant is agreeable to this suggestion but the details remain an ongoing discussion)
The Planning and Zoning Commission reviewed the request at their meeting on August 5, 2020, ultimately voting at the September 2, 2020 meeting and unanimously recommended support.
Public comments were received and there were primarily concerns that relocating residential units to Asheland Avenue (in place of the office component) would add cut-through traffic to the South French Broad residential neighborhood via Morgan Street; a desire for retail spaces along the ground level along Asheland Avenue to provide more places for residents of the adjacent neighborhood to visit by foot and concerns that the reduction in parking spaces within the garage structure will result in overflow parking on-street in the South French Broad residential neighborhood. Additional comments received were not specific to the amendment.
The project location is within Census Tract 9, an Opportunity Zone area. City resolution no. 18-269 states that Council commits to work with investors and the resolution offers guidance on projects within these areas to promote equitable growth, avoid displacement of low income or residents of color and avoid the loss of community assets or land.
Comprehensive Plan Consistency:
As previously stated in the 2019 staff report, this development has been evaluated for consistency with the Living Asheville Comprehensive Plan and determined to be aligned in multiple ways. This amendment does not alter the alignment of this mixed-use project with the Living Asheville plan.
Compatibility Analysis:
With the proposed amendment, the development remains compatible with the surrounding area by including market rate and affordable units in close proximity to downtown.
Regarding the design change to the building on Asheland Avenue, the applicant responded to the requests from both staff and the Downtown Commission to include modifications to the facade to attempt to minimize the massing with several sections of color differentiation.
The B.1 conditions that were agreed to during the previous review for pedestrian safety and traffic improvements are still in place to further minimize potential impacts.
Since the number of residential units and office component have decreased with this amendment, staff does not believe that shifting the location of the uses within the development should have any greater traffic impact and notes that off-street parking is not required in the zoning district.
Further, the proposed number of parking spaces is just under the minimum that would be required for the development if located elsewhere. The location of the project in an urban setting, close to downtown and availability of transit, support the amount of parking provided in this project.
Committee(s):
Technical Review Committee (TRC)
June 2020
approved with conditions
Downtown Commission (DTC)
July 10, 2020
recommended unanimous approval with suggested conditions
Planning & Zoning Commission
August 5 & September 2, 2020
recommended approval 7-0
Staff Recommendation:
Staff recommends approval of this amendment as the project includes market rate and affordable units in a location that is proximate to downtown and still includes a mix of uses to activate this area of the city.
Staff finds that while the residential liner building was preferable, the changes to the Federal Alley parking structure still provide a mechanism for activation at the street level, as well as a creative design that allows for the redistribution of residential units to Asheland Avenue.
As noted above, the applicant has made efforts to break up the visual massing of the building along Asheland Avenue and the redistribution of uses throughout the site is acceptable.
Conditions from the original approval for traffic mitigation and affordable housing are unchanged with this amendment.
Staff does have some concern regarding the unsettled land acquisition that would provide safe pedestrian connectivity offsite to Coxe Avenue. At the request of Mayor Manheimer,
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
At the request of Mayor Manheimer, Councilman Young moved to recuse Mayor Manheimer from participating in this matter due to a conflict of interest.
Description in the minutes
Principal Planner Shannon Tuch said that this is the consideration of an amendment to a previously approved conditional zoning (Ordinance No. 4785) for properties located at 172 Asheland Avenue, 185 and 99999 Coxe Avenue and 5 Federal Alley for changes to a mixed-use development zoned Central Business District-Expansion/Conditional Zone. This public hearing was advertised on September 11 and 18, 2020. Project Location and Contacts:
The project site consists of four parcels with a combined area of approximately 4.43 acres, located at 172 Asheland Avenue, 185 and 99999 Coxe Avenue and 5 Federal Alley (PINs 9648.37-2643, 9648.38-0052, 9648.37-1928 and 9648.37-2825) that are owned by Asheland Properties LLC and South Slope Holdings LLC.
Petitioner: Tribute Investment & Development Inc; Contact: Warren Sugg Summary of
Petition:
The project was approved by City Council on December 10, 2019, under ordinance no. 4785 and is zoned Central Business District Conditional Zone (CBD-CZ).
As detailed in the current ordinance, the development was approved for a mixed-use project with frontage on Coxe Avenue, Asheland Avenue and Federal Alley with residential and commercial uses throughout multiple buildings, a parking structure integrated into the development and urban open space in the form of a series of public and private interior courtyard spaces connecting the frontages and running through the site from east to west.
The requested amendment primarily impacts the use and design of the northernmost building on Asheland Avenue and the use and design of the structure along Federal Alley. There are no changes to the Coxe Avenue buildings, interior courtyards or streetscape.
The Asheland Avenue change proposes a residential building instead of the previous design that was intended for office use and the revision eliminates the residential liner building that was previously shown along Federal Alley.
The changes to the buildings on Federal Alley and Asheland Avenue still comply with City of Asheville Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) standards such as: fenestration and expanses of solid wall and providing pedestrian entrances along street frontages. Since Federal Alley is not a key pedestrian street, the liner building in the previous design is not expressly required.
The applicant has clarified that the land needed to construct the six-foot sidewalk connection from Federal Alley to Coxe Avenue is subject to the acquisition of land currently owned by the State. The process to acquire the land is currently underway but not yet complete and the construction of this offsite improvement is subject to completion of the acquisition.
The ordinance includes a number of site specific conditions that are still applicable (B.1 conditions).
This amendment does not conflict with those conditions, except that the approval was linked to the previous site plan and renderings; therefore, removing the liner building and altering the facades along Federal Alley and Asheland necessitate an amendment to the previously approved conditional zoning approval.
The summary of changes is as follows:
Slight reduction in residential units (from 488 down to 474)
While the number of residential units is reduced there will be no reduction to the number of affordable units; the applicant will still provide the originally approved amount of affordable units (10 percent of 488 units, which is 48 affordable units)
Reduction in commercial programming (from 86,000 square feet down to 44,199 square feet due to a reduction in the large office component in the original plan)
Parking garage footprint remains the same but scale reduced (from 973 spaces down to six levels and approximately 574 spaces)
Federal Alley liner building eliminated with those residential units now relocated to the Asheland Avenue north building
Parking garage pulls up to front directly on Federal Alley and has been designed to include 18 foot deep “stalls” along the ground level that can be activated with a variety of temporary “pop-up” uses
Asheland Avenue north building was previously a 30,000-square foot, four story office building; now five stories and all residential use with significant aesthetic changes to facade due to the new use
Asheland Avenue south building was previously seven stories (two commercial ground levels with five residential levels above); now six stories (one level of commercial eliminated)
Rooftop patio previously on north end of Asheland Avenue building eliminated
The Downtown Commission considered this request at their meeting on July 10, 2020, and voted unanimously to support the proposed change but with the following suggestions:
Revise the design of the north building on Asheland to differentiate and minimize the massing of the building, perhaps using the location of the vehicular entry as a "break" point (the applicant agreed to and made the changes)
Consider adding ground-level commercial space to the north building on Asheland (the applicant prefers to maintain residential units on the ground floor)
Minimize 24-hour parking deck lighting (the applicant is agreeable to this suggestion)
Consider adding amenities / facilities for year-round market stalls on Federal Alley (the applicant is agreeable to this suggestion but the details remain an ongoing discussion)
The Planning and Zoning Commission reviewed the request at their meeting on August 5, 2020, ultimately voting at the September 2, 2020 meeting and unanimously recommended support.
Public comments were received and there were primarily concerns that relocating residential units to Asheland Avenue (in place of the office component) would add cut-through traffic to the South French Broad residential neighborhood via Morgan Street; a desire for retail spaces along the ground level along Asheland Avenue to provide more places for residents of the adjacent neighborhood to visit by foot and concerns that the reduction in parking spaces within the garage structure will result in overflow parking on-street in the South French Broad residential neighborhood. Additional comments received were not specific to the amendment.
The project location is within Census Tract 9, an Opportunity Zone area. City resolution no. 18-269 states that Council commits to work with investors and the resolution offers guidance on projects within these areas to promote equitable growth, avoid displacement of low income or residents of color and avoid the loss of community assets or land.
Comprehensive Plan Consistency:
As previously stated in the 2019 staff report, this development has been evaluated for consistency with the Living Asheville Comprehensive Plan and determined to be aligned in multiple ways. This amendment does not alter the alignment of this mixed-use project with the Living Asheville plan.
Compatibility Analysis:
With the proposed amendment, the development remains compatible with the surrounding area by including market rate and affordable units in close proximity to downtown.
Regarding the design change to the building on Asheland Avenue, the applicant responded to the requests from both staff and the Downtown Commission to include modifications to the facade to attempt to minimize the massing with several sections of color differentiation.
The B.1 conditions that were agreed to during the previous review for pedestrian safety and traffic improvements are still in place to further minimize potential impacts.
Since the number of residential units and office component have decreased with this amendment, staff does not believe that shifting the location of the uses within the development should have any greater traffic impact and notes that off-street parking is not required in the zoning district.
Further, the proposed number of parking spaces is just under the minimum that would be required for the development if located elsewhere. The location of the project in an urban setting, close to downtown and availability of transit, support the amount of parking provided in this project.
Committee(s):
Technical Review Committee (TRC)
June 2020
approved with conditions
Downtown Commission (DTC)
July 10, 2020
recommended unanimous approval with suggested conditions
Planning & Zoning Commission
August 5 & September 2, 2020
recommended approval 7-0
Staff Recommendation:
Staff recommends approval of this amendment as the project includes market rate and affordable units in a location that is proximate to downtown and still includes a mix of uses to activate this area of the city.
Staff finds that while the residential liner building was preferable, the changes to the Federal Alley parking structure still provide a mechanism for activation at the street level, as well as a creative design that allows for the redistribution of residential units to Asheland Avenue.
As noted above, the applicant has made efforts to break up the visual massing of the building along Asheland Avenue and the redistribution of uses throughout the site is acceptable.
Conditions from the original approval for traffic mitigation and affordable housing are unchanged with this amendment.
Staff does have some concern regarding the unsettled land acquisition that would provide safe pedestrian connectivity offsite to Coxe Avenue. At the request of Mayor Manheimer,
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Item J · RES 20-168 · Parks & Recreation · Resolution · consent agenda
Contract with Synergy Sports Charlotte LLC for playground mulch
Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Keith Young
All members present voted yes.
Key facts
$132,930purchase and installation of playground mulch
$13,293contingency amount
Synergy Sports Charlotte, LLCcontractor or recipient
Asset Management Contracted Services line itemfunding source
Description in the minutes
Action Requested:
Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to enter into a contract with Synergy Sports Charlotte, LLC for the purchase and installation of playground mulch in the amount of $132,930.00 and to further authorize change orders up to the contingency amount of $13,293 (10%) for playground mulch and installation.
Background:
Bid packet for Playground Mulch and Installation went out and closed on Thursday, June 4, 2020.
This contract will provide bi-annual safety applications for playground mulch at 10 playground sites across the City for FY 21. The following locations are included:
Carrier Park Playground
Jake Rusher Park Playground
Kenilworth Playground
Malvern Hills Playground
Murphy Oakley Playground
Recreation Park Playground
Stephens-Lee Center Playground
Linwood Crump Shiloh Playground
Walton Street Playground
Weaver Playground
Companies responding were:
Synergy Sports Charlotte LLC, Charlotte, NC
Bid $132,900
On Point, Etowah, NC
Bid $138,596.50
Bliss Products and Services, Lithia Springs, GA
Bid $157,500
Mulch Solutions, LLC, Indian Trail, NC
Bid $151,200
BH Graning Landscapes, Inc., Sylva, NC
Bid $164,776.50
Natural Choice Contracting, West Youngsville, NC
Bid $ $151,200
Power Mulch Inc, Smithfield, NC
Bid $143,073
Cason Companies Inc, East Flat Rock, NC
Bid $141,750
Following review of bids by City staff, Synergy Sports Charlotte LLC was selected as the lowest responsible, responsive bidder.
Vendor Outreach Efforts:
Staff performed outreach to minority and women owned business enterprises (MWBE) through solicitation processes which include posting on the State’s Interactive Purchasing System, targeted outreach with the City’s Business Inclusion Manager. One Women Owned Business submitted a bid, but was not the lowest bid.
Council Goal(s):
A Well-Planned and Liveable Community
Pro(s):
Ensures compliance with playground safety standards for mulch.
Con(s):
None
Fiscal Impact:
Funding for this purchase has been previously approved and is available for expenditure in the Asset Management Contracted Services line item.
Staff: Roderick Simmons, Department Director; Allison Dains, Program and Operations Manager.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Resolution appointing members to the Affordable Housing Advisory Committee
Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Brian Haynes
All members present voted yes.
Recommendations
Boards & Commissions Committee: Approve
Key facts
terms to expire September 1, 2023, or until their successor have been appointedterm
Description in the minutes
Vice-Mayor Wisler, Chair of the Boards & Commissions Committee, said that this is the consideration of appointing members to the Affordable Housing Advisory Committee. The terms of Dewanna Little, Parker Smith, Randall Barnett, Barry Bialik and Leslie Hennessee’s expired on September 1, 2020. The following individuals applied for the vacancy: Paul Holstein, Brian Methvin, Shannon Watkins, Michael Figura, T. Cory Lewis, Tyson Bowman, Thomas A. Christ, Drew Crawford, Rodrigo Afanador, Damita Jo Wilder, Eric Howell, Michael G. Waddle, Joshua Katz, ZaKiya Bell-Rogers, Henry Sannyasa, Scott Adams, Cyd Jaggers, Chris Woodward and DeLores Venable. Boards & Commissions Committee recommended reappointing Dewanna Little, Parker Smith and Barry Bialik; and appointing Brian Methvin and Scott Adams.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Resolution appointing members to the Citizens-Police Advisory Committee
Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Brian Haynes
All members present voted yes.
Recommendations
Boards & Commissions Committee: Approve
Key facts
a three-year term, term to expire June 30, 2023, or until her successor has been appointedterm
Description in the minutes
Vice-Mayor Wisler, Chair of the Boards & Commissions Committee, said that this is the consideration of appointing a member to the Citizens-Police Advisory Committee. Kaaren McNulty (south representative) has resigned as a member of the Citizens-Police Advisory Committee, thus leaving an unexpired term until June 30, 2020. In addition Shana McDowell (at-large representative) has resigned, thus leaving an unexpired term until June 30, 2022. In addition, the terms of Blake Marcus (north representative) and Jerry Kivett (central representative) expired on June 30, 2020. The following individuals applied for the vacancy: Cathy Banks, Tracey DeBruhl, David Angelus, Barbara Wright, Anthony Coggiola, Mary Ammerman, Tim Kelley, Damita Jo Wilder and Michael E. Beech. The Boards & Commissions Committee recommended appointing Damita Jo Wilder as the south representative, Barbara Wright as the central representative, and Michael Beech as the at-large representative. In addition, the Committee recommended reappointing Blake Marcus as the north representative.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Resolution appointing members to the Civic Center Commission
Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Brian Haynes
All members present voted yes.
Recommendations
Boards & Commissions Committee: Approve
Key facts
a three-year term, term to expire June 30, 2023, or until her successor has been appointedterm
Description in the minutes
Vice-Mayor Wisler, Chair of the Boards & Commissions Committee, said that this is the consideration of appointing members to the Civic Center Commission. The terms of Corey Atkins and Yvonne Cook-Riley expired on June 30, 2020. The following individuals applied for the vacancy: Lee Arevian, John W. Ellis, Steven M. Howard, Tony Micocci, Mukunda Pacifici, Sandy Aldridge, Nicole Lee and Josh Batenhorst. Boards & Commissions Committee recommended reappointing Corey Atkins and appointing Nicole Lee.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Resolution appointing members to the Asheville-Buncombe Historic Resources Commission
Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Brian Haynes
All members present voted yes.
Recommendations
Boards & Commissions Committee: Approve
Key facts
Craig Cline and Gordon McKinney have resigned, thus leaving two unexpired terms until July 1, 2022. In addition, Ed Flowers has resigned, thus leaving an unexpired term until July 1, 2021.term
Description in the minutes
Vice-Mayor Wisler, Chair of the Boards & Commissions Committee, said that this is the consideration of appointing members to the Asheville-Buncombe Historic Resources Commission. Craig Cline and Gordon McKinney have resigned, thus leaving two unexpired terms until July 1, 2022. In addition, Ed Flowers has resigned, thus leaving an unexpired term until July 1, 2021. The following individuals applied for the vacancy: Lucy A. Kruesel, J. Wagner and Amanda Vollrath, Sara Gardner, Maggie Brousaides, Sioux Oliva and James Vaughn. The Boards & Commissions Committee recommended appointing James Vaughn, Sara Gardner and Maggie Brousaides..
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Resolution appointing members to the Public Art & Cultural Commission
Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Brian Haynes
All members present voted yes.
Recommendations
Boards & Commissions Committee: Approve
Key facts
a three-year term respectively, terms to expire June 30, 2023, or until their successor have been appointedterm
Description in the minutes
Vice-Mayor Wisler, Chair of the Boards & Commissions Committee, said that this is the consideration of appointing members to the Public Art & Cultural Commission. The terms of Jasmine Washington, Andrew Fletcher, Jay Fields, Katie Cornell, Valeria Watson and Pete Perez expired on June 30, 2020. The following individuals applied for the vacancy: Anne Manner-Mclarty, Marsha Almodovar, Daniele Martin, Nathaniel Wyrick, Christian ODonnell, Hilary Chiz and Michael G. Waddle. Boards & Commissions Committee recommended reappointing Jasmine Washington, Andrew Fletcher, Katie Cornell, Valeria Watson and Pete Perez; and re-advertising for the last vacant seat.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Resolution appointing a member to the WNC Air Quality (board)
Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Brian Haynes
All members present voted yes.
Recommendations
Boards & Commissions Committee: Approve
Key facts
a six-year term, term to expire July 1, 2026, or until his successor has been appointedterm
Description in the minutes
Vice-Mayor Wisler, Chair of the Boards & Commissions Committee, said that this is the consideration of appointing a member to the WNC Air Quality Board. The term of Dean Kahl expired on July 1, 2020. On August 25, 2020, the Boards & Commissions Committee recommended re-advertising for the vacant seat. The following individuals applied for the vacancy: Garry Whisnant., Robert H. Lane, Evan Couzzo and Drew Ball. The Boards & Commissions Committee recommended appointing Evan Couzzo.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
The 30/60/90 Day Work Plan was developed in response to numerous requests from the Black Asheville Demands coalition to address specific racial justice and economic inclusion issues … there were 461 people who engaged virtually.
Presented by Debra Campbell, City Manager; David Zack, Police Chief; Brad Branham, City Attorney.
Supported written consent for pedestrians without further discussion.
Other business
BOARDS & COMMISSIONS
It was the consensus of the Boards & Commissions Committee and City Council to postpone these appointments until after the Human Relations Commission forward their recommendation. … It was the consensus of the Boards & Commissions Committee and City Council to readvertise the Neighborhood Advisory Commission seats.
Presented by Gwen C. Wisler, Chair of the Boards & Commissions Committee.
Proclamation
Announcement of New Councilwoman S. Antanette Mosley
Mayor Manheimer announced that Buncombe County Chief District Court Judge J. Calvin Hill administered the oath to S. Antanette Mosley earlier in the day. On behalf of City Council, she welcomed Councilwoman Mosley to the Asheville City Council.
Presented by Esther E. Manheimer, Mayor.
Statement
Department of Equity and Inclusion
Instruct the City Manager to immediately start the process to fill the vacated role of the director of Equity and Inclusion … Ask this Council to take part in an immediate review of the City Manager, no later than prior to the first meeting in December
over an extended period of time it has become clear to him that the Department of Equity and Inclusion is not part of this culture in City government
Statement
INFORMAL DISCUSSION AND PUBLIC COMMENT
Councilwoman Mayfield thanked City Manager Campbell and City staff for all the work that has gone into this process. … Vice-Mayor Wisler echoed Councilwoman Mayfield and said that she was continued to be amazed at how well and how diligently City Manager Campbell leads the City.
In light of the comments heard, she trusted City Manager [Debra Campbell] explicitly and trusted her to lead our equity efforts in a way to get our City in the way we want to go.
Vice-Mayor Wisler echoed Councilwoman Mayfield and said that she was continued to be amazed at how well and how diligently City Manager [Debra Campbell] leads the City.
Open public comment 3 speakers · 4 topics, as the minutes list them
process for public input is challenging
need to see timelines and dollar amounts with the reimagining process
reimagining public safety listening sessions were not well organized
people are afraid of change but it is necessary
This resource, to the best of its ability, is copied word for word from the official minutes, “…” marks words left out, and [brackets] a name the minutes give elsewhere. The minutes are the record. Staff report details are quoted from the city’s meeting documents, prepared before the vote.