Asheville City Council recorded 12 votes at its regular meeting on October 11, 2022; 1 drew at least one no vote. Most items fell under Boards & Appointments, Zoning & Land Use and Environment & Sustainability.
Met: 5 pm–8:19 pm. Voting: Sandra Kilgore, Esther E. Manheimer, S. Antanette Mosley, Kim Roney, Sheneika Smith, Sage Turner, Gwen Wisler.
Votes 12 recorded · 3 substantive · 1 split
Item IV-B · ORD 4793 · Zoning & Land Use · Ordinance
Conditionally zone 100, 54 & 99999 Woodland Dr from RM-8 to Residential Expansion/CZ (add 2 EV charging stations)
Passed6–1 · Moved by Sandra Kilgore, seconded by Sage Turner
6 spoke, 3 against · changed before the vote · 4 council remarks
Recommendations
Council’s vote matched the city staff recommendation.
City staff: Approve — Staff recommends approval of this rezoning request based on the reasons stated above.
Technical Review Committee: Approve with conditions, June 6, 2022
Planning & Zoning Commission: No recommendation, 2–2, September 21, 2022
Public hearing 6:06 pm–6:34 pm · advertised Sep 30, 2022 and Oct 7, 2022
3 spoke in favor · 3 spoke against
ForDerek Allen · for the applicant — Mr. Derek Allen, attorney representing the developer said that the developer is committed to add two vehicle charging stations and they are working with a solar consultant to look at solar as an option on all their projects. Mr. Allen spoke in support of the project, noting that the project will assist with the missing middle housing shortage.
Three individuals spoke in opposition to the conditional zoning for several reasons, some being, but are not limited to: the Sulphur Springs Neighborhood Association views the Woodland Development Plan as inconsistent with overarching goals explicitly stated in Asheville's current Comprehensive Development Plan; provides almost no affordable housing … Two individuals spoke in support of the conditional zoning for several reasons, some being, but are not limited to: this project is missing middle housing we so desperately need. The minutes name 1 of the 6 speakers.
What council members said 4 remarks from 3 members
SupportsCouncilwoman Turner pointed out the crisis with affordable housing and felt this is a step towards greater density.
The minutes record no remarks on this item from Sandra Kilgore, S. Antanette Mosley, Sheneika Smith and Gwen Wisler.
Changed before the vote 2 changes recorded
Amendment by motionan amendment to the conditions to add two vehicle charging stations · offered by Sandra Kilgore
Offered by the applicant10% affordable units (7 units) with half (4 units) accepting housing choice vouchers - that is an increase from 5% affordable units (4 units) with half (2 units) accepting housing code vouchers; and (2) updated architectural renderings with improved design characteristics and materials proposed
Key facts
100, 54 & 99999 (x3) Woodland Driveaddress
9.12 acressite size
RM-8 → Residential Expansion - Conditional Zone (RES EXP - CZ)zoning, from → to
72 units7 of them affordable
10% affordable units (7 units) with half (4 units) accepting housing choice vouchersaffordability
Birch Circle Associates LLCapplicant
with an amendment to the conditions to add two vehicle charging stations
Presented by Will Palmquist, Principal Planner.
From the staff report
Adoption of an ordinance to conditionally zone all portions of five properties located at 100, 54 & 99999 (x3) Woodland Dr from Residential Multi-Family Medium Density (RM-8) to Residential Expansion - Conditional Zone (RES EXP - CZ).
Residential Multi-Family Medium Density (RM-8) → Residential Expansion - Conditional Zone (RES EXP - CZ)zoning, current → requested
9.12 acresWoodland Dr
Residential Neighborhoodfuture land use designation
Birch Circle Associates LLCowner
9628-44-0165, 9628-43-2859, 9628-43-1782, 9628-33-8790, and 9628-33-8499parcel ID (PIN)
Staff’s stated reasons · approve
The proposed development is compatible with the Future Land Use designation of “Residential Neighborhood”
The proposed townhouse residential project is compatible with the surrounding land uses
Before it reached Council
Technical Review Committee (TRC), June 6, 2022: approve with conditions — approved with conditions.
Planning & Zoning Commission (PZC), September 21, 2022: no recommendation (2–2) — no recommendation given, motion to approve failed with a tie vote (2-2).
Current and requested zoning compared
Provision
Residential Multi-Family Medium Density (RM-8)
Residential Expansion - Conditional Zone (RES EXP - CZ)
Maximum building height
Maximum building height for single-family buildings in the RES EXP district is 40 feet.
The maximum building height of the proposed project is 30 feet.
Density
Maximum density in the RES EXP district is 20 units/acre.
The proposed project’s density is 7.9 units/acre.
Impervious surface
Maximum impervious surface in the RES EXP district for single-family uses is 50%.
The proposed project would result in a total impervious area of 39.95%.
Staff: Todd Okolichany, AICP, LEED AP ND, Planning & Urban Design Director; Will Palmquist, AICP, Principal Planner.
Description in the minutes
99999 (x3) WOODLAND DRIVE FROM RM-8 RESIDENTIAL MULTI-FAMILY MEDIUM DENSITY DISTRICT TO RESIDENTIAL EXPANSION/CONDITIONAL ZONE Principal Planner Will Palmquist said that this is the consideration of an ordinance to conditionally zone 100, 54 & 99999 (x3) Woodland Drive from RM-8 Residential Multi-Family Medium Density District to Residential Expansion/Conditional Zone. This public hearing was advertised on September 30 and October 7, 2022. The project site totals 9.12 acres located at Woodland Dr (PINs 9628-44-0165, 9628-43-2859, 9628-43-1782, 9628-33-8790, and 9628-33-8499). Owner: Birch Circle Associates LLC. The site is currently zoned Residential Multi-Family Medium Density (RM-8). Given the size of the project (over 50 residential dwelling units), a conditional zoning to the Residential Expansion (RES EXP) district is required. The site is designated “Residential Neighborhood” on the city’s Future Land Use (FLU) Map. Overall Project Proposal: New building construction includes 72 dwelling units located across 10 groups of two-story, attached townhomes. The proposed development represents a type of “missing middle” housing. The project proposes to subdivide the site into individual parcels for each townhouse. Other site improvements include a new roadway, off-street parking, sidewalks, a gravel walking path, and a community area and proposed playground. 5% of the units (4 units) will be designated affordable to those earning at or below 80% Area Median Income (AMI) for a minimum of 20 years. 50% of those affordable units (2 units) will accept HACA Housing Choice vouchers.
Committee(s):
Technical Review Committee (TRC)
June 6, 2022
approved with conditions.
Planning & Zoning Commission (PZC)
July 6, 2022
continued to 8/3 PZC meeting.
Planning & Zoning Commission (PZC)
August 3, 2022
continued to 9/7 PZC meeting.
Planning & Zoning Commission (PZC)
September 21, 2022
no recommendation given, motion to approve failed with a tie vote (2-2).
Staff Recommendation:
Staff recommends approval of this rezoning request based on the reasons stated above. Mr. Palmquist reviewed with Council the existing zoning, proposed zoning, aerial imagery and the future land use map. Changes to the project since the October 5 Planning & Zoning Commission meeting include (1) 10% affordable units (7 units) with half (4 units) accepting housing choice vouchers
that is an increase from 5% affordable units (4 units) with half (2 units) accepting housing code vouchers; and (2) updated architectural renderings with improved design characteristics and materials proposed. Councilwoman Roney felt that this is a car centric project, which has a garage in every spot, not enough sidewalks and no bike lanes. In response to Councilwoman Roney about what are the opportunities for renewable energy, Mr. Derek Allen, attorney representing the developer said that the developer is committed to add two vehicle charging stations and they are working with a solar consultant to look at solar as an option on all their projects. Mr. Allen spoke in support of the project, noting that the project will assist with the missing middle housing shortage. Mayor Manheimer opened the public hearing at 6:06 p.m. Three individuals spoke in opposition to the conditional zoning for several reasons, some being, but are not limited to: the Sulphur Springs Neighborhood Association views the Woodland Development Plan as inconsistent with overarching goals explicitly stated in Asheville's current Comprehensive Development Plan; provides almost no affordable housing; makes the Sulphur Springs Neighborhood less walkable and bikeable; provides minimal access to and discourages use of public transit; provides no green stormwater infrastructure; proposes infill housing incompatible with traditional Sulphur Springs Neighborhood; and contributes to worsening traffic safety and congestion. Two individuals spoke in support of the conditional zoning for several reasons, some being, but are not limited to: this project is missing middle housing we so desperately need. Mayor Manheimer closed the public hearing at 6:34 p.m. Mayor Manheimer said that this proposal is extremely challenging for her, but she would support the conditional zoning. Councilwoman Turner pointed out the crisis with affordable housing and felt this is a step towards greater density.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Plastic regulation - revise Chapter 15 of City Code to prohibit plastic bags for curbside leaf litter collection (Phase I)
Passed7–0 · Moved by Sage Turner, seconded by Gwen Wisler
All members present voted yes.
22 spoke · 1 council remark
Recommendations
Sustainability Advisory Committee on Energy and the Environment: Approve, 7–0, July 20, 2022
Governance: Approve, 3–0, September 13, 2022
Public comment on this item
22 spoke in favor · 0 spoke against
Twenty-two individuals spoke in support of an ordinance banning plastic bags at point of sale and disposable foodware products by the end of 2022. The minutes give counts but do not name the speakers.
ConcernCouncilwoman Wisler was discouraged that Buncombe County and other municipalities in Buncombe County are not partnering with the City on this timeline.
The minutes record no remarks on this item from Sandra Kilgore, Esther E. Manheimer, S. Antanette Mosley, Kim Roney, Sheneika Smith and Sage Turner.
Key facts
Presented by Bridget Herring, Director of Sustainability.
From the staff report
Direction to work with staff to revise Chapter 15 of the City Code to prohibit plastic bags for curbside leaf litter collection (Phase I)
staff received a request from the Mayor and members of Councilasked for this item
$20,000Phase one is estimated to cost $20,000
Funding for this work has been identified within the Public Works Department operating budget.funding source
Fiscal impact
Phase one is estimated to cost $20,000, to include the one-time purchase and distribution of 30,000 leaf bags to residents.
Staff’s stated reasons
Phase one will eliminate approximately 120,000 single use plastic bags from the landfill annually.
Phase one will address one of Council’s strategic priorities to improve core service delivery.
A phased approach will allow staff to develop an implementation plan for enforcement and education and outreach.
Before it reached Council
Sustainability Advisory Committee on Energy and the Environment, July 20, 2022: approve (7–0) — 7-0 to recommend the elimination of plastic bags from curbside leaf litter collection
Sustainability Advisory Committee on Energy and the Environment, July 20, 2022: approve (5–2) — 5-2 to recommend ban on plastic bags at point of sale
Plastic regulation - direct staff to further address public input (Phase II)
Passed7–0 · Moved by Sage Turner, seconded by Gwen Wisler
All members present voted yes.
22 spoke
Recommendations
Sustainability Advisory Committee on Energy and the Environment: Approve, 5–2, July 20, 2022
Governance: Approve, 3–0, September 13, 2022
Public comment on this item
One hearing covered this item and agenda item V-A-1; the counts are for the whole hearing.
22 spoke in favor · 0 spoke against
Twenty-two individuals spoke in support of an ordinance banning plastic bags at point of sale and disposable foodware products by the end of 2022. The minutes give counts but do not name the speakers.
Key facts
Presented by Bridget Herring, Director of Sustainability.
From the staff report
for staff to commence external stakeholder engagement process and preparation of an analysis report regarding potential regulation of plastic bags at point of sale and disposable foodware products.
staff received a request from the Mayor and members of Councilasked for this item
$20,000Phase one is estimated to cost $20,000
Funding for this work has been identified within the Public Works Department operating budget.funding source
Fiscal impact
Phase one is estimated to cost $20,000, to include the one-time purchase and distribution of 30,000 leaf bags to residents.
Staff’s stated reasons
Phase one will eliminate approximately 120,000 single use plastic bags from the landfill annually.
Phase one will address one of Council’s strategic priorities to improve core service delivery.
A phased approach will allow staff to develop an implementation plan for enforcement and education and outreach.
Before it reached Council
Sustainability Advisory Committee on Energy and the Environment, July 20, 2022: approve (7–0) — 7-0 to recommend the elimination of plastic bags from curbside leaf litter collection
Sustainability Advisory Committee on Energy and the Environment, July 20, 2022: approve (5–2) — 5-2 to recommend ban on plastic bags at point of sale
Item B · RES 22-225 · Transportation · Resolution · consent agenda
Maintenance agreement with NCDOT for vegetation control along Clingman Avenue/Haywood Road
Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by S. Antanette Mosley
All members present voted yes.
Key facts
$5,200WECAN typically spends about $5,200 per year
SR 3548 (Clingman Avenue/Haywood Road)address
N.C. Dept. of Transportationcontractor or recipient
This action requires no City resources and has no fiscal impact as long as WECAN continues maintenance activities.funding source
Description in the minutes
Action Requested:
Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to enter into and execute a vegetation maintenance agreement with the N.C. Dept. of Transportation (NCDOT) for the City to accept responsibility to provide vegetation control on various NCDOT properties along SR 3548 (Clingman Avenue/Haywood Road).
Background:
The West End/Clingman Avenue Neighborhood (WECAN) has been providing vegetation control services along the subject properties (see map section) for many years.
The purpose of the subject action is intended to solidify and document the partnership between the NCDOT, the City, and WECAN.
The NCDOT prefers to only enter maintenance agreements with another governmental entity.
The City agrees to be that governmental entity and partner with WECAN to provide the appropriate vegetation control.
WECAN agrees to continue to provide vegetation control services along the subject properties (see map section) on behalf of the City (WECAN typically spends about $5,200 per year including volunteer labor at an hourly rate of $25).
Council Goal(s):
Transportation and Accessibility
Committee(s):
None
Fiscal Impact:
This action requires no City resources and has no fiscal impact as long as WECAN continues maintenance activities.
Staff: Ken Putnam, PE, Transportation Department Director.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Item C · RES 22-226 · Transportation · Resolution · consent agenda
Agreement with the N.C. Dept. of Transportation for a traffic signal at South Charlotte Street and Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Drive
Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by S. Antanette Mosley
All members present voted yes.
Key facts
$7,500payment in the amount of $7,500 upon partial execution of the agreement by the City
South Charlotte Street and Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Driveaddress
N.C. Dept. of Transportationcontractor or recipient
General Capital Projects Fundfunding source
Description in the minutes
Action Requested:
Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to enter into and execute a traffic
review and inspection agreement with the N.C. Dept. of Transportation (NCDOT) for the City to install a traffic signal at the intersection of SR 3284 (South Charlotte Street) and Martin Luther King Drive and to submit payment in the amount of $7,500 upon partial execution of the agreement by the City.
Background:
The City performed a traffic signal warrants study at the intersection of SR 3284 (South Charlotte Street) and Martin Luther King Drive and determined that a traffic signal was warranted and it would be effective.
Since South Charlotte Street is a state-maintained street, the NCDOT agreed that a traffic signal was warranted at the intersection of SR 3284 (South Charlotte Street) and Martin Luther King Drive.
The City is responsible to fully fund the traffic signal including design, materials, and installation.
Design and construction funds were approved in the FY 2021-22 adopted budget.
The project includes pedestrian signals and crosswalks.
The NCDOT will review the designs and inspect the work during the construction phase.
Upon completion of the project, the NCDOT will own and maintain the traffic signal.
Council Goal(s):
Transportation and Accessibility
Fiscal Impact:
Funding for this contract was previously budgeted and is available in the General Capital Projects Fund.
Staff: Ken Putnam, PE, Transportation Department Director.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Item D · RES 22-227 · Economic Development · Resolution · consent agenda
Contract with Daikin Applied Americas Inc. for chiller repairs and upgrades at Harrah’s Cherokee Center - Asheville
Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by S. Antanette Mosley
All members present voted yes.
Key facts
$265,000repairs & upgrades to the Harrah’s Cherokee Center - Asheville (HCCA) chiller
$1.7 millionbrand new chiller
Harrah's Cherokee Center - Ashevilleaddress
Daikin Applied Americas Inc.contractor or recipient
HCCA Capital Projects Fundfunding source
The current contract expires on July, 31, 2023. … extend the useful life of the chiller by approximately 15-20 years of additional service.term
Description in the minutes
Action Requested:
Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a change order to the contract with Daikin Applied Americas Inc. for repairs & upgrades to the Harrah’s Cherokee Center
Asheville (HCCA) chiller in the amount of an additional $265,000.
Background:
The HCCA chiller service has been under contract with Daikin Applied Americas Inc. since August 11, 2017. The current contract expires on July, 31, 2023.
HCCA recently upgraded Building Management System software, to assist with controls of the facility HVAC systems.
This software creates a more energy efficient operation and reduces required on-site manpower during off hours.
The current chiller at HCCA is nearly 25 years old and can not ‘communicate’ with the new software, resulting in a requirement for staff to physically turn on, off and adjust building temperature at the chiller unit.
Repairs and upgrades will allow for more energy efficient operation and extend the useful life of the chiller by approximately 15-20 years of additional service.
A brand new chiller would cost approximately $1.7 Million, therefore this repair and upgrade option is recommended.
Council Goal(s):
A Thriving Local Economy
A Clean and Healthy Environment
Fiscal Impact:
Funding for this work is available in the HCCA Capital Projects Fund.
Staff: Chris Corl, HCCA General Manager.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
SupportsCouncilwoman Mosley was pleased to see that the Park Maintenance facility will be moving from Hunt Hill to Thompson Street, as it has been promised to the East End community for several years. She particularly thanked Councilwoman Wisler, City Manager [Debra Campbell] and City staff for their work on this move.
The minutes record no remarks on this item from Sandra Kilgore, Esther E. Manheimer, Kim Roney, Sheneika Smith, Sage Turner and Gwen Wisler.
Key facts
$132,883.2$7.20 per square foot, or $11,073.60 per month or $132,883.20 per year
81 Thompson Streetaddress
North Carolina Department of Transportation (NCDOT) Rail Divisioncontractor or recipient
Parks and Recreation Department operating budgetfunding source
a period of 10 years with the option to renew for one additional five year periodterm
The City has agreed to replace the roof of the facility. In return, the City will receive rent credit until the total cost is satisfied.
Description in the minutes
Action Requested:
Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a lease agreement with the North Carolina Department of Transportation (NCDOT) Rail Division for the facility at 81 Thompson Street.
Background:
The City’s Parks Maintenance Division is currently located at 8 Hunt Hill Place.
81 Thompson Street has been identified as a preferred alternative to house the Parks Maintenance Division.
Located along the Swannanoa River, the parcel at 81 Thompson Street was jointly purchased by NCDOT and the City of Asheville in 2005 to support a future implementation of a multi-modal transportation and passenger rail station.
Norfolk Southern Railroad has an active rail line along the rear property line.
NCDOT’s Rail Division owns 90% of 81 Thompson Street (PIN #9648-70-6712) and the City of Asheville owns a 10% share of the property.
For over ten years, G3 Medical, a medical supply company has been leasing the facility.
They have recently terminated the lease and vacated the facility.
The facility is a mix of office and warehouse space for a total of 18,456 square feet.
The City of Asheville has offered to lease the facility from the NCDOT Rail Division for $8.00 per square foot with a 10% discount applied because of the City’s ownership share.
This would equate to $7.20 per square foot, or $11,073.60 per month or $132,883.20 per year.
The rent rate would increase 2% per year.
The City has agreed to replace the roof of the facility.
In return, the City will receive rent credit until the total cost is satisfied.
The proposed term of the lease is for a period of 10 years with the option to renew for one additional five year period.
Council Goal(s):
A Well Planned and Livable Community
Fiscal Impact:
Funding for this lease was budgeted and is available in the Parks and Recreation Department operating budget.
Staff: Ellen McKinnon, Real Estate Coordinator; D. Tyrell McGirt, Director Parks and Recreation; Jade Dundas, Director of Capital Projects; Jannice Ashley, Senior Assistant City Attorney.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
City Manager Campbell said that City of Asheville employees are heroes in lots of ways. … At this time, she would like to recognize Public Works Fleet Manager Jake Klodt for being honored as the 2022 Fleet Manager of the Year for the State of North Carolina by the NC Chapter of the American Public Works Association. … Mr. Klodt thanked Public Works Director Greg Shuler and his team.
Regarding the Audit Committee, there were no applications. Therefore, City Council instructed the City Clerk to readvertise for the vacancies. … It was the consensus of the Boards and Commissions Committee, and City Council, to wait to make an appointment until the Nominating Committee of HIAC makes a recommendation. … At the request of the Chair of the Public Art & Cultural Commission, it was the consensus of the Boards & Commissions Committee, and City Council, to readvertise for the seat.
Proclamation
PROCLAMATION PROCLAIMING OCTOBER 2022 AS “ASHEVILLE SISTER CITIES MONTH”
Mayor Manheimer read the proclamation proclaiming October, 2022, as “Asheville Sister Cities Month” in the City of Asheville. She presented the proclamation to Asheville Sister Cities President Jessica Coffield, and Asheville Sister Cities Vice-President Ken Nelson, who briefly provided Council with information on their work the past year.
Mayor Manheimer read the proclamation proclaiming October, 2022, as “Asheville Sister Cities Month” in the City of Asheville.
Proclamation
PROCLAMATION IN SUPPORT FOR EFFORTS OF THE TRIBAL COUNCIL OF THE EASTERN BAND OF CHEROKEE INDIANS TO RESTORE THE NAME OF KUWOHI TO THE MOUNTAIN PRESENTLY KNOWN AS CLINGMANS DOME
Councilwoman Roney read the proclamation in Support for Efforts of the Tribal Council of the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians to Restore the Name of Kuwohi to the Mountain Presently known as Clingmans Dome. She presented the proclamation to Lavita Hill Mary Crowe, and others, who briefed City Council on the proclamation.
Councilwoman Roney read the proclamation in Support for Efforts of the Tribal Council of the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians to Restore the Name of Kuwohi to the Mountain Presently known as Clingmans Dome.
Open public comment 3 topics, as the minutes list them
update on the Realignment Working Group
need for dedicated pickleball courts and nets
an offer to assist the community with the opioid crisis
This resource, to the best of its ability, is copied word for word from the official minutes, “…” marks words left out, and [brackets] a name the minutes give elsewhere. The minutes are the record. Staff report details are quoted from the city’s meeting documents, prepared before the vote.