City Council regular meeting — January 12, 2021

Asheville City Council recorded 27 votes at its regular meeting on January 12, 2021; 1 drew at least one no vote. Most items fell under Boards & Appointments, Zoning & Land Use and Budget & Finance.

Met: 5 pm–8:38 pm. Voting: Sandra Kilgore, Esther E. Manheimer, S. Antanette Mosley, Kim Roney, Sheneika Smith, Sage Turner, Gwen Wisler.

Votes 27 recorded · 4 substantive · 1 split

Item II-D · ORD 4849 · Budget & Finance · Ordinance · consent agenda

Ordinance extending Ordinance No. 4801 on suspending certain fees and charges during the COVID-19 pandemic

Passed7–0 · Moved by Sheneika Smith, seconded by Gwen Wisler

All members present voted yes.

Recommendations

Council’s vote matched the city staff recommendation.

  • City staff (staff report): Approve — City staff recommends that Council adopt an Ordinance reaffirming and ratifying its intention that the fee-waiver authority provided for in Ordinance No. 4801 should continue for the duration of the locally declared COVID-19 state of emergency.

Key facts

  • $13,000 Waiver or suspension of fees for outdoor dining, a-frame signage, and push cart permits
  • $58,000 Transit fares continue to be suspended at an estimated monthly revenue loss of approximately $58,000
  • duration of the locally declared COVID-19 state of emergency term
From the staff report

Adopt an ordinance reaffirming and ratifying the authority delegated to the City Manager under Ordinance No. 4801 to waive or suspend collection of fees on a case-by-case basis in order to address the economic fallout of the COVID-19 pandemic.

  • $13,000 approximately
  • $58,000 estimated monthly revenue loss of approximately
Fiscal impact

Waiver or suspension of fees for outdoor dining, a-frame signage, and push cart permits is approximately $13,000 in deferred or lost revenue.

Staff: Eric Edgerton, Sr. Asst. City Attorney; Ben Woody, Development Services Director.

The city’s documents for this item

Item II-F · RES 21-3 · Parks & Recreation · Resolution · consent agenda

Contract amendment with Carolina Specialities of Hendersonville for the Jake Rusher Park improvements

Passed7–0 · Moved by Sheneika Smith, seconded by Gwen Wisler

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $110,000 amendment to the executed construction contract with Carolina Specialties Construction, LLC, in the amount of $110,000
  • $20,000 change orders that may arise during the remainder of the project up to the amount of $20,000
  • $1,202,801 total construction contract amount not to exceed $1,202,801
  • $1,072,801 originally approved contract and contingency of $1,072,801
  • Jake Rusher Park address
  • Carolina Specialties Construction, LLC contractor or recipient
  • the Capital Improvement Program (CIP) contingency budget that was previously approved as part of the Fiscal Year 2020-21 Adopted Budget funding source
  • the project will now be completed in the spring of 2021 term
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute an amendment to the construction contract with Carolina Specialties Construction of Hendersonville for the Jake Rusher Park Project.

Background:

  • Extensive unsuitable soils, unexpected buried building debris, and pervasive groundwater were encountered during the installation of the stormwater system at Jake Rusher Park.
  • Geotechnical analysis was performed on the site prior to construction.
  • Summer rainfall events elevated the groundwater table and had a significant impact on the soil conditions encountered while burying the storm pipe.
  • Changed site conditions resulted in excavations that filled with water which was not expected based upon the geotech analysis.
  • Dealing with these unexpected site conditions required changes in the pipe installation methodology. A stone base and drains were required to provide a suitable substrate on which to install the pipe.
  • Old boilers were also found buried on the site. This equipment was a remnant of a previous site use.
  • This was an unexpected discovery but the debris had to be removed in order to complete the work on this site.
  • There was no expectation that this type of debris would have been left buried from a previous use.
  • These changes resulted in prices that exceeded the originally approved contract and contingency of $1,072,801 by $110,000.
  • The original contracted completion date was October 2020. Due to the challenges described in this staff report and other weather related delays, the project will now be completed in the spring of 2021.

Vendor Outreach Efforts:

  • This is a change to an existing contract.

Council Goal(s):

  • A well planned and livable community.

Committee(s):

  • None.

Pro(s):

  • Provide needed infrastructure improvements for this South Asheville park which are scheduled for completion in the spring of 2021.

Con(s):

  • Unexpected increase in the project cost.
  • Unexpected extension of the project schedule.

Fiscal Impact:

  • Funding for this contract amendment will come from the Capital Improvement Program (CIP) contingency budget that was previously approved as part of the Fiscal Year 2020-21 Adopted Budget.

Staff: Jade Dundas, Capital Projects Director.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item IV-F-2 · Boards & Appointments · Motion

Motion to direct the City Clerk's Office to advertise for the School Board selection process

Passed7–0 · Moved by Sheneika Smith, seconded by S. Antanette Mosley

All members present voted yes.

2 council remarks

What council members said 2 remarks from 2 members

Sheneika Smith Voted yes · moved it

  • Concern Vice-Mayor Smith said that the Boards & Commissions Committee voted 2-1 (her being the dissenting vote) to reappoint Joyce Brown, Patricia Griffin and James Carter to the Asheville City Board of Education.

Kim Roney Voted yes

  • Comment Councilwoman Roney noted that we must make our three appointments by April 1.

The minutes record no remarks on this item from Sandra Kilgore, Esther E. Manheimer, S. Antanette Mosley, Sage Turner and Gwen Wisler.

Key facts

However, she moved the direct the City Clerk’s Office to advertise for the three seats and accept applications (current members included in this process), with the Boards & Commissions Committee to review applications at their February 9 meeting, at which time they will determine if essay questions and interviews should be a part of the appointment process.

Description in the minutes

Interim Human Resources Director Shannon Barrett said that this public hearing on the Civil Service Board Substantive Rules was advertised on January 1 and 8, 2021.

Background:

  • The Asheville Civil Service Act provides that the Civil Service Board (“CSB”) “shall make . . . substantive rules for promoting efficiency in the classified service of the City.”
  • The act further provides that the City Council, after giving members of the classified service and citizens of Asheville an opportunity to be heard at a public hearing, shall act upon the proposed rules and amendments, which become effective upon approval by a majority vote of the Council.
  • On December 3, 2020, the CSB voted to approve substantive rules clarifying important aspects of the City’s personnel administration and the Board’s jurisdiction, including definitions of terms (such as demotion, discharge, due process,and suspension), important to the City’s personnel administration and the Board’s standard of review for grievance hearings.

Pro(s):

  • Will provide employees, the City, and members of the Board with clarity about the types of employment actions falling under the Board’s jurisdiction, as well as the standards the Board uses when determining whether a complaint of employment action is justified.

Con(s):

  • None

Fiscal Impact:

  • None Deputy City Attorney John Maddux said that the Civil Service Act passed in 1953 and it applies only to the City of Asheville. Two it has two main functions (1) review promotional criteria in Police & Fire Departments and (2) hear certain employee grievances. The Civil Service Act was revised in 2009 that required that the Civil Service Board pass substantive rules, subject to amendment and adoption by City Council. Procedural rules were adopted in 2013 and a subcommittee was formed in 2014; however, rules were not finalized. The lack of substantive rules is not an issue for day-to-day administration since employees operate under City Manager administrative and departmental rules. Clarification is needed for how the Civil Service Board will resolve issues in grievance hearings
  • to define common terms and clarify hearing standards. In 2020 the Civil Service Board and City staff collaborated on development of substantive rules (1) engaged proactively with employee associations; and (2) agreement that engagement should value accountability and respect for employees’ due process rights. Ms. Barrett reviewed the following definitions (1) Classified Service
  • city personnel as defined in the Civil Service Act, which includes personnel below the Assistant Department Director level; (2) Demotion
  • involuntary and permanent reassignment into a position in a lower pay grade; (3) Discharge
  • involuntary and permanent separation from employment with the City due to violation of a City policy or unsatisfactory work performance; (4) Entitled
  • an absolute right to a promotion or a raise in pay automatically due to employee based on specific criteria, i.e., time in service, educational attainment, etc.; (5) Suspension
  • involuntary and temporary unpaid leave of more than 14 calendar days; (6) Transfer
  • involuntary and temporary reassignment into a position in a different City department; (7) Due Process
  • notice of allocations and an opportunity to be heard by a department director prior to a decision, and if the employee utilizes a disciplinary matrix, discipline that accords with that matrix; and (8) Probationary Employees
  • newly hired, rehired, promoted, or voluntary transferred employees are probationary employees for 365 calendar days. Mr. Maddux said that regarding grievance hearing standards
  • justified means (1) two part test (a) employee received due process, and (2) employee violated a City or departmental policy, rule or code of conduct, according to abuse of discretion standards; and (2) abuse of discretion
  • a decision that is clearly unreasonable, erroneous, or arbitrary. Councilwoman Wisler, liaison to the Civil Service Board for seven years, felt this is a long-time coming and thanked City staff for their hard work on bringing this forward. Mr. Maddux responded to Councilwoman Kilgore regarding the probation period of 365 calendar days. Mr. Maddux responded to Councilwoman Roney who asked if this item was reviewed by a City Council Committee or were there opportunities for the public to engage in this process. In addition, she asked the reason for the dissenting vote by the one Civil Service Board member. Mr. Maddux did not want to speak for the dissenting Civil Service Board member; however, he felt that the member felt this took away too much of the Board’s discretion and put it in the hands of department directors. Staff felt that this is putting more discretion in the department directors who actually oversee the employee, but there is still a role for the Civil Service Board. Regarding public engagement, employee associations for police officers and firefighters were engaged, as well as working with the City's HR department on behalf of all employees. City Attorney Branham noted that for some time we have been working closely with a lot of neighborhood advocacy groups as well as a number of individuals regarding global efforts to deal with several aspects of employee accountability, in particular the Asheville Police Department. The mutual goal has been to improve the City's ability to hold employees accountable when warranted, while still protecting the due process rights of employees. This effort has been one aspect of that broader initiative, and multiple public advocacy groups have been a part of these discussions. Councilwoman Roney requested information on engagement of community partners who have been at the table regarding the Civil Service Board, with Councilwoman Turner suggesting some analysis of what we have and what this changes. Councilwoman Wisler noted that she talked with a representative of the racial justice coalition about the changes. Mr. Maddux noted that he received an email from a community member and he provided a very extensive response, asking him to contact him if he had questions. He felt the process was transparent in that there were several Civil Service Board meetings. Councilwoman Turner noted that the community member did state that he felt the changes were moving in the right direction. Vice-Mayor Smith felt that we need to reach out to people who have the specific skill set and a deeper level with those who are familiar with due process or legal definition. Mayor Manheimer felt that these rules are more about process and are administratively oriented since these are internally process rules. Mayor Manheimer opened the public hearing at 7:53 p.m. Mayor Manheimer announced that there were no advanced live call-ins for this public hearing item. In accordance with recent legislation amending North Carolina G.S. §166A-19.24(e), regarding public hearings conducted during remote meetings, written comments for this public hearing will be accepted for an additional 24 hours. Therefore,

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

Item V-A-3 · RES 21-9 · Boards & Appointments · Appointment

Resolution appointing members to the ABC Board (reappoint Robin Cape)

Passed6–1 · Moved by Sheneika Smith, seconded by Kim Roney

No: Gwen Wisler  ·  Yes: Sandra Kilgore, Esther E. Manheimer, S. Antanette Mosley, Kim Roney, Sheneika Smith, Sage Turner

Recommendations

  • ABC Board: reappoint Robin Cape; also recommended Sharon West, George Tsiros, Jeff Irvin or David Angelus
  • Boards & Commissions Committee: reappoint Robin Cape; appoint Sharon West and Nian W. Avery

Key facts

  • unexpired term until November 13, 2021 … to serve a three-year term, term to expire November 13, 2023, or until her successor has been appointed term
Description in the minutes

Vice-Mayor Smith, Chair of the Boards & Commissions Committee, said that this is the consideration of appointing members to the Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC) Board. The terms of Robin Cape and John Menkes expired on November 13, 2020. In addition, Januarie West has resigned, thus leaving an unexpired term until November 13, 2021. The following individuals applied for the vacancy: Sharon West, Robin Cape, Meaghan Austin, James J. Spencer, Keaton Edwards, David Angelus, Gregory Hill, Bill Kopp, Harry Michael Lanning, George Tsiros, Jeff Irvin, Nian W. Ivery and Johnnie N. Grant. On December 8, 2020, it was the recommendation of the Boards & Commissions Committee and consensus of City Council to re-advertise for these seats. The ABC Board recommends reappointment of Robin Cape, and recommended Sharon West, George Tsiros, Jeff Irvin or David Angelus. Boards & Commissions Committee recommended reappointing Robin Cape; and appointing Sharon West and Nian W. Avery.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Show the other 23 votes · consent agenda and routine items · consent agenda moved by Sheneika Smith, seconded by Gwen Wisler

Item II-A · Administrative · consent agenda

Approval of the minutes of the regular meeting held on December 8, 2020

Passed7–0 · Moved by Sheneika Smith, seconded by Gwen Wisler

All members present voted yes.

1 spoke, 1 against

Public comment on this item

0 spoke in favor · 1 spoke against

  • Against Greenleaf Clarke — Greenleaf Clarke explained why they were opposed to the adoption of the December 8, 2020, minutes; the adoption of the Fiscal Year 2020-21 City Council budget calendar; and the adoption of the amended contract with Griffin Waste Services.

The city’s documents for this item

Item II-B · Budget & Finance · Motion · consent agenda

Motion adopting the Fiscal Year 2021-22 City Council Budget Calendar

Passed7–0 · Moved by Sheneika Smith, seconded by Gwen Wisler

All members present voted yes.

1 spoke, 1 against

Public comment on this item

One hearing covered this item and agenda item II-A; the counts are for the whole hearing.

0 spoke in favor · 1 spoke against

  • Against Greenleaf Clarke — Greenleaf Clarke explained why they were opposed to the adoption of the December 8, 2020, minutes; the adoption of the Fiscal Year 2020-21 City Council budget calendar; and the adoption of the amended contract with Griffin Waste Services.

Key facts

  • Fiscal Year 2021-2022 Operating and Capital Budget development process term
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Motion to adopt the Fiscal Year 2021-2022 (FY22) Budget Calendar.

Background:

  • As part of the Fiscal Year 2021-2022 Operating and Capital Budget development process staff is proposing a budget schedule.
  • In addition to meeting the statutory requirement that the City Council adopt a balanced budget before July 1, 2021, the FY22 budget process is intended to more clearly identify the links between service, program and project investments and community interests.
  • Staff have already begun work to develop estimates for ongoing cost to deliver existing programs and services, needed capital infrastructure and facility investments, and major revenue sources.
  • Unlike previous years, the process will include a higher level of community engagement as well as consultations with City Council beginning at a retreat and continuing through work sessions with a focus on
  • Integrating with ongoing public engagement efforts building on the 30/60/90 day plan now called Advancing Racial Equity in Asheville.
  • Reviewing key services to identify customer impact.
  • Establishing clear goals to measure desired community outcomes.
  • The process culminates with the following actions as required by state law:
  • Formal presentation of the City Manager’s Proposed Budget on May 11, 2021.
  • A Public Hearing on the Proposed Budget on May 25, 2021.
  • Budget adoption June 8, 2021.

Council Goal(s):

  • A Financially Resilient City
  • A Connected and Engaged Community

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • Provides City Council, staff, and the community with a calendar of upcoming dates related to development of the FY22 budget.

Con(s):

  • None.

Fiscal Impact:

  • None.

Staff: Barbara Whitehorn, Chief Financial Officer; Tony McDowell, Assistant Finance Director Budget & Forecasting.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item II-C · RES 21-1 · Environment & Sustainability · Resolution · consent agenda

Ratifying an amended contract with Griffin Waste Services for public portable toilets and handwashing stations

Passed7–0 · Moved by Sheneika Smith, seconded by Gwen Wisler

All members present voted yes.

1 spoke, 1 against

Public comment on this item

One hearing covered this item and agenda item II-A; the counts are for the whole hearing.

0 spoke in favor · 1 spoke against

  • Against Greenleaf Clarke — Greenleaf Clarke explained why they were opposed to the adoption of the December 8, 2020, minutes; the adoption of the Fiscal Year 2020-21 City Council budget calendar; and the adoption of the amended contract with Griffin Waste Services.

Key facts

  • $45,000 increase the total by $45,000
  • $199,000 the new total amount of $199,000
  • $89,000 an amount not to exceed $89,000
  • Griffin Waste Services contractor or recipient
  • Coronavirus Relief Funds (CRF) funding source
  • work through March 2021 term
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution ratifying a $45,000 amendment to the services contract with FusionSite Asheville, LLC (hereinafter referred to as “Griffin Waste Services”) and authorizing the City Manager’s execution of the amended services contract in the new total amount of $199,000 for rental and maintenance of portable toilets and handwashing stations for public use.

Background:

  • Due to the COVID-19 pandemic and resulting closure of public and private buildings in March 2020, portable restrooms and handwashing stations were deployed for public use as an emergency response as per direction from the City-County Emergency Operations Center.
  • Griffin Waste Services in Asheville was an existing provider of services to City facilities prior to the pandemic and the only contractor identified in the region with the capacity to fulfill the services required.
  • As authorized by the City Manager, a contract was established with Griffin Waste Services in June 2020 for an amount not to exceed $89,000 for rental, routine cleaning, and daily maintenance of the units.
  • On September 8, 2020, City Council adopted resolution 20-157 authorizing the City Manager to execute an amended services contract with Griffin Waste Services increasing the total by $65,000, from $89,000 to $154,000, allowing the vendor to perform the work through December 2020.
  • The need for portable restrooms and handwashing stations is expected to continue until the COVID-19 emergency declaration is canceled.
  • An amended contract with Griffin Waste Services to increase the total by $45,000, from $154,000 to $199,000, will allow the vendor to perform the work through March 2021.

Vendor Outreach Efforts:

  • At the start of the pandemic, staff searched for all providers throughout Western North Carolina, Greensboro, NC, Charlotte, NC, and Greenville-Spartanburg, SC, and engaged in a search for national providers including options to lease or purchase equipment.
  • Griffin Waste Services, recently merged with Able Rent-a-Jon, was the only local vendor with available capacity.

Council Goal(s):

  • A well-planned and livable community
  • A clean and healthy environment
  • Emergency Response

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • Supports basic public health needs during a Pandemic

Con(s):

  • None

Fiscal Impact:

  • Funding for this contract amendment of $45,000 is coming from Coronavirus Relief Funds (CRF). If operations are continued beyond March 2021, another funding source will need to be identified.

Staff: Sam Powers, Community & Economic Development Director; Jon Fillman, Community Event Manager.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item II-E · RES 21-2 · Transportation · Resolution · consent agenda

Resolution authorizing the City Manager to ratify and amend the transit software contract with Swiftly Inc.

Passed7–0 · Moved by Sheneika Smith, seconded by Gwen Wisler

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $11,339 increase the Year 3 contract amount by $11,339
  • $122,082 total cost through Year 3
  • $179,923.1 total contract amount through Year 4
  • Swiftly Inc. contractor or recipient
  • Funding for Year 3 of the agreement is included in the adopted Fiscal Year 2020-21 Transit Services operating budget and Funding for Year 4 will be included in the recommended Fiscal Year 2021-22 Transit Services operating budget. funding source
  • through Year 4 term
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to amend the agreement with Swiftly, Inc. in order to increase the Year 3 contract amount by $11,339 for a total cost through Year 3 of $122,082 and to increase the total contract amount by $1.00 for a total contract amount of $179,923.10 through Year 4.

Background:

  • City Council approved Resolution No. 20-198 on November 10, 2020, authorizing the City Manager to amend the Swiftly, Inc. agreement in order to increase the contract amount through Year 3 to $110,743 resulting in an increase to the total contract amount to $179,922.10.
  • Swiftly, Inc. provides real-time passenger information services.
  • The overall contract for the cumulative amount of four years has only changed by $1.00 The annual contract amounts are as follows:
  • Year 1
  • FY 2019 = $38,180.00
  • Year 2
  • FY 2020 = $30,999.00
  • Year 3
  • FY 2021 = $52,902.00
  • Year 4
  • FY 2022 = $57,842.10
  • The total amount of the contract changed from $179,922.10 to $179,923.10.

Council Goal(s):

  • Transportation and Accessibility

Committee(s):

  • None.

Pro(s):

  • Provides the corrected amount needed through Year 3 of the agreement.
  • Provides the corrected total contract amount through Year 4 of the agreement.

Con(s):

  • None.

Fiscal Impact:

  • Funding for Year 3 of the agreement is included in the adopted Fiscal Year 2020-21 Transit Services operating budget and Funding for Year 4 will be included in the recommended Fiscal Year 2021-22 Transit Services operating budget.

Staff: Ken Putnam, PE, Transportation Department Director; Jessica Morriss, AICP, MPA, Assistant Transportation Department Director; Eunice Lovi, Transit Planning Manager.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item II-G · RES 21-4 / RES 21-5 / ORD 4850 · Housing · Resolution · consent agenda

Ratifying Code Purple emergency shelter agreements with Western Carolina Rescue Ministries and Buncombe County, and budget amendment

Passed7–0 · Moved by Sheneika Smith, seconded by Gwen Wisler

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $80,000 a contract with Western Carolina Rescue Ministries, Inc. in the amount of $80,000 to extend provision of Code Purple emergency shelter
  • $40,000 $40,000 from Buncombe County
  • $40,000 $40,000 from pay-go funding previously approved to support affordable housing
  • $2,130 reimbursed at a flat rate of $2,130.00 for each night Code Purple occurs
  • Western Carolina Rescue Ministries, Inc. contractor or recipient
  • $40,000 from Buncombe County and $40,000 from pay-go funding previously approved to support affordable housing funding source
  • up to 37 nights term
Description in the minutes

Background:

  • Code Purple is a longstanding practice where homeless shelter providers exceed regular capacity and waive regular rules on nights when the temperature or windchill are at/below 32 degrees in order to ensure survival of people experiencing homelessness.
  • Code Purple is a community-led initiative that has primarily been coordinated by agencies in the Homeless Coalition.
  • COVID-19 has created many challenges for homeless service providers and therefore no emergency shelters were able to participate in Code Purple this winter at their facilities.
  • Western Carolina Rescue Ministries, Inc. agreed to operate Code Purple in an off-site location.
  • In order to meet these extraordinary circumstances, on December 1, 2020, the City of Asheville entered into an agreement with Western Carolina Rescue Ministries, Inc. to provide up to 50 Code Purple beds at First Congregational United Church of Christ for the month of December.
  • Funding for this first month of operations came from Coronavirus Relief Funding (CRF) previously approved by the City Council.
  • City staff have been in discussions with Buncombe County and other non-profit organizations to discuss cost-sharing for the extension of the Code Purple shelter.
  • Buncombe County has agreed to provide up to $40,000 of funding to assist in keeping the shelter operational this winter.
  • The additional funding of $40,000 needed for the contract will come from previously budgeted affordable housing pay-go funding in the City’s Capital Improvement Program (CIP).
  • Operational costs will be reimbursed at a flat rate of $2,130.00 for each night Code Purple occurs. The contract provides funding for up to 37 nights, in an amount not to exceed $80,000.00, and may be extended if additional need and additional funds are identified.
  • A new agreement is required to meet this critical need for the duration of winter.

Council Goal(s):

  • A Well-Planned and Livable Community
  • A Connected and Engaged Community
  • A Financially Resilient City

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • Continues the essential operation of Code Purple
  • Supports survival for vulnerable community members
  • Addresses public health and safety

Con(s):

  • Requires the reallocation of a portion of the City’s affordable housing CIP budget.
  • Additional funding will be needed if Code Purple exceeds 37 nights.
  • Staff is talking to other agencies to obtain additional funding if needed.

Fiscal Impact:

  • As noted above, December costs were funded with Coronavirus Relief Funding (CRF).
  • The City-funded portion of the estimated cost after December will be funded by reallocating pay-go funding previously planned to support affordable housing to meet potential shelter costs for 37 nights.
  • Beyond that, additional funding and partners are required.

Staff: Sam Powers, Director of Community and Economic Development; Emily Ball, Community Development Analyst.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item II-H · RES 21-6 / ORD 4851 · Environment & Sustainability · Resolution · consent agenda

Resolution authorizing the City Manager to accept grant funding from the Natural Resources Defense Council for the City's food policy action plan, and budget amendment

Passed7–0 · Moved by Sheneika Smith, seconded by Gwen Wisler

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $16,100 accept funding in the amount of $16,100 from Natural Resource Defense Council (NRDC)
  • Natural Resource Defense Council (NRDC) contractor or recipient
  • there is no required City match funding source
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to accept funding in the amount of $16,100 from Natural Resource Defense Council (NRDC) for the Office of Sustainability’s food policy and waste reduction work, and a budget amendment in the amount of $16,100 to appropriate the funding in the City’s Office of Sustainability budget.

Background:

  • In November 2017, Asheville City Council approved the Municipal Food Policy Goals and Action Plan by adopting Resolution 17-257.
  • The adopted plan includes six focus areas. This project will address the “Resource Stewardship” focus area which prioritizes city-wide waste reduction.
  • Within the resource stewardship focus area, the plan outlines a need to create an actionable plan for city food waste recovery, composting, and redistribution.
  • Project efforts will include:
  • Public Food Waste Reduction statement
  • Snapshot food waste audits at city facilities
  • Community compost drop off pilot program
  • Public outreach and education campaign, with a goal of reducing food waste within the Asheville community.
  • Through a competitive process, NRDC has selected the City of Asheville’s Office of Sustainability to participate in a Southeast regional cohort with Atlanta, Memphis, Nashville, and Orlando to develop food waste reduction initiatives.
  • The City of Asheville’s Office of Sustainability will pilot four strategies to increase food waste reduction and educate residents on opportunities for decreasing residential and commercial food waste.
  • Grant funds will be utilized to engage the community through outreach, education, and program opportunity strategies.
  • NRDC Grant recipients are not required to provide a cash match.

Council Goal(s):

  • A well-planned and livable community
  • A clean and healthy environment
  • A connected and engaged community

Committee(s):

  • Although the grant was not routed through the Sustainability Advisory Committee, members of the committee are working with staff to help implement the grant.

Pro(s):

  • Helps support City’s Food Policy Action Plan Resolution 17-257 while leveraging NRDC funding
  • Addresses Resolution 14-27 Asheville’s Waste Reduction Goal
  • Engage with regional partner cities to connect, collaborate, and share best practices

Con(s):

  • None

Fiscal Impact:

  • None; there is no required City match

Staff: Amber Weaver, Sustainability Officer, Office of Sustainability.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item IV-A · Zoning & Land Use · Public hearing

Public hearing to permanently close a portion of right-of-way - motion to continue comment period 24 hours

Passed7–0 · Moved by Sandra Kilgore, seconded by Sage Turner

All members present voted yes.

Recommendations

  • Multimodal Transportation Committee: Approve, unanimous, October 28, 2020

Public hearing advertised Dec 18, 2020 and Dec 25, 2020 and Jan 1, 2021 and Jan 8, 2021

No one from the public spoke.

Mayor Manheimer announced that there was one advanced live call-ins for this public hearing item; however, that person did not join into the meeting.

Key facts

  • 55 S. Market St., PIN# 9648-59-0637 address
  • Fifty-Five South Market, LLC applicant

In accordance with recent legislation amending North Carolina G.S. §166A-19.24(e), regarding public hearings conducted during remote meetings, written comments for this public hearing will be accepted for an additional 24 hours. Therefore, Councilwoman Kilgore moved to recess this item until January 26, 2021, at which time this public hearing will be voted.

Presented by Chad Bandy, Streets Division Manager.

From the staff report

Adoption of a resolution to permanently close a portion of right-of-way known as Velvet St

  • Fifty-Five South Market, LLC has petitioned for this closure. asked for this item
  • 0.01 acres 55 S. Market St.
  • 9648-59-0637 parcel ID (PIN)
Fiscal impact

There will be no fiscal impact related to this closure.

Staff’s stated reasons
  • This closure will not impede any future use of this right-of-way.
Before it reached Council
  • Multimodal Transportation Committee, October 28, 2020: approve — Recommended closing the right-of-way by unanimous vote.
City Code sections

N.C. Gen. Stat. § 160A-299

Staff: Greg Shuler, Public Works Director; Chad Bandy, Streets Division Manager.

Item IV-B · Zoning & Land Use · Public hearing

Public hearing to permanently close a portion of right-of-way - motion to continue comment period 24 hours

Passed7–0 · Moved by Sage Turner, seconded by Gwen Wisler

All members present voted yes.

1 spoke

Recommendations

  • Multimodal Transportation Committee: Approve with conditions, unanimous, October 28, 2020

Public hearing advertised Dec 18, 2020 and Dec 25, 2020 and Jan 1, 2021 and Jan 8, 2021

1 spoke in favor · 0 spoke against

  • For Youngblood Haske · applicant — He said they feel that if the closure is approved, they will be able to better define their property and avoid ongoing issues with their neighbor.

Key facts

  • 137 Houston Street address
  • Youngblood and Sarah Haske applicant

In accordance with recent legislation amending North Carolina G.S. §166A-19.24(e), regarding public hearings conducted during remote meetings, written comments for this public hearing will be accepted for an additional 24 hours. Therefore, Councilwoman Turner moved to recess this item until January 26, 2021, at which time this public hearing will be voted.

Presented by Chad Bandy, Streets Division Manager.

From the staff report

Adoption of a resolution to permanently close of a portion of right-of-way at the intersection of Courtland Avenue and Houston Street.

  • Youngblood and Sarah Haske have petitioned to close this right-of-way. asked for this item
Fiscal impact

There will be no fiscal impact related to this closure.

Staff’s stated reasons
  • This closure will allow for the recombination of parcels while removing the excess unused portion of right-of-way from the parcels.
Before it reached Council
  • Multimodal Transportation Committee, October 28, 2020: approve with conditions — unanimously supported the closure of the right-of- way with the condition of an 11.5’ easement remaining for future City of Asheville use.
City Code sections

N.C. Gen. Stat. § 160A-299

Staff: Greg Shuler, Public Works Director; Chad Bandy, Streets Division Manager.

The city’s documents for this item

Item IV-C · Zoning & Land Use · Public hearing

Public hearing to permanently close a portion of an unopened right-of-way - motion to continue comment period 24 hours

Passed7–0 · Moved by S. Antanette Mosley, seconded by Sandra Kilgore

All members present voted yes.

Recommendations

  • Multimodal Transportation Committee: Approve, unanimous, October 28, 2020

Public hearing advertised Dec 18, 2020 and Dec 25, 2020 and Jan 1, 2021 and Jan 8, 2021

No one from the public spoke.

Mayor Manheimer announced that there were no advanced live call-ins for this public hearing item.

Key facts

  • unopened right-of-way known as Trade Street address
  • 4 units housing units
  • Meinch Construction, Inc. applicant

In accordance with recent legislation amending North Carolina G.S. §166A-19.24(e), regarding public hearings conducted during remote meetings, written comments for this public hearing will be accepted for an additional 24 hours. Therefore, Councilwoman Mosley moved to recess this item until January 26, 2021, at which time this public hearing will be voted.

Presented by Chad Bandy, Streets Division Manager.

From the staff report

Adoption of a resolution to permanently close an unopened right-of-way known as Trade Street.

  • Meinch Construction, Inc. has petitioned to close this right-of-way. asked for this item
Fiscal impact

There will be no fiscal impact related to this closure.

Staff’s stated reasons
  • The right-of-way is needed to provide the required screening in the back of the property for 4 residential units that will front on Roberts Street.
Before it reached Council
  • Multimodal Transportation Committee, October 28, 2020: approve — Supported closing the right-of-way by unanimous vote.
City Code sections

N.C. Gen. Stat. § 160A-299

Staff: Greg Shuler, Public Works Director; Chad Bandy, Streets Division Manager.

The city’s documents for this item

Item IV-D · Zoning & Land Use · Public hearing

Public hearing to consider an amendment to Articles II and III (UDO) - motion to continue to March 23, 2021

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Sage Turner

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

Councilwoman Wisler moved to continue this public hearing until March 23, 2021.

Item IV-E · Zoning & Land Use · Public hearing

Public hearing to consider the conditional zoning of 32.2 acres at Sand Hill Road - motion to continue comment period 24 hours

Passed7–0 · Moved by Sandra Kilgore, seconded by S. Antanette Mosley

All members present voted yes.

4 spoke · 4 council remarks

Recommendations

  • City staff (staff report): Approve with conditions — Staff recommends approval of this rezoning request with the conditions as shown in the associated site plans and building elevations (Exhibit D) and attached Exhibit B1.
  • Technical Review Committee: Approve with conditions, November 16, 2020
  • Planning & Zoning Commission: Approve, December 17, 2020

Public hearing advertised Jan 1, 2021 and Jan 8, 2021

4 spoke in favor · 0 spoke against

  • For Brian Hall · for the applicant, Samet Corporation — Brian Hall, Director of Development of Samet Corporation, said that jobs range in scale beginning at a minimum of $15.00/hour.

From advanced live call-ins, 3 individuals spoke in support of this project. The minutes name 1 of the 4 speakers.

What council members said 4 remarks from 4 members

Sage Turner Voted yes

  • Concern Councilwoman Turner felt that when the application is reviewed by City Council, it should have the TIA included.

Gwen Wisler Voted yes

  • Concern In response to Councilwoman Wisler, [Shannon Tuch] provided information on why this area would have been identified as a future urban center, noting that there is tech and industrial property around it.

Kim Roney Voted yes

  • Question When Councilwoman Roney asked about the annual property tax, [Shannon Tuch] said that the estimated amount is approximately $130,000, which will more than offset the City’s serve needs to this property.

Esther E. Manheimer Voted yes

  • Question Mayor Manheimer wondered if there has been an analysis done on the number of miles driven by consumers to pick up their goods vs. having the delivery truck deliver the goods.

The minutes record no remarks on this item from Sandra Kilgore, S. Antanette Mosley and Sheneika Smith.

Key facts

  • $3.5 million investing roughly $3.5 Million now on that electrical conduit
  • $130,000 anticipated property tax revenue (approximately $130,000 annually
  • 99999 Sand Hill Road (PIN 9617-43-0440) address
  • 32.2 acres site size
  • Commercial Industrial District → Commercial Expansion/Conditional Zone zoning, from → to

In accordance with recent legislation amending North Carolina G.S. §166A-19.24(e), regarding public hearings conducted during remote meetings, written comments for this public hearing will be accepted for an additional 24 hours. Therefore, Councilwoman Kilgore moved to recess this item until January 26, 2021, at which time this public hearing will be voted.

Presented by Shannon Tuch, Principal Planner.

From the staff report

Conditionally zone 32.2 acres from Commercial Industrial - Conditional Zone (CI - CZ) to Commercial Expansion - Conditional Zone (COM EXP - CZ) and amend the Future Land Use Map from Urban Center to Employment/Anchor Institution.

  • $130,000 approximately
  • Commercial Industrial - Conditional Zone (CI - CZ) → Commercial Expansion - Conditional Zone (COM EXP - CZ) zoning, current → requested
  • 32.2 acres 99999 Sand Hill Road
  • Enka Partners of Asheville owner
  • 9617-43-0440 parcel ID (PIN)
Fiscal impact

The proposed road improvements are not in the City's jurisdiction and will not be city maintained, while other service costs and are expected to be offset by anticipated property tax revenue (approximately $130,000 annually, based on an initial investment of $30 M).

Staff’s stated reasons · approve with conditions
  • The proposed zoning and land use is compatible with the surrounding zoning and uses.
  • The proposed development’s warehouse and distribution use contributes to the employment center that already exists in this location and is well located for access to transportation corridors.
Before it reached Council
  • Technical Review Committee (TRC), November 16, 2020: approve with conditions — approved with conditions
  • Planning & Zoning Commission (PZC), December 17, 2020: approve — recommend approval

Staff: Todd Okolichany, AICP, LEED AP ND, Planning & Urban Design Director; Shannon Tuch, RLA, Principal Planner.

Description in the minutes

When Mayor Manheimer said that no Traffic Impact Analysis (TIA) has been reviewed by the City, Councilwoman Turner and Councilwoman Wisler said they would be okay in moving into the public hearing phase; however, they want to make sure that as soon as the TIA and recommendation from the N.C. Dept. of Transportation (NCDOT) is available, that it is provided to City Council. Councilwoman Turner felt that when the application is reviewed by City Council, it should have the TIA included. Principal Planner Shannon Tuch said that the TIA has been completed and sent to the NCDOT; however, staff has not heard the results. She did note that in the B.1 conditions, there is a condition that the applicant will be required to complete any recommendations identified through the TIA review process. She did note that most likely, those recommendations will be off-site and affect the roads around the project. Ms. Tuch said that this is the consideration of an ordinance to conditionally zone 32.2 acres of property located at 99999 Sand Hill Road from Commercial Industrial District to Commercial Expansion/Conditional Zone for an approximately 130,000 square foot warehouse and distribution facility and surface parking and vehicle storage areas, along with a change in the Future Land Use Map from Urban Center to Employment/Anchor Institution Center. This public hearing was advertised on January 1 and 8, 2021. Project Location and Contacts:

  • The project site consists of a portion of a larger 45.4 acre parcel located at 99999 Sand Hill Road (PIN 9617-43-0440).
  • Owner: Enka Partners of Asheville. Summary of

Petition:

  • The applicant is proposing to build an approximately 130,000 square foot single-story warehouse building with an overall height of 48 feet.
  • The application is for a rezoning via conditional zoning due to the size of the building, and includes a site plan and conditions proposed by the developer.
  • 926,807 square feet or 21.3 acres (61% of the site) is covered with an impervious surface.
  • The project includes 34.87 acres of disturbance with 3.17 acres of that disturbance occurring off-site for the purpose of constructing the access road and an above ground detention basin
  • The site will obtain access via a new road construction off of Enka Heritage Way, which will connect to Smokey Park Highway (US 19/23) via a newly constructed bridge.
  • A traffic impact analysis is required with the N.C. Dept. of Transportation to review and approve.
  • The Enka Heritage Trail greenway and easement is planned to run along the west side of the property as identified on the landscape plan.
  • Hominy Creek and tributaries are nearby, but off-site of the project area.
  • 278 employee surface parking spaces are provided (including seven ADA spaces) as permitted by the City’s Unified Development Ordinance (UDO).
  • 696 van storage spaces are also shown and are classified as outdoor vehicle storage.
  • Sidewalks and/or striped pedestrian pathways connect the parking areas to the building; additional sidewalk is provided along the access drives and around the building and range in size from four feet to 12 feet wide.
  • A wider 18 foot pedestrian/loading zone is located in front of the building.
  • An existing historic clock tower is currently protected under Ordinance No. 3921 (2010) and is shown on the site plan and B1 conditions to be protected and preserved.
  • If approved, the new ordinance will supplant the 2010 Ordinance.
  • While historic, the tower is not a designated landmark or identified as a contributing structure to a registered historic district.
  • Other key site features include:
  • Permanent and construction easements for a segment of the Enka Heritage Trail Greenway.
  • 15 percent of the site is set aside as open space.
  • 10 to 11 percent of the site will be reforested to meet tree canopy requirements, the remaining nine to 10 percent will be provided through a fee-in-lieu.
  • A portion of a new road (Enka Heritage Way) will be constructed as part of this project and maintained by NCDOT, connecting Smokey Park Highway (US 19/23) to Sand Hill Road.
  • The project does not comply with the zoning standards in the following ways:
  • Commercial Expansion requires 10 foot wide sidewalks throughout; the proposed plan provides a range of sidewalk widths from four to 12 feet wide.
  • Commercial Expansion requires operable pedestrian entrances every 75’ along the primary facade; operable entrances will be provided as shown on the approved building elevations.
  • Parking lot islands must maintain an average width of 10 feet; most islands will average nine feet wide as shown on the approved site plans.
  • Outdoor site lighting shall maintain a Backlight-Uplight-Glare (“BUG”) rating of B3-U0-G3; approximately two thirds of onsite pole luminaires will be type 5 (360 degree) lamps which have a BUG rating of B4-U0-G2.

Comprehensive Plan Consistency:

  • This proposal is consistent with the Living Asheville Comprehensive Plan themes of a “Livable Built Environment” and “Resilient Economy” by aligning with the following goals:
  • Encourage Responsible Growth by directing growth in designated growth areas that provide access to housing, transportation, goods and services, and employment opportunities.
  • Promote Great Architecture and Urban Design to Enhance Placemaking by encouraging the preservation of the historic Enka community clock tower.
  • Make Streets More Walkable, Comfortable and Connected by preserving the opportunity for future greenway construction.
  • Facilitate Real Estate Development that Maximizes Public Benefit by locating an employment opportunity in areas slated for future growth and in proximity to transportation and recreation facilities. The growth scenario maps all identify the areas around the intersection with Sand Hill Road and Smokey Park Highway as employment/anchor institution centers suitable for higher density/intensity development.

Compatibility Analysis:

  • The proposed zoning and land use is compatible with the surrounding zoning and uses.
  • South of the subject property is industrial (IND) zoned property that supports an active manufacturing plant; to the west is additional IND zoned property that supports the AB Tech Community College; to the east is a mix of industrial and warehouse uses located in Buncombe County and zoned Employment (EMP); and to the north across Smokey Park Highway is a mix of highway oriented commercial businesses zoned Highway Business (HB).
  • The proposed development’s warehouse and distribution use contributes to the employment center that already exists in this location and is well located for access to transportation corridors.

Committee(s):

  • Technical Review Committee (TRC)
  • November 16, 2020
  • approved with conditions
  • Planning & Zoning Commission (PZC)
  • December 2 and 17, 2020
  • recommend approval

Fiscal Impact:

  • The proposed road improvements are not in the City's jurisdiction and will not be city maintained, while other service costs and are expected to be offset by anticipated property tax revenue (approximately $130,000 annually, based on an initial investment of $30 M). This project also supports the Asheville economy by providing approximately 115 full time, 50 part time, and 190 delivery service driver jobs (drivers are third party contractors). Ms. Tuch said that on the Site Plan, it shows 278 employee parking spaces, 696 van storage spaces, landscaping (parking lot, building impact), 21.3 acres (61%) of impervious surfaces, bioretention cells in parking lot + 2.3 acre pond, sidewalks (4-12’ wide, throughout site), tree preservation (reforest 10% + fee-in-lieu), open space, historic historic clock tower preserved and protected, greenway easements (to be coordinated with Buncombe County), access via new road construction, and bike lanes. The conditions, in general (1) one-story warehouse and distribution facility (a) approximately 130,000 square feet; (b) 278 employee parking spaces; (c) 696 van parking/storage spaces; (d) 31.7 acres of disturbance; and (e) landscape, open space and tree preservation requirements met; and (2) two access points from Enka Heritage Way (a) a Traffic Impact Analysis required and reviewed by the N.C. Dept. of Transportation
  • any recommendations must be met; and (b) the new roadway and bridge will be maintained by the N.C. Dept. of Transportation. Modifications/exemptions from the conditions include (1) sidewalk width (varies 4-12’ throughout); (2) tree island width (9’ minimum); (3) spacing of pedestrian entrances (further than 75 feet apart); and (4) backlight rating exceeded (4 instead of 3) on most parking lot lights. In response to Councilwoman Wisler, Ms. Tuch provided information on why this area would have been identified as a future urban center, noting that there is tech and industrial property around it. When Councilwoman Roney asked about the annual property tax, Ms. Tuch said that the estimated amount is approximately $130,000, which will more than offset the City’s serve needs to this property. Mr. Brian Hall, Director of Development of Samet Corporation, said that jobs range in scale beginning at a minimum of $15.00/hour. There will be 115 full-time employees, 50 part-time employees and 190 service delivery drivers or independent delivery contractors, for a total of 355 jobs. Full-time employees begin benefits the first day hired and they include medical, dental and vision. This is a brownfields site and they are complying with the brownfields program. They have a work plan to be able to accommodate their proposed project into the N.C. Dept. of Environmental Quality for approval in accordance with the brownfields agreement. That involves creating, developing and constructing this site to protect against future environmental issues as well as allowing the site to move forward from its past of environmental contamination. Scopes of work include mitigation systems and barriers to protect the building. In the vehicle storage area, in addition to the bioretention cells and the landscaping islands and the trees, they have included in their plan an electrical conduit underneath that entire outdoor store area to allow a charging station at each one of the van parking spaces. In the future, as the electric vehicles are manufactured and available, the expectation is for that entire fleet of delivery service vehicles to be electric and to be able to be plugged in. They are investing roughly $3.5 Million now on that electrical conduit to be able to accommodate those electric vehicles as they become available. As part of the project on the construction side, they will adhere to the construction pollution prevention plans on site, including erosion control and stormwater quantity and quality retention on site. In addition to the commitment to the greenway and preservation of the historic clock tower, they will be happy to reforest and replant 10% of trees on the site that doesn’t really have any. Regarding the TIA, that was completed three weeks ago and submitted to the NCDOT. The NCDOT said they would respond by January 19. He noted that they have committed upfront that any recommendation from the NCDOT for traffic mitigation will be incorporated into their plan. Mayor Manheimer opened the public hearing at 6:41 p.m. From advanced live call-ins, 3 individuals spoke in support of this project. In response to Councilwoman Roney, Mayor Manheimer said that at the January 26 meeting when this vote will be taken, there will be an opportunity for Council to deliberate, but there will be no future public comment. However, she did note that the public is able to submit written comments on any public hearings 24 hours after the hearings and City Council will be provided with those comments. In response to Councilwoman Turner, Mr. Hall said that the electric delivery vehicles should be available in 24-36 months and once those have been acquired, they want to immediately switch over to all electric service vans. Regarding solar, their plans include construction of the building roof to be capable of holding solar panels. But since the electrical service for the building and vehicles is a complex electric system, they also anticipate 24-36 months to have the solar panels installed. When Councilwoman Turner asked about the traffic impact, Mr. Hall said that the facility would receive approximately 16 truckloads a day, which would be 16 truck movements in and out a day to supply to the facility. They often come in during the evenings hours to restock. The products in the building are then loaded on the delivery service vehicles, generally in the morning, and then dispersed throughout the day. Often, there is a second shift later in the day, based on customer demand. Mayor Manheimer wondered if there has been an analysis done on the number of miles driven by consumers to pick up their goods vs. having the delivery truck deliver the goods. When Councilwoman Turner and Councilwoman Roney expressed concern about losing land that could be used for affordable housing, Mr. Hall stated that the brownfields agreement in place for that site specifically states that residential is not allowed based on its previous contamination. In addition, Assistant City Manager Cathy Ball noted that the property is deed restricted against residential. In accordance with recent legislation amending North Carolina G.S. §166A-19.24(e), regarding public hearings conducted during remote meetings, written comments for this public hearing will be accepted for an additional 24 hours. Therefore,

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item IV-F · Administrative · Public hearing

Public hearing on proposed Civil Service Board substantive rule - motion to continue comment period 24 hours

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Sandra Kilgore

All members present voted yes.

6 council remarks

Recommendations

  • Civil Service Board: Approve, December 3, 2020

Public hearing advertised Jan 1, 2021 and Jan 8, 2021

No one from the public spoke.

Mayor Manheimer announced that there were no advanced live call-ins for this public hearing item.

What council members said 6 remarks from 6 members

Gwen Wisler Voted yes · moved it

  • Supports Councilwoman Wisler, liaison to the Civil Service Board for seven years, felt this is a long-time coming and thanked City staff for their hard work on bringing this forward.

Sandra Kilgore Voted yes · seconded

  • Question [John Maddux] responded to Councilwoman Kilgore regarding the probation period of 365 calendar days.

Kim Roney Voted yes

  • Question Councilwoman Roney requested information on engagement of community partners who have been at the table regarding the Civil Service Board

Sage Turner Voted yes

  • Concern Councilwoman Turner noted that the community member did state that he felt the changes were moving in the right direction.

Sheneika Smith Voted yes

  • Concern Vice-Mayor Smith felt that we need to reach out to people who have the specific skill set and a deeper level with those who are familiar with due process or legal definition.

Esther E. Manheimer Voted yes

  • Comment Mayor Manheimer felt that these rules are more about process and are administratively oriented since these are internally process rules.

The minutes record no remarks on this item from S. Antanette Mosley.

Key facts

In accordance with recent legislation amending North Carolina G.S. §166A-19.24(e), regarding public hearings conducted during remote meetings, written comments for this public hearing will be accepted for an additional 24 hours. Therefore, Councilwoman Wisler moved to recess this item until January 26, 2021, at which time this public hearing will be voted.

Presented by Shannon Barrett, Interim Human Resources Director; John Maddux, Deputy City Attorney.

From the staff report

Public hearing on Approval of Civil Service Board Substantive Rules

Fiscal impact

None

Staff’s stated reasons
  • Will provide employees, the City, and members of the Board with clarity about the types of employment actions falling under the Board’s jurisdiction, as well as the standards the Board uses when determining whether a complaint of employment action is justified.
Before it reached Council
  • Civil Service Board, December 3, 2020: approve — On December 3, 2020, the CSB voted to approve substantive rules clarifying important aspects of the City’s personnel administration and the Board’s jurisdiction

Staff: Shannon Barrett, Interim Human Resources Director; John Maddux, Deputy City Attorney.

Description in the minutes

Interim Human Resources Director Shannon Barrett said that this public hearing on the Civil Service Board Substantive Rules was advertised on January 1 and 8, 2021.

Background:

  • The Asheville Civil Service Act provides that the Civil Service Board (“CSB”) “shall make . . . substantive rules for promoting efficiency in the classified service of the City.”
  • The act further provides that the City Council, after giving members of the classified service and citizens of Asheville an opportunity to be heard at a public hearing, shall act upon the proposed rules and amendments, which become effective upon approval by a majority vote of the Council.
  • On December 3, 2020, the CSB voted to approve substantive rules clarifying important aspects of the City’s personnel administration and the Board’s jurisdiction, including definitions of terms (such as demotion, discharge, due process,and suspension), important to the City’s personnel administration and the Board’s standard of review for grievance hearings.

Pro(s):

  • Will provide employees, the City, and members of the Board with clarity about the types of employment actions falling under the Board’s jurisdiction, as well as the standards the Board uses when determining whether a complaint of employment action is justified.

Con(s):

  • None

Fiscal Impact:

  • None Deputy City Attorney John Maddux said that the Civil Service Act passed in 1953 and it applies only to the City of Asheville. Two it has two main functions (1) review promotional criteria in Police & Fire Departments and (2) hear certain employee grievances. The Civil Service Act was revised in 2009 that required that the Civil Service Board pass substantive rules, subject to amendment and adoption by City Council. Procedural rules were adopted in 2013 and a subcommittee was formed in 2014; however, rules were not finalized. The lack of substantive rules is not an issue for day-to-day administration since employees operate under City Manager administrative and departmental rules. Clarification is needed for how the Civil Service Board will resolve issues in grievance hearings
  • to define common terms and clarify hearing standards. In 2020 the Civil Service Board and City staff collaborated on development of substantive rules (1) engaged proactively with employee associations; and (2) agreement that engagement should value accountability and respect for employees’ due process rights. Ms. Barrett reviewed the following definitions (1) Classified Service
  • city personnel as defined in the Civil Service Act, which includes personnel below the Assistant Department Director level; (2) Demotion
  • involuntary and permanent reassignment into a position in a lower pay grade; (3) Discharge
  • involuntary and permanent separation from employment with the City due to violation of a City policy or unsatisfactory work performance; (4) Entitled
  • an absolute right to a promotion or a raise in pay automatically due to employee based on specific criteria, i.e., time in service, educational attainment, etc.; (5) Suspension
  • involuntary and temporary unpaid leave of more than 14 calendar days; (6) Transfer
  • involuntary and temporary reassignment into a position in a different City department; (7) Due Process
  • notice of allocations and an opportunity to be heard by a department director prior to a decision, and if the employee utilizes a disciplinary matrix, discipline that accords with that matrix; and (8) Probationary Employees
  • newly hired, rehired, promoted, or voluntary transferred employees are probationary employees for 365 calendar days. Mr. Maddux said that regarding grievance hearing standards
  • justified means (1) two part test (a) employee received due process, and (2) employee violated a City or departmental policy, rule or code of conduct, according to abuse of discretion standards; and (2) abuse of discretion
  • a decision that is clearly unreasonable, erroneous, or arbitrary. Councilwoman Wisler, liaison to the Civil Service Board for seven years, felt this is a long-time coming and thanked City staff for their hard work on bringing this forward. Mr. Maddux responded to Councilwoman Kilgore regarding the probation period of 365 calendar days. Mr. Maddux responded to Councilwoman Roney who asked if this item was reviewed by a City Council Committee or were there opportunities for the public to engage in this process. In addition, she asked the reason for the dissenting vote by the one Civil Service Board member. Mr. Maddux did not want to speak for the dissenting Civil Service Board member; however, he felt that the member felt this took away too much of the Board’s discretion and put it in the hands of department directors. Staff felt that this is putting more discretion in the department directors who actually oversee the employee, but there is still a role for the Civil Service Board. Regarding public engagement, employee associations for police officers and firefighters were engaged, as well as working with the City's HR department on behalf of all employees. City Attorney Branham noted that for some time we have been working closely with a lot of neighborhood advocacy groups as well as a number of individuals regarding global efforts to deal with several aspects of employee accountability, in particular the Asheville Police Department. The mutual goal has been to improve the City's ability to hold employees accountable when warranted, while still protecting the due process rights of employees. This effort has been one aspect of that broader initiative, and multiple public advocacy groups have been a part of these discussions. Councilwoman Roney requested information on engagement of community partners who have been at the table regarding the Civil Service Board, with Councilwoman Turner suggesting some analysis of what we have and what this changes. Councilwoman Wisler noted that she talked with a representative of the racial justice coalition about the changes. Mr. Maddux noted that he received an email from a community member and he provided a very extensive response, asking him to contact him if he had questions. He felt the process was transparent in that there were several Civil Service Board meetings. Councilwoman Turner noted that the community member did state that he felt the changes were moving in the right direction. Vice-Mayor Smith felt that we need to reach out to people who have the specific skill set and a deeper level with those who are familiar with due process or legal definition. Mayor Manheimer felt that these rules are more about process and are administratively oriented since these are internally process rules. Mayor Manheimer opened the public hearing at 7:53 p.m. Mayor Manheimer announced that there were no advanced live call-ins for this public hearing item. In accordance with recent legislation amending North Carolina G.S. §166A-19.24(e), regarding public hearings conducted during remote meetings, written comments for this public hearing will be accepted for an additional 24 hours. Therefore,

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item V-A-1 · RES 21-7 · Boards & Appointments · Appointment

Resolution appointing Barbara Ann Philip to the Affordable Housing Advisory Committee

Passed7–0 · Moved by Sheneika Smith, seconded by S. Antanette Mosley

All members present voted yes.

Recommendations

  • Affordable Housing Advisory Committee: appoint Chris Day (recommendation of the Board chair)
  • Boards & Commissions Committee: Approve

Key facts

  • an unexpired term until September 1, 2022 term
Description in the minutes

Vice-Mayor Smith, Chair of the Boards & Commissions Committee, said that this is the consideration of appointing a member to the Affordable Housing Advisory Committee. Sage Turner has resigned, thus leaving an unexpired term until September 1, 2022. The following individuals applied for the vacancy: Rodrigo Afanador, Damita Jo Wilder, Eric Howell, Michael G. Waddle, Joshua Katz, ZaKiya Bell-Rogers, Henry Sannyasa, Cyd Jaggers, Chris Woodward, DeLores Venable, Jessica Montanez, Shannon M. Watkins, Barbara Ann Philip and Chris Day. The Affordable Housing Advisory Committee Board chair recommended Chris Day. The Boards & Commissions Committee recommended appointing Barbara Ann Philp.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item V-A-10 · RES 21-16 · Boards & Appointments · Appointment

Resolution appointing Robert Frances Hoke to the Planning and Zoning Commission

Passed7–0 · Moved by Sheneika Smith, seconded by Sandra Kilgore

All members present voted yes.

Recommendations

  • Planning & Zoning Commission: appoint (in order) Robert Frances Hoke, Ricardo Seijo or Sherry Coggiola
  • Boards & Commissions Committee: appoint Robert Frances Hoke

Key facts

  • an unexpired term until August 14, 2023 term
Description in the minutes

Vice-Mayor Smith, Chair of the Boards & Commissions Committee, said that this is the consideration of appointing a member to the Planning & Zoning Commission. Sandra Kilgore has resigned, thus leaving an unexpired term until August 14, 2023. The following individuals applied for the vacancy: Sherrye Coggiola, Kimberly Levi, Roosevelt Harvin, Robert Frances Hoke, Ricardo Seijo and Sara Wilcox. The Planning & Zoning Commission recommended (in order) Robert Frances Hoke, Ricardo Seijo or Sherry Coggiola. The Boards & Commissions Committee recommended appointing Robert Frances Hoke.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item V-A-11 · RES 21-17 · Boards & Appointments · Appointment

Resolution appointing Tim Ormond, Steven Baron and Kim Austin to the board

Passed7–0 · Moved by Sheneika Smith, seconded by Kim Roney

All members present voted yes.

Recommendations

  • Sustainability Advisory Committee on Energy & the Environment: appoint Tim Ormond, Steven Baron and Kim Austin
  • Boards & Commissions Committee: appoint Tim Ormond, Steven Baron and Kim Austin

Key facts

  • to each serve a three-year term respectively, terms to expire December 31, 2023, or until their successors have been appointed term
Description in the minutes

Vice-Mayor Smith, Chair of the Boards & Commissions Committee, said that this is the consideration of appointing members to the Sustainable Advisory Committee on Energy & the Environment (SACEE). The terms of Geoffrey Habron, Renee Mazurek and John Noor, as members of SACEE, expired on December 31, 2020. The following individuals applied for the vacancy: Kim Austin, Steven Baron, Lynn Hurley, Carlisle Rankin Harper, Ben Prater, Kathryn Ancaya, Tim Ormond and Kelsey Wood. The SACEE Board recommended and the Boards & Commissions Committee recommended appointing Tim Ormond, Steven Baron and Kim Austin.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

Item V-A-12 · RES 21-18 · Boards & Appointments · Appointment

Resolution reappointing Cecil Bothwell and Sharon Sumrall to the board

Passed7–0 · Moved by Sheneika Smith, seconded by Kim Roney

All members present voted yes.

Recommendations

  • Urban Forestry Commission: reappoint Cecil Bothwell, Sharon Sumrall and Perrin de Jong
  • Boards & Commissions Committee: reappoint Cecil Bothwell, Sharon Sumrall and Perrin de Jong

Key facts

  • to each serve an additional three-year term, terms to expire December 31, 2023, or until their successors have been appointed term
Description in the minutes

Vice-Mayor Smith, Chair of the Boards & Commissions Committee, said that this is the consideration of appointing members to the Urban Forestry Commission. The terms of Cecil Bothwell, Sharon Sumrall and Perrin de Jong as members of the Urban Forestry Commission, expired on December 31, 2020. The following individuals applied for the vacancy: Catherine Murphy, Deborah Margaritov and Zoe A. Hoyle. The Urban Forestry Commission chair and the Boards & Commissions Committee recommended reappointing Cecil Bothwell, Sharon Sumrall and Perrin de Jong.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

Item V-A-2 · RES 21-8 · Boards & Appointments · Appointment

Resolution appointing Beverly Miller to the African American Heritage Commission

Passed7–0 · Moved by Sheneika Smith, seconded by Sandra Kilgore

All members present voted yes.

Recommendations

  • African American Heritage Commission: Approve
  • Boards & Commissions Committee: Approve

Key facts

  • an unexpired term until July 1, 2022 term
Description in the minutes

Vice-Mayor Smith, Chair of the Boards & Commissions Committee, said that this is the consideration of appointing a member to the African American Heritage Commission. S. Antanette Mosley has resigned, thus leaving an unexpired term until July 1, 2022. The following individuals applied for the vacancy: Thomas Ryan, Dewayne McAfee and Beverly Miller. The African American Heritage Commission and the Boards & Commissions Committee recommended appointing Beverly Miller.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item V-A-4 · RES 21-10 · Boards & Appointments · Appointment

Resolution appointing members to the Board of Adjustment (reappoint Paul Wilczynsky)

Passed7–0 · Moved by Sheneika Smith, seconded by Kim Roney

All members present voted yes.

Recommendations

  • Boards & Commissions Committee: reappoint Paul Wilczynsky, Suzanne Godsey and John Michael Kledis; re-advertise two Alternate seats

Key facts

  • term to expire January 21, 2024, or until his successor has been appointed term

In addition, it was their consensus to re-advertise for the remaining two Alternate seats.

Description in the minutes

Vice-Mayor Smith, Chair of the Boards & Commissions Committee, said that this is the consideration of appointing members to the Board of Adjustment. The terms of Phillip Hardin (Regular member), Paul Wilczynski (Regular member), John Michael Kledis (Alternate member) and Suzanne Godsey (Alternate member) expire on January 21, 2021. In addition, due to a discrepancy between the Unified Development Ordinance and Session Laws, City Council should appoint another Alternate member. (Buncombe County now appoints only one Regular and one Alternate member

  • not two Alternate members). No individuals applied for the vacancies. Boards & Commissions Committee recommended reappointing Paul Wilczynsky (Regular Member), Suzanne Godsey (Regular Member) and John Michael Kledis (Alternate Member). In addition, it was their consensus to re-advertise for the remaining two Alternate seats.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item V-A-5 · RES 21-11 · Boards & Appointments · Appointment

Resolution appointing members to the board (reappoint Andrew Fletcher, Kimberly Hunter and Steven)

Passed7–0 · Moved by Sheneika Smith, seconded by Kim Roney

All members present voted yes.

Recommendations

  • Downtown Commission: reappoint Andrew Fletcher, Kimberly Hunter and Steven Lee Johnson; appoint Guillermo Rodriguez
  • Boards & Commissions Committee: reappoint Fletcher, Hunter and Johnson; appoint Guillermo Rodriguez

Key facts

  • unexpired term until December 31, 2021 … terms to expire December 31, 2023, or until their successors have been appointed term
Description in the minutes

Vice-Mayor Smith, Chair of the Boards & Commissions Committee, said that this is the consideration of appointing members to the Downtown Commission. Pamela Winkler has resigned, thus leaving an unexpired term until December 31, 2021. In addition, the terms of Andrew Fletcher, Kimberly Hunter and Steven Lee Johnson expired on December 31, 2020. The following individuals applied for the vacancy: Joy Wilson, Tal Frankfurt, Douglas Buchalter, Guillermo Rodriguez, Clair Greear and Ricardo Seijp. The Downtown Commission and the Boards & Commissions Committee recommended rappointing Andrew Fletcher, Kimberly Hunter and Steven Lee Johnson and appointing Guillermo Rodriguez.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

Item V-A-6 · RES 21-12 · Boards & Appointments · Appointment

Resolution appointing Daniel Young to the Human Relations Commission

Passed7–0 · Moved by Sheneika Smith, seconded by S. Antanette Mosley

All members present voted yes.

1 council remark

Recommendations

  • Human Relations Commission: appoint Daniel Young, Susy Chandler and Melanie Noyes
  • Boards & Commissions Committee: appoint Daniel Young, Susy Chandler and Melanie Noyes

What council members said 1 remark from 1 member

Kim Roney Voted yes

  • Comment Councilwoman Roney, newly appointed liaison to the Human Relations Commission, said that she does not have any information on the reasons … for the three vacancies; however, the City Clerk’s Office does send outgoing members with an exit interview form, which are then sent to City Council.

The minutes record no remarks on this item from Sandra Kilgore, Esther E. Manheimer, S. Antanette Mosley, Sheneika Smith, Sage Turner and Gwen Wisler.

Key facts

  • unexpired terms until June 1, 2021 … then a full two-year term, term to expire June 1, 2023, or until his successor has been appointed term
Description in the minutes

Vice-Mayor Smith, Chair of the Boards & Commissions Committee, said that this is the consideration of appointing members to the Human Relations Commission. Zakiya Bell-Rogers, Nicole Townsend and Daniele Martin have resigned as members of the Human Relations Commission, thus leaving unexpired terms until June 1, 2021. The following individuals applied for the vacancy: Suzy Chandler, Bennie Lee Miller, Alexandra DiSclarfani, Britni Worley, Ricky McGrath, Emma Nichole Worthy, Melanie Noyes, Tim Collins and Daniel Young. The Human Relations Commission and the Boards & Commissions Committee recommended appointing Daniel Young, Susy Chandler and Melanie Noyes. In response to Councilwoman Turner, Councilwoman Roney, newly appointed liaison to the Human Relations Commission, said that she does not have any information on the reasons for the three vacancies; however, the City Clerk’s Office does send outgoing members with an exit interview form, which are then sent to City Council.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item V-A-7 · RES 21-13 · Boards & Appointments · Appointment

Resolution reappointing Gwen Wisler to the Metropolitan Sewerage District board

Passed7–0 · Moved by Sheneika Smith, seconded by Sandra Kilgore

All members present voted yes.

Recommendations

  • Boards & Commissions Committee: reappoint Gwen Wisler

Key facts

  • an additional three-year term, term to expire January 19, 2024, or until her successor has been appointed term
Description in the minutes

Vice-Mayor Smith, Chair of the Boards & Commissions Committee, said that this is the consideration of appointing a member to the Metropolitan Sewerage District Board of Directors. The term of Gwen Wisler expires on January 19, 2021. No individual applied for the vacancy. Boards & Commissions Committee recommended reappointing Gwen Wisler.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

Item V-A-8 · RES 21-14 · Boards & Appointments · Appointment

Resolution appointing Michael Stratton (at-large) to the board

Passed7–0 · Moved by Sheneika Smith, seconded by Gwen Wisler

All members present voted yes.

Recommendations

  • Multimodal Transportation Commission: appoint Michael Stratton (at-large) and Maggie Ullman (bike/ped task force)
  • Boards & Commissions Committee: appoint Michael Stratton and Maggie Ullman

Key facts

  • to serve a three-year term to expire July 1, 2023, or until his successor has been appointed … term to expire July 1, 2021, and then a full three-year term, term to expire July 1, 2024, or until her successor is appointed term
Description in the minutes

Vice-Mayor Smith, Chair of the Boards & Commissions Committee, said that this is the consideration of appointing a member to the Multimodal Transportation Commission. The term of Rich Lee (at-large representative) expired on July 1, 2020. Michael Stratton, currently a bike/ped task force member, will be filling the at-large seat until July 1, 2023. Therefore, there is a vacancy for Mr. Stratton’s vacant bike/ped task force seat until July 1, 2021. The following individuals applied for the vacancy: Sandy Aldridge, Kristen Goldsmith, Marty Shults, Joseph Chester, Maggie Ullman, Bill Loftis, Christine Harris and Micah McLain. On December 8, 2020, it was the recommendation of the Multimodal Transportation Commission and consensus of Council to readvertise for the at-large seat. The Multimodal Transportation Commission recommended, and the Boards & Commissions Committee concurred to appoint Michael Stratton as the at-large representative, and Maggie Ullman to serve as the bike/ped task force member.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

Item V-A-9 · RES 21-15 · Boards & Appointments · Appointment

Resolution appointing Wendy Haner (28804 representative) to the board

Passed7–0 · Moved by Sheneika Smith, seconded by Gwen Wisler

All members present voted yes.

Recommendations

  • Neighborhood Advisory Committee: appoint Wendy Haner (28804) and Peter Abzug (at-large)
  • Boards & Commissions Committee: appoint Wendy Haner and Peter Abzug

Key facts

  • to serve a three-year term, term to expire July 1, 2023, or until her successor has been appointed term

Damita Jo Wilder (requested her name be removed from consideration)

Description in the minutes

Vice-Mayor Smith, Chair of the Boards & Commissions Committee, said that this is the consideration of appointing members to the Neighborhood Advisory Committee. The term of Philip Lenowitz (28804 representative) expired on July 1, 2020. In addition, Diane Dankert (at-large representative) has resigned, thus leaving an unexpired term until July 1, 2023. The following individuals applied for the vacancy: Damita Jo Wilder (requested her name be removed from consideration), Bonnie Snyder Hanrick, Peter Abzug, Wendy Haner and Sandra K. Smith. On December 8, 2020, it was the consensus of Council to re-advertise for the seat, since no one was eligible for the 28804 zip code. The Neighborhood Advisory Committee, and the Boards & Commissions Committee recommended appointing Wendy Haner (28804 representative) and Peter Abzug (at-large representative).

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

Discussed, no vote

Manager’s report

Capital Project Update

Capital Projects Director Jade Dundas provided a capital project update. Key takeaways of this update include (1) There is a lot of work planned, also a lot that needs to be done; (2) New project requirements are making projects more expensive; (3) There are many competing demands on City funds; (4) Funds and funding sources are limited;

Presented by Jade Dundas, Capital Projects Director; Debra Campbell, City Manager.

Presentation: Manager's Report ↗

Manager’s report

Update on Status of Relief for Non-Payment Utility Shutoffs

Water Resources Director David Melton provided an update on the status of relief for non-payment utility shut-offs. They are in compliance with the Governor’s Executive Order and provided a timeline of implementation. He noted there is an extension of relief for non-payment utility shutoffs.

Presented by David Melton, Water Resources Director; Debra Campbell, City Manager.

Presentation: Manager's Report ↗

Council remarks

Gwen Wisler

  • Since the City also collects MSD fees on the City’s water bill, in response to Councilwoman Wisler, [David Melton] said that MSD is being amenable to all our suggestions for relief.

Sandra Kilgore

  • In response to Councilwoman Kilgore, [David Melton] said that last week there are approximately 34 accounts off for non-payment and the staff will need to see if the residences are still occupied because some are noted as move-outs.

Kim Roney

  • Councilwoman Roney was still concerned about what will happen on February 18 and urged Council to lead this pathway forward and not wait.

Other business

BOARDS & COMMISSIONS

There was a brief discussion and instruction to set up a meeting with the City Council, Buncombe County Board of Commissioners and Asheville City Board of Education in order to discuss the process for an appointed vs. an elected School Board and to broach the idea of going to the legislature to make that change.

Council remarks

Kim Roney

  • Councilwoman Roney noted that we must make our three appointments by April 1.

Other business

BOARDS & COMMISSIONS

Regarding the Audit Committee, no one from the City of Asheville applied for the vacancy, so it was the consensus of Council to re-advertise. Regarding the Asheville Area Riverfront Redevelopment Commission, no one applied for the vacancy, so it was the consensus of Council to re-advertise.

Proclamation

PROCLAMATION PROCLAIMING JANUARY 12, 2021, AS "CITY EMPLOYEE HEROES DAY"

Mayor Manheimer read the proclamation proclaiming January 12, 2021, as "City Employee Heroes Day" in the City of Asheville.

Council remarks

Esther E. Manheimer

  • On behalf of City Council, she thanked our frontline and onsite City of Asheville employees who have continued to serve the City throughout the COVID-19 pandemic.

Open public comment 7 speakers · 8 topics, as the minutes list them

This resource, to the best of its ability, is copied word for word from the official minutes, “…” marks words left out, and [brackets] a name the minutes give elsewhere. The minutes are the record. Staff report details are quoted from the city’s meeting documents, prepared before the vote.