Asheville City Council recorded 5 votes at its regular meeting on September 10, 2024; 1 drew at least one no vote. Most items fell under Zoning & Land Use and Boards & Appointments.
Met: 5 pm–9:29 pm. Voting: Sandra Kilgore, Esther E. Manheimer, S. Antanette Mosley, Kim Roney, Sage Turner, Maggie Ullman. Absent: Sheneika Smith.
Votes 5 recorded · 2 substantive · 1 split
Item IV-B · ORD 5098 · Zoning & Land Use · Public hearing
Ordinance to amend the conditional zoning of 179 and 144 Riverside Drive to allow construction of 240 residential units and remove commercial uses
Passed4–2 · Moved by Sandra Kilgore, seconded by S. Antanette Mosley
5 spoke, 1 against · changed before the vote · 5 council remarks
Recommendations
Council’s vote matched the city staff recommendation.
City staff: Approve — At this time, staff finds that the proposed changes are reasonable improvements in addressing concerns outlined in the staff report and therefore concurs with the Planning and Zoning Commission approval of this request for an amendment to the existing rezoning.
Planning & Zoning Commission: Approve
Public hearing 6:24 pm–6:35 pm · continued from Aug 27, 2024
4 spoke in favor · 1 spoke against
ForDerek Allen · for the applicant — Derek Allen, attorney representing the applicant, provided Council with a summary of the updates, revised renderings (illustrating updates), and revised site plan (illustrating updates). … [Derek Allen] said the following conditions are acceptable to the applicant:
One individual spoke in opposition to this conditional zoning amendment; and three individuals spoke in support of the amendment. The minutes name 1 of the 5 speakers.
What council members said 5 remarks from 3 members
QuestionCouncilwoman Roney shared appreciation that her request on solar-readiness was answered. Regarding place-making, she has heard community requests for public art on the North-facing wall and requests to confirm the parking area will not be fenced in as it currently is.
ConcernCouncilwoman Roney said that it is her opinion that Council really messed up the safe access to transit for this project by downzoning Roberts Street as the primary access to transit. … She then expressed concern for precedent-setting design issues.
QuestionIn response to Councilwoman Turner regarding the integrity of the smokestack during construction … [Derek Allen] responded to Councilwoman Turner regarding the loss of commercial activation.
SupportsCouncilwoman Turner had hoped that there would have been greater breaks in the building, and more affordability; however, we need to get housing jump-started in that area and hoped this project will meet future housing needs.
SupportsVice-Mayor Kilgore also expressed some of the same concerns as Councilwoman Turner and felt that any housing is better than no housing.
The minutes record no remarks on this item from Esther E. Manheimer, S. Antanette Mosley and Maggie Ullman.
Changed before the vote 1 change recorded
Amendment by motionthe following four additional project conditions: (1) installation of public art on the North side of the building, not on the smokestack; (2) the plaza on the south end of the plaza be ADA accessible; (3) the construction methods will take priority so that the smokestack is preserved; and (4) the food truck area on the 144 Riverside side will have seating and dining areas that will be river appropriate; and as approved by the City · offered by Sandra Kilgore
Key facts
179 and 144 Riverside Driveaddress
Commercial Expansion - Conditional Zone (COM EXP-CZ) and RAD-OSP CZ per Ord. No. 4398, adopted August 24, 2021 → changes in use from mixed-use to residential only, an increase in densityzoning, from → to
240 unitshousing units
Presented by Clay Mitchell, Urban Planner.
From the staff report
Consider adoption of an ordinance to amend a previously approved conditional zoning of the property located at 179 & 144 Riverside Drive
2.95 acres179 Riverside Drive
159 RAD River LLCowner
9638-88-3640parcel ID (PIN)
Staff’s stated reasons · no recommendation
Staff’s strongest recommendation is that Council considers deferring voting on this amendment until the applicants and staff can bring the project into better alignment with the areas mentioned above.
Before it reached Council
Technical Review Committee (TRC), March 4, 2024: approve with conditions — approved with conditions
Design Review Committee (DRC), June 20, 2024: deny (7–0) — the committee voted 7-0 to find the design inconsistent with the River Design Guidelines and the Wilma Dykeman Riverway Master Plan
Planning and Zoning Commission (PZC), July 11, 2024: approve with conditions (5–0) — The Commission voted 5-0 to recommend that City Council approve the amendment request
Conditions
That the applicant explore installation of a speed table or enhanced signalization for the existing crosswalk connecting the two lots
That the applicant explore enhancing the connection from the sidewalk along 144 Riverside Drive and the Wilma Dykeman Greenway across the parcel.
Staff: Stephanie Monson Dahl, Planning and Urban Design Director; Chris Collins, Assistant Director; Clay Mitchell, Urban Planner II.
Description in the minutes
Mayor Manheimer said that this public hearing was held on August 27, 2024, and continued to this date in order for the applicant to consider the concerns expressed by City Council at their August 27 meeting, and bring back a project that adheres to the existing plans we have. Urban Planner Clay Mitchell said that this is the consideration of an ordinance to consider an ordinance to amend a previously approved conditional zoning of the property located at 179 & 144 Riverside Drive (formerly addressed as 159 Riverside Dr.) to incorporate and reflect: changes in use from mixed-use to residential only, an increase in density, and modifications to the design that increase building height, increase the number of building stories and alter related site plan elements. The parcels are currently zoned Commercial Expansion
Conditional Zone (COM EXP-CZ) and RAD-OSP CZ per Ord. No. 4398, adopted August 24, 2021. Mr. Mitchell explained the following chart: Project Component: Original: Amendment: 09/06/24 Changes: Commercial Use 14,000 s.f. Food truck space on 179 Riverside EV Bike rental space at 179 Riverside. Additional food truck spaces and kayak racks on 144 Riverside Building design Glassed in entries Glassed in entries. Expanded glazing at vertical break above entries. Building stepback between northern end center portion Solar None None Solar ready roof Pervious parking None 144 Riverside spaces Added 32 spaces at 179 Riverside Rainwater harvesting Mill Building None Comprehensive main building system Ground level parking access None None Additional pedestrian connection at northern end Dedicated EV Parking None None Added to podium parking Plaza spaces Shown Expanded southern end Further expansion at southern end, new space at northern end. At this time, staff finds that the proposed changes are reasonable improvements in addressing concerns outlined in the staff report and therefore concurs with the Planning and Zoning Commission approval of this request for an amendment to the existing rezoning. Modifications to the project conditions must be made to document to reflect the applicant’s submission on 09/06/2024. Derek Allen, attorney representing the applicant, provided Council with a summary of the updates, revised renderings (illustrating updates), and revised site plan (illustrating updates). He said the revisions include the following project updates (1) added all glass to the eastern wall at all building breaks to further emphasize transparency and the building breaks. Assists the project appearing as three apparent separate buildings joined by gall entry vestibules/connectors from Riverside Drive; (2) added sidewalks from the building to Riverside Drive spaced no greater than every 100’ for residential access; (3) added public enhancements to both the Nw and SW building plazas along Riverside Drive; (4) added green features (a) added 100% permeable grass pavers for parking on the 144 Riverside Drive parking area (b) added 100% permeable grass pavers for parking on the 179 Riverside Drive at all diagonal parking area along the railroad; (c) added building infrastructure for future rooftop solar capacity on the 179 Riverside Drive; (d) added electrical vehicle charging stations under the 179 Riverside Drive building; and (e) added cisterns for rainwater harvesting from the 169 Riverside Drive roof; and (5) added commercial features (a) added a food truck area, on 100% permeable grass pavers, to the 144 Riverside Drive site; (b) added a kayak and canoe rental area, on 100% permeable grass pavers, to the 144 Riverside Drive site; and (c) added an electric bicycle rental area to the 179 Riverside Drive site (NW corner adjacent to food truck area. He also Council with a revised set of project conditions, which included the new conditions the applicant has agreed to, as outlined above. Derek Allen, attorney representing the applicant, responded to various questions/comments from Council, some being, but are not limited to: is the expanded courtyard and sidewalk ADA accessible; why is the applicant not putting any breaks in the building; regarding the food truck area, and will there be space for people to stand in line or have seating. Councilwoman Roney shared appreciation that her request on solar-readiness was answered. Regarding place-making, she has heard community requests for public art on the North-facing wall and requests to confirm the parking area will not be fenced in as it currently is. Mr. Allen confirmed that once the project is built out, the fence will be taken down. Regarding public art on the North-facing wall, Mr. Allen said that they would be happy to incorporate that into the conditions. In response to Councilwoman Turner regarding the integrity of the smokestack during construction, Mr. Allen said that they will study that and if there is any shoring up that needs to be done during project construction they will do that as that is a design element they wish to keep. Mr. Allen responded to Councilwoman Turner regarding the loss of commercial activation. Mayor Manheimer opened the public hearing at 6:24 p.m. One individual spoke in opposition to this conditional zoning amendment; and three individuals spoke in support of the amendment. Mayor Manheimer closed the public hearing at 6:35 p.m. Councilwoman Roney said that it is her opinion that Council really messed up the safe access to transit for this project by downzoning Roberts Street as the primary access to transit. She shared the history of transit planning in the River Arts District on Hill Street and Depot Street. She then expressed concern for precedent-setting design issues. Councilwoman Turner had hoped that there would have been greater breaks in the building, and more affordability; however, we need to get housing jump-started in that area and hoped this project will meet future housing needs. Vice-Mayor Kilgore also expressed some of the same concerns as Councilwoman Turner and felt that any housing is better than no housing. Mr. Allen said the following conditions are acceptable to the applicant: (1) installation of public art on the North side of the building, not on the smokestack; (2) the plaza on the south end of the plaza be ADA accessible; (3) the construction methods will take priority so that the smokestack is preserved; and (4) the food truck area on the 144 Riverside side will have seating and dining areas that will be river appropriate; and as approved by the City. Mayor Manheimer said that members of Council have previously received a copy of the ordinance and it would not be read.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Resolution appointing members to the Planning & Zoning Commission
Chosen by ballot Zuevskaya 4, Johnson 1, Silverman 1, Fletcher 0
A vote between candidates, not a yes/no vote. Absent: Sheneika Smith.
Key facts
three-year term, term to expire August 14, 2027 … the unexpired term of Kimberly Levi, term to expire August 14, 2026term
Because there was not a majority vote, City Council then voted for one member each, with Andrew Fletcher receiving no votes; Jameka Shante’ Johnson receiving 1 vote; Beth Silverman receiving 1 vote; and Anna Zuevskaya receiving four votes.
Description in the minutes
Vice-Mayor Kilgore, Chair of the Boards & Commissions Committee, said that this is the consideration of appointing members to the Planning & Zoning Commission. The terms of Geoffrey Barton and Susan Bean, as members of the Planning & Zoning Commission, will expire on August 14, 2024. In addition, Kimberly Levi has resigned, thus leaving an unexpired term until August 14, 2026. On August 27, 2024, City Council decided to interview the following five candidates on September 10: Jane Margaret Bell, Andrew Fletcher, Jameka Shante’ Johnson, Beth Silverman and Anna Zuevskaya. Ms. Silverman was unable to attend the interview. Also on August 27, 2024, Geoffrey Barton was reappointed to serve an additional three-term, term to expire August 14, 2027, or until his successor has been appointed. After each Council member voted for two members, Jane Margaret Bell received 4 votes, Andrew Fletcher received one vote; Jameka Shante’ Johnson received two votes, Beth Silverman received two votes; and Anna Zuevskaya received three votes. Because there was not a majority vote, City Council then voted for one member each, with Andrew Fletcher receiving no votes; Jameka Shante’ Johnson receiving 1 vote; Beth Silverman receiving 1 vote; and Anna Zuevskaya receiving four votes. Therefore, Anna Zuevskaya was appointed to serve a three-year term, term to expire August 14, 2027, or until Anna Zuevskaya’s successor has been appointed; and (2) Jane Margaret Bell was appointed to fill the unexpired term of Kimberly Levi, term to expire August 14, 2026, or until Jane Margaret Bell’s successor has been appointed.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
6 spoke · changed before the vote · 3 council remarks
Recommendations
City staff: Deny — Staff recommends denial of the resident-led proposed zoning text amendment to Section 7-16-1(b)(20) of the UDO and finds it unreasonable and not in the public interest because it undermines the intent of the Cottage Cluster ordinance as stated in the UDO, and acts as a way to circumvent permitted uses within certain residential zoning districts.
Planning & Zoning Commission: Approve, 3–1, August 2, 2023
Urban Forestry Commission: support staff alternate ordinance, April 10, 2024
Public hearing 7:10 pm–7:22 pm · continued from Apr 23, 2024 · advertised Oct 13, 2023 and Oct 20, 2023
6 spoke in favor · 0 spoke against
ForBarry Bailik · applicant — Mr. Barry Bailik, applicant, said that we have proven tactics from other cities in North Carolina and beyond that are already in place and working to create more attainable housing. … allow two cottages to be attached. Current doesn't allow; (3) remove primary street facing and build line requirement.
Five individuals spoke in support of the cottage development standards and flag lot standards amendments. The minutes name 1 of the 6 speakers. The minutes don’t give enough detail to count everyone.
What council members said 3 remarks from 2 members
QuestionIn response to Councilwoman Turner, Planning & Urban Design Director Stephanie Dahl said that on September 24, 2024, City Council will have a worksession where we will be discussing housing through an anti-displacement lens.
SupportsCouncilwoman Roney thanked the applicant for creative solutions: … I share your concern about infrastructure and the delays in our MMHS. Your professional and lived experience is a tremendous asset to this conversation, and I look forward to your work informing the UDO changes that are coming as we get the process right.
ConcernAfter the item received no motion, Councilwoman Roney questioned the interpretation of Section 7-7-5 when Deputy City Attorney John Maddux stated that a motion was required. She read the section aloud in the meeting as well as the terminology of "may" versus "shall", and repeatedly interrupted the process with procedural concerns.
The minutes record no remarks on this item from Sandra Kilgore, Esther E. Manheimer, S. Antanette Mosley and Maggie Ullman.
Changed before the vote 1 change recorded
Offered by the applicantThe petitioner has amended the original to leave the current minimum of five cottages for properties south of I-40 and north of the Blue Ridge Parkway as a response to concerns from the Shiloh neighborhood.
Key facts
Barry Bailikapplicant
When Mayor Manheimer asked for a motion, no one spoke. … Councilwoman Turner moved to continue the text amendments regarding cottage development standards to February 11, 2025.
Presented by Vaidila Satvika, Urban Planner III.
From the staff report
Consideration of a resident-led text amendment of Section 7-16-1(b)(20) to change the development regulations related to cottage developments.
Fiscal impact
This action requires no additional City resources and has no fiscal impact.
Staff’s stated reasons · deny
finds it unreasonable and not in the public interest because it undermines the intent of the Cottage Cluster ordinance as stated in the UDO, and acts as a way to circumvent permitted uses within certain residential zoning districts.
Before it reached Council
Planning and Zoning Commission, August 2, 2023: approve (3–1) — Recommended approval by 3-1 vote
Urban Forestry Commission, April 10, 2024 — Support staff alternate ordinance
City Code sections
Section 7-16-1(b)(20)
Staff: Vaidila Satvika, AICP, Urban Planner III; Chris Collins, AICP, Assistant Director; Stephanie Monson Dahl, Director of Planning & Urban Design.
City staff: Deny — Staff recommends denial of the resident-led proposed zoning text amendment to revise Sections 7-11-2(j) of the UDO for procedural reasons only. Staff finds it is not reasonable and in the public interest to do so based on earlier Council direction; that is, before options to mitigate the potential for negative impacts leading to the displacement of vulnerable landowners, neighbors and surrounding communities have been explored and considered for adoption.
Planning & Zoning Commission: Approve with conditions, 3–1, August 2, 2023
Technical Review Committee: did not approve original proposal; approved staff alternate with conditions, 4–1
Urban Forestry Commission: support staff alternate ordinance, April 10, 2024
Public hearing 8:06 pm–8:33 pm · continued from Apr 23, 2024 · advertised Oct 13, 2023 and Oct 20, 2023
10 spoke in favor · 0 spoke against
ForBarry Bailik · applicant — Mr. Barry Bailik explained his suggested flag lot standards at a glance as follows: … Technical tweeks to flag lot standards, already in place in other municipalities, can accomplish this and create 1,000s of new lots without increasing allowed density. … These text amendments are technical fixes, but they will have an impact.
Nine individuals spoke in support of the flag lot standard text amendments. The minutes name 1 of the 10 speakers.
What council members said 3 remarks from 3 members
ConcernCouncilwoman Mosley expressed concern about the way the public involvement in the Shiloh neighborhood was handled regarding the two text amendments.
SupportsCouncilwoman Turner moved to approve the resident-led proposed wording amendments to Chapter 7 of the Asheville Code of Ordinances regarding flag lot standards as proposed with a delayed effective date of January 31, 2025 … Because Councilwoman Turner felt that there was not majority support for her motion to adopt the text amendment with a delayed effective date, she withdrew her motion.
The minutes record no remarks on this item from Sandra Kilgore, Esther E. Manheimer and Maggie Ullman.
Key facts
Barry Bailikapplicant
Councilwoman Turner moved to continue the text amendments regarding flag lot standards to February 11, 2025. This motion was seconded by Councilwoman Ullman and carried unanimously.
Update on the Human Resources Department Organizational Assessment Report
Raftelis was retained in September 2023 and their work was coordinated with the Carter Development Group, who at the time, was also conducting a Cease the Harm Audit of both the City and Buncombe County policies, processes, procedures and services; … Twenty-two (22) recommendations were proposed and prioritized to provide clear direction and a path forward to improve service delivery and employee morale;
Presented by Debra Campbell, City Manager; Mayra Cummings, Organizational Learning and Development Specialist.
In response to Vice-Mayor Kilgore, [Mayra Cummings] said that once the new software is fully implemented, we will be able to pull diversity information together.
Councilwoman Mosley said that the Cease the Harm audit came first and was the impetus for the Black women who worked internally for us. … She wanted to lift those women up in that conversation and make sure they recognize that efforts are underway and where we expect to go.
Start with an apology to City staff. She was embarrassed that she missed the release of this Ratilis report in February and then had difficulty finding it when it was brought to attention this summer. … so she requested that the report be public facing and on a public agenda which is within the scope of her duty, and she’s grateful the request is being met today.
Concerns around merit-based pay include outcomes related to implicit and explicit bias as well as potential for retaliation. … Given the findings of the Cease the Harm audit around lacking data, she asked what are some of the ways the City is looking to collect data, protect our staff in systemic ways, and what does it look like for staff to bring forward concerns … without fear of retaliation?
Report
Fiscal Year 2024 Annual Report
Full Obligation of 2016 Affordable Housing Bond Funds - In April 2024, City Council authorized the remaining $4.8 million in the Housing Trust Fund to support the construction and/or purchase of 197 affordable housing units; … $80 million bond package was approved by City Council for inclusion on the upcoming November ballot; … Staff has identified 28 projects to be included in the FY 2025 Organizational Work Plan to continue progress towards these priorities;
Presented by Tony McDowell, Finance and Management Services Director; Lindsay Spangler, Budget and Performance Manager.
Councilwoman Roney requested follow-up after articulating difficulty finding Annual Report on City's website.
Other business
Public hearing to pursue and negotiate on behalf of the City debt financing associated with the refunding of the $42 million 2022 Limited Obligation Bonds
Mayor Manheimer said that resolution on the 2024 Limited Obligation Refunding Bonds will be held at the September 24, 2024, meeting.
As of August, the City has fully utilized the $42 million interim LOBs amount to reimburse itself for expenses associated with a number of capital projects including the Broadway Public Safety Station, the Dr. Wesley Grant Sr. Southside Community Center, City Hall elevator modernization, Muni Golf Course repairs, and the annual street resurfacing program. … the City intends to issue 20-year, fixed-rate LOBs Refunding Bonds in October 2024. … City Council approved the initial resolution associated with this refunding on August 27, 2024 and is scheduled to vote on the final resolution on September 24, 2024.
Motion to adopt the flag lot standards amendments with a delayed effective date of January 31, 2025
Because Councilwoman Turner felt that there was not majority support for her motion to adopt the text amendment with a delayed effective date, she withdrew her motion. Vice-Mayor Kilgore withdrew her second.
In response to Councilwoman Turner, Planning & Urban Development Director Stephanie Dahl said that staff feels strongly that by the end of January, 2025, staff can present one or more zoning tools that will address Council’s concerns around anti-displacement.
Councilwoman Turner moved to approve the resident-led proposed wording amendments to Chapter 7 of the Asheville Code of Ordinances regarding flag lot standards as proposed with a delayed effective date of January 31, 2025 … to allow for community input and anti-displacement strategies to be adopted.
Open public comment 8 speakers · 5 topics, as the minutes list them
missing middle housing
support for International Day of Peace
racism
support for ceasefire resolution
invitation to the 2nd Annual Festival of Neighborhoods
Work session, Tuesday, Sep 10, 2024 the agenda briefing after this meeting · 11 am–11:42 am
Other business
Agenda Briefing Worksession - For September 10, 2024, Council Meeting
City Council held an agenda briefing worksession to discuss the upcoming and future agenda items. In addition, City Council reviewed upcoming City Council committees that will be taking place during the next two weeks.
Staff briefed on
Upcoming and future agenda items
upcoming City Council committees that will be taking place during the next two weeks
This resource, to the best of its ability, is copied word for word from the official minutes, “…” marks words left out, and [brackets] a name the minutes give elsewhere. The minutes are the record. Staff report details are quoted from the city’s meeting documents, prepared before the vote.