Asheville City Council recorded 15 votes at its regular meeting on May 28, 2024; 4 drew at least one no vote. Most items fell under Zoning & Land Use, Economic Development and Public Safety.
Met: 5 pm–9:37 pm. Voting: Sandra Kilgore, Esther E. Manheimer, S. Antanette Mosley, Kim Roney, Sheneika Smith, Sage Turner. Absent: Maggie Ullman.
Votes 15 recorded · 6 substantive · 4 split
Item II-G · RES 24-109 / ORD 5080 · Public Safety · Resolution
Resolution accepting the ONDCP 2024 HIDTA Grant on behalf of the Asheville HIDTA branch, with budget amendment
Passed5–1 · Moved by S. Antanette Mosley, seconded by Sheneika Smith
ConcernCouncilwoman Roney said we are having serious public safety issues in our community and though we are having these conversations one at a time, she looked forward to having community conversations around quality equity service outcomes and long-term planning budget strategies.
The minutes record no remarks on this item from Sandra Kilgore, Esther E. Manheimer, S. Antanette Mosley, Sheneika Smith and Sage Turner.
Key facts
$154,6382024 High Intensity Drug Trafficking Areas (HIDTA) Grant
Office of National Drug Control Policycontractor or recipient
Funding for this grant is provided by the Office of National Drug Control Policy (ONDCP).funding source
From the staff report
Adoption of a resolution to accept the 2024 High Intensity Drug Trafficking Areas (HIDTA) Grant on behalf of the Asheville HIDTA branch and authorize the City Manager to execute all documents associated with the grant; and adopt a budget amendment in the City’s Special Revenue Fund in the amount of $154,638.00.
$154,638this grant totaling $154,638
Office of National Drug Control Policy (ONDCP)funding source
Fiscal impact
Matching funds are not required for this grant.
Staff’s stated reasons
Fosters partnerships with federal and local law enforcement agencies.
Before it reached Council
Environment & Safety Committee, July 25, 2023: approve (3–0) — The Environment & Safety Committee approved to move the application of this grant forward to City Council on 7/25/2023 with a 3-0 vote.
Staff: Mike Lamb, APD Police Chief; Elise Lewis, APD Financial Business Manager.
Council’s vote matched the city staff recommendation.
City staff: Approve — staff concurs with the Planning & Zoning Commission and recommends approval of the proposed conditional zoning.
Technical Review Committee: Approve with conditions, December 18, 2023
Planning & Zoning Commission: Approve, 6–0, February 7, 2024
Public hearing 7:39 pm–7:41 pm · continued from Mar 26, 2024 · advertised Feb 16, 2024 and Feb 23, 2024
3 spoke in favor · 0 spoke against
ForDerek Allen · for the applicant — Derek Allen, attorney representing the applicant, responded to various questions from City Council … Allen then read a condition that “the applicant will make good faith efforts to follow (and will expect its subcontractors to follow) the principles set forth in the Federal Procurement Regulations of 24 CFR 85.36(e) regarding contracting with small and minority firms and women’s business enterprises
ForWarren Suggs · for the applicant — Warren Suggs, civil engineer for the project, said that even though a Traffic Impact Analysis was not required for this project, they performed one, which the N.C. Dept. of Transportation agreed with their findings. He said that 80% of the traffic will go toward Sweeten Creek Road and 20% will move towards Shiloh.
ForRobert Robinson — Robert Robinson spoke in support of this conditional zoning.
On February 27, 2024, this public hearing was continued to March 26, 2024, per the applicant’s request. On March 26, 2024, this public hearing was continued to this date, per the applicant’s request.
Changed before the vote 1 change recorded
Offered by the applicantthe applicant will make good faith efforts to follow (and will expect its subcontractors to follow) the principles set forth in the Federal Procurement Regulations of 24 CFR 85.36(e) regarding contracting with small and minority firms and women’s business enterprises
Key facts
21 London Roadaddress
2.63 acressite size
Commercial Industrial (CI) → Residential Expansion - Conditional Zone (RES EXP-CZ)zoning, from → to
208 unitshousing units
London Asheville LLCapplicant
Presented by Will Palmquist, Urban Planner.
From the staff report
Adoption of an ordinance to conditionally rezone the entire property located at 21 London Road from Commercial Industrial (CI) to Residential Expansion - Conditional Zone (RES EXP-CZ) and to amend the Future Land Use Map from Industrial/Manufacturing to Urban Corridor.
Commercial Industrial (CI) → Residential Expansion - Conditional Zone (RES EXP-CZ)zoning, current → requested
2.63 acres21 London Rd
Industrial/Manufacturingfuture land use designation
London Asheville LLCowner
9647-89-2135parcel ID (PIN)
Staff’s stated reasons · approve
Provides infill development in targeted growth areas
Eliminates gaps in the city-wide sidewalk network
Enhances transit-supportive infrastructure such as bus shelters
Before it reached Council
Technical Review Committee (TRC), December 18, 2023: approve with conditions — approved with conditions.
Planning & Zoning Commission (PZC), February 7, 2024: approve (6:0)
Conditions
Maximum building height of 75’ instead of the 60’ maximum.
Maximum residential density of 80 units/acre instead of the 20 units/acre maximum.
Setbacks of 0’ for the front yard, 5’ for the side yards, and 10’ for the rear yard, instead of the required 15’ setback for all yards.
5’-wide sidewalks internal to the site instead of the required 10’-wide standard,
No sidewalk as required on Sweeten Creek Rd.
No street tree (1) as required on Sweeten Creek Rd.
Street trees to be located in tree grates along London Road where a planting strip is required.
No bike lanes into the development.
Staff: Stephanie Monson Dahl, Planning and Urban Design Director; Will Palmquist, Principal Planner.
Description in the minutes
Urban Planner Will Palmquist said that this is the consideration of an ordinance to conditionally zone 21 London Road from Commercial Industrial District to Residential Expansion
Conditional Zone, and to amend the Future Land Use Map from Industrial/Manufacturing to Urban Corridor. This public hearing was advertised on February 16 and 23, 2024. On February 27, 2024, this public hearing was continued to March 26, 2024, per the applicant’s request. On March 26, 2024, this public hearing was continued to this date, per the applicant’s request. Project Location and
Contacts:
The project site totals 2.63 acres located at 21 London Rd (PIN 9647-89-2135)
Owner: London Asheville LLC Summary of Petition: Project Site
The project area consists of one property totalling 2.63 acres located at 21 London Rd and is identified in the Buncombe County land records as PIN 9647-89-2135)
The site is currently zoned Commercial Industrial (CI), which is the predominant zoning for the surrounding area.
The site is currently vacant with the previously existing 1-story garage building recently demolished.
Sweeten Creek is located to the northeast of the property with a 30'-wide stream buffer located on the property.
Given the size of the project (over 50 residential dwelling units) a conditional zoning to the Residential Expansion
Conditional Zone (RES EXP
CZ) district is required.
Based on the Living Asheville Comprehensive Plan Future Land Use Map (FLUM) the property is currently designated “Industrial/Manufacturing”, which reserves land with good access to transportation systems to support the economic section for light industry and office or business incubators.
While Industrial/Manufacturing may include opportunities for housing for workers who may live amongst or adjacent to the industry or other businesses in the area, the property is adjacent to properties along Sweeten Creek Rd and London Rd designated as “Urban Corridor.” Therefore, a change to the Future Land Use map is recommended. Overall Project Proposal
New building construction includes a new six-story building with a total of 208 units of multi-family housing.
Four stories of residential construction are proposed above two stories of structured parking
Other site improvements include structured parking, new sidewalks, and a pool and amenity area. Site Layout and Design
Maximum building height for multifamily buildings in the RES EXP district is 60 feet.
The maximum building height of the proposed project is 74 feet.
The project is seeking a technical modification for maximum building height.
Maximum density in the RES EXP district is 20 units/acre or 50 units/acre if at least 20% of the dwelling units are affordable at 80% AMI.
The proposed project’s density is 79.1 units/acre.
The project is seeking a technical modification for maximum residential density.
Front yard, rear yard and side yard setbacks of 15 feet are required in the RES EXP district.
The project proposes no front yard setback, 5' side yard setbacks, and a 10' rear yard setback.
The project is seeking a technical modification for setbacks.
Maximum impervious surface in the RES EXP district for multifamily uses is 80%.
The proposed project would result in a total impervious area of 63%. Access, Sidewalks and Parking
Access to the site will be provided by two entrances into the proposed structured parking.
The main pedestrian entrances to the building are at the eastern end of the north elevation and the southern end of the west elevation.
A total of 223 parking spaces are proposed for the project. Based on the number of bedrooms and dwelling units, the minimum/maximum number of required parking spaces is 208/412 for the RES EXP district.
Bicycle parking is required at a rate of 5% of the total number of vehicle parking spaces, which equates to 11 required bicycle parking spaces. The project is proposing 99 bicycle parking spaces.
The pedestrian network in general along Sweeten Creek Rd and at the intersection of London Rd is problematic with few crosswalks and many areas without a sidewalk.
NCDOT has a planned roadway improvement project for Sweeten Creek Rd (currently slated for construction in 2031) but it does not include this section of roadway.
The City’s Transportation Department is currently assessing the feasibility of a sidewalk along London Rd, between Sweeten Creek and W. Chapel Roads.
The RES EXP district requires new 10 foot-wide sidewalks be constructed, both along the primary access corridor and internally throughout the site.
The project is proposing a new 10.5'-wide sidewalk along London Rd. The project proposes 5'-wide sidewalks internal to the site.
The project is seeking a technical modification for sidewalks internal to the site and for the required sidewalk on Sweeten Creek Rd. The project has a very small portion of its property fronting on Sweeten Creek Rd and the roadway is constrained as it travels east across the bridge, which is not on the subject property.
London Road is served by Asheville Rides Transit (ART) route S1. The closest transit stop (#648) is located at the corner of Sweeten Creek and London Roads, approximately 150’ north of the subject property.
As recommended by City transit planning staff, the project proposes relocating this bus stop to an area adjacent to the project, with the exact final location to be determined, and improved to a bus shelter. Landscaping / Open Space / Tree Canopy
Landscape requirements apply, including street trees, building impact, and parking deck landscaping.
Street trees are required as being one small maturing tree for every 30 linear feet of property abutting a street, as there are overhead utilities present, which equates to 16 trees required along London Rd.
The applicant is proposing 12 large maturing trees in tree grates, which would be required if there were no overhead utilities.
The project is requesting a technical modification for the required street tree on Sweeten Creek Rd.
The project is seeking a technical modification for street trees to be located in tree grates instead of a planting strip.
Exposed parking decks are required to plant a minimum of one tree and two shrubs for every 30 linear feet of the parking structure's perimeter, with trees being planted within 20 feet of the structure. The project has 250 linear feet of exposed parking deck, and proposes the required 8 trees and 16 shrubs.
Building impact landscaping is required as being one tree and two shrubs for every 1,000 square feet of building footprint, equalling 64 trees and 128 shrubs.
Open Space is required at a rate of 50% of the site, or a rate of 20% of the site if the project meets the incentive requirements for either enhanced stormwater or affordable housing. Open space can be further reduced to 15% if the proposed open space meets certain design and operational standards. The project proposes 50% open space as required, equaling 1.35 acres.
The project proposes to meet Tree Canopy Preservation requirements of 16% through a combination of 12% preservation and 4% plantings. The project site is classified as "Suburban" under the Tree Canopy Preservation standards, with a classification of “Class C”. The site has an existing tree canopy of 37%. Technical Modifications
The project is seeking technical modifications to development standards through the conditional zoning process including:
Maximum building height of 75’ instead of the 60’ maximum.
Maximum residential density of 80 units/acre instead of the 20 units/acre maximum.
Setbacks of 0’ for the front yard, 5’ for the side yards, and 10’ for the rear yard, instead of the required 15’ setback for all yards.
5’-wide sidewalks internal to the site instead of the required 10’-wide standard,
No sidewalk as required on Sweeten Creek Rd.
No street tree (1) as required on Sweeten Creek Rd.
Street trees to be located in tree grates along London Road where a planting strip is required.
No bike lanes into the development. Consistency with the Comprehensive Plan and Other Plans: Living Asheville Comprehensive Plan (2018)
The proposed development supports a number of goals in the Living Asheville Comprehensive Plan, including:
Encourage Responsible Growth
by providing infill development in targeted growth areas.
Make Streets More Walkable, Comfortable and Connected
by eliminating gaps in the city-wide sidewalk network..
Improve the Multimodal Transportation System
by enhancing transit-supportive infrastructure such as bus shelters.
The proposed rezoning is compatible with the proposed Future Land Use designation of "Urban Corridor", which is proposed, in part, as “redevelopment in the form of mixed-use residential, commercial and office uses that place emphasis on pedestrian-friendly amenities and infrastructure”.
Compatibility Analysis:
The proposed multi-family project is compatible with the surrounding land uses, including:
Commercial and mixed-uses along Sweeten Creek Rd and London Rd, as well as in and around Biltmore Village.
Multi-family residential uses, planned and existing, to the north of the project site along Fairview Rd.
Residential single-family uses to the southwest and east of the project site.
Committee(s):
Technical Review Committee (TRC)
December 18, 2023
approved with conditions.
Planning & Zoning Commission (PZC)
February 7, 2024
approved (Vote 6:0)
Staff Recommendation:
Staff recommends approval of this rezoning request based on the reasons stated above. Mr. Palmquist reviewed the existing and proposed zoning, the aerial imagery and the future land use map. About the site plan, (1) Vacant site, 30’-wide stream buffer; (2) New 6-story multi-family building; (3) 208 residential dwelling units; (4) Other site improvements: structured parking, sidewalks, and a pool/amenity area; (5) 223 parking spaces, 99 bike parking spaces; (6) Access by two new driveways into parking garage; (7) 10.5’-wide sidewalk on London Rd, 5’-wide sidewalks internally; and (8) ART route S1 and stop #648. Regarding the landscape plan, (1) Landscaping standards: street tree, building impact, and parking deck screening; (2) Open space at 50% of site (1.35 acres); and (3) Tree Canopy Preservation standards met through combination of preservation and new tree plantings. Regarding conditions, (1) A new bus stop and shelter, designed to standard city specifications, will be installed adjacent to the project with the final location to be determined in coordination with City staff; (2) Technical modifications: (a) Maximum building height of 75’ instead of the 60’ maximum; (b) Maximum residential density of 80 units/acre instead of the 20 units/acre maximum; (c) Setbacks of 0’ for the front yard, 5’ for the side yards, and 10’ for the rear yard, instead of the required 15’ setback for all yards; (d) 5’-wide sidewalks internal to the site instead of the required 10’-wide standard; (e) No sidewalk as required on Sweeten Creek Rd; (f) No street tree (1) as required on Sweeten Creek Rd; (g) Street trees to be located in tree grates along London Road where a planting strip is required; and (h) No bike lanes into the development. He then showed building elevations, along with an architectural rendering. He showed pictures of the different street views from various angles. He said the Technical Review Committee approved the project with conditions. The Planning & Zoning Commission voted to approve the project. He then explained how the project was consistent with the Living Asheville Comprehensive Plan. He said that staff concurs with the Planning & Zoning Commission and recommends approval of the proposed conditional zoning. Mr. Derek Allen, attorney representing the applicant, responded to various questions from City Council, some being, but are not limited to: is the project either available for a renewable energy plan or does it have a renewable energy plan; is there a plan for a sidewalk on Sweeten Creek Road on the other side of the bridge; was a Traffic Impact Study performed and if so, what did it show for that area; and what was the outcome of the neighborhood community meeting. Mr. Allen then read a condition that “the applicant will make good faith efforts to follow (and will expect its subcontractors to follow) the principles set forth in the Federal Procurement Regulations of 24 CFR 85.36(e) regarding contracting with small and minority firms and women’s business enterprises, as modified as follows: (a) applicant will take affirmative steps to assure that minority firms and women’s business enterprises are used where possible; and (b) affirmative steps will include (i) placing qualified small and minority businesses and women’s business enterprises on solicitation lists; (ii) assuring that small and minority businesses, and women’s business enterprises are solicited whenever they are potential sources; (iii) dividing total requirements, when economically feasible, into smaller tasks or quantities to permit maximum participation by small and minority business, and women’s business enterprises; (iv) conducting job fairs in minority neighborhoods; (v) working with the YMI, Mountain BizWorks and other local non-profit agencies that serve the minority communities in Asheville; and (vi) requiring the prime contractor, if subcontracts are to be let, to take the affirmative steps listed in this section.” Mr. Warren Suggs, civil engineer for the project, said that even though a Traffic Impact Analysis was not required for this project, they performed one, which the N.C. Dept. of Transportation agreed with their findings. He said that 80% of the traffic will go toward Sweeten Creek Road and 20% will move towards Shiloh. Mayor Manheimer opened the public hearing at 7:39 p.m. Robert Robinson spoke in support of this conditional zoning. Mayor Manheimer closed the public hearing at 7:41 p.m. Mayor Manheimer said that members of Council have previously received a copy of the ordinance and it would not be read.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Item IV-C · ORD 5082 · Zoning & Land Use · Public hearing
Public hearing / ordinance to conditionally zone 57 Max (property)
Passed6–0 · Moved by S. Antanette Mosley, seconded by Sandra Kilgore
All members present voted yes. Absent: Maggie Ullman.
3 spoke · 2 council remarks
Recommendations
Council’s vote matched the city staff recommendation.
City staff: Approve — Accordingly, staff concurs with the Planning & Zoning Commission’s recommendation to approve the Conditional Zoning petition.
Technical Review Committee: Approve with conditions, March 18, 2024
Planning & Zoning Commission: Approve, 5–0, May 1, 2024
Public hearing 7:58 pm–8:04 pm · advertised May 17, 2024 and May 24, 2024
3 spoke in favor · 0 spoke against
ForJessie Landl · applicant, Preservation Society of Asheville-Buncombe County — Jessie Landl, Executive Director of the Preservation Society of Asheville-Buncombe County, was excited to explain how the project came to be and how they worked with the neighborhood. Their goal is that the three units be affordable structures
ForRobert Robinson — Robert Robinson spoke in support of this conditional zoning, noting that the Unified Development Ordinance needs revisions as conditional zonings are burdensome and expensive for developers.
ForJim Abbott · organization, East End/Valley Street Neighborhood Association — Jim Abbott said that the East End/Valley Street Neighborhood Association strongly supports this conditional zoning.
What council members said 2 remarks from 2 members
QuestionIn response to Councilwoman Roney, [Clay Mitchell] said that he has not talked with the applicants about renewable energy plans since this is an adaptive reuse of an historic building
SupportsCouncilwoman Smith spoke in support of adaptive reuse of churches for affordable housing. She noted it would be a great benefit to keep neighborhoods in tact and faith-based communities to keep their properties alive
The minutes record no remarks on this item from Sandra Kilgore, Esther E. Manheimer, S. Antanette Mosley and Sage Turner.
Key facts
57 Max Streetaddress
0.266 acressite size
RS-8 → RM-8-CZzoning, from → to
3 unitshousing units
Preservation Society of Asheville and Buncombe County Inc.applicant
Presented by Clay Mitchell, Urban Planner.
From the staff report
Adoption of an ordinance to conditionally rezone the property located at 57 Max Street from Residential Single-Family High Density (RS-8) to Residential Multi-Family Medium Density - Conditional Zone (RM-8-CZ) for the purpose of adaptively reusing the Cappadocia Church into 3 residential units.
Residential Single-Family High Density (RS-8) → Residential Multi-Family Medium Density - Conditional Zone (RM-8-CZ)zoning, current → requested
0.266 acres57 Max Street
Traditional Neighborhoodfuture land use designation
Preservation Society of Asheville and Buncombe County Inc.owner
9648-59-7392parcel ID (PIN)
Staff’s stated reasons · approve
prioritizes greater densities of development overall as a means of achieving more walkable and efficient urban environments and as a tool to help protect and preserve open space and the natural environment
increases the supply of housing in proximity to jobs, schools, transit and public amenities
by promoting adaptive reuse as a means of conserving materials, history, and embodied energy in buildings
Before it reached Council
Technical Review Committee (TRC), March 18, 2024: approve with conditions — Approved with conditions.
Planning & Zoning Commission (PZC), May 1, 2024: approve (5–0)
City Code sections
Sec. 7-10-8
Staff: Stephanie Monson Dahl, Planning and Urban Design Director; Clay Mitchell, Urban Planner II.
Description in the minutes
Urban Planner Clay Mitchell said that this is the consideration of an ordinance to consider the conditional zoning of 57 Max Street from RS-8 Residential Single-Family High Density District to RM-8 Residential Multi-Family Medium Density District
Conditional Zone for the purpose of adaptive reusing the Cappadocia Church into 3 residential units. This public hearing was advertised on May 17 and 24, 2024. Project Location and
Contacts:
The project site totals 0.266 acres at 57 Max Street | Pin: 9648-59-7392
Owner: Preservation Society of Asheville and Buncombe County Inc. Summary of Petition: Project Site
The project site consists of one property totalling 0.266 acres, and is located at 57 Max Street across from the Stephens-Lee Community Center.
The project site is occupied by the vacant Cappadocia Church building.
The property was acquired by the Preservation Society to protect the building from demolition in the East End neighborhood.
The project is seeking a conditional zoning to permit the preservation of the building and its adaptive reuse for three multi-family units.
The site is designated as “Traditional Neighborhood" on the city’s Future Land Use (FLU) Map.
A change in Future Land Use is not required. Living Asheville.
The project is located in the East End/Valley Street neighborhood. Overall Project Proposal
The project proposes to convert the existing church building into 3 residential units with associated infrastructure.
The existing church building has historical importance to the East End Neighborhood and is owned by the Preservation Society of Asheville and Buncombe County Inc.
The facade elements of the existing building will be substantially preserved.
The project includes 3 residential units, four parking spaces, bicycle parking, and a new access from Max Street.
The requirements of UDO Sec. 7-10-8 Neighborhood-scale multifamily design standards do not apply due to the adaptive reuse of a historically significant existing building. Access, Sidewalks and Parking
Access to the site is proposed by a new drive access from Max Street northeast of the intersection with Old Max Street.
The driveway is shown as 12 feet in width widening to 16 feet in width for the parking aisle.
The project will provide compliant parking for vehicles and bicycles.
Sidewalks are shown on site and reconstructed along Max Street.
The applicant is coordinating with City Transportation on the proper configuration of Old Max Street along the frontage of the property.
Parking is along the side of the building and grading will take place requiring a retaining wall to the east that will be 9’ max height and facing toward the property with landscaping at the top and bottom of the wall. Landscaping & Buffer Requirements
The rezoned property abuts RS-8 and requires a 20’ property buffer along the eastern boundary.
The applicant is seeking a technical modification for the required 20 foot property buffer to the adjacent property zoned RS-8.
The change in grade and associated retaining wall faces internal to the site and additional plantings along the top of the wall mitigate visual impacts to the abutting property.
The site has been configured to accommodate additional landscaping and dedicated space for resident use as garden spaces.
The project proposes to provide 3 dedicated 4’ by 8’ garden plots for residents at the base of the retaining wall.
Tree Canopy Protection required at 15% will be achieved through planting one tree for 1.48% and the remainder paid as fee in lieu. Technical Modifications
The project is seeking the following technical modifications through the conditional zoning process:
The project shows a modified landscaping and required type A 20’ buffer along the eastern edge of the property to accommodate several requirements and improvements to the site.
The site changes in topography from the RS-8 district which includes a 5’ to 9’ (max) height retaining wall facing internal to the site.
At the top of the retaining wall, a row of 23 evergreen shrubs screen the abutting parcel.
At the base of the retaining wall buffer plantings will include 7 trees and 50 shrubs.
The buffer area to the southeast of the property at the base of the retaining wall accommodates the required safe accessible dispersal area. Consistency with the Comprehensive Plan and Other Plans: Living Asheville Comprehensive Plan (2018)
The proposed development supports a number of goals in the Living Asheville Comprehensive Plan, including:
Encourage Responsible Growth
by prioritizing greater densities of development overall as a means of achieving more walkable and efficient urban environments and as a tool to help protect and preserve open space and the natural environment.
Increase and Diversify the Housing Supply
by increasing the supply and variety of housing types, especially in existing neighborhoods and proximity to schools, transit, and public amenities.
Promote Great Architecture and Urban Design to Enhance Placemaking
by promoting adaptive reuse as a means of conserving materials, history, and embodied energy in buildings.
The proposed development is compatible with the Future Land Use designations of “Traditional Neighborhood":
Traditional Neighborhood: “In a traditional neighborhood, the types of housing can vary and often include a mix of housing types such as single family with accessory dwelling units, duplexes, townhomes and multifamily apartments usually located seamlessly together.
Compatibility Analysis:
The proposed adaptive reuse and 3 unit multi-family project is generally compatible with the surrounding land uses, including:
The site abuts RM-8 districts along the southern and eastern boundary.
Includes the adaptive reuse and general preservation of an existing building of historic significance.
Medium density single-family residential land uses located in the surrounding vicinity on smaller lots.
The existing building is preserved resulting in no increased height, mass, or floor area.
The required neighborhood meeting provided a substantial engagement opportunity for the community.
Technical Review Committee (TRC)
March 18, 2024
Approved with conditions.
Planning & Zoning Commission (PZC)
May 1, 2024
Recommend Approve, 5-0.
Staff Recommendation:
Staff supports this rezoning request based on the reasons stated above. Mr. Mitchell reviewed the aerial imagery map. Site details include (1) Located in the legacy neighborhood of East End; (2) Future Land Use
Traditional Neighborhood; (3) Across the street from Stephens-Lee Community Center; (4) Existing building to be rehabilitated; (5) Property abuts “paper street”/alley; (6) Property owner is The Preservation Society of Asheville and Buncombe; (7) Site is walkable to downtown; and (8) N5 Transit Route on nearby Martin Luther King Drive. About the site plan (the current zoning is RS-8 and the proposed zoning is RM-8 Conditional Zone, (1) Adaptive reuse of existing church building to 3 multi-family residential units and associated infrastructure; (2) 0.266 Acres Total; (3) Site currently has no driveway access. Land partially fronts on Old Max Street; (4) Primary frontage and access to be constructed from Max Street. Maximum driveway grade is 19.6%; (5) New construction: Parking lot, Retaining walls, Sidewalk (internal & Max St.), Garden area, and Landscaping; and (6) 4 total parking spaces, 1 accessible, 2 bicycle. (Meeting CoA requirements). Regarding the landscape plan, (1) Landscaping standards: Street trees and buffer to RS zone required; (2) Open Space not required; (3) 20’ buffer required
technical modification requested; (4) Parking, street buffer and building do not apply; (5) TCP (met with on site planting 10.2% and fee in lieu ); (6) Open space not required; (7) Retaining wall landscaping details indicate natural or artificial stone; and (8) Tenant garden spaces. The technical modification regarding the buffer is (1) Modification for buffer width and plantings
Required = 20’ from RS District; and (2) Average width reduced to 14.2’: (a) Accommodation for safe disposal area; (b) Part of buffer area dedicated to garden spaces for residents; and (c) Modified planting counts to achieve optimal design and screening proposed as: (i) 4 small deciduous trees; (ii) 11 large shrubs (all evergreen); (iii) 23 medium shrubs (all evergreen and at top of retaining wall); and (iv) 26 small shrubs (all deciduous). The Technical Review Committee and the Planning & Zoning Commission voted to approve the project. He then explained how the project was consistent with the Living Asheville Comprehensive Plan, the East End Vision Plan and the Compatibility Analysis. He said that based upon the application materials and our analysis thereof, staff finds that the application is consistent with several of the City of Asheville goals, ordinances, and adopted plans for the location and use. Accordingly, staff concurs with the Planning & Zoning Commission’s recommendation to approve the Conditional Zoning petition. In response to Councilwoman Roney, Mr. Mitchell said that he has not talked with the applicants about renewable energy plans since this is an adaptive reuse of an historic building; however, there will be energy efficiency improvement funding from the state, but the state has not released its program information yet. Jessie Landl, Executive Director of the Preservation Society of Asheville-Buncombe County, was excited to explain how the project came to be and how they worked with the neighborhood. Their goal is that the three units be affordable structures Mayor Manheimer opened the public hearing at 7:58 p.m. Robert Robinson spoke in support of this conditional zoning, noting that the Unified Development Ordinance needs revisions as conditional zonings are burdensome and expensive for developers. Jim Abbott said that the East End/Valley Street Neighborhood Association strongly supports this conditional zoning. Councilwoman Smith spoke in support of adaptive reuse of churches for affordable housing. She noted it would be a great benefit to keep neighborhoods in tact and faith-based communities to keep their properties alive Mayor Manheimer closed the public hearing at 8:04 p.m. Mayor Manheimer said that members of Council have previously received a copy of the ordinance and it would not be read.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
OpposesCouncilwoman Roney was pleased that 100% of the applicants are MWBE, which speaks to the work that our staff and the community did around engagement. … however, she could not support the action today
The minutes record no remarks on this item from Sandra Kilgore, Esther E. Manheimer, S. Antanette Mosley, Sheneika Smith and Sage Turner.
Key facts
$180,000total contract amount not to exceed $180,000
$3 millionan associated budget amendment in the amount of $3,000,000
Illumined Leadership Solutions (partnering with BennettWeston Consulting)contractor or recipient
Boosting the Block project funded by the Mellon Foundationfunding source
27-30 monthsterm
Presented by Dana Frankel, Downtown Projects Manager.
From the staff report
Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a contract with Illumined Leadership Solutions for community engagement, facilitation and overall support through implementation of the Boosting the Block project funded by the Mellon Foundation; and an associated budget amendment in the amount of $3,000,000.
$3 millionan associated budget amendment in the amount of $3,000,000
$180,000a total contract amount not to exceed $180,000
Mellon Foundationfunding source
An RFP process to hire a Community Facilitator launched on November 17, 2023 · 11 responseshow the vendor was chosen
Fiscal impact
Funding for this contract is available as part of the associated budget amendment.
Staff’s stated reasons
This grant-funded project will implement aspects of the community’s vision as laid out in the Pack Square Plaza Vision Plan as applicable to The Block.
The hiring of a community facilitator will support further engagement and planning on aspects of design and programming, and ensure implementation that’s aligned with the community’s vision.
Before it reached Council
Planning and Economic Development Committee, March 13, 2023: approve — recommended that City Council authorize staff to apply for and accept Mellon Foundation funding to implement the Pack Square Plaza Vision Plan
Planning and Economic Development Committee, August 14, 2023: approve — recommended approval of the Pack Square Plaza Vision Plan
Planning and Economic Development Committee, February 12, 2024: approve (3–0) — voted 3-0 to recommend that City Council authorize staff to execute a $180,000 contract with the selected Community Facilitator.
Staff: Dana Frankel, Downtown Projects Manager; Stephanie Dahl, Planning and Urban Design Director.
Item V-A-budget · ORD 5083 · Economic Development · Ordinance
Budget amendment for the Boosting the Block project
Passed6–0 · Moved by S. Antanette Mosley, seconded by Sandra Kilgore
All members present voted yes. Absent: Maggie Ullman.
Key facts
$3 millionan associated budget amendment in the amount of $3,000,000
Boosting the Block project funded by the Mellon Foundationfunding source
Presented by Dana Frankel, Downtown Projects Manager.
From the staff report
Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a contract with Illumined Leadership Solutions for community engagement, facilitation and overall support through implementation of the Boosting the Block project funded by the Mellon Foundation; and an associated budget amendment in the amount of $3,000,000.
$3 millionan associated budget amendment in the amount of $3,000,000
$180,000a total contract amount not to exceed $180,000
Mellon Foundationfunding source
An RFP process to hire a Community Facilitator launched on November 17, 2023 · 11 responseshow the vendor was chosen
Fiscal impact
Funding for this contract is available as part of the associated budget amendment.
Staff’s stated reasons
This grant-funded project will implement aspects of the community’s vision as laid out in the Pack Square Plaza Vision Plan as applicable to The Block.
The hiring of a community facilitator will support further engagement and planning on aspects of design and programming, and ensure implementation that’s aligned with the community’s vision.
Before it reached Council
Planning and Economic Development Committee, March 13, 2023: approve — recommended that City Council authorize staff to apply for and accept Mellon Foundation funding to implement the Pack Square Plaza Vision Plan
Planning and Economic Development Committee, August 14, 2023: approve — recommended approval of the Pack Square Plaza Vision Plan
Planning and Economic Development Committee, February 12, 2024: approve (3–0) — voted 3-0 to recommend that City Council authorize staff to execute a $180,000 contract with the selected Community Facilitator.
Staff: Dana Frankel, Downtown Projects Manager; Stephanie Dahl, Planning and Urban Design Director.
Description in the minutes
Downtown Projects Manager Dana Frankel said that this is the consideration of adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a contract with Illumined Leadership Solutions for community engagement and overall support through implementation of the Boosting the Block project funded by the Mellon Foundation; and an associated budget amendment in the amount of $3,000,000.
Background:
City Council adopted “Reimagining Pack Square Plaza: A Vision Plan” (Pack Square Plaza Vision Plan) at their September 26, 2023 meeting as a result of a planning and engagement process led by the McAdams Company and City and County staff.
The City received a $3,000,000 grant from the Mellon Foundation’s Monuments Project to move the following elements of the plan forward: design and engineering for reshaping Pack Square; design, engineering and construction to better connect The Block and enhance its cultural character (“Boosting the Block”); and programming and education around more inclusive storytelling and history efforts in our community.
The first proposed investment in the Boosting the Block project is hiring a Community Facilitator to lead engagement and support all aspects of community organizing, planning, conceptual design and implementation of the project deliverables.
Boosting the Block project deliverables include construction of a physical gateway and cultural corridor between Pack Square and The Block; increased capacity of neighborhood anchors to shape and influence the future of The Block; enhanced public spaces and programming that authentically narrates the past, present and future of The Block; and consensus and implementation of neighborhood identity of and marketing for The Block.
An RFP process to hire a Community Facilitator launched on November 17, 2023; 11 proposals were received; 2 rounds of interviews took place by a selection committee that included City and County staff and community representatives
A collaborative partnership between Illumined Leadership Solutions and BennettWeston Consulting was selected based on their qualifications, experience and proposed approach to the project.
The facilitator is anticipated to work for 27-30 months, the entire length of the Boosting the Block project.
Vendor Outreach Efforts:
Staff conducted outreach to all MWBE vendors registered with the City of Asheville that provide services related to communications, project management, consulting and community development as well as additional outreach to local business and community organizations.
Prime contractors were also required to reach out to Minority & Women-Owned Business Enterprise (MWBE) service providers for subcontracted services.
The selected vendor (Illumined Leadership Solutions) and the partnering firm (BennetWeston Consulting) are both MWBE certified.
There will be additional City contracting opportunities as part of the Boosting the Block project including for a consulting artist/creative strategist, community coordinator, marketing/promotion related needs, event production, design/engineering and construction.
Illumined Leadership Solutions and BennettWeston Consulting will coordinate with City staff to contract with local MWBE vendors.
Committee(s):
March 13, 2023
Planning and Economic Development Committee recommended that City Council authorize staff to apply for and accept Mellon Foundation funding to implement the Pack Square Plaza Vision Plan, including design and construction of a gateway corridor on S.Market Street to connect Pack Square and The Block
April 11, 2023
City Council adopted a resolution to authorize staff to apply for and accept Mellon Foundation funding to implement the Pack Square Plaza Vision Plan, including design and construction of a gateway corridor on S.Market Street to connect Pack Square and The Block
August 14, 2023
Planning and Economic Development Committee recommended approval of the Pack Square Plaza Vision Plan
September 26, 2023
City Council adopted the Pack Square Plaza Vision Plan
February 12, 2024
Planning and Economic Development Committee voted 3-0 to recommend that City Council authorize staff to execute a $180,000 contract with the selected Community Facilitator.
March 7, 2024
Staff presented information about the RFP evaluation process to City Council as part of the Agenda Briefing.
March 12, 2024
Staff presented information about the RFP evaluation process as well as additional information requested in the Agenda Briefing. No vote occurred.
Pro(s):
This grant-funded project will implement aspects of the community’s vision as laid out in the Pack Square Plaza Vision Plan as applicable to The Block.
The hiring of a community facilitator will support further engagement and planning on aspects of design and programming, and ensure implementation that’s aligned with the community’s vision.
Con(s):
None
Fiscal Impact:
Funding for this contract is available as part of the associated budget amendment.
While matching funds are not required for this grant, additional funding in the General Capital Projects Fund has been identified to support the Boosting the Block project.
Staff will work to assess City funding capacity and identify other funding opportunities (beyond the existing Mellon Foundation grant) to implement future phases of the Pack Square Vision Plan. Ms. Frankel highlighted the following key takeaways from her presentation: (1) Boosting the Block is one of three projects funded by a $3 million grant from the Mellon Foundation that will build on and implement recommendations of the Pack Square Plaza Vision Plan (in this case, specific to The Block area
Eagle/S.Market Streets); (2) The Boosting the Block project will include extensive and strategic community engagement, and will ultimately result in construction of a physical gateway and cultural corridor between Pack Square and The Block, along with enhanced public spaces and increased community capacity; (3) An RFP and extensive evaluation process took place to select a community facilitator to support all aspects of community organizing, planning, design and project implementation; (4) A collaborative partnership between Illumined Leadership Solutions and BennettWeston Consulting was selected based on their qualifications, experience and proposed approach to the project. Both firms are MWBE certified; (5) There are additional local contracting opportunities as part of the project for a community coordinator, consulting artist/creative strategist, marketing/promotion, event production, design/engineering and construction; and (6) With May 28 City Council authorization of the community facilitator contract, anticipated project kick-off is July 2024. The Mellon Foundation funding is available through Dec 2026. She outlined the following City Council actions/directions as follows: (1) Apr. 11, 2023: City Council adopts resolution to authorize staff to apply for and accept Mellon Foundation funds to implement recommendations of the Pack Square Plaza Vision Plan; (2) Sept. 26, 2023: City Council adopts the Pack Square Plaza Vision Plan; (3) Feb. 12, 2024: City Council’s PED Committee recommends authorization for staff to execute a $180,000 contract for a community facilitator to support the Boosting the Block project following an RFP and selection process; (4) Feb. 27, 2024: City Council requests more information about community facilitator selection process; (5) March 7, 2024: Staff provide presentation at agenda briefing with more information about community facilitator selection process; (6) Mar. 12, 2024: Consideration to authorize community facilitator contract; no vote taken; and (7) May 28, 2024: City Council to consider authorizing staff to execute a $180,000 contract with Illumined Leadership Solutions (partnering with BennettWeston Consulting), both NC-based Black and women-owned business, for community facilitator services to support the Boosting the Block project following an RFP and selection process. Regarding Boosting the Block, (1) One of three projects funded by the Mellon Foundation Monuments Project Initiative; (2) Boosting the Block ($1.8M) (a) A physical gateway and cultural corridor between Pack Square and The Block; (b) Enhanced public spaces and programming in alignment with the community’s vision and in a way that authentically narrates the past, present, and future of The Block; (c) Consensus and implementation of neighborhood identity and marketing for The Block; and (d) Increased capacity of neighborhood stakeholders to help shape and influence the future of The Block; (3( Reframing the Square ($1.1M)
Design and engineering for Pack Square Plaza (based on Vision); and (4) Sharing our Stories ($163,400)
Partnership with Buncombe County Library to expand history and story-telling initiatives. Regarding the community facilitator scope and role, it will be to support all aspects of community organizing, planning, communications, design and implementation of project outcomes. This includes (1) Communications and Engagement (a) Lead engagement and serve as a liaison for City and community; (b) Foster authentic collaboration and facilitate successful outcomes; and (c) Ensure appropriate engagement on other Mellon Foundation projects; (2) Project Management (a) Create and manage work plan in alignment with City, community and grant; (b) Plan and execute learning opportunities, temporary activations and events to support the design and implementation process; and (c) Facilitate capacity building for the further establishment and success of the neighborhood; and (3) Strategic Planning (a) Compile research and plans to lay a foundation for strategic planning and investment; and (b) Expand community participation and explore partnerships to support the long-term well being of the district and elevate outcomes. The $180,000 budget available for 27-30 month contract Project resources and next steps include (1) 2.5 year work plan to be developed by community facilitator in collaboration with community stakeholders and city/county staff; (2) Broader public engagement to take place with focus on communities with connections to The Block (past, present, future); (3) Local community coordinator under a separate contract to be hired to support additional community involvement during year 1 of project, and capacity building for The Block Collaborative; (4) Additional local contracting opportunities: Community coordinator (~$25,000); Creative strategist/consulting artist (~$12,500); Marketing/promotion/advertising (~$15,000); Community celebration production (~$15,000); Design/Engineering ($166,325); and Construction (up to $1,638,250); and (5) Project page: www.ashevillenc.gov/boostingtheblock. Councilwoman Roney was pleased that 100% of the applicants are MWBE, which speaks to the work that our staff and the community did around engagement. She felt that no matter what happens with the decision, it will positively impact the outcomes of our disparity study. She knows that takes relationships and time. She noted that four applicants are local companies which is a potential opportunity to invest in capacity building for this and other projects but she hears and acknowledges community concerns that the resulting recommendation is currently missing subject matter experts, like local history and zoning impacts that she hears will be critical for the project’s success. She appreciated the subject matter experts on local issues may include non-local companies including displaced people, and she appreciated the City’a stated commitment on this process moving forward; however, she could not support the action today When Mayor Manheimer asked for public comments, none were received. Mayor Manheimer said that members of Council have been previously furnished with a copy of the resolution and ordinance and they would not be read.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Item VI-A · RES 24-114 / RES 24-115 · Budget & Finance · Resolution
Resolutions directing publication of notice of intention to apply to the LGC for approval of GO Bonds and making statements of fact concerning the proposed bond issue
Passed5–1 · Moved by Sage Turner, seconded by Sandra Kilgore
1 spoke · changed before the vote · 3 council remarks
Recommendations
Council’s vote matched the city staff recommendation.
City staff: Approve — That extensive planning process has led staff to recommend that Council move forward with a $75 million GO Bond referendum in November 2024
Public comment on this item
0 spoke in favor · 0 spoke against · 1 stance not recorded
Not recordedSally Grau — Sally Grau urged Council to put their commitment to earmark $3 M into the GO Bonds for the Malvern Hills pool in writing.
What council members said 3 remarks from 2 members
ConcernCouncilwoman Roney wanted to make sure that the Climate Justice Initiative and Vulnerability Index which includes heat mapping is one of the plans that is used in prioritizing capital needs.
QuestionIn response to Councilwoman Roney, [Jade Dundas] said that we have reached out to Buncombe County with our plans on the Oakley Complex, noting that the scope of this, and the other projects, have not been finalized.
QuestionMayor Manheimer requested details on the possible two new sidewalk improvement projects of Fairview Road and Tunnel Road.
The minutes record no remarks on this item from Sandra Kilgore, S. Antanette Mosley, Sheneika Smith and Sage Turner.
Changed before the vote 1 change recorded
Amendment by motionEach Resolution shall be updated from the Staff Report proposal to reflect the following bond amounts: $20 Million for Affordable Housing; $20 Million for Transportation; $20 Million for Parks and Recreation, and $20 Million for Public Safety. · offered by Sage Turner
Key facts
$75 million$75 million GO Bond referendum in November 2024
$75M November 2024 General Obligation (GO) Bond referendumfunding source
Presented by Tony McDowell, Finance Director.
From the staff report
Council approval of: 1) a Resolution of the City Council of the City of Asheville, North Carolina, Directing the Publication of Notice of Intention to Apply to the Local Government Commission for Approval of Bonds; and 2) Resolution of the City Council of the City of Asheville, North Carolina Making Certain Statements of Fact Concerning Proposed Bond Issue and Authorizing the Application to the Local Government Commission.
$75 milliona $75 million GO Bond referendum in November 2024
$25 millionAffordable Housing: $25 million
$20 millionTransportation: $20 million
$15 millionParks and Recreation: $15 million
$15 millionPublic Safety: $15 million
Fiscal impact
A GO bond commits the full faith and credit of the City of Asheville to repayment of the bonded debt.
Staff’s stated reasons · approve
Provide enhanced funding for transportation, parks and recreation, affordable housing, and public safety infrastructure needs as identified in City master plans and Council strategic goals utilizing GO Bonds, which come with the lowest possible interest rates.
Ensures City’s compliance with North Carolina General Statutes.
Staff: Tony McDowell, CFO, Finance and Management Services Director.
Item II-B · ORD 5079 · Zoning & Land Use · Ordinance · consent agenda
Ordinance amending Section 7-3-11 of Chapter 7 of the Code of Ordinances revising the terms of the Downtown Commission
Passed6–0 · Moved by Sage Turner, seconded by Sheneika Smith
All members present voted yes. Absent: Maggie Ullman.
Recommendations
Design Review Committee: Deny, unanimous, March 21, 2024
Planning & Zoning Commission: Approve, 6–0, April 3, 2024
Boards & Commissions Committee: Approve, 3–0, April 9, 2024
Description in the minutes
Committee (DRC).
Action Requested:
Adoption of an amendment to Article III, Section 7-3-11 of Chapter 7 of the Code of Ordinances for the purpose of revising the committee terms on the Design Review Committee (DRC).
Background:
On February 23, 2021 the Asheville City Council adopted Ordinance No. 4855, “Ordinance Amending Chapter 7 of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Asheville to establish new standards for hotel development.”
Ordinance No. 4855, adopted on February 23, 2021, established new standards for hotel development and also formalized the city’s design review process and established the Design Review Committee (DRC).
On January 25, 2022, via Ordinance No. 4926, changes to the DRC included reducing the number of appointments that must come from both the Downtown Commission (DTC) and Asheville Area Riverfront Redevelopment Commission (AARRC) from four seats to three, and making the remaining three seats to be appointed at large by the City Council (for a total of nine seats all appointed by City Council).
Since those appointments were made, it has come to the attention of City staff that committee terms are not consistent with their representing board; and thus, should be revised that all terms of the Downtown Commission representatives and the Asheville-Buncombe Riverfront Commission representatives on the Design Review Committee should be concurrent with the terms of their respective board.
Council Goal(s):
An Equitable and Diverse Community
A Well-Planned & Livable Community
Committee(s):
Design Review Committee (DRC)
February 15, 2024
informational review
Design Review Committee (DRC)
March 21, 2024
unanimous negative recommendation
- Concern about possibly reducing continuity and experience of DRC members.
If adopted by City Council as proposed, the Clerk’s Office will monitor this Committee to address concern and appointment scheduling.
Planning & Zoning Commission (PZC)
April 3, 2024
voted unanimously (6-0) to recommend change.
Boards & Commissions Committee
April 9, 2024
voted unanimously (3-0) to recommend change.
Fiscal Impact:
This action requires no City resources and has no fiscal impact.
Staff: Stephanie Dahl, Director of Planning & Urban Design; Will Palmquiest, Principal Planner.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a contract with Rock Creek Grading LLC for the FY 2024 bridge maintenance project
Passed6–0 · Moved by Sage Turner, seconded by Sheneika Smith
All members present voted yes. Absent: Maggie Ullman.
Key facts
$368,000contract with Rock Creek Grading, LLC. in the amount of $368,000.00
$44,16012% contingency
$412,160$412,160.00 total
Rock Creek Grading LLCcontractor or recipient
Funding for this project was previously budgeted and is available in the General Capital Projects Fund.funding source
Description in the minutes
Action Requested:
Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a contract with Rock Creek Grading, LLC. in the amount of $368,000.00 plus a 12% contingency of $44,160.00 ($412,160.00 total) for the FY 2023-24 Bridge Maintenance contract.
Background:
The North Carolina Department of Transportation performs periodic inspections of City-owned bridges
The inspections provide recommendations for maintenance.
This contract is intended to address these recommendations for bridges on Beaver Valley Road, Chestnut Street, Chunns Cove Road, Depot Street, Faircrest Road and Meadowview Road.
The contract was advertised on March 12, 2024, and bids were opened on April 9, 2024.
The following bids were received: Rock Creek Grading, LLC. of Burnsville, NC $368,000.00 Cinderella Partners of Indian Trail, NC $526,400.40 IPC Paving, LLC DBA IPC Structure of Hendersonville, NC $1,299,870.00
Vendor Outreach Efforts:
Funding for this contract was previously budgeted and is available in the General Capital Projects Fund, as a result the outreach and engagement followed the City’s business inclusion processes.
This process at a minimum requires staff to outreach businesses that have a documented contracting disparity directly and/or through prime contractors.
Staff performed outreach to minority- and women-owned businesses through solicitation processes which include posting on the State’s Interactive Purchasing System and requiring prime contractors to reach out to Minority & Women-Owned Business Enterprise (MWBE) service providers for subcontracted services.
Staff also checked the NC Historically Underutilized Business and NCDOT MWBE databases for potential contractors along with the City of Asheville ABI database.
No companies from an identified disparity group (Black American or Hispanic) were found in the ten-county search area.
No companies from an identified disparity group submitted a bid for the project.
The contractor anticipates self-performing all of the work on this contract.
Council Goal(s):
A Well-Planned and Livable Community
Committee(s):
None
Pro(s):
The award of this contract will result in maintenance being performed on six City-owned bridges
Con(s):
Construction will cause access delays to the impacted neighborhoods.
Fiscal Impact:
Funding for this project was previously budgeted and is available in the General Capital Projects Fund.
Staff: Greg Shuler, Public Works Director; Chad Bandy, Streets Division Manager; Chuck Watson, Streets Project Manager.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a contract with Kessler Consulting Inc. for solid waste master planning services
Passed6–0 · Moved by Sage Turner, seconded by Sheneika Smith
All members present voted yes. Absent: Maggie Ullman.
Key facts
$350,000contract with Kessler Consulting Inc. for solid waste master planning services for an amount not to exceed $350,000.
Kessler Consulting Inc.contractor or recipient
Funding for this project is provided through the City General Fund and the Sanitation Division operating budget.funding source
Description in the minutes
Action Requested:
Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a contract with Kessler Consulting Inc. for solid waste master planning services for an amount not to exceed $350,000.
Background:
Council approved funding in the amount of $350,000 in the FY 2023-24 budget for a solid waste master plan.
The purpose of the solid waste master plan is to evaluate the City of Asheville’s existing solid waste management system and provide short- and long-term recommendations to improve and enhance the efficiency and quality of the system and increase waste reduction and diversion.
Conducting a solid waste master planning process is listed as a high-impact activity in the Council-approved Municipal Climate Action Plan.
Vendor Outreach Efforts:
Funding for this project is provided through the City General Fund and the Sanitation Division operating budget. As a result, the outreach and engagement followed the City’s business inclusion processes.
Staff utilized the NC HUB vendor portal to identify individuals and firms for direct outreach. RFP respondents performed outreach for subcontracting utilizing the newly approved MWBE participation requirement of 8.39% for General Services.
Staff issued a Request for Proposals in December 2023 and received four responsive proposals from the following firms:
NewGen Strategies & Solutions, LLC of Colorado: $327,370
Geosyntec Consultants, Inc. of Florida: $344,000
Raftelis Financial Consultants, In.c of North Carolina: $324,500
Kessler Consulting, Inc. of Florida: $329,800
Proposals were reviewed by a panel and Kessler Consulting, Inc. (KCI) was selected as the prime consultant for the project.
KCI, founded in 1988, is a niche firm that specializes in developing and implementing strategic, practical, and sustainable solid waste plans and in optimizing the business and operational efficiencies of solid waste management systems.
KCI is headquartered in Tampa, FL with numerous satellite offices, including one in Boone, NC. KCI’s proposed team includes three North Carolina-based members, two of which currently reside in Asheville, and a Project Manager who has roots in Asheville.
The selected vendor has proposed to utilize a local MWBE, Aisha Adams Media, to assist with stakeholder engagement, equity and inclusion analysis, and climate resilience analysis.
Council Goal(s):
Clean, Safe, and Healthy Environment
Well Planned and Livable Community
Financially Resilient City
Committee(s):
3/14/2023: Policy, Finance and HR Committee: Staff presented recommendations to increase the solid waste fee to, in part, support funding for a solid waste master plan in the FY24 budget. Update only with no vote.
11/28/2023: Environment and Safety Committee: Staff presented an overview of the solid waste master plan project, including background, scope of work, deliverables, and estimated timeline. Informational only with no vote.
Pro(s):
Supports Resolution 14-27 to reduce waste by 50% by 2035
Addresses Council’s strategic priorities to Improve and Expand Core Services and to focus on Neighborhood and Climate Resilience
Engages in a high-impact activity listed in the City’s Municipal Climate Action Plan
Con(s):
None
Fiscal Impact:
Funding for this contract is available in the Public Works Department operating budget.
Staff: Greg Shuler, Public Works Director; Jes Foster, Sanitation Division Manager.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Resolution authorizing the City Manager to accept grant funds from the N.C. Dept. of Environmental Quality for a 2024 community waste reduction grant
Passed6–0 · Moved by Sage Turner, seconded by Sheneika Smith
All members present voted yes. Absent: Maggie Ullman.
Key facts
$35,0002024 Community Waste Reduction and Recycling (CWRAR) Grant
$7,000required $7,000 local match
N.C. Dept. of Environmental Qualitycontractor or recipient
Funding for the required $7,000 local match has been identified within the Public Works Department operating budget.funding source
Description in the minutes
Action Requested:
Adoption of a Resolution authorizing the City Manager to accept grant funding from the N.C. Dept. of Environmental Quality (NCDEQ) for a 2024 Community Waste Reduction and Recycling (CWRAR) Grant; and to authorize the City Manager to execute all documents.
Background:
On February 13, 2024, City Council passed Resolution 24-31 authorizing the City Manager to apply for the Community Waste and Recycling Grant from the N.C. Department of Environmental Quality.
In 2014, City Council passed Resolution 14-27 adopting a waste reduction goal of 50 percent by 2035.
The CWRAR grant will provide funding to support programming that increases awareness and drives education around how to ‘Recycle Right’ in order to reduce contamination in the recycling stream and improve, protect, and preserve our recycling program.
Educating Asheville residents and businesses about what can go in their recycling carts will help to reduce contamination, reduce Material Recovery Facility (MRF) disposal tonnages and costs, ensure that our MRF has marketable commodities, and support the long-term viability of our recycling program.
Grant funds will be used to purchase outreach and educational materials and to fund an educational media campaign.
The City’s contracted Material Recovery Facility, Curbside Management, supports the development and implementation of this recycling outreach campaign.
Other internal COA departments that are supporting this campaign include the Office of Sustainability and the Communications and Public Engagement team (CAPE).
Vendor Outreach Efforts:
N/A
Council Goal(s):
Improve and Expand Core Services
Neighborhood and Climate Resilience
Committee(s):
N/A
Pro(s):
Increase waste reduction and recycling contamination awareness with City residents and businesses
Reduce recycling contamination rates and deliver a clean stream of recyclables to our contracted Material Recovery Facility (MRF), Curbside Management, and help reduce MRF disposal tonnages and associated costs
Leverage City waste reduction programming funds to help develop and implement an educational recycling outreach campaign through printed materials and media outlets
Con(s):
None
Fiscal Impact:
Funding for the required $7,000 local match has been identified within the Public Works Department operating budget.
The grant funding, matching funds, and associated expenses will be included in the FY 2024-25 Proposed Budget.
Staff: Alex Miller, Waste Reduction Program Manager; Jes Foster, Sanitation Division Manager; Greg Shuler, Public Works Director.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Resolution authorizing the sale of one 2013 Freightliner vacuum truck deemed surplus city personal property
Passed6–0 · Moved by Sage Turner, seconded by Sheneika Smith
All members present voted yes. Absent: Maggie Ullman.
Key facts
$30,000expected to sell for more than $30,000
The vehicle is fully depreciated and the Water Fund will recognize the entire amount as revenue.funding source
Description in the minutes
Action Requested:
Adoption of a resolution authorizing the sale of one (1) 2013 Freightliner Vacuum Truck which is beyond its useful life and deemed surplus City personal property.
Background:
The City’s Water Department identified one (1) vacuum truck as surplus personal property, with no anticipation of future utilization by the City.
The vac truck is a jet vac truck, which is the same as what stormwater uses.
The vac truck can be used to clean drains and also for clearing debris around pipes, valves, and other water infrastructure.
The 2013 Freightliner Vacuum Truck is expected to sell for more than $30,000.
All bids are solicited through online auction.
Pursuant to N.C.G.S. §160A-266, the Sale and Disposal of Personal Property valued at $30,000 or more must be approved by the City Council.
The City’s Purchasing Manager has authority to dispose of personal property valued at less than $30,000 by private negotiation and sale.
Vendor Outreach Efforts:
Not Applicable
Council Goal(s):
A Financially Resilient City
Committee(s):
None
Pro(s):
Prudent asset management
Space utilization eliminates the need to store large, unused equipment
Competitive process yielded market price
Con(s):
None
Fiscal Impact:
The vehicle is fully depreciated and the Water Fund will recognize the entire amount as revenue.
Estimated revenue from the sale of fixed assets is already budgeted in the Water Fund.
Staff: Tony McDowell, Chief Financial Officer; Amy Patterson, Purchasing Manager.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Item II-H · RES 24-110 · Parks & Recreation · Resolution · consent agenda
Resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a contract amendment with Smart Builders Construction for the Murphy-Oakley Playground
Passed6–0 · Moved by Sage Turner, seconded by Sheneika Smith
All members present voted yes. Absent: Maggie Ullman.
Key facts
$20,000increase the contract with Smart Builders Construction in the amount of $20,000, for the Murphy Oakley Fence and Curb Change Order
$441,516The lowest responsive/responsible bidder was Smart Builders Construction and a contract was entered into with them for $441,516.00.
Smart Builders Constructioncontractor or recipient
Funding for this contract was previously budgeted and is available in the Parks Bond Program Fund.funding source
Description in the minutes
Action Requested:
Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to increase the contract with Smart Builders Construction in the amount of $20,000, for the Murphy Oakley Fence and Curb Change Order.
Background:
The Murphy Oakley playground renovation is Asheville’s first inclusive playground and is currently under construction.
Additional picket style fencing is needed around the inclusive playground. A picket style of fence provides the required safety around the playground.
Also, additional construction work has been added to the original project scope due to unanticipated curb work that is required on the north side of the parking lot.
The original contractor selection process included a formal advertised bid on May 10, 2023 with bids received June 22, 2023. Not enough bids were received and the project was readvertised on June 23,2023. The bids were opened on July 6, 2023. The lowest responsive/responsible bidder was Smart Builders Construction and a contract was entered into with them for $441,516.00.
Construction is expected to be substantially completed by June 1, 2024.
Vendor Outreach Efforts:
Outreach was performed for the original bid and no new vendors are needed for this increase of fencing and curbing. Initial outreach included staff performing outreach to minority and women owned businesses through solicitation processes using the State’s Interactive Purchasing System and requesting prime contractors to reach out to Minority & Women-Owned Business Enterprise (MWBE) service providers for subcontracted services.
Additionally, the contractor performed outreach and has a minority contractor performing 7% of the construction contract.
Council Goal(s):
A well-planned and livable community
Committee(s):
None
Pro(s):
No delay in construction completion.
Con(s):
Additional project cost and administrative time required to revise the contract amount.
Fiscal Impact:
Funding for this contract was previously budgeted and is available in the Parks Bond Program Fund.
Staff: Jade Dundas, Director of Capital Projects.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
CommentMayor Manheimer explained that (1) the Housing Authority is a separate entity from the City of Asheville; and (2) the developer is actually not the Housing Authority. She explained that this is a privately-owned housing provider that is using these funds to do their own project which will accept vouchers. She said the City of Asheville has no financial liability.
The minutes record no remarks on this item from Sandra Kilgore, S. Antanette Mosley, Kim Roney, Sheneika Smith and Sage Turner.
Key facts
$28 millionissuance of up to $28,000,000 Multifamily Housing Revenue Bonds
171 Monticello Road in Weavervilleaddress
10.26 acressite size
156 units156 of them affordable
30% or less (58 units), 60% or less (24 units) and 80% or less (74 units) of Area Median Incomeaffordability
Meribel LPapplicant
Asheville Housing Authoritycontractor or recipient
issuance of up to $28,000,000 Multifamily Housing Revenue Bonds to provide financing for Meribel LP’s multi-family developmentfunding source
30 yearsterm
Description in the minutes
SECTION 147(f) OF THE INTERNAL REVENUE CODE, WITH NO CITY FINANCIAL OBLIGATION ASSOCIATED WITH THE BONDS OR ANY DEBT TAKEN ON BY THE DEVELOPER
Action Requested:
Request of the Housing Authority for City Council to adopt a resolution approving the issuance of up to $28,000,000 Multifamily Housing Revenue Bonds to provide financing for Meribel LP’s multi-family development located at 171 Monticello Road in Weaverville to satisfy Section 147(f) of the Internal Revenue Code, with no City of Asheville financial obligation associated with the bonds or any debt taken on by the developer.
Background:
The Asheville Housing Authority was created by the City of Asheville in 1940 in accordance with Chapter 157 of the NC General Statutes.
It is a public body and is independent from the City with its own powers as outlined in North Carolina General Statute Chapter 157.
The Housing Authority is governed by a Board of Commissioners, consisting of 7 members, who serve for a 4 year term and are appointed by the Mayor of the City of Asheville.
The Internal Revenue Service requires that any bonds issued by the Housing Authority for developments such as the one described herein, have the financing plan approved by the City Council, following a public hearing with respect to such plan.
Meribel LP, a North Carolina limited partnership (the “Borrower”) has requested that the Asheville Housing Authority (the “Issuer”) issue up to $28,000,000 in multifamily housing revenue bonds for the acquisition and construction of a 156-unit affordable rental development known as Meribel located on a 10.26 acre site at 171 Monticello Road in Weaverville, North Carolina, parcel identified as PIN 973360350300000 in the Buncombe County Registry.
The project will consist of 5 residential buildings. There will be a mix of 1,2 and 3-bedroom units. Units will be set aside for individuals and families at 30% or less (58 units), 60% or less (24 units) and 80% or less (74 units) of Area Median Income (“AMI”).
The affordability period will be 30 years.
LDG Development is the developer and is an affiliate of the owner. Gateway Property Management, LLC will be the manager of this project.
Construction is scheduled to commence in June 2024 and has an expected completion date of July 2026.
Staff notes that approval does not obligate the City in any way to issue or pay for the bonds, or for any debt taken on by the developer. Council Goals:
Quality Affordable Housing
Pro(s):
156 units of new housing affordable to households at or below 30%, 60% and 80% of AMI will be constructed.
The affordability period will be at least 30 years.
Con(s):
None.
Fiscal Impact:
This action requires no City resources and has no fiscal impact.
Staff: Jannice Ashley, Sr. Assistant City Attorney.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
Item II-J · RES 24-112 · Public Safety · Resolution · consent agenda
Resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a service and cost share agreement with Buncombe County for centralized data entry
Passed6–0 · Moved by Sage Turner, seconded by Sheneika Smith
All members present voted yes. Absent: Maggie Ullman.
Key facts
Buncombe Countycontractor or recipient
Funding for the first year of this agreement is available in the Police Department operating budget.funding source
This agreement has a one year term initiating on July 1, 2024, and will renew annually if not earlier terminated.term
Description in the minutes
Action Requested:
Resolution authorizing approval of a Service and Cost Share Agreement with Buncombe County for Centralized Data Entry.
Background:
The City of Asheville and Buncombe County have long standing interlocal agreements regarding the provision of certain joint public safety-related technology and data services.
Those services are rendered through the Centralized Data Entry (CDE) Division of the Buncombe County Bureau of ID.
A Service and Cost Share Agreement is necessary to establish rights and obligations for CDE and data entry services provided by the City and County.
Historically, the City of Asheville has covered 45% of CDE costs and the County has paid 55%. Thanks to a revised governance structure and coordination with other jurisdictions benefitting from CDE, the City’s current share for these services has been reduced from 45% to 30.2% with Woodfin, Black Mountain, and Weaverville all contributing to the system for the first time in Fiscal Year 2024-25.
Under the new agreement, the County will provide the City and other participating jurisdictions with cost estimates during budget development based on their proportionate share of CDE service areas.
CDE service areas include:
RMS master name record entry and maintenance,
Arrest data entry, and
Booking data entry.
This agreement has a one year term initiating on July 1, 2024, and will renew annually if not earlier terminated.
Council Goal(s):
A Financially Resilient City
Pro(s):
Provides authorization to continue key public safety technology services and authorizes the City to to fund the associated interlocal agreement.
Con(s):
None
Fiscal Impact:
Funding for the first year of this agreement is available in the Police Department operating budget.
Future years will be planned during the annual budget development process.
Staff: Rachel Wood, Assistant City Manager.
Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).
presented Jonathon Ballard, Stormwater Operations Manager, with the American Public Works Association (APWA) the H.W. Kueffner award for 2024. … This year, the CAYLA program had 24 graduating seniors, receiving more than $1,029,920 in scholarships.
Presented by Debra Campbell, City Manager; C. Maie Armstrong, APWA Awards & Scholarships Committee Co-Chair; Rachel Ingham, APWA Awards & Scholarships Committee Co-Chair.
Quarterly Update on the Capital Improvement Program
Regarding New Haw Creek and Johnston Boulevard 2016 GO Bond projects, (1) Original funding not sufficient to build project - received Federal funding in 2018; (2) Federal funding requirements, NCDOT ROW, challenges with land acquisition have slowed progress; … Upcoming Council actions include (1) McCormick Field - June - Guaranteed Maximum Price/Contract Amendment; (2) Southside Ped Improvements - June - Construction Award;
Presented by Jade Dundas, Capital Projects Director; Pete Wall, Assistant Director of Parks & Recreation; Greg Shuler, Public Works Director.
Regarding the update on the Walton Street Park, Councilwoman Roney said that as we are having the conversation about the bonds, neighbors who are hearing support for the Malvern Hills Pool are asking why you didn’t listen to them about the Walton Street Pool. … She noted that some requests by the Walton Street community and the Southside community still don’t feel heard.
Councilwoman Roney asked about why we can’t queue up other projects since the College/Patton Avenue sidewalk project is delayed, impacting our local businesses through their biggest part of the season, and start that repair in September. Public Works Director Greg Shuler explained that this is an in-house project and most of the money is being used for labor.
Other business
Public hearing on the Fiscal Year 2025 Annual Operating Budget
City Council will consider adoption of the budget at their June 11, 2024, formal meeting.
Fiscal Year (FY) 2024-25 Proposed Budget totals $249.6 million and includes: (1) No change to the current property tax rate; (2) A focus on employee compensation and benefits; … Recommended changes to salary and benefits include (1) 4.11% compensation increase for all staff, meeting annual salary of Just Economics pledged living wage rate;
Councilwoman Roney noted that even though it says we are meeting the annual salary of the Just Economics pledge living wage rate, we are not. We are running parallel to the Just Economics pledge living wage rate of $19/hour but we are not eligible because we don’t pay our temporary staff or firefighters but there also no pledge involved and we’re not planning to get to $22.10.
Mayor Manheimer said that at our last couple of meetings, there were a lot of questions around different options to facilitate raises for staff … For example, what it looks like to do a 6% raise for all staff and not dip below our 15% threshold for our Fund Balance and what the implications would be, or a 6% for all first responders and 4.11% for all other City staff. … She stressed that City Council is not voting on the budget at this time and that they are only listening to the public.
Proclamation
PROCLAMATION PROCLAIMING JUNE 2024 AS “ASHEVILLE’S 12TH ANNUAL POLLINATION CELEBRATION! MONTH
Councilwoman Turner read the proclamation … She presented the proclamation to Virginia Currie,and others, who briefed City Council on some activities taking place during the month.
Presented by Virginia Currie.
Open public comment 8 topics, as the minutes list them
request to condemn all antisemitism speech
request to adopt a living wage policy to adjust City employee pay in order to keep on track with the local cost of living
resolution calling for a ceasefire in Gaza
opposition to the creation of a Business Improvement District
need to preserve the Malvern Hills Pool
need to protect the southside community farm from eviction
need to increase firefighter’s pay
request to have Candace Pickens Memorial Park become a City park in perpetuity
What staff answered afterwards 5 questions from council, answered in the city’s follow-up memo
Kim Roneymeeting, May 28, 2024 Capital Projects Update
Can the Patton Ave sidewalk project be delayed, and if not, what is the reason(s)?
Staff:Link to Patton Sidewalk Information
Answered by Capital Management and Greg Shuler/Public Works
Could FY Housing Trust Fund allocation be redirected to compensation needs?
Staff:On April 23, 2024, the City Council approved $4,813,948 from the Housing Trust Fund to support the development of five affordable housing projects. The April 23rd Council action fully exhausted the balance in the Housing Trust Fund (including all remaining 2016 Affordable Housing Bond funds) and obligated the $500,000 programmed in the City Manager's Recommended Fiscal Year 2024-2025 Operating Budget to support the Housing Trust Fund. During recent budget discussions, the City Council has discussed potentially using the FY 2024-2025 Housing Trust Fund allocation to support compensation needs. Given that the City Council has taken previous action approving the use of the FY2024-2025 Housing Trust Fund allocation to support affordable housing, it is not advisable to redirect those funds to support employee compensation expenses.
Answered by CED
Councilmeeting, May 28, 2024 Additional Staff Updates
Assessment of Compensation proposals for FY 25
Staff:Link to memo
Answered by Finan ce
Sage Turnermeeting, May 28, 2024 Additional Staff Updates
can council receive an update on hotel community benefits including a list of entitled projects that have elected to participate in community benefits; for entitled projects what benefits categories have been selected and how much money has been committed; what is the timing of benefit selection and estimated payment amounts; when does actual payment of a benefit occur; when is the review of the hotel overlay and community benefits coming back to Council for review and possible update?
Staff:Link to a memo from PUD
Answered by PUD
Esther E. Manheimermeeting, May 28, 2024 Additional Staff Updates
Request for 2023 Council Follow Up Report tracking requests for information
Staff:Link to 2023 Report
Answered by Clerk Office/CM O
Work session, Tuesday, May 28, 2024 the agenda briefing after this meeting · 11 am–12:55 pm
Staff briefed on
Quarterly Update on Capital Improvement Program
Fiscal Year 2025 Budget
This resource, to the best of its ability, is copied word for word from the official minutes, “…” marks words left out, and [brackets] a name the minutes give elsewhere. The minutes are the record. Staff answers are quoted from the city’s follow-up memos. Staff report details are quoted from the city’s meeting documents, prepared before the vote.