City Council regular meeting — June 9, 2020

Asheville City Council recorded 26 votes at its regular meeting on June 9, 2020; 1 drew at least one no vote. Most items fell under Zoning & Land Use, Budget & Finance and Community Programs.

Met: 5:15 pm–10:03 pm. Voting: Brian Haynes, Vijay Kapoor, Esther E. Manheimer, Julie Mayfield, Sheneika Smith, Gwen Wisler, Keith Young.

Votes 26 recorded · 6 substantive · 1 split

Item D · RES 20-100 · Transportation · Resolution · consent agenda

Contract amendment with Equinox Environmental Consultation & Design Inc. for the Swannanoa River Greenway - Phase II

Passed7–0 · Moved by Vijay Kapoor, seconded by Keith Young

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $454,811.2 supplemental increase
  • $612,449.3 the total amount of the contract
  • $45,481.12 10% contingency
  • $657,930.42 total required budget
  • Equinox Environmental Consultation and Design, Inc. contractor or recipient
  • General Obligation Bond Program as part of the Transportation and Infrastructure Program funding source
Description in the minutes

ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTATION & DESIGN iNC. FOR THE SWANNANOA RIVER GREENWAY

  • Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute an amendment to the existing greenway design contract between the City of Asheville and Equinox Environmental Consultation and Design, Inc. (Equinox, contract #91900109), in the amount of $454,811.20 increasing the total value of the contract to $612,449.30 and to enter into change orders to this contract not to exceed an additional 10% of the current contract amount or $45,481.12.

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute an amendment to the existing greenway design contract between the City of Asheville and Equinox Environmental Consultation and Design, Inc. (Equinox, contract #91900109), in the amount of $454,811.20 increasing the total value of the contract to $612,449.30 and to enter into change orders to this contract not to exceed an additional 10% of the current contract amount or $45,481.12.

Background:

  • The City of Asheville entered into a contract with Equinox in July 2018 for a feasibility analysis of potential greenway routes within the Swannanoa River area.
  • The September 2019 feasibility analysis determined that coordination with the North Carolina Department of Transportation (NCDOT) on NCDOT’s work within the area would result in the best value for the City’s project.
  • The scope of work for the contract amendment includes surveys, greenway design, geotechnical engineering, permitting, public engagement, and other tasks needed for greenway design.
  • During March and April 2020, Equinox assembled a design team and estimated that the design and construction document creation would cost $454,811.20.
  • The referenced segment of this greenway will connect new housing along Thompson St to recreation and shopping facilities.
  • This segment is part of a much larger Wilma Dykeman Riverway Corridor system. In total the Wilma Dykeman Riverway will provide nearly 10 miles of greenway. Between this segment and the segment in the RiverArts District nearly 3.5 miles of this greenway will be built by 2021
  • Additional phases are contingent upon future funding and coordination with the NCDOT.
  • The design to construction contract process is estimated to have an 18-month duration. Assuming a July 1, 2020 design phase start date, the construction contract advertisement is projected to start in December 2021.

Vendor Outreach Efforts:

  • Staff performed outreach through solicitation processes using the State’s Interactive Purchasing System and requesting prime contractors to reach out to Minority & Women-Owned Business Enterprise (MWBE) service providers for subcontracted services. No MWBE service providers are being used in the delivery of this contract. Equinox was unable to find local MWBE businesses for the services needed on this project, but is committed to using MWBE participation as needed and available for other services going forward.

Council Goal(s):

  • Transportation and accessibility.

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • Greenway construction would enhance multi-modal transportation within the area and provide alternatives to commuters
  • Contributes to increasing the City’s greenway inventory
  • Works towards defining Asheville as a recreation destination Con(s)
  • Eventual construction will be disruptive to the area.

Fiscal Impact:

  • With this supplemental increase of $454,811.20, the total amount of the contract is increased to $612,449.30. Adding in a 10% contingency of $45,481.12 to the supplemental increase brings the total required budget to $657,930.42. This contract is funded through the General Obligation Bond Program as part of the Transportation and Infrastructure Program.

Staff: Jade Dundas, Capital Projects Director.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item H · RES 20-104 · Economic Development · Resolution · consent agenda

Contract amendment with J. Brady Contracting Inc. for the Harrah's Cherokee Center renovation and HVAC project

Passed7–0 · Moved by Vijay Kapoor, seconded by Keith Young

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $166,360.77 contract amendment
  • $4,219,637.65 revised total maximum price
  • $1.5 million grant from the 2016 Tourism Product Development Fund
  • J. Brady Contracting, Inc. contractor or recipient
  • Funds from the HCCA General Maintenance project funding source
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to amend the contract with Brady Services, Inc. in the amount of $166,360.77, for a revised total maximum price amount of $4,219,637.65 to complete the Harrah’s Cherokee Center Asheville (HCCA) Facility Renovation & HVAC Modernization Project.

Background:

  • This amendment authorizes capital project funds required to close out the HVAC modernization phase of the project.
  • This three phase project installed 1) flexible theater seating in the arena, a sound and lighting package; 2) converted a storage room into a press/meeting room with additional supporting projects including the expansion of storage for the displaced room; and 3) modernized much of the building’s 1970’s era HVAC system.
  • The project was included in the City’s 2016-17 fiscal year capital improvements budget. The project is partially funded by a $1,500,000 grant from the 2016 Tourism Product Development Fund.
  • On August 28, 2018, City Council authorized a contract amendment to begin the Phase 2 facility renovation (press/meeting room renovation and storage expansion). This phase was completed in November 2018 ahead of the HVAC Modernization to meet a HCCA scheduling commitment.
  • On March 26, 2019, City Council authorized a contract amendment to begin the HVAC Modernization phase. This phase replaced critical parts of the building’s 40+ year old HVAC system. Where equipment could not be replaced due to budget constraints, it was upgraded with zone controls, monitoring, and other smart technology systems.
  • All new and upgraded equipment included in this project were integrated with the recently installed building automation system.
  • The City used the Construction Manager at Risk (CMAR) delivery method to contract with J. Brady Contracting, Inc. to complete the facility renovations and HVAC modernization. This delivery method was chosen because it allows a lead contractor to coordinate the efforts of many different trades over a large area and a broad scope.
  • The CMAR delivery method groups the work into smaller “bid packages”. The HVAC modernization project was grouped into six (6) separate bid packages and a total of 14 bids were received from first tier subcontractors across all bid packages.
  • The project is complete and this contract amendment reconciles all changes through the end of the project. Additionally this amendment will secure an extended service agreement for the new equipment.

Vendor Outreach Efforts:

  • Staff performed outreach to minority and women-owned business through solicitation processes which included posting on the State’s Interactive Purchasing System and required vendors to reach out to Minority & Women-Owned Business Enterprise (MWBE) service providers for subcontracted services. MWBE firms were involved in the completion of this work through the prime contractor.

Council Goal(s):

  • A Thriving Local Economy
  • A Clean and Healthy Environment

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • Improved the venue’s ability to host a wider range of events.
  • Reduced energy consumption with new efficient equipment or with upgrades to existing equipment with intelligent controls.
  • Capital investment provided reliable building infrastructure, reducing repair costs, and downtime associated with broken HVAC equipment.

Con(s):

  • Redirecting budget from other HCCA capital maintenance projects means that less funding is available in the short term for other deferred maintenance needs.

Fiscal Impact:

  • The amount of this contract amendment exceeds the available budget in the (HCCA) Facility Renovation & HVAC Modernization project. Funds from the HCCA General Maintenance project will be used to fund this contract amendment.

Staff: Jade Dundas, Capital Projects Department Director.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item M · ORD 4808 · Zoning & Land Use · Ordinance · consent agenda

Ordinance waiving construction (requirements)

Passed7–0 · Moved by Vijay Kapoor, seconded by Keith Young

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $6,000 Waived fees
  • 2 South Pack Square address
  • Asheville Art Museum applicant
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of an ordinance waiving construction permitting fees in relation to the Asheville Art Museum’s construction of a fire resistant Exit Passageway at 2 South Pack Square.

Background:

  • The City of Asheville owns real property located at 2 South Pack Square, the Asheville Art Museum (“AAM”), and at 18 Biltmore Avenue, The Wortham Performing Arts Center, (“Wortham”).
  • AAM is required to construct, as part of its renovation project, a fire resistant Exit Passageway through the arcade from Biltmore Avenue leading to Wortham.
  • The construction of the proposed Exit Passageway will promote the safe operation of the City’s facilities.
  • AAM has requested that the City waive the construction permitting fees that it would normally be required to pay in order to construct the Exit Passageway.
  • The basis for this fee waiver request is that the proposed project is intended to, in part, benefit a City-owned property.
  • Completion of this Exit Passageway is required in order for AAM and Wortham to gain certificates of occupancy. Council Goals:
  • Transportation and Accessibility
  • A Thriving Local Economy
  • A Financially Resilient City Committee:
  • None. Pros:
  • Will facilitate the safe operation of a City-owned facility. Con:
  • Limited loss of revenue to the City.

Fiscal Impact:

  • Waived fees are expected to total approximately $6,000.

Staff: Ben Woody, Development Services Director; Brad Branham, City Attorney.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item NB-A · RES 20-116 · Community Programs · Resolution

Joint resolution with Buncombe County to remove the Confederate monuments and establish a task force regarding the Vance Monument

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Keith Young

All members present voted yes.

21 spoke, 2 against · 2 council remarks

Public comment on this item

18 spoke in favor · 2 spoke against · 1 stance not recorded

Eighteen callers supported taking the Vance Monument and other Confederate monuments down. Two callers were opposed to taking down the Vance Monument and other Confederate monuments. One caller favored repurposing of the Vance Monument and supported removing the other Confederate monuments. The minutes give counts but do not name the speakers.

What council members said 2 remarks from 2 members

Keith Young Voted yes · seconded

  • Supports Councilman Young said that a few people mentioned context. … The argument that the Confederate flags or monuments or other displays represent heritage not hate, ignores the near universal heritage of African Americans enslaved by millions in the south. … Those statues and monuments were not erected during reconstruction or Jim Crow - they were erected sometime far after that to remind Black people that we still have power and we still have control and this is your place in our society.

Sheneika Smith Voted yes

  • Supports Councilwoman Smith said that this is not an insignificant action. We must start healing from racial trauma passed through our blood line. … The white supremacy legacy has been there and it’s time for us to confront it.

The minutes record no remarks on this item from Brian Haynes, Vijay Kapoor, Esther E. Manheimer, Julie Mayfield and Gwen Wisler.

Key facts

  • within three months of all appointments being made term

The City further requests that it receive from the United Daughters of the Confederacy its intent to remove the monument within 30 days, and that said removal is completed within 90 days. … Upon passage of this resolution and until such time as the monument is removed or repurposed, it shall be shrouded in order to reduce its impact on the community

From the staff report
City Code sections

N.C. Gen. Stat. § 100-2.1(c)

Description in the minutes

Mayor Manheimer read the resolution as follows: “WHEREAS, Monuments to Confederate soldiers and military leaders, which were installed in Asheville and many other communities in the South in the late 19th and early 20th Centuries by white Southerners seeking to preserve the Confederacy, are widely perceived as offensive and painful public reminders of the legacy of slavery and present realities of systemic racism in our country; and WHEREAS, A memorial monument honoring the 60th Regiment of North Carolina Confederate soldiers currently stands in front of the Buncombe County Courthouse, sitting on county-owned land; and WHEREAS, A memorial monument known as the “Robert E. Lee Dixie Highway,Colonel John Connally Marker” is located in Pack Square Park, sitting on city-owned land; and WHEREAS, Both of these monuments were paid for and erected by a private organization known as the United Daughters of the Confederacy, and ownership of these monuments have never passed to either the City or the County; and WHEREAS, A memorial monument known as the “The Vance Monument” is also located in Pack Square Park, the former site of the county courthouse which is the likely location where slaves were sold and traded locally; and WHEREAS, African-American residents of the City of Asheville and Buncombe County have issued a clear call to remove and/or repurpose these monuments as expeditiously as possible due to the harm they pose, and to replace them with monuments that honor local African-American history and are created by African-American artists; and WHEREAS, The Confederacy was formed by its political leaders for the express purpose of perpetuating and expanding slavery of African Americans; and WHEREAS, the City of Asheville and Buncombe County recognize that the legacy of slavery, institutional segregation and ongoing systemic racism directly harm public safety and public health; and WHEREAS, pursuant to N.C. Gen. Stat. § 100-2.1(c), the City and County are authorized to remove the two Confederate monuments from public property; and WHEREAS, The City of Asheville and Buncombe County are committed to promoting racial equity and justice, and desire to express this commitment through a joint resolution of their respective governing boards; and WHEREAS, The City of Asheville and Buncombe County desire to remove Confederate monuments from the public spaces within the City of Asheville; and WHEREAS, the City of Asheville and Buncombe County desire specifically to remove the monument to Confederate soldiers from the grounds near the County Courthouse and the Robert E. Lee monument from Pack Square Park; and WHEREAS, The City of Asheville and Buncombe County desire to explore options for removing, relocating, or making alterations to the Vance Monument; and WHEREAS, It is the intent of the governing boards of the City of Asheville and Buncombe County that these monuments be replaced or altered in such as manner as to honor the local history of African Americans; and WHEREAS, The City of Asheville and Buncombe County want to seek citizen input

  • and particularly to hear from those most impacted by the monuments
  • regarding the future of the Vance Monument by the establishment of a jointly appointed task force which will explore options including removal, relocation, and alteration of the monument; and WHEREAS, the City of Asheville and Buncombe County approve this resolution jointly at separate meetings of their governing boards; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ASHEVILLE AND THE BUNCOMBE COUNTY COMMISSION THAT: Request is hereby made to the United Daughters of the Confederacy to immediately remove the two Confederate monuments located at the Buncombe County Courthouse and Pack Square Park. The City further requests that it receive from the United Daughters of the Confederacy its intent to remove the monument within 30 days, and that said removal is completed within 90 days. If the intent to remove is not received or the removal is not completed within the specified timeframes from the date of full adoption of this resolution, then the City of Asheville and Buncombe County shall take action to remove the monuments; and a jointly appointed task force shall be established by the Asheville City Council and the Buncombe County Commission, consisting of not more than 12 members whose appointments will be made in equal numbers by the two governing boards. This task force shall, within three months of all appointments being made, provide a report to the City Council and the County Commission with a recommendation regarding the removal and/or repurposing of the Vance Monument. Once the report is presented, the task force shall perform such other duties as requested by the governing bodies. When no further action is requested, the task force shall dissolve. Upon passage of this resolution and until such time as the monument is removed or repurposed, it shall be shrouded in order to reduce its impact on the community and to reduce the risk of harm it presents in its current state.” Eighteen callers supported taking the Vance Monument and other Confederate monuments down. Two callers were opposed to taking down the Vance Monument and other Confederate monuments. One caller favored repurposing of the Vance Monument and supported removing the other Confederate monuments. Councilman Young said that a few people mentioned context. From a personal standpoint, his family has a long history in the City of Asheville. He spoke with his grandfather (who was born approximately 50 years at the end of the Civil War) about his experiences in life and his experiences of his great grandfather who was born in 1888, in the middle of Jim Crow. Some people feel that removing a flag or monument, etc. is erasing history. In fact, for example, across this country, but mostly in the south, say confederate flag supporters had more than 350 rallies in the 6 months after the Charleston attack. In Charlottesville, Virginia, Council voted to remove statues of Robert E. Lee and Stonewall Jackson and that sparked several demonstrations, including deadly protests in August of 2017. The argument that the Confederate flags or monuments or other displays represent heritage not hate, ignores the near universal heritage of African Americans enslaved by millions in the south. It trivializes their pain, their history and their concern about racism, whether it’s the racism of the past or the racism of today. And it conceals the true history of the Confederate states of America and seven decades of Jim Crow segregation and oppression that followed the reconstruction era. And there is no doubt that if you ask any historian that Confederacy was established upon the premise of white supremacy and that the south fought the Civil War to preserve it’s slave labor. It’s founding documents and its leaders were very clear in what their intentions were
  • our new government is founded upon the great truth that the Negro is not equal to the whtie man. Those statues and monuments were not erected during reconstruction or Jim Crow
  • they were erected sometime far after that to remind Black people that we still have power and we still have control and this is your place in our society. I don’t want to be a part of that and if anyone else wants to be a part of that, you show your true colors. Councilwoman Smith said that this is not an insignificant action. We must start healing from racial trauma passed through our blood line. This is equally powerful as well as ceremonial. The white supremacy legacy has been there and it’s time for us to confront it. She was glad to be a part of this history, but hated the opportunity came at the death of George Floyd.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item PR-A · RES 20-114 · Zoning & Land Use · Resolution

Resolution granting a land use incentive grant for 2 Restaurant Court Rental Community, Beaucatcher Vista LLC

Passed7–0 · Moved by Vijay Kapoor, seconded by Gwen Wisler

All members present voted yes.

1 council remark

Public hearing continued from May 26, 2020

No one from the public spoke.

this public hearing was held on May 26, 2020 … written comments for this public hearing were accepted for an additional 24 hours. The minutes don’t give enough detail to count everyone.

What council members said 1 remark from 1 member

Julie Mayfield Voted yes

  • Supports Councilwoman Mayfield said that neighbors had complained about trash issues. She said that the developer, Kirk Booth, has installed a trash dumpster so there will no longer be overflowing trash bins at the 444 Beaucatcher Road development.

The minutes record no remarks on this item from Brian Haynes, Vijay Kapoor, Esther E. Manheimer, Sheneika Smith, Gwen Wisler and Keith Young.

Key facts

  • 444 Beaucatcher Road address
  • Beaucatcher Vista LLC applicant
From the staff report

Approve the application for the Land Use Incentive Grant for 2 Restaurant Court Rental Community, Beaucatcher Vista LLC.

  • The developer has requested a Land Use Incentive Grant (LUIG) award asked for this item
  • $289,481.85 estimated at $289,481.85
  • $1 million a loan of $1,000,000 from the City’s Housing Trust Fund
  • $13,784.85 would result in an annual grant award of $13,784.85
  • $1,289,481.85 The combined City subsidy should both awards be approved is $1,289,481.85
  • 1.31 acres 2 Restaurant Court
  • $786,000 assessed value
  • Kirk Booth d/b/a as Beaucatcher Vista LLC applicant
  • 9658-08-2350 parcel ID (PIN)
Fiscal impact

The estimated tax value upon completion is $4.0M, which at current rates would result in a City tax bill of $17,156. The difference in tax payment is $13,784.85. An equivalent amount would be granted back annually to the property owner for 21 years.

Staff’s stated reasons
  • The property’s location and commitment to affordable housing merits a score of 150 on the LUIG scoring matrix, resulting in an award period of 21 years.
  • The proposed project will create 40 affordable rental housing units made available to households earning 80% or less of AMI for a period of 20 years.
  • The proposed project addresses the City’s stated priority for one-bedroom apartments.
City Code sections

N.C. Gen. Stat. § 158-7.1, N.C. Gen. Stat. § 160A-456

Staff: Paul D'Angelo, CD Program Director; Andrew Mayronne, CD Analyst.

Description in the minutes

Mayor Manheimer said that this public hearing was held on May 26, 2020, and in accordance with recent legislation amending North Carolina G.S. § 166A-19.24(e), regarding public hearings conducted during remote meetings, written comments for this public hearing were accepted for an additional 24 hours. After reviewing the written public comments made 24 hours after the public hearing, Mayor Manheimer closed the public hearing at 7:10 p.m. and said that members of Council have previously received a copy of the resolution and it would not be read. Councilwoman Mayfield said that neighbors had complained about trash issues. She said that the developer, Kirk Booth, has installed a trash dumpster so there will no longer be overflowing trash bins at the 444 Beaucatcher Road development.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item PR-B · RES 20-115 · Zoning & Land Use · Resolution

Resolution granting a land use incentive grant for Tribute Development Collier Avenue Apartments

Passed6–1 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Vijay Kapoor

No: Brian Haynes  ·  Yes: Vijay Kapoor, Esther E. Manheimer, Julie Mayfield, Sheneika Smith, Gwen Wisler, Keith Young

Public hearing continued from May 26, 2020

No one from the public spoke.

this public hearing was held on May 26, 2020 … written comments for this public hearing were accepted for an additional 24 hours. The minutes don’t give enough detail to count everyone.

Key facts

  • Tribute Development Collier Avenue Apartments applicant
From the staff report

Approve the application for the Land Use Incentive Grant application for Tribute Companies Collier Development.

  • Tribute Company has applied for a Land Use Incentive Grant (LUIG) for their development at 11 Collier Avenue asked for this item
  • $383,292 the city will grant back a total of $383,292 over the 21 years of the LUIG
  • $18,251 The difference is $18,251 which would be granted to the property owner annually
  • $6.5 million The developer estimates a total development cost of $6.5M
  • $521,000 assessed value
  • Tribute Company applicant
  • 9648-38-5770 parcel ID (PIN)
Fiscal impact

Under the estimated tax value of $4,776,599 post-completion, the annual city property tax will be approximately $20,487. The difference is $18,251 which would be granted to the property owner annually after payment for 21 years.

Staff’s stated reasons
  • Staff has scored the project with 160 points, which qualifies the project for twenty-one years (21) of Land Use Incentive Grant.
  • The proposed project will provide 54 affordable rental housing units to households earning 80% or less of area median income
  • The proposed project will have an affordability period of twenty (20) years
Before it reached Council
  • Housing & Community Development Committee, February 11, 2020: approve — Housing & Community Development Committee - February 11, 2020 - approved
  • Finance & HR Committee, February 25, 2020: approve — Finance & HR Committee - February 25, 2020 - approved
City Code sections

N.C. Gen. Stat. § 158-7.1

Staff: Paul D'Angelo, CD Program Director; Sam Powers, CED Director.

Description in the minutes

Mayor Manheimer said that this public hearing was held on May 26, 2020, and in accordance with recent legislation amending North Carolina G.S. § 166A-19.24(e), regarding public hearings conducted during remote meetings, written comments for this public hearing were accepted for an additional 24 hours. Hearing no more public comment, Mayor Manheimer closed the public hearing at 7:13 p.m. and said that members of Council have previously received a copy of the resolution and it would not be read.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Show the other 20 votes · consent agenda and routine items · consent agenda moved by Vijay Kapoor, seconded by Keith Young

Item B · RES 20-97 · Public Safety · Resolution · consent agenda

Resolution accepting the annual flood (mitigation/grant)

Passed7–0 · Moved by Vijay Kapoor, seconded by Keith Young

All members present voted yes.

Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution accepting the annual Flood Mitigation Actions report and supporting the re-certification as a member of the Community Rating System Program.

Background:

  • The City of Asheville joined the Community Rating System (CRS) program, a program through the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), and administered by the Insurance Services Office (ISO) in 2014. As required by the CRS program, a Repetitive Loss Area Analysis (RLAA) was prepared in 2014 by Brown and Caldwell to supplement the Buncombe-Madison Regional All Hazards Mitigation Plan.
  • CRS provides lower insurance premiums under the National Flood Insurance Program. The premium reduction is in the form of a CRS Class. The classes are obtained by actions that are above and beyond the requirements of the National Flood Insurance Program administered by FEMA.
  • Currently, property owners in Asheville receive a 10 percent reduction in their flood insurance premiums through participation in the CRS program.
  • In order to maintain the current status in the CRS program, staff is required to provide to council the annual report of the Flood Mitigation Actions Items that were part of the RLAA report from Brown and Caldwell adopted by Council on December 10, 2013.
  • Highlighted in the report, staff from multiple departments continue to work together, looking for ways to reduce flooding and damage from floods.
  • We do this through community outreach from the City website, social media, flyers, and events, working with the Army Corps of Engineers and other partners on flood mitigation opportunities, and working with developers and property owners on ways to protect their properties from flooding.

Vendor Outreach Efforts:

  • Not Applicable.

Council Goal(s):

  • A Clean and Healthy Environment
  • Thriving Local Economy

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • The property owners in Asheville will continue to receive a 10% reduction on their flood insurance.
  • Provides a higher level of protection through the current flood ordinance, improving resilience.
  • Promotes public education of the Special Flood Hazard Areas.

Con(s):

  • None

Fiscal Impact:

  • There is no additional fiscal impact to continuing the efforts necessary for the CRS program, staff time is currently programmed into the annual operating budget.

Staff: Ben Woody, Director, Development Services Dept.; Nancy Watford, Site Engineering Coordinator and Floodplain Administration, Development Services Dept..

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item C · RES 20-98 / RES 20-99 · Administrative · Resolution · consent agenda

Resolution authorizing the City Manager to acquire property along Federal Alley from the State of North Carolina to facilitate improvements in Federal Alley

Passed7–0 · Moved by Vijay Kapoor, seconded by Keith Young

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $49,225 The value of the area in question has been determined by appraisal
  • Federal Alley address
  • State of North Carolina contractor or recipient
  • funds from Tribute Investment & Development as reimbursement for the purchase price funding source
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Authorize the City Manager to acquire property from the State of North Carolina to facilitate improvements in Federal Alley that will make the area more pedestrian friendly and to facilitate ingress and egress from a new mixed use development and; to accept funds from Tribute Investment & Development as reimbursement for the purchase price.

Background:

  • Tribute Development wants to improve an existing unopened City right-of-way, known as Federal Alley, with sidewalks and vehicle access to benefit the future mixed use development at Asheland and Coxe. The City’s Planning Department supports these right-of-way improvements since they will benefit public infrastructure and provide much needed cross-connections between Asheland and Coxe.
  • However, the existing Federal Alley is narrow, and to accommodate the sidewalk, additional property (718.2 square feet of real property) was needed from the adjacent property owner
  • the State of NC (specifically, the area is used by NC State Minerals Lab). The State prefers to sell the property to the City of Asheville rather than the developer.
  • Although the developer will construct the improvements, the improved alley will be owned and maintained by the City of Asheville’s Streets Department.
  • The value of the area in question has been determined by appraisal to be $49,225. The State has agreed to sell the property to the City of Asheville for that amount.
  • Tribute has agreed to reimburse the City the purchase price and they will construct the improvements outlined above.
  • The Board of Trustees acting on behalf of NCSU has authorized the State of NC to sell this property to the City of Asheville.
  • The Council of State will vote on the sale this summer. They have accepted the City’s initial Offer Letter containing these terms.

Council Goal(s):

  • A More Livable Community

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • Supports the development of projects that increase pedestrian safety and accessibility in the downtown area of Asheville.
  • City will acquire property and be reimbursed by Tribute for the cost of the purchase.

Con(s):

  • None

Fiscal Impact:

  • As noted earlier in the staff report, the City will be reimbursed for its purchase of the property. Since the transaction will not take place until next fiscal year, the budget for the purchase and the reimbursement will be included in the Fiscal Year 2020-21 Budget Ordinance that Council is scheduled to approve on June 23, 2020. Suggested Motion:
  • Move to adopt a (1) resolution to authorize the City Manager to acquire property along Federal Alley from the State of NC and (2) resolution to accept funds from Tribute to cover those costs. RESOLUTION NO. 20-98
  • RESOLUTION BOOK NO. 41
  • PAGE 344 RESOLUTION NO. 20-99
  • RESOLUTION BOOK NO. 41
  • PAGE 345

Staff: Nikki Reid, Economic Development Program Director; Jessica Bernstein, Planning & Development.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item E · RES 20-101 · Transportation · Resolution · consent agenda

Resolution of support for the Federal Transit Administration Public Transportation Agency Safety Plan

Passed7–0 · Moved by Vijay Kapoor, seconded by Keith Young

All members present voted yes.

Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adopt a resolution of support for the Federal Transit Administration Public Transportation Agency Safety Plan.

Background:

  • On July 19, 2019, the Federal Transit Administration (FTA) Final Rule for the Public Transportation Agency Safety Plan (PTASP) became effective, which requires public transportation operators to develop processes and procedures to implement the safety plans.
  • The PTASP ensures that the City of Asheville develops performance targets as part of its Plan as required by the FTA in the National Public Transportation Safety Plan (NSP).
  • The PTASP ensures the City of Asheville develops criteria as part of its plan to address applicable federal requirements and standards set forth by the FTA, and to include a timeline for conducting an annual review to update the City’s PTASP.

Council Goal(s):

  • Transportation and Accessibility

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • The PTASP will be managed by staff in the Transit Planning Division in the Transportation Department and coordinated with the City’s Transit Management Company, RATPDev Inc.
  • The PTASP requires working with the French Broad River Metropolitan Planning Organization.

Con(s):

  • None

Fiscal Impact:

  • N/A

Staff: Ken Putnam, Transportation Department Director; Jessica Morriss, Assistant Transportation Department Director; Eunice Lovi, Transit Planning Manager.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item F · RES 20-102 · Public Safety · Resolution · consent agenda

Agreement extension with the N.C. Dept. of Public Safety for the State Regional Hazardous Materials Response Team Number 6

Passed7–0 · Moved by Vijay Kapoor, seconded by Keith Young

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $69,000 administration, equipment, training, medical surveillance, and workman’s compensation
  • $1.5 million truck and equipment provided to the City by the State for use on State and local hazmat missions
  • N.C. Dept. of Public Safety contractor or recipient
  • State of North Carolina funding source
  • July 1, 2020 through October 31, 2020 term
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of 2020 Contract Extension Agreement for the State Regional Hazardous Materials Response Team Number Six (6) Background

Council Goal(s):

  • Smart City

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • The State of North Carolina provides the hazardous materials response truck, all response equipment and provides for administrative costs of operating the team. In addition, the state funds extensive training for members of the Asheville Fire Department to enable us to competently handle hazardous materials emergencies.
  • The City of Asheville has full use of the truck and all specialty equipment within the City of Asheville. Without the state hazardous materials contract, Asheville taxpayers would need to provide much of the resources necessary to properly respond to Hazardous Materials emergencies within Asheville.
  • With the contract, we have the advantage of the equipment and resources being funded at the state level, rather than at the local level.
  • During the twenty nine years that we have provided regional hazardous materials response services, we have not experienced difficulties or disadvantages with the program. This program is also consistent with the City’s Strategic Operating Plan.
  • Firefighter and citizen safety will be enhanced.

Con(s):

  • None identified

Fiscal Impact:

  • There are no fiscal impacts that have been identified

Staff: Scott Burnette, Chief; Abby Moore.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item G · RES 20-103 · Public Safety · Resolution · consent agenda

Resolution authorizing the City Manager to amend the terms of the 2019 agreement with Advent Health to provide annual physicals examinations for firefighters

Passed7–0 · Moved by Vijay Kapoor, seconded by Keith Young

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $117,300 total cost of the contract
  • $40,175 additional six months of firefighter physicals
  • $77,125 new agreement for FY20
  • Advent Health contractor or recipient
  • adopted FY 2019 - 2020 budget funding source
  • January 1, 2020 to December 31, 2020 term
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to amend the terms of the 2019 agreement with Advent Health to provide annual physical examinations for firefighters in 2019 in the amount of $117,300.

Background:

  • The current Fiscal Year (FY) 2019 agreement with Advent Health allocates $89,125 and allows firefighters to receive required annual physical examinations in accordance with standards set forth by the National Fire Protection Association.
  • The original term of the FY2019 contract was July 1, 2018 to June 30, 2019.
  • The Asheville Fire Department (AFD) and Advent agreed to amend the original agreement to extend the term of the contract to December 31, 2019, but no funds were added to the contract.
  • Due to the way in which Advent processes patients, bills those patients, and invoices those patients, there were some discrepancies with invoicing and billing for firefighter physicals.
  • During the six month extension period, AFD and Advent were working out the correct number of employees and the services they received during this time to ensure the correct amount of funds were available and added to the agreement at the expiration of the extension.
  • Furthermore, the original term of the agreement date ending alongside the end of the fiscal year caused logistical difficulties in contract renewal and service conducted--waiting for the new fiscal year’s funding to renew the agreement and/or enter a new agreement with Advent Health meant ceasing firefighter physicals for the duration it took to get the amendment executed.
  • The Asheville Fire Department and Advent Health did not want to have this break in service because of the extremely difficult nature of conducting 275 physicals in a 52 week period (and alternatively 413 physicals in a 76 week period).
  • All firefighter physicals conducted between July 1, 2018 and December 31, 2019 were assigned to the FY19 contract and Advent has correctly and appropriately invoiced the City for the remaining physicals conducted from July 1, 2019 to December 31, 2019.
  • The agreement needs to include an additional six months of firefighter physicals at the cost of $40,175. This brings the total cost of the contract to $117,300, which pushes the contract above the $90,000 threshold.
  • The Asheville Fire Department and Advent Health have entered into a new agreement for FY20 with a changed scope of service for firefighter physicals. The new agreement term is for January 1, 2020 to December 31, 2020 in the amount of $77,125.
  • This new agreement term no longer aligns with the end of the fiscal year and remediates the logistical difficulties the Department was having with agreement execution versus physicals conducted.

Vendor Outreach Efforts:

  • Prior to entering the original contract with Advent Health, similar organizations were solicited to provide estimates of their services. SiteMed, which held the contract previously, did not provide the organizational efficiency needed to examine 275 firefighters throughout the course of the year. The costs of Mission Hospital’s services were prohibitive. Thus, the services and costs of Advent Health best fit the mission of Asheville Fire Department’s desire to provide its firefighters with the best care to meet and exceed health standards while controlling costs. A review of the costs, operational efficiencies, and satisfaction of the firefighters with the services, factored into making the determination to renew the agreement with Advent Health.
  • No MWBE firms were identified for this contract.

Council Goal(s):

  • Smart City

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • Meets best practices for the industry by complying with consensus standards of NFPA 1582 that will reduce risks and provide for the health, safety, and effectiveness of firefighters
  • Allows for the continued medical monitoring and testing of firefighters to ensure they are fit for the challenges of emergency response

Con(s):

  • None

Fiscal Impact:

  • Funding for the physicals is included in the adopted FY 2019 – 2020 budget, thus there are no additional impacts.

Staff: Scott Burnette, Fire Chief; Abigail Riley, Fire Finance Analyst.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item I · RES 20-105 · Economic Development · Resolution · consent agenda

Amended contract with Walter P. Moore & Associates for the Harrah's Center parking garage stairwell replacement

Passed7–0 · Moved by Vijay Kapoor, seconded by Keith Young

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $92,280 new total contract
  • $6,480 this amendment will increase the contract
  • $85,800 current contract
  • Walter P. Moore & Associates contractor or recipient
  • Parking Services Fund capital projects budget funding source
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to amend the Harrah’s Cherokee Center
  • Asheville Garage Repairs project management contract with Walter P. Moore & Associates (# 91700048) increasing the total value of the contract to $92,280.

Background:

  • The City of Asheville entered into a contract with Walter P. Moore & Associates in June 2016 for a condition assessment and project management of various repairs to the Harrah’s Cherokee Center
  • Asheville parking garage.
  • The repairs included a significant rehabilitation of the center stairwell within the garage.
  • The scope of work was developed from a comprehensive garage condition assessment that was completed during October 2016.
  • During February 2020, a detailed structural analysis of the center stairwell indicated a significant deterioration in the overall condition of the center stairwell and it was recommended to totally replace it.
  • During May 2020, Walter P. Moore and Associates estimated that in order to provide project management services for the replacement of the center stairwell, an additional $5,400 would be required.
  • The current contract is $85,800 and this amendment will increase the contract by $6,480 (including contingency funds in the amount of $1,080) for a new total contract of $92,280. Contingency funds are included to ensure satisfactory completion of the work by late summer 2020.

Vendor Outreach Efforts:

  • N/A
  • This is a current contract.

Council Goal(s):

  • Transportation and Accessibility.

Committee(s):

  • None.

Pro(s):

  • Enables the City to continue to provide safe and functional access within the parking garage.
  • Part of an overall plan to extend the service life of the parking garage.

Con(s):

  • The center stairwell is closed until the replacement work is completed.

Fiscal Impact:

  • The required funds are included in the current Parking Services Fund capital projects budget.

Staff: Ken Putnam, Transportation Department Director; Garrett Male, Parking Services Division Manager.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item J · RES 20-106 / ORD 4807 · Transportation · Resolution · consent agenda

Application for Fiscal Year 2020 CARES Act Section 5307 transit funds and subrecipient agreement; and budget amendment

Passed7–0 · Moved by Vijay Kapoor, seconded by Keith Young

All members present voted yes.

4 spoke

Recommendations

Council’s vote matched the city staff recommendation.

  • City staff (staff report): Approve — Transportation Department staff is recommending approving the CARES Act Subrecipient and Suballocation Agreement to be executed between the City of Asheville and subrecipients

Public comment on this item

0 spoke in favor · 0 spoke against · 4 stance not recorded

Four voicemail comments were received to urge the city to use the full amount of the Community Development block grant funds for a rental assistance program. The minutes give counts but do not name the speakers.

Key facts

  • $4,936,900 FY 2020 Transit Multi-Year Fund (6510) budget
  • $8,605,369 Asheville Urbanized Area (AUZA)
  • $1,462,000 CARES Act funding for City of Asheville uses
  • Federal Transit Administration contractor or recipient
  • CARES Act provides 100% of the funding with no local match required funding source
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adopt a resolution authorizing the City Manager to apply for the FY 2020 CARES Act (Section 5307) grant funds and to sign all appropriate agreements with the Federal Transit Administration (FTA), Federal and State agencies, execute subrecipient agreements; and amend the FY 2020 Transit Multi-Year Fund (6510) budget by $4,936,900 to include that portion of the CARES Act revenue which will be passed on to the subrecipients.

Background:

  • In March 2020, the Federal Transit Administration (FTA) published a Notice of Funding Availability for the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act, which is intended to provide additional supplemental funding to transit systems to prevent, prepare for, and respond to COVID-19.
  • On April 9, 2020, the FTA announced availability of $25 billion apportioned to the transit industry under the CARES Act, including $8.6 million for the Asheville Urbanized Area (AUZA). The FTA announced that the CARES Act funds will be used for transit operating and capital expenses and all other expenses incurred on or after January 20, 2020 in response to economic or other conditions caused by COVID-19.
  • At its April 28, 2020 special meeting, the French Broad River Metropolitan Planning Organization (FBRMPO) Board approved and adopted a resolution allocating the CARES Act funding to eligible AUZA transit systems. The chart on page 2 outlines the amount allocated to each transit system in the AZUA region.
  • CARES Act funds will provide 100% of the Federal match of the anticipated funding and does not require any local match.
  • Transportation Department staff is working with all subrecipients on how they will use the funds allocated to them and will submit an application to the FTA in the amount of $8.6 million by June 30, 2020 for approval.
  • Transportation Department staff is recommending approving the CARES Act Subrecipient and Suballocation Agreement to be executed between the City of Asheville and subrecipients and approve Haywood County to become a formal subrecipient of the City of Asheville, instead of the non-profit transportation contractor.
  • On May 1, 2020, the Transportation Department staff submitted the required Federal Split Letter to the FTA Region VI Office outlining the FBRMPO-approved allocation of CARES Act funds.
  • The budget amendment will provide expenditure authorization for the $4.9 million in grant funds which will be passed on to the subrecipients. FBRMPO ALLOCATED FY2020 CARES ACT (SECTION 5307) FUNDS PROPOSED DISTRIBUTION/ PERCENT ESTIMATED DISTRIBUTION/AMOUNT CIty of Asheville 42.63% $3,668,469 Buncombe County 28.62% $2,462,856 Henderson County 20.41% $1,756,356 Haywood County 8.34% $717,688 SUB-RECIPIENTS TOTAL $4,936,900 ALLOCATED TOTAL $8,605,369

Council Goal(s):

  • Transportation and Accessibility

Committee(s):

  • N/A

Pro(s):

  • CARES Act funds will enable the City of Asheville to use federal funds to help offset operational and capital expenses incurred on or after January 20, 2020 in response to economic or other conditions caused by COVID-19.

Con(s):

  • N/A

Fiscal Impact:

  • The CARES Act provides 100% of the funding with no local match required. As noted above, the budget amendment included with this staff report will appropriate the funding that will be passed on to the subrecipients. Council has already taken action at prior meetings to budget $1,462,000 in CARES Act funding for City of Asheville uses, including purchasing protective barriers for buses and contracting for supplemental operations support. The City will continue to utilize CARES Act funding to help offset operational and capital expenses associated with the COVID-19 response, and bring forward additional budget amendments as needed.

Staff: Ken Putnam, Transportation Department Director; Jessica Morriss, Assistant Transportation Department Director; Eunice Lovi, Transit Planning Manager.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item K · RES 20-107 · Transportation · Resolution · consent agenda

Sole source purchase of safety barriers from Gillig Aftermarket Parts for 18 Asheville Rides Transit buses

Passed7–0 · Moved by Vijay Kapoor, seconded by Keith Young

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $160,000 purchase order
  • Gillig Aftermarket Parts contractor or recipient
  • CARES Act funding to purchase and install the safety protection barriers funding source
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to purchase safety protection barriers using sole source procurement from Gillig Aftermarket Parts for installation in existing eighteen (18) Gillig transit buses in Asheville Rides Transit (ART) fleet.

Background:

  • On May 12, 2020, the City Council adopted a Resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a purchase order of approximately $160,000 to work with Gillig to engineer, design, retrofit, and install safety protection barriers from AROW Global Corporation, the manufacturer of the safety protection barriers, in eighteen (18) existing 30-foot diesel and diesel electric hybrid buses.
  • A sole source procurement through Gillig Aftermarket Parts is necessary to ensure that the safety barriers are designed and installed correctly to fit the various Gillig bus models that the City of Asheville owns. AROW Global corporation is Gillig’s approved provider of the safety protection barriers.
  • CARES Act funds will be used to purchase and install safety protection barriers in the existing eighteen (18) Gillig buses.
  • The use of sole-source procurement is permitted in this instance pursuant to N.C.G.S. 143-129(e)(g)(iii) as equipment compatibility is an overriding concern.

Council Goal(s):

  • Transportation and Accessibility

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • Provides protection for transit bus drivers
  • Use CARES Act funding to purchase and install the safety protection barriers in the Gillig buses
  • No local match is required

Con(s):

  • None

Fiscal Impact:

  • As noted above, the CARES Act provides 100% of the funding with no local match required. The budget for this purchase was adopted at City Council’s May 12, 2020 meeting.

Staff: Ken Putnam, Transportation Department Director; Jessica Morriss, Assistant Transportation Department Director; Eunice Lovi, Transit Planning Manager.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item L · RES 20-108 · Zoning & Land Use · Resolution · consent agenda

Resolution accepting an offer for (property/purchase)

Passed7–0 · Moved by Vijay Kapoor, seconded by Keith Young

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $753 air rights
  • 26 Battery Park address
  • Collaborative Partnership Properties applicant
  • unbudgeted compensation for the air rights funding source
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution accepting an offer for sale of air rights over Wall Street; directing the City Clerk to advertise for upset bids; and if no bids are received or accepted, authorizing the City Manager to grant air rights to Collaborative Partnership Properties who want to construct a balcony over the sidewalk along Wall Street.

Background:

  • The City was approached by a local architect concerning air rights over the sidewalk along Wall Street for a unit within a building located at 26 Battery Park.
  • Initial concerns were raised by Streets and Downtown Planning regarding the well-being of street trees on Wall Street.
  • The architect met with the City’s Arborist who requested that the balcony be shortened in length to reduce the impact on the trees. The owners agreed to a design revision and they agreed that their contractor would again meet with the Arborist to discuss protecting the trees during construction.
  • It was determined that the balcony for the office space unit would be 21 feet long and 5 feet wide for a total request of 105 square feet of air rights that would be needed to accommodate the balcony.
  • The construction of the balcony, along with the air rights easement, will not substantially impair or hinder the use of the right of way as a passage.
  • The value of the air rights was determined by consulting two recent appraisals of land value in the surrounding area. The value was determined to be $753 and the owners have agreed to pay that amount.
  • A public notice will be placed in the newspaper after the City Council has approved the air rights and a sale will not occur until 10 days after the notice has been published.

Council Goal(s):

  • A Well Planned and Livable Community

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • City is receiving compensation for the air rights being granted.

Con(s):

  • There will be temporary disruption during construction.

Fiscal Impact:

  • City is receiving unbudgeted compensation for the air rights in the amount of $753.

Staff: Greg Shuler, Public Works Director; Sam Powers, Community and Economic Development Director; Chad Bandy, Streets Dept.; Mark Foster, City Arborist; Nikki Reed, Economic Development Program Director.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item N · RES 20-109 · Community Programs · Resolution · consent agenda

Contract with Ashewell Medical Group for COVID-19 antibody and PCR testing for City employees

Passed7–0 · Moved by Vijay Kapoor, seconded by Keith Young

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $148,750 COVID-19 testing
  • $175 per employee
  • Ashewell Medical Group contractor or recipient
  • Fiscal Year 2019-20 Health Fund budget funding source
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to enter into an agreement with Ashewell Medical Group for up to $148,750 for COVID-19 testing.

Background:

  • The agreement allows for up to 850 city employees to be tested for COVID-19 and its antibodies at $175 per employee and a total of $148,750.
  • Ashewell Medical Group will provide FDA-approved antibody and PCR testing of COVID-19 for employees who have been working in the community since March 2020.

Vendor Outreach Efforts:

  • Three local vendors provided quotes for testing
  • Ashewell Medical Group is a woman-owned business.

Council Goal(s):

  • Clean and Healthy Environment

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • Testing will provide information for employees, their families, and leadership about the impacts working in the pandemic has had so far.
  • Testing will provide reassurance to employees and the community as workgroups are reassembled.
  • Enhanced PPE and procedures developed based on outcomes
  • Understanding what level of potential immunity we have in our employee community

Con(s):

  • None

Fiscal Impact:

  • Funding for this agreement will come from the existing Fiscal Year 2019-20 Health Fund budget. There will be an opportunity for the City to be reimbursed for these expenses from FEMA.

Staff: Scott Burnette, Fire Chief; Abigail Riley, Fire Finance Analyst.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item O · RES 20-110 · Budget & Finance · Resolution · consent agenda

Resolution authorizing the City Manager to temporarily suspend or defer rent and loan payments to the City on a case-by-case basis, as necessary

Passed7–0 · Moved by Vijay Kapoor, seconded by Keith Young

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $8,500 rental payments
  • $18,900 capital contributions
Description in the minutes

TO ADDRESS HARMS CAUSED BY THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC AND TO RATIFY ANY ADMINISTRATIVE DECISION ALREADY ENACTED TO DEFER LOAN PAYMENTS OR TO SUSPEND COLLECTION OF RENTS

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to temporarily suspend/waive or defer rental (including capital contributions to leased property) and loan payments to the City on a case-by-case basis, as necessary to address harms caused by the COVID-19 pandemic.

Background:

  • On May 12, 2020, the City Council adopted an ordinance authorizing the City Manager to temporarily suspend fees and charges listed in the FY 2019-20 Fees and Charges Manual. At the time of adoption, the temporary suspension or deferral of rental or loan payments to the City on a case-by-case basis was also contemplated as discussed in the May Staff Report. However, that action was inadvertently left out of the adopted ordinance. Adoption of this resolution will correct that omission.
  • The City has rental (including capital contributions to leased property) and loan payment schedules with other parties.
  • Many Asheville businesses are either closed or operating in a limited capacity due to the COVID-19 pandemic creating substantial economic challenges for owners, employees, and customers.
  • Some businesses have requested temporary relief from loan payments, rent payments, and capital contributions in an effort to help reduce their expenses.
  • Categories and Criteria for suspending or deferring rent payments or loan payments.
  • This action is intended to aid businesses during the formal declaration of emergency. When that declaration expires, any further deferral or waiver would be considered case-by-case by the City Manager. Council Goals:
  • A Thriving Local Economy
  • A Financially Resilient City Committee:
  • None Pros:
  • Facilitates business operations that are able to continue normally during the COVID-19 pandemic.
  • Reduces operating costs for businesses during the COVID-19 pandemic.
  • City Manager authority to temporarily suspend or defer rent or loan payments and capital contributions provides heightened responsiveness to community needs during the COVID-19 pandemic. Con:
  • Loss or deferment of revenue to the City.

Fiscal Impact:

  • Loan payments deferred (discussed below) have no impact on operations and no long-term financial impact as the amounts will be repaid as part of the final payment on notes outstanding.
  • Rent or capital contribution payments to the City temporarily waived or suspended could result in a loss of revenue to the City of approximately $4,000 to $8,500 for rental payments and up to $18,900 in capital contributions (assuming three to six months of waiver), depending on how many Lessee’s request relief and for how long. To date, the City has only received one request to waive rent and one request for waiver of capital contribution.

Staff: Sam Powers, Economic Development Director; Barbara Whitehorn, CFO Finance Department Director.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item P · RES 20-111 / RES 20-112 · Administrative · Resolution · consent agenda

Resolutions ratifying the City Manager's actions

Passed7–0 · Moved by Vijay Kapoor, seconded by Keith Young

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $183,024 Red Roof Inn for up to two additional 30 day periods
  • $100,000 Homeward Bound for up to two additional 30 day periods
  • Red Roof Inn, Inc. and Homeward Bound of Western North Carolina contractor or recipient
  • previously approved budget authorization that was approved as part of the Affordable Housing Capital Improvement Program funding source
  • up to two additional 30 day periods term
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Approval of resolutions to ratify City Manager’s execution of contract extensions with Red Roof Inn, Inc. and Homeward Bound of Western North Carolina.

Background:

  • On May 12, 2020, Council ratified the City Manager’s execution of agreements with Red Roof Inn, Inc., Homeward Bound of Western North Carolina, and Axis Security for operations of a COVID-19 motel-based non-congregate emergency homeless shelter for persons experiencing unsheltered homelessness and at significant risk of contracting COVID-19 because of age and/or underlying chronic health concerns.
  • Sixty-five people (couples, families occupying some rooms) are currently in shelter and will continue to achieve the public health objective of prevention of COVID-19 among the community’s unsheltered homeless population.
  • It is desirable to continue this program, but the current term of the City’s agreements with its partner organizations terminate in advance of the June 9th City Council Meeting.
  • To avoid any lapse in service to this population, it is necessary to execute the amendments prior to June 9th to continue the agreements.
  • The existing agreements with the vendors allow for extensions to continue operations if needed, however additional funding is necessary.
  • The existing agreement with Axis Security requires only an extension beyond the current term ending on June 30th. Sufficient funds for this activity were previously approved on May 12th and no additional amounts are needed to extend the term of the contract for security. No council action on this contract is requested at this time.

Council Goal(s):

  • A Diverse Community
  • A Well-Planned and Livable Community
  • Fiscally Resilient City

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • Continues the successful operation of the existing expanded COVID-19 homeless shelter.
  • Addresses public health and safety.
  • Non-congregate motel shelter, essential operations, and security costs are eligible for FEMA reimbursement.

Con(s):

  • Potential damages incurred at the Hotel are not eligible for reimbursement from FEMA

Fiscal Impact:

  • Additional costs for the extensions include $100,000 for Homeward Bound for up to two additional 30 day periods and $183,024 for Red Roof Inn for up to two additional 30 day periods.
  • Funding for the contracts will come from previously approved budget authorization that was approved as part of the Affordable Housing Capital Improvement Program, so no budget amendment is required. Community & Economic Development will utilize Capital Improvement Program funding to cover upfront costs pending FEMA reimbursement.

Staff: Sam Powers, Director of Community and Economic Development; Brian Huskey, Community Development Analyst.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item Q · RES 20-113 · Housing · Resolution · consent agenda

Resolution amending the 2020 City (action plan/policy)

Passed7–0 · Moved by Vijay Kapoor, seconded by Keith Young

All members present voted yes.

From the staff report
City Code sections

N. C. Gen. Stat. sec. 160A-71

Description in the minutes

ON JULY 14, 2020 … Mayor Manheimer said that members of Council have been previously furnished with a copy of the resolutions and ordinances on the Consent Agenda and they would not be read.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item VI-A · Zoning & Land Use · Public hearing

Public hearing to consider an amendment to a previously approved conditional zoning (signage) (continued)

Passed7–0 · Moved by Vijay Kapoor, seconded by Julie Mayfield

All members present voted yes.

2 spoke

Recommendations

Council’s vote matched the city staff recommendation.

  • City staff: Approve — Staff finds that the request for signage is appropriate and supports the amendment of the ordinance and conditions.

Public hearing advertised May 29, 2020 and Jun 5, 2020

2 spoke in favor · 0 spoke against

  • For HP Patel · applicant, Tru Hotel — [HP Patel], owner of the hotel, gave a brief background of the hotel site. He was unaware that signage was required by City Council at the time of original approval. He is proposing a much smaller sign than the other hotel in the area. He asked for Council’s support.

One voicemail individual spoke in favor of this conditional zoning amendment. The minutes name 1 of the 2 speakers.

Key facts

  • 1500 Tunnel Road address
  • 2.67 acres site size
  • Highway Business District → ? zoning, from → to
  • 86 units housing units
  • HP Patel applicant

Therefore, Councilman Kapoor moved to recess this item until June 23, 2020, at which time this public hearing will be voted.

Presented by Sasha Vrtunski, Urban Planner.

Description in the minutes

Urban Planner Sasha Vrtunski said that this is the consideration of an amendment to a previously approved conditional zoning at 1500 Tunnel Road known as "Tru Hotel" to include a free-standing identification sign. This public hearing was advertised on May 29 and June 5, 2020. Project Location and Contacts:

  • The project site consists of a 2.67 acres parcel located at 1500 Tunnel Road (PIN 9678.15-1933) that is owned by Commodore Holdings LLC.
  • Petitioner and Contact: HP Patel. Summary of

Petition:

  • The project was approved by City Council on July 25, 2017 (Ordinance No. 4604).
  • The approved project was for a 86 room hotel in a 43,000 square foot building.
  • The site was previously zoned Highway Business District.
  • While the 2017 approved project included an image reference to a wall-mounted sign, it failed to provide specific size allowances and did not include any free-standing signage. The applicant is requesting an amendment to the B1 conditions for the project to clarify sign allowances.
  • The conditions allow for some flexibility and provide for a free-standing sign not to exceed 60 square feet and 12 feet tall and attached building signage not to exceed 80 square feet. This will ensure flexibility for any changes to signage in the future and would be compatible with the surrounding area.
  • New condition is “Signage for project shall be limited to one free-standing monument sign not to exceed twelve feet in height and 60 square feet in size, and one wall-mounted sign not to exceed 80 square feet in size. Temporary and directional signage may be permitted as allowed by the Unified Development Ordinance.

Comprehensive Plan Consistency:

  • This proposal is consistent with the Living Asheville Comprehensive Plan in that “appropriate and contextual signage and articulation” is encouraged as a part of urban design.

Compatibility Analysis:

  • The proposed signage would be less than what is allowed in the surrounding Highway Business District where free-standing identification signs are commonly used and relied upon.
  • The proposed sign’s smaller and slimmer profile helps to avoid conflict with adjacent signage along the corridor.

Committee(s):

  • None.

Staff Recommendation:

  • Staff finds that the request for signage is appropriate and supports the amendment of the ordinance and conditions. Mr. Patel, owner of the hotel, gave a brief background of the hotel site. He was unaware that signage was required by City Council at the time of original approval. He is proposing a much smaller sign than the other hotel in the area. He asked for Council’s support. Mayor Manheimer opened the public hearing at 8:40 p.m. One voicemail individual spoke in favor of this conditional zoning amendment. In accordance with recent legislation amending North Carolina G.S. § 166A-19.24(e), regarding public hearings conducted during remote meetings, written comments for this public hearing will be accepted for an additional 24 hours. Therefore,

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

Item VI-B · Housing · Public hearing

Public hearing to solicit comments for the community (CDBG plan amendment) (continued to July 14, 2020)

Passed7–0 · Moved by Vijay Kapoor, seconded by Gwen Wisler

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

Councilman Kapoor moved to continue the public hearing amending the 2019-20 U.S. Dept. of Housing & Urban Development Annual Action Plan to allocate funds to help prevent, prepare for, and respond to COVID-19 until July 14, 2020.

Item VI-C · Housing · Public hearing

Public hearing to amend the 2019-20 U.S. Dept. of Housing and Urban Development plan (continued to June 23, 2020)

Passed7–0 · Moved by Vijay Kapoor, seconded by Sheneika Smith

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

Councilman Kapoor moved to continue the public hearing amending the 2019-20 U.S. Dept. of Housing & Urban Development Annual Action Plan to allocate funds to help prevent, prepare for, and respond to COVID-19 until June 23, 2020.

Item VI-D · Budget & Finance · Public hearing

Public hearing regarding the Fiscal Year 2020-21 budget (continued to August 25, 2020)

No action No separate vote: the hearing had been continued to August 25, 2020 earlier in the meeting (motion to continue the budget public hearing)

No vote was taken.

Public hearing advertised May 29, 2020

No one from the public spoke.

Mayor Manheimer said that we received 1,379 people who called in and left voicemail messages, mostly regarding the budget. That is almost 57 hours of voicemail messages. In addition, we received 1,642 written comments, mostly regarding the budget. The minutes don’t give enough detail to count everyone.

Key facts

Mayor Manheimer said that earlier in this meeting, Councilman Young moved to continue the budget public hearing until August 25, 2020.

From the staff report

Conduct public hearing on the City of Asheville Fiscal Year (FY) 2020-21 Proposed Annual Operating Budget and include public input in City Council’s consideration of the budget.

  • $134.6 million The Proposed General Fund Budget is $134.6 million
  • $184.6 million is $184.6 million which is a $5.8 million or 3.0% decrease compared to the FY 2019-20 Adopted Budget
Fiscal impact

None.

Staff’s stated reasons
  • Provides the opportunity for the public to comment on the Proposed Annual Operating Budget for FY 2020-21.
City Code sections

G.S. 159-12

Staff: Barbara Whitehorn, CFO, Finance and Management Services Director; Tony McDowell, Asst. Director of Finance for Budget & Forecasting.

Description in the minutes

This public hearing was advertised on May 29, 2020. Mayor Manheimer said that earlier in this meeting,

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item add-agenda · Community Programs · Motion

Motion to modify the agenda to add a new business item (Vance Monument joint resolution) before public hearings

Passed7–0 · Moved by Keith Young, seconded by Gwen Wisler

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

Mayor Manheimer asked that the agenda be modified to add an item under New Business, and that the New Business item be considered before the public hearings.

Item budget-1 · Budget & Finance · Motion

Motion to amend the budget schedule to hold the budget public hearing

Passed7–0 · Moved by Keith Young, seconded by Sheneika Smith

All members present voted yes.

1 council remark

What council members said 1 remark from 1 member

Brian Haynes Voted yes

  • Question asked that the line item budget for all departments be made available

The minutes record no remarks on this item from Vijay Kapoor, Esther E. Manheimer, Julie Mayfield, Sheneika Smith, Gwen Wisler and Keith Young.

Key facts

Councilman Young moved to amend the budget schedule to hold the budget public hearing on August 25, 2020, and adoption of the budget on September 8, 2020.

From the staff report
Staff’s stated reasons
  • An interim budget allows time to engage the community.
Description in the minutes

to hold the budget public hearing on August 25, 2020, and adoption of the budget on September 8, 2020. This motion was seconded by Councilwoman Smith and carried unanimously by roll call vote.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item budget-2 · Budget & Finance · Motion

Motion to continue the budget public hearing until August 25, 2020

Passed7–0 · Moved by Keith Young, seconded by Sheneika Smith

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

City Manager Campbell noted that the budget before Council is not what we would like to be considered, so we are asking to continue the public hearing until we do have a budget that we think is appropriate.

From the staff report
Staff’s stated reasons
  • An interim budget allows time to engage the community.
Description in the minutes

ring until August 25, 2020. City Manager Campbell noted that the budget before Council is not what we would like to be considered, so we are asking to continue the public hearing until we do have a budget that we think is appropriate. City Manager Campbell said we are hearing (1) Defund the Police Department to fund other services; (2) Ensure police accountability, both individually and organizationally; and (3) Repair past and continuing harm to Asheville’s black community. She said the response is: (1) We have heard the community; (2) We want to respond and move forward together; (3) Racism is a systemic problem, not just a police problem, and the City cannot solve it alone; (4) The solution lies in collaborative work with the County, schools, and other organizations to address social disparities and equity; and (5) The solution needs to be strategic and reflect community values. Her recommendation is that we adopt an interim budget. We will spend the next 60 days engaging the community to develop the final budget, with the final budget will be adopted early September. She reviewed the revised budget schedule

  • Budget public hearing on August 25 and Council adoption on 9-8-20. Why did the budget show an increase to the Police Department of $410,000? (1) $200,000: state-mandated increase in the City’s contribution to the Local Government Employee Retirement System (LGERS); (2) $108,000: fuel and fleet maintenance costs associated with the implementation of a take-home vehicle program approved during the current fiscal year; (3) $81,000: lease costs associated with the relocated South District Substation; (4) $21,000: The department will no longer receive state grant funding for the DWI Task Force. Salary costs that used to be partially covered by the grant will be fully funded in the General Fund in FY 2020-21; and (5) No new personnel or equipment. Why did the budget show an increase to the Fire Department of $1,000,000? (1) $200,000: state-mandated increase in the City’s contribution to the Local Government Employee Retirement System (LGERS); (2) $316,000: the City’s share of the cost for 15 firefighter positions that were added in November 2018 and November 2019 as part of the Staffing for Adequate Fire & Emergency Response (SAFER) grant program; (3) $200,000: increases to the AFD overtime budget and fleet and fuel budget based on spending trends from recent fiscal years; and (4) $284,000: other cost increases associated with the firefighters added in 2018 and 2019. In summary, we are listening, hearing, and trying to be responsive to all community needs in a constrained fiscal situation. We must use these challenges as an opportunity to rethink and reinvest in collaboration with the community. An interim budget allows time to engage the community. Councilman Haynes asked that the line item budget for all departments be made available. City Clerk Burleson said that department summaries (which show expenses by category, as well as highlights of any major budget to budget changes for each department) is available on the City’s website.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Discussed, no vote

Presentation

Draft I-26 Connector Project Aesthetics Committee Report: Phase 1 - Vertical Aesthetic Treatments

Councilwoman Mayfield noted that this will come back to Council on the final recommendations and a funding plan.

Cost estimates for vertical aesthetic treatments that exceed the standard agreed upon treatments range from $6,200,000 to $9,800,000. … The City’s share of the betterment costs would be $1,700,000 which is 17% of the total cost for betterments

Presented by Ken Putnam, Director of Transportation; Ted Figura, Chair of the I-26 Connector Project Aesthetics Committee.

Presentations: I-26 Aesthetics Committee Report ↗ · PowerPoint for I-26 ↗

Council remarks

Julie Mayfield

  • Councilwoman Mayfield thanked the members of the I-26 Connector Aesthetics Committee and the tremendous amount of work they did. She also thanked the NCDOT and AECOM for their help, and our own transportation staff. … We are still waiting on the timing of payment requirements from NCDOT.

Gwen Wisler

  • In response to Vice-Mayor Wisler, [Ted Figura] and Councilwoman Mayfield said that they will try to produce some images on what the funding options would look like with no funding vs. what the Aesthetics Committee is proposing.

Presentation

Update from the Chief of Police

Highlights for 30/60/90 Day Action Plan for APD: (1) department-wide restructuring; (2) equitable promotional process; and (3) higher accountability in use of force reporting. … Drug Suppression Unit (DSU) will be abolished. … Beyond 90 days - organizational chart showed a new Community Engagement Division.

Presented by Debra Campbell, City Manager; David Zack, Police Chief.

Presentation: Update from Police Chief ↗

Council remarks

Sheneika Smith

  • In response to Councilwoman Smith, Chief [David Zack] said that the use of tear gas is a use of force and the officers are required to make their reports per the policy. All body cam footage is being downloaded for review.

Julie Mayfield

  • Councilwoman Mayfield said that before restructuring occurs, she suggested that there be opportunities to sit down and meet with some community leaders to talk more about their ideas on restructuring, as we have a lot of creative people who would like to participate in the restructuring proposal

Brian Haynes

  • In response to Councilman Haynes, Chief [David Zack] said that they will use existing personnel for the new Community Engagement Division by realigning certain positions.

Vijay Kapoor

  • Councilman Kapoor read the following statement: “I want to speak directly to the officers at the Asheville Police Department. … I am asking you to buy-in to the reforms that Chief [David Zack] talked about not because you have to, but because you actually want to take a step in the direction of establishing trust.

Keith Young

  • Councilman Young said that a big conversation needs to be about how we do public safety, and we need to begin by looking at a menu of options which will lead to reallocation of funding. … He would reject any options of change by staff without input from the Black community.

Esther E. Manheimer

  • This isn’t the first time we have tried to embark on significant change. We tried to get legislation to create a citizen review board, changes to the Civil Service Board, and legislation for body cam access.

Manager’s report

City Manager update on Fiscal Year 2020-21 interim budget

Councilman Young moved to amend the budget schedule to hold the budget public hearing on August 25, 2020, and adoption of the budget on September 8, 2020.

Mayor Manheimer said that we received 1,379 people who called in and left voicemail messages, mostly regarding the budget. That is almost 57 hours of voicemail messages. In addition, we received 1,642 written comments, mostly regarding the budget. … Her recommendation is that we adopt an interim budget.

Presented by Debra Campbell, City Manager.

Council remarks

Brian Haynes

  • asked that the line item budget for all departments be made available

Statement

Councilman Haynes read the following statement:

Councilman Haynes read the following statement: … The Defunding of the APD must begin now as part of this budget and continue into the next. We need to not only deny the 400,000 increase being requested but seek much deeper cuts, reallocating funds towards programs providing opportunity to the Black Community and poverty remediation. … (1) That we instruct staff to audit the APD budget to find the appropriate areas to make meaningful cuts.

Council remarks

Brian Haynes

  • So I would like to move some proposals forward, Mayor Manheimer. Should we take these one by one?

Open public comment 5 topics, as the minutes list them

This resource, to the best of its ability, is copied word for word from the official minutes, “…” marks words left out, and [brackets] a name the minutes give elsewhere. The minutes are the record. Staff report details are quoted from the city’s meeting documents, prepared before the vote.