City Council regular meeting — May 26, 2020

Asheville City Council recorded 19 votes at its regular meeting on May 26, 2020; none drew a no vote. Most items fell under Zoning & Land Use, Transportation and Housing.

Met: 5 pm–6:51 pm. Voting: Brian Haynes, Vijay Kapoor, Esther E. Manheimer, Julie Mayfield, Sheneika Smith, Gwen Wisler, Keith Young.

Votes 19 recorded · 5 substantive · none split

Item B · RES 20-84 · Public Safety · Resolution · consent agenda

Resolution authorizing the City Manager to enter into a contract with J. Bartholomew Construction LLC for the Shelburne roof and window replacement project

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Sheneika Smith

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $632,500 Shelburne Roof and Window Replacement project
  • $31,625 contingency amount of 5% ($31,625)
  • $774,000 WNC Roofing Fletcher, NC $ 774,000
  • 75 Shelburne Road address
  • J. Bartholomew Construction, LLC contractor or recipient
  • Capital Improvement Program (CIP) funding source

Window Replacement not accepted: Additive Alternate #2 for upper window replacement did not meet the project budget.

Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to enter into a contract with J. Bartholomew Construction, LLC in the amount of $632,500, for the Shelburne Roof and Window Replacement project; and further authorizing the City Manager to execute any change orders that may arise during the project up to the contingency amount of 5% ($31,625).

Background:

  • This property located at 75 Shelburne Road was returned to City ownership at no cost to the City from a Federal agency about ten years ago. At the time of transfer to City ownership, the building was in poor condition and has continued to deteriorate.
  • Currently this facility houses Facilities Maintenance and several Police operations. The site also serves as a materials storage facility for Public Works stormwater, sanitation, and fleet management.
  • The building now houses essential City functions that require dry, secure conditions.
  • The roof and masonry are leaking. This project will replace roofing systems throughout the 1960's building and complete structural masonry repairs. High-bay windows in the former “drill hall”, while significantly deteriorating, are currently functional.
  • Request for Bids was first advertised on March 11, 2020. No pre-bid meeting was held due to observance of pandemic public health concerns. Additional site information was provided to bidders.
  • Formal bids were received April 30, 2020. The bids were not opened because only two bids were received.
  • Request for Bids was Re-Advertised on May 5, 2020. Contractors were offered site visits following current COVID-19 restrictions per the State of North Carolina, Buncombe County, and the City of Asheville.
  • Window Replacement not accepted: Additive Alternate #2 for upper window replacement did not meet the project budget. Windows are currently functioning and will need to be addressed in a future project.
  • Construction will begin around July 15, 2020 with completion around November 15, 2020.
  • Two bids were received and formally opened on May 14, 2020, their names and Base Bid + Alternate # 1 amounts are listed below:
  • J. Bartholomew Construction Hendersonville, NC $ 632,500
  • WNC Roofing Fletcher, NC $ 774,000 J. Bartholomew Construction, LLC was the lowest responsive, responsible bidder.

Vendor Outreach Efforts:

  • Staff performed outreach to minority and women owned businesses through solicitation processes which include posting on the State’s Interactive Purchasing System and requiring prime contractors to reach out to Minority & Women-Owned Business Enterprise (MWBE) service providers for subcontracted services. The low bidder is not MWBE. The Contractor did document outreach to MWBE sub-contractors. Hemphill Concrete and Finishing (Black Minority Business Enterprise) of Brevard, NC will be performing masonry repairs.

Council Goal(s):

  • A Clean and Healthy Environment & A Financially Resilient City

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • The roof system will be insulated per current codes and leak free.

Con(s):

  • None

Fiscal Impact:

  • Funding for this contract is included in the Capital Improvement Program (CIP).

Staff: Jade Dundas, Capital Projects Director.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item H · RES 20-89 · Transportation · Resolution · consent agenda

Resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a contract amendment with Mattern & Craig Inc. for the New Hawcreek bond sidewalk project

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Sheneika Smith

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $39,405 amendment with Mattern & Craig, Inc. in the amount of $39,405
  • $719,780 for a total contract amount of $719,780
  • $35,500 change orders up to the contingency amount of $35,500 (5.2%)
  • $71,000 change orders up to the contingency amount of $71,000 (9.8%)
  • Mattern & Craig, Inc. contractor or recipient
  • Funding for this contract is already included in the 2016 General Obligation (G.O.) Bond Program and has since been supplemented by federal grant funding at an 80% Federal/20% City level. funding source
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a contract amendment with Mattern & Craig, Inc. in the amount of $39,405, for a total contract amount of $719,780 and to further authorize change orders up to the contingency amount of $35,500 (5.2%) for Bond Sidewalk Bundle B.

Background:

  • This project, New Haw Creek Sidewalks, is part of the original Bond Sidewalk Bundle B design contract consisting of three other active GO bond sidewalk projects with Mattern & Craig, Inc.
  • The City originally entered into a contract in the amount of $573,725 for Bond Sidewalk Bundle B design services (Resolution 17-261, dated November 27, 2017), and later expanded the scope of services to meet the requirements the Federal grants that were awarded to supplement the project budgets. The first contract amendment resulted in a revised contract of $680,375 (Resolution 19-109, dated May 14, 2019)
  • Design consideration, to date, for the Haw Creek sidewalk envisioned the sidewalk being constructed on the west side of the road past Dogwood Grove then crossing to the east side of the road.
  • Certain challenges with constructing on the east side of the road prompted the suggestion to further evaluate construction on the west side allowing crossings at intersections of Beverley Road and Bel Road.
  • Site investigation of the original alignment identified obstructions. The full significance of these obstacles was not realized until a design review workshop in February 2020.
  • Understanding the significance of the east side obstructions prompted an investigation of a new alignment. After preliminary design work on the new alignment, it was determined that the new alignment is feasible and recommended.
  • This amendment to the design services contract will include additional survey as well as additional drainage and retaining wall design required for constructing on the west side of Haw Creek. The cost of this additional work is $39,405, bringing the total cost of the design contract for the four projects to $719,780.
  • The additional contingency of $35,500 is being requested to cover unexpected changes which may occur in the design of this and the other three active projects in this bond package.
  • New Haw Creek design will be complete in August 2020, with construction completion in May 2020.
  • Johnston Boulevard design will be complete in November 2020, with construction completion in January 2023.
  • Onteora Boulevard design will be complete in October 2020, with the construction completion in April 2021. Vendor Outreach:
  • During the establishment of the original contract, staff performed outreach to minority and women owned businesses through solicitation processes which included posting on the State’s Interactive Purchasing System and encouraging consultants to reach out to Minority & Women-Owned Business Enterprise (MWBE) service providers for subcontracted services. No MWBE firms submitted qualifications for consideration as the prime consultant.

Council Goal(s):

  • Smart City
  • Well-planned and livable community

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • Design of sidewalk that will meet City and National standards
  • Improve mobility and safety on city streets
  • Adhere to federal guidance and project federal funding

Con(s):

  • Construction will be disruptive to adjacent residences and businesses

Fiscal Impact:

  • Funding for this contract is already included in the 2016 General Obligation (G.O.) Bond Program and has since been supplemented by federal grant funding at an 80% Federal/20% City level.

Staff: Jade Dundas, Capital Projects Department Director; Lora Sepion, Capital Projects Project Manager.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item I · RES 20-90 · Budget & Finance · Resolution · consent agenda

Resolution approving the 2020 General Obligation bond draw program

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Sheneika Smith

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $25 million issuance of interim, variable rate General Obligation Bonds (GOs) in an amount not to exceed $25,000,000
  • $5.1 million The initial draw on the GO bonds for costs incurred to date is $5.1 million.
  • Funds are included in the City's FY 2020-2021 proposed debt service budget to cover these costs. funding source
  • This short-term debt is then “refunded,” or refinanced with longer-term, fixed rate debt (20 years). term
Description in the minutes

Council Goal:

  • Financially Resilient City

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution directing the City Manager and Chief Financial Officer to pursue debt financing for capital projects with a draw program that includes the issuance of interim, variable rate General Obligation Bonds (GOs) in an amount not to exceed $25,000,000. The interim GOs will provide construction financing for projects which, upon completion, will be permanently financed through longer-term, fixed rate GOs. Background
  • Timeline:

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • Allows the City to move forward with the Capital Improvement Program as funds are spent

Con(s):

  • None

Fiscal Impact:

  • The initial draw on the GO bonds for costs incurred to date is $5.1 million. At current variable rates associated with this facility (roughly 1.92%), the annualized interest expense on the initial draw is $98 thousand. As further draws are made on the bonds, the interest expense will increase accordingly. Funds are included in the City’s FY 2020-2021 proposed debt service budget to cover these costs. They are also included in the City’s multi-year capital improvements debt model.

Staff: Barbara Whitehorn, CFO & Director of Finance and Management Services.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item N · RES 20-95 / ORD 4806 · Transportation · Resolution · consent agenda

Selection of a contractor for supplemental transit service; and budget amendment from CARES Act funding

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Sheneika Smith

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $962,000 contract with Young Transportation in an amount not to exceed $962,000
  • $3.75 million Approximately $3.75 million in CARES Act funding has been provided to the City of Asheville
  • Young Transportation contractor or recipient
  • CARES Act funding will be used to fund these services, and there is a 0% City match required. funding source
  • 4 buses for 12 hours per day, operating 7 days per week, between June 1 and December 31 term
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a contract with Young Transportation in an amount not to exceed $962,000 to provide supplemental transit operations support for the City of Asheville in an effort to restore portions of fixed-route transit services that have been reduced due to COVID-19 impacts to service capacity; and a budget amendment in the Transit Services Fund in the amount of $962,000 from CARES Act funding to provide budget authorization for the contract cost.

Background:

  • The COVID-19 pandemic has impacted the City of Asheville’s fixed-route transit service, Asheville Rides Transit (ART), in a number of specific ways that have resulted in the need to reduce transit service.
  • Specifically, social distancing requirements have necessitated limiting the number of people on a bus to 10 (including the driver). This has essentially reduced the overall service capacity by more than 50%, resulting in instances of overcrowding and not being able to pick up all riders.
  • Additionally, staffing levels at ART have also been impacted, both due to COVID-19, natural employee turnover, and nationwide driver shortage, which has been exacerbated by COVID-19.
  • Staffing shortages contributed to the need to cut 3 routes (170, S6, and one bus on WE1 route) in March, which has had a significant negative impact on many ART riders.
  • Approximately $3.75 million in CARES Act funding has been provided to the City of Asheville specifically to be used for transit expenses related to COVID-19, including expenses related to purchasing operational support.
  • The City released an RFP on May 13 requesting proposals to provide supplemental transit operations support, specifically requesting the provision of large vehicles and drivers to be used 12 hours per day in order to cover the peak ridership times of day on the 3 routes that were previously cut (170, S6, WE1). The contractor may also be asked to provide pick-ups and drop-offs to aid in overcrowding being experienced due to the 10-person limit per bus.
  • It is unknown how long these services will continue to be necessary, though it is likely that it will no longer be needed when ART staffing levels return to normal and physical distancing measures are no longer required.
  • The $962,000 cost to be authorized is a maximum amount and includes 4 buses for 12 hours per day, operating 7 days per week, between June 1 and December 31. It is possible that the number of buses per day needed may be less than 4 on any given day, and it is possible that the City may not need the additional support through December, however staff requests authorization for this maximum amount in case it is needed. Any remaining funds would be returned to the Transit Operations Fund.
  • This supplemental service is not new or supplanted service and has no impact on the existing contract with RATPDev, Inc. or the Collective Bargaining Agreement between RATPDev, Inc. and its staff.

Vendor Outreach Efforts:

  • A Request for Proposals was issued and posted on the City’s bid page as well as the State Department of Administration Historically Underutilized Business website.
  • The City received one proposal from a minority/woman-owned business based in Winter-Garden, Florida; however the proposal did not meet the selection criteria as well as Young Transportation’s proposal and therefore was not selected.

Council Goal(s):

  • Transportation and Accessibility.

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • The contract will provide service 12-hours per day to cover peak ridership times, primarily on the 3 routes that were previously cut. The contractor may also provide service to pick up and drop off riders that may be left at a stop due to the bus being full as a result of the 10-person limit.
  • CARES Act funding can be used to fund this contract, rather than City funds.

Con(s):

  • The cost to procure additional private services to supplement our fixed-route transit service.

Fiscal Impact:

  • The contract is for a not-to-exceed amount of $962,000. CARES Act funding will be used to fund these services, and there is a 0% City match required.
  • A budget amendment is needed in order to provide sufficient budget authorization to encumber the contract in the current year Transit Services Fund budget.

Staff: Ken Putnam, Transportation Department Director; Jessica Morriss, Assistant Transportation Department Director.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item V-A · RES 20-96 · Housing · Resolution

Resolution approving a Housing Trust Fund loan request by Beaucatcher Vista LLC

Passed7–0 · Moved by Julie Mayfield, seconded by Keith Young

All members present voted yes.

1 council remark

What council members said 1 remark from 1 member

Gwen Wisler Voted yes

  • Question In response to Vice-Mayor Wisler, City Attorney Branham said that this action is to approve a Housing Trust Fund loan. If the land use incentive grant requested is not approved, the development would no longer be viable and there would be no Housing Trust Fund loan for this development.

The minutes record no remarks on this item from Brian Haynes, Vijay Kapoor, Esther E. Manheimer, Julie Mayfield, Sheneika Smith and Keith Young.

Key facts

  • $1 million Housing Trust Fund loan
  • $1,910,600 Loan commitments from TruPoint Bank for $1,910,600
  • $296,334 Buncombe County for $296,334
  • $786,000 The development partnership is committing the property (valued at $786,000) as equity.
  • $25,000 The per unit HTF subsidy of $25,000 per affordable unit
  • 2 Restaurant Court address
  • 1.31 acres site size
  • 40 units 40 of them affordable
  • 30 of the units set aside for households at or below 60% of Area Median Income (AMI) and the remaining 10 for 80% AMI households affordability
  • Kirk Booth d/b/a as Beaucatcher Vista LLC applicant
  • Housing Trust Fund funding source
  • The loan will be structured to require full repayment of principal and interest (accruing at 2% annually) over a term of 20-years. term

Presented by Paul D'Angelo, Director of Community Development Programs.

From the staff report

Support of a request by Beaucatcher Vista LLC to utilize the Housing Trust Fund to construct affordable rental housing at the property located at 2 Restaurant Court.

  • $1 million The developer seeks a loan of
  • $1,910,600 Loan commitments from TruPoint Bank for
  • City’s Housing Trust Fund funding source
Fiscal impact

The project would require $1,000,000 from the City’s Housing Trust Fund.

Staff’s stated reasons
  • Mr. Booth is an experienced developer, and familiar with City of Asheville affordable housing programs and the expectations associated with them.

Staff: Sam Powers, Community & Economic Development Director; Paul D'Angelo, CD Program Director; Andrew Mayronne, CD Analyst.

Description in the minutes

Director of Community Development Programs Paul D’Angelo said that this is consideration of support of a request by Beaucatcher Vista LLC to utilize the Housing Trust Fund to construct affordable rental housing at the property located at 2 Restaurant Court. Review::

  • Kirk Booth d/b/a as Beaucatcher Vista LLC has proposed the development of a 40-unit, 100% affordable multifamily property on a 1.31 acre parcel located at 2 Restaurant Court (PIN #9658-08-2350) in Asheville directly off of Tunnel Road. All 40 units are intended to be 1 bedrooms, with 30 of the units set aside for households at or below 60% of Area Median Income (AMI) and the remaining 10 for 80% AMI households.
  • Since 2009, Mr. Booth has completed 9 affordable housing projects in partnership with the City of Asheville resulting in 136 affordable units. This will be his second project using a factory-built product manufactured by Clayton Homes in Tennessee. The technology promises a faster, more efficient construction process, with on-site responsibilities restricted mostly to installation and finishing. He anticipates the units will be available by early 2021.

Proposal:

  • The developer seeks a loan of $1,000,000 from the City’s Housing Trust Fund (HTF). In addition, the developer has requested a Land Use Incentive Grant (LUIG) award estimated at $289,481.85, which request will be considered at the May 26, 2020, Council meeting. Loan commitments from TruPoint Bank for $1,910,600 and Buncombe County for $296,334 have already been secured. The development partnership is committing the property (valued at $786,000) as equity.
  • The units will be located in two separate buildings framing an interior breezeway, and set back towards the rear of the property facing resident parking. All units will be approximately 450 square feet, and possess full baths, kitchens, and enclosed bedrooms.
  • Units will be made available to qualified affordable residents, as well as persons possessing rental assistance. The developer has a demonstrated history of close engagement with the Asheville Housing Authority, Homeward Bound, and other entities providing resident placement and rental assistance.

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • The project produces 40 units of affordable housing at a location near the City’s core, with good access to transit and essential services. The developer’s commitment to set aside the majority of these units for 60% AMI households and citizens utilizing rental assistance addresses one of the City of Asheville’s highest stated needs.
  • The per unit HTF subsidy of $25,000 per affordable unit ($32,237.05 of combined City subsidy) which is lower than the current estimate of up to $80,000 in subsidy for 80% AMI homes as suggested at the Affordable Housing Workshop on September 6, 2019.
  • Mr. Booth is an experienced developer, and familiar with City of Asheville affordable housing programs and the expectations associated with them.
  • The developer’s use of a modular construction product promises a less risk versus a fully site-built construction process.

Con(s):

  • None.

Fiscal Impact:

  • The project would require $1,000,000 from the City’s Housing Trust Fund.
  • The loan will be structured to require full repayment of principal and interest (accruing at 2% annually) over a term of 20-years. In response to Vice-Mayor Wisler, City Attorney Branham said that this action is to approve a Housing Trust Fund loan. If the land use incentive grant requested is not approved, the development would no longer be viable and there would be no Housing Trust Fund loan for this development. When Mayor Manheimer asked for public comments, none were received. Mayor Manheimer said that members of Council have been previously furnished with a copy of the resolution and it would not be read.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Show the other 14 votes · consent agenda and routine items · consent agenda moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Sheneika Smith

Item C · RES 20-85 · Utilities & Infrastructure · Resolution · consent agenda

Sewer easement on City property on Old Haywood Road and Eastview Circle for Hawthorne at Haywood Apartments LLC

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Sheneika Smith

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $4,820 City is receiving unbudgeted revenue for the easement in the amount of $4,820.
  • OLD HAYWOOD ROAD AND EASTVIEW CIRCLE address
  • Hawthorne at Haywood Apartments, LLC applicant
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to grant a sewer easement to Hawthorne at Haywood Apartments, LLC.

Background:

  • The City was approached by a local developer who is building a new phase of the Hawthorne at Haywood Apartments and needed a connection to the nearest Metropolitan Sewerage District (MSD) sewer line. The closest opportunity for sewer connection is a line on Eastview Circle.
  • The N.C. Dept. of Transportation does not allow sewer within the roadway of Eastview Circle and no remaining right of way outside of pavement is accessible for the sewer installation.
  • The only feasible connection left is across city property (9618-90-5267) at the intersection of Old Haywood and Eastview Circle.
  • The Real Estate Division consulted other City departments to determine whether it would be in the City’s best interest to allow this easement on City property. The Asheville Fire Department uses the property as a fire station and Asheville Police Department has a traffic division at this location.
  • Representatives of both departments indicated that they had no objections to this sewer extension. The Streets Department was also consulted and they have no objection.
  • The easement being requested is approximately 100 linear feet long and is 20 feet wide. The width is mandated by MSD regulation specifying minimum width. Fair Market Value has been determined to be $4,820 and the developer has agreed to pay this amount.

Council Goal(s):

  • A Well Planned and Livable Community

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • Project will bring much needed rental units to the Asheville area.
  • City is receiving compensation for the easement.

Con(s):

  • There will be temporary disruption on City property during construction.

Fiscal Impact:

  • City is receiving unbudgeted revenue for the easement in the amount of $4,820.

Staff: Nikki Reid, Economic Development Program Director.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item D · ORD 4803 · Budget & Finance · Ordinance · consent agenda

Technical budget amendment to the 2019-20 General Fund for the 2018 general obligation bond refunding

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Sheneika Smith

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $22,445,994 technical budget amendment to the Fiscal Year 2019-20 General Fund (2100 Fund) budget
  • There is no net fiscal impact from this technical budget amendment. funding source

Ordinance No. 4803

Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a technical budget amendment to the Fiscal Year (FY) 2019-20 General Fund (2100 Fund) budget in the amount of $22,445,994 to account for the refunding component of the 2018 General Obligation (GO) Bond draw program.

Background:

  • In 2016, the voters of Asheville approved a GO bond referendum for $74 million.
  • The City uses a draw program to minimize the cost of debt. A draw program is a model using short-term debt (24-59 month) during the construction of projects. This short-term debt is then “refunded,” or refinanced with long-term debt (20 years). This model minimizes the interest the City pays on debt during construction, ensuring that the City’s debt capacity is used most efficiently.
  • In June 2018, the City entered into a GO bond draw program in an amount not to exceed $23 million.
  • Over the subsequent 21 months, the City drew down on the loan to fund various GO-related projects. In March 2020, the City repaid the interim GO bond ($22.2 million) by issuing 20 year, fixed-rate bonds.
  • The FY 2019-20 budget did not include appropriations for the refunding of the 2018 GO bond draw program debt with long-term debt because the amount to be refinanced and the timing were not yet determined when the FY 2019-20 budget was adopted.
  • This technical amendment incorporates this appropriation into the budget in order to ensure that the General Fund does not exceed the approved annual budget in the City’s Comprehensive Annual Financial Report (CAFR). Council Goal:
  • Financially Resilient City

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • Amends the FY 2019-20 budget in order to ensure statutory budgetary compliance.

Con(s):

  • None

Fiscal Impact:

  • There is no net fiscal impact from this technical budget amendment. It will simply amend the FY 2019-20 budget in the General Fund to reflect the receipt of refunding proceeds from the bank and the subsequent payment to bondholders to defease the prior debt issuance.

Staff: Barbara Whitehorn, CFO & Director of Finance and Management Services.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item E · RES 20-86 · Transportation · Resolution · consent agenda

Contract with GMV Syncromatics for real-time arrival and departure signs at the Downtown Transit Center

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Sheneika Smith

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $188,068 contract with GMV Syncromatics in an amount not to exceed $188,068
  • $137,573 hardware
  • $27,514 The City is responsible for 20% of this cost ($27,514)
  • downtown transit station at 49 Coxe Ave address
  • GMV Syncromatics contractor or recipient
  • The hardware component ($137,573) of the project is to be funded primarily through previously awarded Federal Transit Administration funds budgeted as part of the transit center renovation project. funding source
  • The contract is for 3 years with options to renew for two additional years for a total of 5 years. term

Installation of the signage will be done under a separate city contract.

Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute a contract with GMV Syncromatics in an amount not to exceed $188,068 to provide digital real-time arrival/departure signage at the downtown transit center.

Background:

  • The City of Asheville is currently in the process of renovating various aspects of the downtown transit station at 49 Coxe Ave.
  • Recently completed portions of the renovation project include a complete renovation of the interior waiting room and ART staff space; new paint, furniture, and lighting on the platform, and new static signage for the platform bays and building.
  • Outstanding items include the addition of solar panels to the roof (to be completed this summer), ADA improvements to the sidewalks and ramps adjacent to the transit station on the west side, and the addition of digital real-time arrival/departure signage to improve the rider experience.
  • The City issued a request for proposals February 13, 2020,and received 5 proposals.
  • The vendor was selected by a committee of transit staff from the City, ART and City IT staff.
  • Installation of the signage will be done under a separate city contract.

Vendor Outreach Efforts:

  • A Request for Proposals was issued and posted on the City’s bid page as well as the State Department of Administration Historically Underutilized Business website.
  • No bids were received from disadvantaged or minority businesses.
  • Electrical work and installation of the signage will be bid separately and will include additional outreach to local disadvantaged and minority businesses.

Council Goal(s):

  • Transportation and Accessibility.

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • Digital signage will be placed at the transit center inside the passenger waiting area and outside on the platform to provide riders with real-time transit arrival and departure information, as well as rider alerts and messages.
  • The digital signage will improve the rider experience and provide additional opportunities for the City and ART to communicate with riders.

Con(s):

  • The cost of the signage.

Fiscal Impact:

  • The contract is for 3 years with options to renew for two additional years for a total of 5 years.
  • The total 5 year cost of the contract is $188,068. This includes $137,573 in hardware and $6,995 in annual software licensing, support, and maintenance fees for the first year. Years 2 through 5 would include an annual payment of $10,875 for software licensing, support and maintenance.
  • The contract allows for additional signage purchases to be made as funding is available in order to expand the system.
  • The hardware component ($137,573) of the project is to be funded primarily through previously awarded Federal Transit Administration funds budgeted as part of the transit center renovation project. The City is responsible for 20% of this cost ($27,514), which is also budgeted in that same capital project. Annual maintenance, support and licensing fees are included in the Transit Operations Fund budget and will be funded with City funds.

Staff: Ken Putnam, Transportation Department Director; Jessica Morriss, Assistant Transportation Department Director.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item F · RES 20-87 · Contracts & Procurement · Resolution · consent agenda

Resolution authorizing the City Manager to enter into a contract with Esri Inc. for GIS software maintenance

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Sheneika Smith

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $178,155 The total for the three-year contract is $178,155, including sales tax.
  • $55,500 first year
  • Esri, Inc. contractor or recipient
  • $5,500 will come from the Water Service Fund and $50,000 will come from IT Services GIS Application Service funding. funding source
  • 3 years term
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to renew a three-year contract with Esri, Inc. for GIS software maintenance.

Background:

  • On August 22, 2017, Council approved Resolution No. 17-185 Esri, Inc. for a three-year contract for GIS Software Maintenance.
  • This new contract would allow the City of Asheville to continue building an award-winning GIS program using Esri software for GIS dashboards, Map Asheville, the open data program, water utility management, Public Works asset management, Equity mapping and storytelling, and other initiatives.
  • Currently, Esri software is also providing a central data repository and dashboard for the coordinated COVID-19 response.

Vendor Outreach Efforts:

  • Esri provides a competitive enterprise license agreement for public sector clients. Changing the City’s underlying GIS infrastructure would result in significant costs in terms of lost productivity and the need to rebuild existing GIS assets.
  • While City staff keeps a close eye on the enterprise GIS software market, there are few alternatives and none that can provide the same level of value compared to Esri.

Council Goal(s):

  • Connected and Engaged Community
  • A Diverse Community
  • A Well-Planned and Livable Community

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • Increased support of departmental business requirements via greater options for GIS software licensing
  • Ability to install additional software without additional purchases
  • Hold the line on increasing software maintenance costs

Con(s):

  • If continued funding is not appropriated, some staff will lose the ability to utilize GIS software and data.

Fiscal Impact:

  • The first year is $55,500; $5,500 will come from the Water Service Fund and $50,000 will come from IT Services GIS Application Service funding.
  • Funding for the first year of the contract is included in the adopted Fiscal Year 2019-20 Budget.
  • The total for the three-year contract is $178,155, including sales tax.

Staff: Jonathan Feldman, Chief Information Officer; Linda Brinkley, Business Services Specialist.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item G · RES 20-88 · Boards & Appointments · Resolution · consent agenda

Resolution appointing Vice-Mayor (to the Fonta Flora State Trail/related body)

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Sheneika Smith

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • 3 years term
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution appointing Vice-Mayor Gwen Wisler to the Friends of the Fonta Flora State Trail, Inc. Board of Directors.

Background:

  • The Fonta Flora State Trail is the second state trail in North Carolina. It starts in Burke County at Lake James and is planned to extend through McDowell and Buncombe Counties to terminate in Asheville.
  • The City Council of the City of Asheville approved the adoption of the Fonta Flora State Trail extension to Asheville on December 13, 2016, via Resolution # 16-273.
  • The Friends of the Fonta Flora State Trail, Inc. is a newly formed non-profit organization designed to support local jurisdictions to coordinate and hasten the planning and implementation of the Fonta Flora State Trail from Morganton to Asheville.
  • The Board of Directors is currently being formed and will be made up of elected officials, economic development officials, and trail builders from the three county area.
  • Vice-Mayor Gwen Wisler, liaison to the Greenway Committee, was invited to sit on the board for a three-year term.

Council Goal(s):

  • Transportation and Accessibility
  • Connected and Engaged Community

Committee(s):

  • All committees suspended until further notice due to COVID-19.

Pro(s):

  • The City of Asheville will have a representative on the Board of Directors.
  • State trail status should provide high level planning and funding opportunities to governing entities that are involved with the state trail.

Con(s):

  • Time commitment would be required for the city’s representative.

Fiscal Impact:

  • There is no fiscal impact for this action.

Staff: Ken Putnam, PE, Transportation Department Director; Lucy Crown, Greenway Planner.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item IV-A · Zoning & Land Use · Public hearing

Public hearing to consider a land use incentive grant (continued)

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Julie Mayfield

All members present voted yes.

3 spoke · 2 council remarks

Public hearing continued from May 12, 2020 · advertised May 1, 2020

1 spoke in favor · 0 spoke against · 2 stance not recorded

  • For Chris Day · for the applicant, Civil Design Concepts — Mr. Chris Day, with Civil Design Concepts, said this project proposes 40 affordable housing. They had a neighborhood meeting in December and heard concerns of trash, landscaping, etc.

Two individuals spoke about the concern of problems associated with the developer's prior development at 444 Beaucatcher Road. … written comments for this public hearing will be accepted for an additional 24 hours The minutes name 1 of the 3 speakers.

What council members said 2 remarks from 2 members

Gwen Wisler Voted yes · moved it

  • Concern Vice-Mayor Wisler said that she has heard concerns regarding the developer's neighboring development at 444 Beaucatcher Road.

Julie Mayfield Voted yes · seconded

  • Concern asked that these concerns be addressed prior to the final vote

The minutes record no remarks on this item from Brian Haynes, Vijay Kapoor, Esther E. Manheimer, Sheneika Smith and Keith Young.

Key facts

  • $289,481.85 Land Use Incentive Grant (LUIG) award estimated at $289,481.85
  • $13,784.85 annual grant award of $13,784.85
  • $1 million $1,000,000 Housing Trust Fund request
  • 2 Restaurant Court address
  • 1.31 acres site size
  • 40 units 40 of them affordable
  • 30 of the units set aside for households at or below 60% of Area Median Income (AMI) and the remaining 10 for 80% AMI households affordability
  • Kirk Booth d/b/a as Beaucatcher Vista LLC applicant
  • 21 years term

Vice-Mayor Wisler moved to recess this item until June 9, 2020, at which time this public hearing will be voted on.

Presented by Paul D'Angelo, Community Development Program Director.

From the staff report

Approve the application for the Land Use Incentive Grant for 2 Restaurant Court Rental Community, Beaucatcher Vista LLC.

  • $289,481.85 the total value of the LUIG award would amount to
  • $13,784.85 an annual grant award of
  • 1.31 acres 2 Restaurant Court
  • $786,000 assessed value
  • Beaucatcher Vista LLC applicant
  • 9658-08-2350 parcel ID (PIN)
Fiscal impact

The estimated tax value upon completion is $4.0M, which at current rates would result in a City tax bill of $17,156.

Staff’s stated reasons
  • The property’s location and commitment to affordable housing merits a score of 150 on the LUIG scoring matrix, resulting in an award period of 21 years.

Staff: Paul D'Angelo, CD Program Director; Andrew Mayronne, CD Analyst.

The city’s documents for this item

Item IV-B · Zoning & Land Use · Public hearing

Public hearing to consider a land use incentive grant (continued)

Passed7–0 · Moved by Keith Young, seconded by Gwen Wisler

All members present voted yes.

3 spoke, 2 against · 2 council remarks

Recommendations

Council’s vote matched the city staff recommendation.

  • City staff: Approve — Staff has scored the project with 160 points, which qualifies the project for twenty-one years (21) of Land Use Incentive Grant.
  • Housing & Community Development Committee: Approve, February 11, 2020
  • Finance & HR Committee: Approve, February 25, 2020

Public hearing continued from May 12, 2020 · advertised Mar 13, 2020

0 spoke in favor · 2 spoke against · 1 stance not recorded

  • Not recorded Chris Day · for the applicant, Civil Design Concepts — Mr. Chris Day, with Civil Design Concepts, said that they are in active conversation with Ravenscroft Reserve to preserve this land.

Two voicemail comments were received opposing this item, as this is the last potential public green space in the South Slope neighborhood. … written comments for this public hearing will be accepted for an additional 24 hours The minutes name 1 of the 3 speakers.

What council members said 2 remarks from 2 members

Julie Mayfield Voted yes

  • Comment Councilwoman Mayfield said that many people are trying to preserve this property and wanted the public to know that if this land use incentive grant gets approved, that does not mean that negotiations with the developer are finished.

Brian Haynes Voted yes

  • Comment Councilman Haynes confirmed that voting on recessing this matter does not constitute support for the project.

The minutes record no remarks on this item from Vijay Kapoor, Esther E. Manheimer, Sheneika Smith, Gwen Wisler and Keith Young.

Key facts

  • $383,292 the city will grant back a total of $383,292 over the 21 years of the LUIG
  • $18,251 The difference is $18,251 which would be granted to the property owner annually
  • $20,487 the annual city property tax will be approximately $20,487
  • $6.5 million The developer estimates a total development cost of $6.5M.
  • 11 Collier Avenue address
  • 54 units 54 of them affordable
  • earning between 60% and 80% Area Median Income (AMI) for 20 years affordability
  • Tribute Companies applicant
  • 21 years term

Councilman Young moved to recess this item until June 9, 2020, at which time this public hearing will be voted on.

Presented by Paul D'Angelo, Community Development Program Director.

From the staff report

Approve the application for the Land Use Incentive Grant application for Tribute Companies Collier Development.

  • $383,292 the city will grant back a total of
  • $18,251 The difference is
  • $521,000 assessed value
  • Tribute Companies applicant
  • 9648-38-5770 parcel ID (PIN)
Fiscal impact

For 21 years and 54 affordable units at or below 80% AMI, the city will grant back a total of $383,292 over the 21 years of the LUIG which equals $7,098 per unit of subsidy

Staff’s stated reasons
  • Staff has scored the project with 160 points, which qualifies the project for twenty-one years (21) of Land Use Incentive Grant.
Before it reached Council
  • Housing & Community Development Committee, February 11, 2020: approve — approved
  • Finance & HR Committee, February 25, 2020: approve — approved

Staff: Paul D'Angelo, CD Program Director; Sam Powers, CED Director.

The city’s documents for this item

Item IV-C · Housing · Public hearing

Public hearing to amend the 2019-20 U.S. Dept. of Housing and Urban Development plan (continued)

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Sheneika Smith

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

Vice-Mayor Wisler moved to continue the public hearing to amend the 2019-20 U.S. Dept. of Housing & Urban Development Annual Action Plan to June 9, 2020.

Item IV-D · Zoning & Land Use · Public hearing

Public hearing to consider an amendment to a previously approved conditional zoning for a mixed-use building (continued to July 28, 2020)

Passed7–0 · Moved by Keith Young, seconded by Gwen Wisler

All members present voted yes.

Recommendations

Council’s vote matched the city staff recommendation.

  • City staff (staff report): Approve — Staff recommends approval of this project

Key facts

  • 137 Broad Street address
  • Community Business I → Community Business I/Conditional Zone zoning, from → to

Councilman Young moved to continue this public hearing to consider an amendment … new mixed-use building until July 28, 2020.

From the staff report

Amend a previously approved conditional zoning to adjust an interior lot line and include development on an adjacent parcel, currently zoned CB-I (Community Business I) and CBI-CZ (Community Business I - Conditional Zone) to CB I-CZ (Community Business I - Conditional Zone)

  • Owner / Petitioner: Broad Properties LLC asked for this item
  • CB-I (Community Business I) → CB-I CZ (Community Business I Conditional Zone) zoning, current → requested
  • Traditional Corridor future land use designation
  • Broad Properties LLC owner
  • Broad Properties LLC applicant
  • 9649-53-7557 parcel ID (PIN)
Staff’s stated reasons · approve
  • Staff recommends approval of this project and finds that the mixed use development and higher residential density is compatible with the goals of the zoning district and the Living Asheville Comprehensive Plan in numerous ways as noted in the report.
  • The small size of the residential units is aligned with needs identified in the most recent Bowen report and the offer of an affordable unit is a benefit for the needs of the community.
Before it reached Council
  • Technical Review Committee (TRC), February 3, 2020: approve with conditions — approved with conditions
  • Planning & Zoning Commission, March 4, 2020: approve (6–0) — recommended approval (6-0)
Conditions
  • The applicant has offered to dedicate 25% of the residential units (one unit) as affordable at 80% area median income (AMI) for a period of 10 years.
  • There will be shared access following the driveway as shown on plans.
  • The sidewalk will follow the existing development pattern of six foot back-of-curb.
  • The parking spaces will be allowed to be used by the residential units during off-business hours.
City Code sections

Section 7-11-2(c)(4), Section 7-9-10

Staff: Todd Okolichany, Planning & Urban Design Director; Jessica Bernstein, Urban Planner II.

Description in the minutes

at 137 Broad Street from Community Business I to Community Business I/Conditional Zone to include an adjacent parcel for the construction of a new mixed-use building until July 28, 2020. This motion was seconded by Vice-Mayor Wisler and carried unanimously by roll call vote.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item IV-E · Zoning & Land Use · Public hearing

Public hearing relative to amending the Unified Development Ordinance (continued)

Passed7–0 · Moved by Keith Young, seconded by Gwen Wisler

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

Councilman Young moved to continue this public hearing to consider an ordinance to amend the Unified Development Ordinance to update open space requirements until June 23, 2020.

Item J · RES 20-91 · Transportation · Resolution · consent agenda

Resolution authorizing the City Manager to amend the contract with Parker Technologies Inc. for the parking garage video call center answering service

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Sheneika Smith

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $91,000 increasing the total value of the contract to $91,000
  • Parker Technology, Inc. contractor or recipient
  • Parking Services Fund operating budget funding source
  • to extend the contract until May 31, 2020 term

Parking garage video call center answering service

Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution authorizing the City Manager to amend the existing parking garage call center contract (# 91700296) with Parker Technology, Inc., increasing the total value of the contract to $91,000, and to extend the contract until May 31, 2020.

Background:

  • The City of Asheville entered into a contract with Passport Labs in February 2017 for a video-based customer answering / “call for assistance” service within the four City-operated parking garages.
  • The fee structure paid is dependent on the number of “call for assistance” buttons placed at each parking garage exit, as well as the hours within a day that each assistance point is monitored.
  • At the beginning of the contract, not all garage exits were equipped with “call for assistance” buttons, and all in-place buttons were only being monitored during evening and weekend hours.
  • During May 2018, additional “call for assistance” buttons were installed, and all exits used by hourly garage customers were enhanced to 24/7 monitoring.
  • Parking Services raised all parking garage gates on March 18, 2020 due to COVID-19 response. No use of the video call for assistance service has been recorded since then, although the garages have remained open for patrons.
  • The contract expired in February 2020 and the requested additional funds would allow Parking Services to pay for services through May 31, 2020.

Vendor Outreach Efforts:

  • N/A
  • This is a current contract.

Council Goal(s):

  • Transportation and Accessibility.

Committee(s):

  • None.

Pro(s):

  • Enables the City to continue to provide timely assistance for parking garage customers.
  • Provides “face-to-face” customer support.

Con(s):

  • None

Fiscal Impact:

  • The cost of increasing the contract value in order to maintain 24/7 customer assistance is included in the current Parking Services Fund operating budget.

Staff: Ken Putnam, Transportation Department Director; Garrett Male, Parking Services Division Manager.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item K · RES 20-92 · Budget & Finance · Resolution · consent agenda

Resolution authorizing the City Manager to enter into a contract with Loomis Armored US, LLC, for armored carrier service

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Sheneika Smith

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $160,000 Contracted service costs not to exceed $160 thousand over a five year period.
  • Loomis Armored US, LLC contractor or recipient
  • Each department or division has included these costs in their respective budgets. funding source
  • 5 years term
Description in the minutes

Council Goal:

  • Financially Resilient City

Action Requested:

  • Approval for a contract between the City and Loomis Armored US, LLC, a cash pickup & delivery service, in an amount not to exceed $160,000 over a five year period. Background
  • Timeline:

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • Improved employee safety, ensuring that employees are not responsible for carrying cash to the bank.
  • Compliance with State Statute through the use of Smart Safes on site.
  • Efficient use of City resources, APD officers will not be needed to escort Water Resources deposits to the bank.

Con(s):

  • None

Fiscal Impact:

  • Contracted service costs not to exceed $160 thousand over a five year period. Each department or division has included these costs in their respective budgets.

Staff: Barbara Whitehorn, CFO & Director of Finance and Management Services.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item L · RES 20-93 / ORD 4804 · Public Safety · Resolution · consent agenda

U.S. Dept. of Justice Coronavirus Emergency Supplemental Funding Program grant; and budget amendment

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Sheneika Smith

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $153,278 2020 Coronavirus Emergency Supplement Funding (CESF) grant
  • There is no local match required. funding source
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution to apply for and accept the 2020 Coronavirus Emergency Supplement Funding (CESF) grant and adopt a budget amendment in the City’s Special Revenue Fund in the amount of $153,278.

Background:

  • The City of Asheville received an email notifying us of the opportunity to apply for a Department of Justice (DOJ) Coronavirus Emergency Supplemental Funding Program (CESF) grant.
  • The DOJ has preliminarily determined that the Asheville Police Department (APD) is eligible to receive a 2020 award of $153,278 which is allocated solely to the APD.
  • The APD will use the funds to prevent, prepare for, and respond to the coronavirus pandemic.

Council Goal(s):

  • A Connected and Engaged Community

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • Allows for reimbursement for purchases pertaining to the Coronavirus pandemic.

Con(s):

  • None

Fiscal Impact:

  • There is no local match required.

Staff: Elise Lewis, APD Financial Business Manager.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Item M · RES 20-94 / ORD 4805 · Public Safety · Resolution · consent agenda

2020 High Intensity Drug Trafficking Areas grant; and budget amendment

Passed7–0 · Moved by Gwen Wisler, seconded by Sheneika Smith

All members present voted yes.

Key facts

  • $285,416 2020 High Intensity Drug Trafficking Areas (HIDTA) Grant
  • The Office of National Drug Control Policy has preliminarily determined that the City of Asheville is eligible to receive a grant of $285,416. funding source
Description in the minutes

Action Requested:

  • Adoption of a resolution to apply for and accept the 2020 High Intensity Drug Trafficking Areas (HIDTA) Grant; and adopt a budget amendment in the City’s Special Revenue Fund in the amount of $285,416.

Background:

  • The City of Asheville receives an annual opportunity to receive a HIDTA Program Grant.
  • The Office of National Drug Control Policy has preliminarily determined that the City of Asheville is eligible to receive a grant of $285,416.
  • The purpose of the HIDTA program is to reduce drug trafficking and production in the United States, specifically in areas where drug related activities are having a significant harmful impact.
  • The Asheville HIDTA is comprised of members of the United States Drug Enforcement Administration, Asheville Police Department, and the Sheriff Offices’ of several Western North Carolina Counties.
  • Grant funds are used for overtime, travel, services and supplies. All expenses are tracked and audited by local and Federal authorities.
  • The Asheville HIDTA is the direct beneficiary of the grant funds. A United States Drug Enforcement Administration supervisor, who is the Asheville HIDTA manager, determines how grant funds will be expended. All members of the Asheville HIDTA receive reimbursement when they incur qualified expenses conducting Asheville HIDTA business.
  • The Asheville Police Department acts as the fiduciary for the grant. When expenses are incurred, the fiduciary settles the claims using appropriated City of Asheville funds and then requests a 100% reimbursement from the Federal Government.

Council Goal(s):

  • A Connected and Engaged Community

Committee(s):

  • None

Pro(s):

  • Fosters partnerships with Federal and local law enforcement agencies.

Con(s):

  • None

Fiscal Impact:

  • There is no local match required.

Staff: Elise Lewis, APD Financial Business Manager.

Copied word for word from the minutes (“…” marks words left out).

The city’s documents for this item

Discussed, no vote

Presentation

Presentation of the Fiscal Year 2020-21 Budget

The FY 2020-21 recommended budget continues funding for existing services with limited enhancements, new programs or initiatives; and maintains current property tax rate (42.89¢) and recommends no fee increases. … In summary for the General Fund, revenue is $133.1 Million; expenditures are $134.6 Million; for a use of Fund Balance of $1.5 Million. … The budget adoption is scheduled for June 23, 2020.

Presented by Debra Campbell, City Manager; Barbara Whitehorn, Chief Financial Officer.

Presentations: Budget Document with Manager's Message ↗ · Budget PowerPoint ↗

Council remarks

Vijay Kapoor

  • In response to Councilman Kapoor, [Barbara Whitehorn] said that they will provide Council with a list of the continuing capital projects, along with a list of a list of streets they anticipate to repair.

Report

Deputy Police Chief James Baumstark provided Council with an update on the concerns about fireworks in west Asheville stating that they are increasing patrol in the Pisgah View area (which seems to be the source of the fireworks) to talk to residents, using social media to advise people of the danger of fireworks and educate them which fireworks are legal and which are not, etc.

Presented by James Baumstark, Deputy Police Chief.

Council remarks

Julie Mayfield

  • Councilwoman Mayfield also noted that she spoke with the Executive Director of the Housing Authority who will remind tenants about quiet times requirements in their leases.

Open public comment 6 speakers · 3 topics, as the minutes list them

This resource, to the best of its ability, is copied word for word from the official minutes, “…” marks words left out, and [brackets] a name the minutes give elsewhere. The minutes are the record. Staff report details are quoted from the city’s meeting documents, prepared before the vote.